10 Classic Rock Bands That Got Better After Selling Out
The Upside of Cashing In.
When it comes to the music business, selling out seems to be one of the worst crimes an artist can commit. While most fans will stand by their favorite acts, many listeners are left feeling burned after a band changes their sound to reach a broader audience. This often lead to fans either writing off their favorite acts or complaining to their friends that "they used to better back in the day."
At the same time, no one said that selling out had to always be a drawback. On the rare occasion, some bands are able to sell out and become even greater than they were in their early years. Sure, their previous material may have been great, but the possibilities for them to pull off other styles would lead to even greater musical feats down the road.
Though it's essential for a band to be true to themselves, sometimes hanging onto your old sound is what's holding you back from being something legendary. While playing rock is fun, there's a plethora of material waiting for you out in the wild. These acts may have gotten blowback for "selling out," but it's hard to deny how great they became after they hit it big.
10. Journey
Journey are easily one of the most successful bands to come out of the 80's. Regardless of what you think of their music, the impact of songs like "Don't Stop Believin" and "Faithfully" are so undeniable that they feel more or less a part of arena rock's DNA. When the group got the ball rolling though, their sound was far from the radio singles we know them for.
With the original lineup featuring vocalist Gregg Rolie of Santana, the band's first few releases saw them developing a sound that was more jazz fusion than pop. Songs would often have separate movements and contain multiple instrumentals, which while cool, never really found its footing on the charts. This period of the band's work certainly has its fans, but the group's big reach for the gold came when powerhouse Steve Perry joined their ranks.
Instead of having the more complex musical passages, the newer material had a certain sonic sheen to it that made it irresistible every time you listened to it. With ballads and poppy material becoming their new sound, even guitarist Neal Schon wasn't sure what to make of it at the time, but the results ended up becoming the soundtrack to a whole new generation of rock fans.
9. Def Leppard
Def Leppard's sell-out period was so seemless that it's hard to pin down. It almost seems silly to lump Def Leppard into the New Wave of British Heavy Metal scene, but their beginnings ran essentially parallel with bands like Diamond Head and Iron Maiden.
At the early stages, the band had more sonic similarities with bands like AC/DC and Led Zeppelin than a typical pop outfit, but the band could feel change in the air once they hooked up with producer Mutt Lange. Coming off of monster albums like Back in Black, Lange dared the band to aim bigger than their typical hard rock audience.
Once Pyromania came out, more radio-friendly elements started to make their way into the band's sound, from layered vocal harmonies to a more cleaned up guitar sound. Many early fans may have felt burned at first, but the actual tunes on the record were some of the most infectious the rock genre had to offer.
With the follow up Hysteria going in an even more commercial direction, the band created a record that could hold its own in nearly any genre. Def Leppard may have dove head first into their poppy sound, but no one could have predicted the sonic gold mine they had hit upon.
8. T Rex
You can't really talk about the glam rock movement of the '70s and not bring up T. Rex. The no frills attitude behind their classic tunes left a huge impact on everyone from peers like David Bowie to the hair metal scene that formed on the Sunset Strip in the '80's. The look may have been in your face, but the initial first steps from the band were much more stripped back.
Before he started slinging his classic Les Paul, frontman Marc Bolan originally formed Tyrannosaurus Rex as a meager folk outfit during the late 60's. There were some psychedelic elements added into the mix for sure, but the crux of the tunes was still far removed from the glitter scene. After a few years of moderate success, Bolan took the leap into more androgynous territory.
When many fans saw the cover of Electric Warrior, they knew that this music was something different. Instead of the acoustic style rock of years passed, Bolan had transformed himself into the next glam rock god, as he assaulted the audience with swaggering riffs like "Bang A Gong." The folk rock scene was a nice start, but the one way for Bolan to truly wow the crowd was to make his amp roar.
7. Fleetwood Mac
Fleetwood Mac's music is some of the most timeless folk rock ever conceived. With every passing hit, the songwriting minds of Stevie Nicks, Lindsey Buckingham, and Christine McVie produced concentrated perfection in musical form. Their sound has become so identifiable with the band that many don't even realize the first incarnation of the band had none of these creative minds.
Forming initially in the 1960s as part of the British Blues Boom, Fleetwood Mac was originally a much harder rock outfit fronted by Peter Green. Though the band did have some modest success in their early days with songs like "Oh Well" and "Albatross," they were far from capturing audiences like fellow peers Led Zeppelin or Cream. After Green departed, the band tried to desperately to find their new voice by adding different members to their ranks. Once another prospective guitarist abruptly quit before recording, the band found Buckingham and Nicks in the neighboring studio and asked if they would be interested in joining.
From then on, the band's sound had fully metamorphosed into something that was much more subdued but absolutely dripping with emotion. This change in direction may have been a far stretch from the blues, but the songs could touch your heart in a way nothing else could.
6. The Police
Ever since their debut, the Police always seemed to be on a path towards something big. As the band moved from one record to the next, they pushed themselves that much further into different instrumentation and musical styles. While most bands get accused of selling out once they reach the charts, the Police's gradual ascent felt less like a betrayal and more like the logical next step.
By the time the band got around to making albums like Ghost in the Machine, fans had already grown accustomed to Sting's more poppy material on songs like "Message in a Bottle" and "Don't Stand So Close To Me."
