10 Craziest Musical Urban Legends

The Strange, Weird, and What The Hell? Of Music.

Paul McCartney Michael Jackson
Columbia

Most of the tabloid circus surrounding rock music can feel like a bunch of BS at the end of the day. For as much as people like to brag about their extravagant lifestyle, it's ultimately no one's business as to what they do when they're off the stage. Every so often though, you get that one little tidbit that seems almost too good (or bad) to be true.

From every stripe of music history, there have been certain stories surrounding music legends that have followed them around for years.

Instead of just fading like your usual stories, these have hung in the back of everyone's collective memory for so long that they feel like their true through sheer force of will alone. However, what do the people who actually live them have to say?

If you just tend to believe the usual music magazines, you're missing the full stories behind your favorite bands. While some parts might get a bit dicey, these rumors have hung around long enough to go down in history.

Across each of these cases, we'll see the too good to be true and the downright creepy things that went down after the stage lights went out. But hey, any publicity is good publicity, right?

10. Michael Jackson and the Elephant Man

Michael Jackson has always had a bit of a weird streak ever since becoming a solo star. Granted, it's not like you're expected to grow up amid the tabloid circus and not run into some weird detours along the way. Despite some of the more eccentric sides of Jacko's personality, the craziest has to be when he went back to the vaudeville stage.

While at the height of his popularity in the late '80s, Jackson became transfixed on the character of the Joseph Merrick, who was known as The Elephant Man decades before. Unlike most other performers, the Elephant Man's bones were completely warped, leaving different remnants of bone sticking out from his facial structure. Though he was able to win over the attention of circus goers back in the day, it turns out that same kind of deformity was actually profitable after his death.

As has been commonly believed over the years, Jackson actually bought the bones of the Elephant Man, after being displayed in a museum ever since his death. Going for the hefty price of $1 million dollars, Jackson ended up becoming the owner for what he cited as a fascination with the ethical nature of Merrick's work. Aside from your regular celebrity vanity projects, this takes the extravagance of stardom to an entirely different level.


9. Phil Collins' Drowning

Most people's common understanding of In the Air Tonight can be summed up by its iconic drum break. Ever since its release in the early '80s, there isn't anyone who hasn't played air drums to Collins' fill when he cuts through the mix on the radio. Then again, people have looked a bit deeper into what they claim to be some murderous behavior in the lyrics.

As the fans have speculated over the years, Collins was originally writing this as a bit of moral revenge after seeing someone refuse to save a drowning man one night. In that respect, the entire song seems to shift into creepy territory as Phil darkly intones that "You can wipe off that grin, I know where you been." The rumor ran rampant for so long that Collins was even believed to have called out the murderer from the stage when he showed up to one of his gigs.

Like all great pop songs though, it just comes back to love at the end of the day. In fact, the whole reason why Phil wrote his first solo record Face Value was to make peace with his first wife, whom he was separating from at the time. While everyone falls out of love at some point in their life, sometimes it's more interesting to focus on a watery grave than actual heartbreak.


8. Kurt Cobain Was Murdered

Not many other artists can claim to have the '90s by the throat quite like Kurt Cobain. Despite having almost incomprehensible lyrics and virtually no desire to be famous, Cobain became the unofficial spokesman for the alternative movement after the success of Smells Like Teen Spirit blew every other genre out of the water. Then in an instant, it was done in a gunshot...but by whom?

For years, fans have accepted the fact that Cobain killed himself via a shotgun wound, and yet there are still people who will attest to his death being a homicide. While some of the claims are more ridiculous than others, there are at least some points that are worth some serious consideration. After already attempting suicide in Rome, Cobain was already in a bad way, but the effects of his heroin intake at the time suggest that he was too weak to even so much as stand up, let alone operate a firearm.

However, things start to get tasteless really quick once fans started to insinuate that his wife Courtney Love planned her husband's death, going so far as to name her album Live Through This to capitalize on it. For as many coincidences as there are, there's no reason to drag her name through the mud like that. Still, with only a few scant details about discovering the body, the death of the Alternative Icon will probably remain mysterious forever.


7. Judas Priest On Trial

Metal on the whole has never really had the most pleasant experience in the public eye. For every metalhead looking to bang their head to these furious riffs, there's always a few people too uptight to really give it a fair chance. While the musicians in question tended to get off easy, no one would have suspected metal's godfathers to be on trial for their life.

As Judas Priest were riding high throughout the mid '80s, they were given a subpoena shortly before a gig by two families blaming them for their sons' death. Having killed themselves a few months prior, the parents were claiming that the music mesmerized their sons into committing suicide, citing the song Better By You Better Than Me as the most egregious example. Despite not even being a Judas Priest song (original by Spooky Tooth), the court worked every angle to try to catch Priest in the act, arguing that the phrase "DO IT" could be discerned if you played the record backward.

Even though Priest ended up walking away clean, it did impact their momentum going forward, from their weird experimentations on Turbo to Rob Halford eventually resigning from the Priesthood. For as many outlandish things happen in metal songs, there's no reason to think that they actually are trying to lead you towards death.


6. Van Halen's Chocolate Mandate

By the time most rock acts reach the top, a certain level of diva starts to set in. No matter how humble your beginnings might be, you can afford to have some more outlandish expectations for a gig when you're playing to thousands of people night after night. Then again, having specifics when it comes to sweets might be kind of stretching it.

When going out on tour in the early '80s, Van Halen's stage setup was already complicated enough, from David Lee Roth swinging a sword around to Eddie Van Halen's various effects pedals that needed to be triggered every night. Once you got to the dressing room requirements though, fans and fellow musicians were stunned that VH insisted to have M+M's in the room, but with all of the brown ones removed. However, there was actually a bit of method to the madness.

