10 Criminally Underappreciated Christmas Songs

Garfield Xmas It's the holiday season again, when radio stations flood the airwaves with Christmas carols non-stop, so I thought it might be a good time to review some of the lesser appreciated Christmas songs out there (and, in some cases, lesser appreciated versions of the classic tunes). Everyone loves Elvis "The King" Presley's "Blue Christmas" and Nat King Cole's "The Christmas Song (Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire)," and for good reason, but there is a stocking full of little loved holiday gems out there that still brighten my Christmas spirit. In all honesty, some of these choices will sound oddball (the Muppets and Boyz II Men?), but I will at least attempt to describe why I fell in love with these particular Christmas chestnuts over the years€”and decades. There are even a few selections on this list that I'm embarrassed to admit I like (I'm looking in your direction, New Kids), but that's what happens when the rose-coloured glasses of Christmas nostalgia warp your mind. Nostalgia doesn't always make sense, especially if you grew up in the '80s like me. So, without further ado, here in no order are 10 under-appreciated Christmas songs.

10. "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas" €“Rolf the Dog and John Denver

Off the soundtrack of their T.V. special "A Christmas Together," which still hasn't been released on home video, John Denver and the Muppets came together to celebrate the holidays and cheer our spirits. Though, to be blunt, a few of the songs, especially "When the River Meets the Sea" and "It's in Every One of Us," sound more depressing than cheerful, which is ironic considering I just explained this is a Christmas album by John Denver and the Muppets. The standout track for me though is the second, which I noticed is the CD slot usually reserved for an album's best tune. "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas" is probably my favorite Christmas carol, and this is definitely one of my favorite versions. It's less than two minutes, but Rolf and John make beautiful music together, even if half of their duo is a furry, inanimate Muppet. Sweet and tuneful in its simplicity, with Rolf accompanying John's vocals on piano, it fortunately keeps the newer, less discouraging lyrics, ditching the inferior bleak lines like "From now on, we'll have to muddle through somehow." My favorite line is, "From now on, our troubles will be out of sight," because it reminds me, during all the crazy hustle and bustle of the season, to just relax and enjoy it. Christmas is supposed to be fun. Besides, I like the idea of leaving your worries for the rest of the year.

9. "Silver Bells" €“ The Radio City Christmas Spectacular Version

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EicJHgO9ORE This is the quintessential New York City Christmas song (sorry "A New York City Christmas"), and, working in this city every day, it's hard not to think of the lyrics, "City sidewalks, busy sidewalks" when you're shoving past store-friendly tourists and Salvation Army Santas clogging the walkways. I also always thought the line, "Strings of streetlights, even stoplights/blink a bright red and green" was fairly clever, since red and green are traditional Christmas colors. The reason I chose the Radio City version is because when I first saw the show as a kid, I remember thinking how appropriate this song choice was, given my Manhattan surroundings. Just hearing it on the radio every year (though it's usually not this version, which is accompanied by a full orchestra and, of course, those prancing Rockettes) reminds me of the first time I heard it, sitting in the theater at Radio City Music Hall and impatiently waiting for Christmas to arrive.

8. "Silent Night/Let It Snow" €“ Boyz II Men

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rDigf1XM9DQ Boyz II Men? Smells like the '90s. Maybe so, but this unique medley proved that the "Boyz" were more "Men" while singing a cappella on the first part; they always sounded better without instruments. They even performed this "Silent Night" version on a Christmas-themed episode of "The Fresh Prince of Bel Air." (Now it really smells like the '90s.) And as we now all know, even though they were the special guest stars, the band descended into relative obscurity while star Will Smith skyrocketed to A-list movie fame. Apparently, one Christmas Carol wasn't enough for the boy/man band, so in the generous spirit of the holidays, you got two for the price of one with this selection. Being a hybrid song, the "Let It Snow" capper was predictably funky, in that "I-wanna-get-close-to-you-by-the-fireside" kinda way. Dated or not, this band knew how to turn on the heat and provide the soundtrack to your winter snuggling.

