10 Cover Songs That Shouldn't Have Worked (But Did)
When Musical Worlds Collide.
The art of making a cover song shouldn't necessarily be all that hard. After all, if you're a good enough act, most of it just comes down to doing your own version of karaoke to a song that you love. Then again, there are some artists that are willing to go a bit further than just your standard copy and paste song job.
Across rock's history, cover songs have been the bread and butter of getting a band's foot in the door, but they can also act as a unique creative opportunity as well. By all accounts, the music is written, you just have to put yourself into that space...and boy did these artists have a field day with these.
Compared to the original songs, some of these don't even sound anywhere close to the source material, with them reinventing the entire track from the ground up. It's one thing when it's just for a gag...it's something else entirely when it actually manages to work.
As wrong as some of these feel to listen to, the execution of these tracks are nearly flawless, with no note being out of place across a second of runtime. Though there is a fair amount of creative license at work, it should be illegal for people to pull something off this well.
10. Turn the Page - Metallica
For any die hard Metallica fan, the mid '90s are not a time period that they look back on fondly. Even though the thrash legends had made their millions off of the Black Album, the one-two punch of Load and Reload was a bit much for a lot of fans to take in all at once. While Garage Inc. feels like a bit of course correction for these guys in retrospect, we did get an unexpected left hook with their version of Turn the Page by Bob Seger.
Granted, it's not like the Seger classic wasn't already dark in its own way, as it told the tale of the lonesome traveler going across the country and getting more lonesome by the day. Then again, this is Metallica, the same guys that were known for songs about drug addiction, war atrocities, and the pure darkness that existed in every human's head. How the hell are they able to make this work?
Well, the real crux of this tune comes from James' delivery, which is actually spot on for Seger's tone. As much vocal acrobatics that he put his throat through, this is the one instance where the Load-era experimentation really works. Hell, even the guitar solo and Kirk Hammett mimicking the original's saxophone line goes over like gangbusters here. Even though this is the polar opposite of what a Metallica fan was expecting, the AM rock radio look isn't too shabby on them.
9. California Sun - Ramones
From day one, the punk rock explosion always seemed to be sticking out against the more corporate side of rock. At a time when most bands were stretching out into more advanced playing styles and trying to outsolo one another, the Ramones' debut was a ferocious return to the three chord rock that made people fall in love with the genre. It was loud, it was nonconformist....and it apparently worked well with '50s doo wop music?
For their sophomore effort Leave Home, the Ramones decided to dig back a little deeper into rock history and pull out a version of California Sun, which seems like it would sound better playing out of a transistor radio on a beach rather than the rough and tumble clubs of CBGB's. There's a lot of bizarro world charm in this too, so why doesn't it feel more cynical as a result?
Well, when you boil everything down, it's not like punk and doo wop are that dissimilar of genres, which each relying on simple melodies and a tight groove to keep things together. As much as Joey Ramone doesn't strike you as the sunbather type, this still has the same energy that could kick off a summer beach party. But hey, even the hot fun in the summertime jams need to find their way to Redondo Beach eventually, right?
8. I've Seen All This World I've Cared To See - Jerry Cantrell
By all intents and purposes, metal has never been a genre for the sensitive side of rock and roll. If you were to even entertain the idea of taking things down a notch for a Slayer, chances are you would either get laughed out of the room or bludgeoned to death before you could finish your next sentence. Then again, sometimes the musical gods work in mysterious ways with Jerry Cantrell.
During the interim period when Alice in Chains were on their indefinite hiatus, Cantrell managed to squeeze in a cover of Willie Nelson's song I've Seen All This World I've Cared to See for a tribute album, which went over a lot better than you might expect. While the very idea of someone from Alice in Chains going country makes as much sense as Slayer doing disco, it's not that far off the mark when you realize the artist you're working with.
Throughout his tenure, Cantrell has always been a fan of all kinds of music, from Elton John to the Beatles to Anthrax, so this kind of left field turn might not have been all that strange. As far as the song is concerned too, this is one of Willie's more dour compositions, which works perfectly off of Cantrell's melancholy croon. Despite Nelson himself being shocked by the inclusion, you can't argue when the results actually sound like this.
7. Wild Is the Wind - David Bowie
Considering his massive pedigree in the rock landscape, David Bowie is not really a man who needs to rely too much on cover songs. Since he basically invented genres like glam metal from the ground up, it's safe to say he has the songwriting chops to keep writing bangers until the end of time. When you're transitioning genres though, it's sometimes best to have a musical life raft like Wild is the Wind.
Compared to the kraut rock vibe coming from the album Station to Station, this cover of an old Ned Washington song feels almost momentum destroying. After all, you're not really supposed to go from the sounds of the impending European destruction to one of the weepier standards of the modern age. Then again, when you're the Thin White Duke, you're free to do whatever the hell you want.
Aside from just being an amazing rendition, this is a performance that is carried on Bowie's vocal range, which is one of the more impressive outings he would take on in his classic period. Even with the sterile sounds of the Berlin period creeping in, there's something about this track that ties it in to feeling oddly human. As much as Bowie likes to play with different genres left and right, this song alone should be the real posterchild for his musical diversity.
6. Under Pressure - Foo Fighters
Covering Under Pressure just feels like something that should not happen in the regular world. Since the original is already perfect in every single way, there's no real reason to have someone come along to do their own version of it. Though Freddie Mercury has the charisma and unbridled joy in every word he sings, the Foo Fighters just bring it to another level entirely.
Granted, it's not like Dave Grohl doesn't have the chops to pull something like this off, considering his proficiency in nearly every instrument he touches. Even so, this version of Under Pressure gives us a little bit of a different bent to the narrative, as Taylor Hawkins breaks his silence behind the drum throne to take lead vocals on David Bowie's part. While Grohl doesn't have nearly the vocal chops to rival Mercury's, his delivery just makes everything feel like a big party whenever it comes on.