As Roth put it later, most of the band's staging was already complicated, which could lead to dangerous situations if not set up properly. Therefore, if the guys walked into the room and saw an M+M's bag with no brown ones, they would know that the show was going to go off without a hitch. For the less diligent type though, these hair metal giants were also known to trash the room if they found any stray brown M+M's. You might call it a bit snobbish, but it's at least nice to know that VH always had their crew in mind when setting up a concert rider.


5. Dark Side of the Moon Cinematic Power

When it comes to some of the greatest albums of all time, Dark Side of the Moon by Pink Floyd is that rare record that hasn't aged a day. Being a proto concept album about the way people journey through life, the actual construction of each of the songs bleed into each other in a way that makes each of them feel greater than the sum of its parts. Long before the Wall became a movie though, many a Floyd fan was questioning the cinematic origins of Dark Side.

In what can only be described as ingenious serendipity, almost every single second of Dark Side of the Moon is alleged to sync up perfectly with The Wizard of Oz when played back. Though there is no set time as to when to start playing the record during viewings, many people have linked up Dorothy and Toto's journey to the Emerald City to songs like Time and Money, with the narrative matching the vicious guitar stabs every step of the way.

Then again, it's not like these things are polar opposites either, with Dark Side's reflection of the fanciful parts of life before going back to reality being a unique parallel to Dorothy's journey from a wonderland back to Kansas. For as much as this be considered a stoner's fever dream, sometimes the fiction ends up being more accurate than the truth.


4. Alice Cooper Poultry Genocide

It's hard to really think of the days before shock-rock and not bring up Alice Cooper. Long before KISS and Slipknot had really started to strike fear into the hearts of parents, Cooper was the ringleader of rock and roll mayhem, known for "killing" babies and adding various macabre elements to every show he played. However, the real start of his notoriety came entirely by accident... at the expense of some poor chicken.

Despite having some weird first steps on albums like Pretties For You, Cooper's luck didn't turn around until he made his entrance at the Toronto Peace Festival. Going on between the Doors and John Lennon, Cooper's finale always revolved around opening up feather pillows and covering the audience with debris. On this occasion though, Cooper spotted a chicken at the foot of the stage and (not really being the farming type) threw it into the audience.

In one of the more macabre things he ever did, everyone in the crowd tore it to pieces and threw the remnants of it back onstage. Whereas animal shelters nowadays would have been outraged, this is actually what Cooper credits with making him a shock-rock star, even getting a phone call from Frank Zappa telling him to run with it. Though Cooper has never been known to engage in any outlandish behavior now, you probably shouldn't let him around any of your livestock.


3. Stairway to Hell?

The journey for Led Zeppelin into the realm of rock gods lies in Stairway to Heaven. Though Jimmy Page had already carved his name into rock history with the Yardbirds, this monumental 8 minute journey of a track is so compact that it almost seems to be part of the DNA of rock and roll itself. Now if only people knew it was just about a journey...and nothing more.

Across its runtime, Stairway's build is absolutely beautiful, from a lone acoustic guitar to a pastoral opening to one of the greatest guitar solos of all time. However, some concerned parents were starting to question what the lyrics really meant. In another case of backwards recording, people starting coming out of the woodwork suggesting that the backmasked lyrics were actively encouraging children to worship Satan. While this would be laughed out of the room for any other rock band, Jimmy Page's known fixation with the occult has given this rumor legs for years now.

Despite it making the rounds both on the Internet and by word of mouth, the silence on Page's part has kept the debate going, adding just another level of mystique to Zeppelin's aura. While Stairway might have the power to outlive any other rock and roll out there, we'll probably never know whether or not its immortality actually lies in some form of dark magic.


2. Kiss' Bloody Comic Books

From the first time they strapped on instruments, KISS always wanted to put together a band that was larger than anything that came before them. Donning horrific makeup and singing amazing tunes about the excesses of rock and roll, these masked giants became almost superheroes to an entire generation of music fans. However, every superhero has to have their origin story, and KISS' story may have been a bit too close for comfort.

In association with Marvel, KISS was the first band to have a comic book made about them, with their superpowers reflecting their onstage personas, with Gene Simmons as the Demon and Ace Frehley as the Spaceman. When it came time to go to print though, the shock rockers were alleged to have put their actual blood into the ink that went into the comic book pressing. While this could have easily been done just to stir up controversy, it's actually 100% true.

During some downtime in between touring and recording, each respective member of KISS had blood work done before eventually going to the printing plant to mix their blood into the red ink that would be found in the comic book. Then again, seeing how this is the same band with a bass player that breathes fire and sprays blood from his mouth every time he takes to the stage, to do anything less might not keep with their image.


1. Paul is Dead

Even after 50 years of existence, the music of the Beatles is pretty much bulletproof in the realm of rock music. Aside from a few hiccups here and there, stuff like Sgt. Peppers and Abbey Road have become musical classics regardless of the genre, all thanks to the creative minds of John, Paul, George, and Ringo. Or at least...that's what they want you to think.

Ever since the late '60s, many Fab fans have speculated as to whether the Paul McCartney we have known all these years is the same man we met on Please Please Me and A Hard Day's Night. As many have claimed, the original Paul McCartney was killed in an automobile accident around 1966, leading to the other three Beatles to replace him with a lookalike for the rest of their artistic run.

It's not like they don't have "evidence" to back it up either, with clues to his demise being found in the Sgt. Pepper album sleeve and even in the band's lyrics. Paul has ended up taking the entire thing in stride over the years though, either laughing it off as a joke or going so far as to directly confront it by naming one of his live records Paul Is Live. I mean, even if this version of Paul is an imposter, the work he made during the Beatles' later years is still among some of the greatest music of the 20th century.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97