Once they hit Synchronicity, they hit a higher mark than they could have ever anticipated, with "Every Breath You Take" becoming one of the most successful songs of the entire decade. Even with the band's more commercial success, their music still had its off-kilter weirdness, with songs like "Synchronicity II" featuring inventive drum work from Stewart Copeland and Andy Summers expanding on his sonic effects wizardry.
The main melodies behind the songs may have been a bit simpler than normal, but the subtle nuances made these songs nearly impossible to reproduce. When most bands use more commercial material to woo the corporate big wigs, the Police are the one instance where the mainstream came to them rather than the other way around.
5. Tom Petty
For most of Tom Petty's career, he was the epitome of the genuine rock and roller. From his laid back attitude to the power of his band the Heartbreakers, Petty's music seemed as essential to the growth of rock music as the Rolling Stones or the Byrds. The foundation of the music was so secure that even when he took on more poppy production, the tunes never suffered for it.
While most Petty fans will tell you that Damn the Torpedoes is the highlight of his rock career, everything was blown wide open once Jeff Lynne came into the picture. Being the mastermind behind ELO, Lynne had the production mindset that worked perfectly for Petty's style, which resulted in some of his finest work on songs like "Free Fallin." Even when Petty went more soft on albums like Wildflowers, he still could depend on his songwriting prowess when it came to crafting fantastic hooks on songs like "You Wreck Me."
These ideas may have been poised for commercial cash-in on paper, but Petty was never one to focus on the money over his music. It's rare to see an artist put out some of their best work over a decade after their debut, but Petty's reach for gold gave him one of the biggest second winds in rock history.
4. David Bowie
David Bowie was always one of the most eccentric personalities the rock world had ever seen. With each change in trend and style, Bowie found a way to shift his styles to blend in with whatever was popular at the time. On the other hand, even a chameleon has to get comfortable in their own skin at first.
Bowie's initial attempts at rock music were a far cry from his elaborate costumes and leaned more into the vaudeville tradition. With tunes that were centered around lavish arrangements, Bowie could tell that this style was just not clicking with audiences in the way he wanted it to. Once he started noticing the rise in more glam-centric artists, Bowie took his first step into rock history by introducing his Major Tom character on "Space Oddity." While many may have seen this as aping glam trends, Bowie proved he not only could pull off the glam look, but dominate the entire landscape.
In the coming years, Bowie turned himself into one of the greatest musical visionaries in the world, with characters like Ziggy Stardust, Aladdin Sane, and the Thin White Duke becoming part of his musical identity. Though this change may have come out of nowhere, it wouldn't be the last time Bowie would wow us with his musical shifts.
3. Queen
Throughout each of their albums, Queen have always had a certain amount of gravitas to their presentation. No matter what type of adventurous pursuit you go through in life, chances are Queen has got the ideal soundtrack for the occasion. Though the band are known for their singalong hits, their original iteration was ambitious in a much different way.
At the start of the band's career, the loud guitars and multiple movements of their songs put them more in line with prog rock, with Freddie Mercury even going so far as to create a fictional fantasy world called Rhye that he would set some of his songs in. Even the band's opus a Night at the Opera featured "The Prophet's Song," whose sound featured an array of disparate musical passages.
Once the band reached the nest decade, they knew their more pompous movements had no place in the era of disco. With albums like the Game and Jazz, the band were shifting their sound into something much more palletable for the standard pop fan, with songs like "Another One Bites the Dust" not only becoming great rock tunes, but fantastic feats of songwriting. The band may have been looking for more fans, but they did the near-impossible by getting respect from both the rockers and the average music fans in equal capacity.
2. Genesis
Genesis's sound has always been an ever-evolving process. Originally conceived as a more progressive group, the band created songs that were mini epics across albums like Nursery Cryme and Selling England By the Pound. However, the fanbase was left dejected when frontman and primary songwriter Peter Gabriel left the band to pursue a solo career.
Instead of hiring a new singer, drummer Phil Collins stepped up to the mic and gave the band a new life with his own tunes. While the initial albums with Collins up front were still rooted in prog, the band started to slightly maneuver into the pop realm with each release. The change in direction became too much for guitarist Steve Hackett, who abruptly quit the band midway through the recording of one of their albums.
This kind of behavior from a band would usuau seem shallow and greedy, but the band never skimped out when it came to writing more commercial stuff. It may have been a bit easy on the ears, but along the way, the band were always genuine and gave off the impression that they really enjoyed making this more mainstream kind of music. The hardcore fans may have been pissed, but Genesis do deserve a bit of credit for bringing prog onto the charts in a way few other artists could.
1. Bob Dylan
Bob Dylan has the distinction of having one of the most drastic shifts in tone of any other rock artist. When he started out, Dylan was known as the folk poet in the vein of Woody Guthrie, with subtle acoustic songs that had some of the most biting lyrics the world had ever heard. Once he picked up an electric guitar, everything started to change.
From his very first public performance with a rock band, Dylan was infamously heckled from the stage and was even labelled as "Judas" based on his betrayal of his folk roots. While the original fans of his work may have thought Dylan was hopping on trends, he was actually hitting on a new type of music no one had ever heard before.
Sure, the guitars may have been a bit more crunchy than his trademark acoustic, but the words behind these tunes were some of the most scathing critiques on the modern world. Incorporating his initial wordplay into rock helped inspire legions of artists to put more thought and attention into their lyrics, which helped launch the entire '60s Revolution. Even when Dylan was being accused of selling out, he was more ahead of the curve than any of us could have imagined.