7. "I Wish It Could Be Christmas All Year Long" - Larry Groce

If you're a Christian, you believe Christmas celebrates the time when your God was a child. In other words, it's a time to remember what it was like to be a kid again, and when I was one, I played the record (remember those?) "Disney's Merry Christmas Carols" nonstop during the month of December, to the increasing annoyance of my parents. My favorite song happened to be an original, though I didn't realize it at the time. Like the best Christmas carols, "I Wish It Could Be Christmas All Year Long" is that perfect combo of longing lyrics and warm, wistful music that serve such cathartic comfort for lonely winter nights. Sure, some of the words are cheesy ("I wish that every spirit in the world could feel the power/and know love not once a year but every minute, every hour"), but when you're eight years-old, it's one of the deepest things you've ever heard. I guarantee you've never heard this one before, but once you do, it'll instantly sound familiar, like a classic you've known for years. Luckily for me, it already is.

6. "I Still Believe in Santa Claus" €“Joey McIntyre

Yes, that Joey McIntyre. The one from New Kids on the Block. Now we enter surreal territory, as this is where I'm going to lose half my readers, but hear me out! Speaking of playing childhood records nonstop, my sister, as most of her friends did at the time, played this New Kids Christmas album, "Merry, Merry Christmas" over and over, and this was my favourite song off it, if for no other reason than my nostalgic memories of it and the fact that the song itself is about nostalgia. McIntyre was wishing he was still a kid again while I was still a kid myself listening to it. I told you this would be a surreal entry. "Funky, Funky Xmas" was the more popular song on the album (and yes, after 25 years, it's still a terrible title), but "I Still Believe in Santa Claus" was just hokey enough€”but not too much to be maudlin€”to pull my young heartstrings. On it, McIntyre, the youngest member of the group, sings, "I still believe in Santa Claus/Maybe that's just because/I'm still a child at heart." Never mind the fact that little Joey was barely past puberty when he recorded the song, so he was technically still a child, but over the years, the song still resonates for me, especially considering the fact I'm definitely not a child anymore, yet there's that excited 10 year old in me that awakens every Christmas.

5. "Oh, What a Merry Christmas Day" €“from "Mickey's Christmas Carol"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D9zXG958Aq4 I know there are 18,000 different versions of A Christmas Carol, including a Muppet version, one with a CGI Jim Carrey, a "special Christmas episode" of every single sitcom ever created, and even a clunker romantic comedy called Ghosts of Girlfriends Past, but "Mickey's Christmas Carol" was my favorite. I used to own an audiotape featuring the whole story plus additional dialogue and songs, which I suppose would be considered "deleted scenes" these days. While the extra tunes "Being Tight Is Not Alright" and "This Is the Way Christmas Ought to Be" haven't exactly become lasting standards, the animated special did preserve "Oh, What a Merry Christmas Day," by far the best and understandably only one they kept for the video, and it has become one of my favorite Christmas carols of all time. I believe this was also the first cartoon to introduce Scrooge McDuck, and with a name like "Scrooge," you know he had to be in this story. McDuck would go on to star in "Duck Tales," one of my favorite shows as a kid, which even became a theatrical movie, so this special has always been an essential part of my video collection. Despite being a Disney toon, the voice acting is quite convincing, and the story is surprisingly moving. (Just try not to well up with tears as Mickey's Bob Cratchit looks longingly at Tiny Tim's grave in the end). Of course, it helps that the original Charles Dickens classic is my favourite story, though not favourite book, of all time.

4. "Even a Miracle Needs a Hand" €“from "Twas the Night Before Christmas"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2kRt1gbUXJg While we're on the subject of songs from Christmas specials, "Even a Miracle Needs a Hand" from "'Twas the Night Before Christmas" may be the granddaddy of them all, second only to "Christmas Time Is Here" from the perennial "A Charlie Brown Christmas" special, but unlike that tune, this one isn't overplayed. Ironically, the lyrics have nothing to do with Christmas, but the clever alliteration still kills me: "You hope, and I'll hurry/You pray, while I'll plan." This special not only incorporated the familiar elements of the poem, it built its own unique backstory. But if the cute, clever story of a small town trying to win Santa's affection again wasn't enough, this show boasts three toe-tapping songs that are insanely catchy, and my favorite is this one. To me, it's so much more than a song; it's practically a way of life: You can't just sit on your butt waiting for miracles to happen. Sometimes you have to give them a push in the right direction. In other words, the cliché is true: "God helps those who help themselves."