For everything that the original Under Pressure does right, this is equivalent of taking the original version and giving it steroids, with every single instrument operating at full capacity from start to finish. Even with Taylor Hawkins having the cover band Chevy Metal operating during the Foos' off seasons, it's safe to say that the Foos proper haven't lost their will to take a kickass tune and see where it goes.
5. No Quarter - Tool
In the pantheon of amazing metal musicians, it's a crime that we don't get new Tool music as much as we could. Despite being around for the better part of three decades, you can still count on one hand the amount of albums of original material that these rockers have at their disposal. Then again, even when they want to reach into someone else's territory, it's going to be the biggest head trip you can possibly imagine.
As much as Led Zeppelin have been a mainstay of the hard rock genre, it almost feels wrong to see a band like Tool making something out of Whole Lotta Love or Rock and Roll. If you had to pick one song though, No Quarter pretty much fits the bill, considering the original sounding like an epic unto itself in the '70s.
Taken from the box set of some of their live cuts, this rendition of the Zeppelin classic is so distinct that it's almost sounds like Maynard rewrote this song from the ground up, keeping the same rhythmic accents while adding in the trademark Tool vibe. Keep in mind this was the days of Aenima, which showed Tool just coming into their own as one of the greatest in their field. Not better by any stretch, but a damn solid outing nonetheless.
4. Ass*ole - Tom Petty
Ever since the start of his career, Tom Petty has always been willing to pay tribute to the greats who have come before him. Whether it's performing covers of the Byrds songs or jamming on some old rockabilly from the garage days, Petty was always a rocker that was as much of a fan of others' music as he was his own. So when you give him a soundtrack to cover whatever he wants, the first person he decides to cover is...Beck?
That's not to say Beck isn't an amazing talent in his own right, but the pairing itself doesn't really scan properly in your brain. Hell, even the idea of covering a Beck song in and of itself seems weird, considering his eccentric nature from one song to the next. There is one common link in country though, and Petty milked it for all it was worth on Ass*ole.
Each of them being huge descendants of country legends like Johnny Cash, Petty recognizes the pure melancholy in this tune and manages to make it sound even more downtrodden, almost matching the same lackadaisical delivery that Mr. Hansen was already so good at doing in his own right. Not necessarily the happiest of songs...just one for those rainy days when the pain becomes a little too much to bear.
3. Waiting for the Night - Ghost
For as much as their aesthetic is linked to them specifically, it feels like Ghost doesn't have the right to really cover artists in the first place. Unless they're covering some old chamber music tune from centuries ago, Tobias Forge's unique approach to metal feels like it's made to stick in one lane until the end of time. Although he was able to find common ground in terms of darkness, how the hell did we manage to bridge the worlds of Satanic metal and synth pop?
Granted, it's not like the original Waiting for the Night wasn't already dark to begin with, given that the backing track of Depeche Mode's original is practically dripping with dread. As great as the original is on its own though, that dark nature is somewhat reserved by comparison to what we got. Suffice to say, you aren't going to have the same problem when approaching a Ghost song.
Since Papa Emeritus is known to go over the top on more than a few occasions, the subtle delivery of this tune starts off as faithful to the original, before building and building until it's one of the most haunting pieces of music that it could possibly become. As much as synths are supposed to sound cold and distant by nature, no amount of electronics can make up for a delivery that is truly bonechilling.
2. All Along the Watchtower - Jimi Hendrix
Any Bob Dylan song feels like it's meant to be played on an acoustic guitar and nowhere else. As much as Dylan's work has been poured over by virtually every stripe of rock band since the dawn of time, there's nothing that suits his songs better than just stripping things down and focusing on the lyrics at hand. Then again, if you have the potential to do something else, sometimes you can put even the classic artists to shame.
Taking a liking to All Along the Watchtower when it was released in its acoustic form, Jimi Hendrix gave Dylan's recounting of a Joker and the Thief scenario his own spin by making a psychedelic pastiche of the tune. Going even more grandiose than his Woodstock beginnings, Jimi throws every verse of this song into the stratosphere, sprinkling in bits and pieces of guitar brilliance that seem to tell this story of dread in a way that the lyrics couldn't have on their own.
Even after all this time being heralded as a cultural icon unto himself, Dylan himself has seemed to abandon ownership of the song over time, saying that Hendrix recorded the definitive version of the tune. As much as you might want to flatter the author of the tune, you really had to have knocked it out of the park when even the author is saying you did the better job.
1. The Ghost of Tom Joad - Rage Against the Machine
Ever since breaking onto the scene in the '70s, Bruce Springsteen's music has always been about something larger than life. Though the characters in each of his stories aren't meant to be epic in any way, shape, or form, the way that he writes these Everyman tales feels like the fate of the world is in our hands rather than the heroes we hear about in movies. When you want to get a little more gutteral though, it tends to work wonders for the aggro crowd.
While The Ghost of Tom Joad was definitely a highlight of the Boss' later career, the real left turn came when this song was co-opted for Rage Against the Machine's covers album Renegades. Though most of the record was known for including the likes of hardcore punk bands and hip hop outfits, this turn into heartland rock seemed to come right out of nowhere. Then again, when you take a look at the lyrics, it's easy to see where everything lines up.
Framed as a man down and out and looking for some sort of hope to come around, Rage frames this song in a dangerous sort of haze, almost like the coming Armageddon could take place before Tom Joad even decides to return. Since Tom Morello has become a card carrying member of the Springsteen fan club at this point, it feels like the marriage between the Everyman and the apolitical rebel is a lot more feasible than you might think.