3. "That Spirit of Christmas" €“Ray Charles

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dWmgTXuNoRY We're back to somber Christmas ballads. You may remember this one from National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation, underscoring perhaps the only peaceful moment in an otherwise frenetic, maniacal comedy. Ray Charles' legendary voice in "That Spirit of Christmas" is matched only by his backing band, which concludes with, naturally, a gospel choir. Probably my favorite part is how he sings the line, "Taking a walk through the snow." He almost shouts it, unable to contain his joy for the coming Christmas season. It's heartening sometimes how something so simple as walking through the snow can become powerful, beautiful moments, and Charles flawlessly nails the delivery. Driving the song's point home, Charles and his band recount how "truly amazing" this time of year is, that is, if you don't let endless commercials and crazed shoppers discourage you of course. It's a battle we seem to be losing every year, but it's still one worth fighting.

2. "Christmas Is Here" €“Desiree Goyette and Ed Bogas

This song is better known as the tune from "A Garfield Christmas." Since I was a kid of the '80s, I cherished everything Garfield, including the comic books, all the specials, and even the stuffed animals. This one was my second favorite Garfield special (just behind the Halloween one), and today, I own an animation cel from this production and proudly display it on the wall of my "man cave" (Every guy needs one!) The scene with Grandma rocking with Garfield in her chair and quietly reminiscing about her long-departed husband gets me every time. And the songs here by long-time Garfield collaborators Desiree Goyette and Ed Bogas are some of the best you'll find in a holiday show. By far, my favorite song in this special by the Goyette-Bogas songwriting team is "Christmas Is Here," which is suspiciously titled like the one from the Charlie Brown special, I suppose hoping to ape its success. And while it never did reach the former song's popularity, it never fails to draw at least one tear from me upon each annual viewing of the show, especially in light of its last line: "Keep Christmas here...in your heart." As an added Christmas treat, the singer and songwriter ended up marrying each other and€”two decades later€”are still happily married. Aw.

1. "What Child Is This" €“Dar Williams

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1A3i0GATnRI I first heard this song on a charity CD named "A Home for the Holidays" that I was given to review when I was the Features Editor of my college newspaper, and it quickly became my favourite track off the album. There are many versions of the classic "What Child Is This," but Dar Williams' haunting take is probably one of the best. Her soulful voice is perfectly paired with the angelic anthem, as she serenades the newly born Jesus. Towards the beginning, her sultry vocals almost break as she poignantly recounts the story of Christ's birth: "This, this is Christ the King/whom shepherds guard and angels sing." This song can melt any cynic's heart. It seems aimed at people like me who feel Christmas has been completely commercialized to an insane degree, e.g., Black Friday has now become Black Thursday, in essence taking over Thanksgiving. The commercialisation of Christmas was a semi-novel observation when "A Charlie Brown Christmas" first aired 48 years ago, but now it's gone way past the point of parody. (Even last week's "South Park" episode seemed exhausted dissecting Black Friday.) This song reminds me to slow down and at least attempt to contemplate the reason for the season. To me, this song really is "what Christmas is all about," to quote Linus from the aforementioned Peanuts special; it seamlessly juxtaposes Jesus' divinity with his humanity: "Raise, raise your song on high/while Mary sings a lullaby." Just beautiful. So which quirky Christmas carols capture your fancy? If you're man€”or woman€”enough, reveal your guilty pleasures in the comments below.

In this post: 
video
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Michael Perone has written for The Baltimore Sun, Baltimore City Paper, The Island Ear (now titled Long Island Press), and The Long Island Voice, a short-lived spinoff of The Village Voice. He currently works as an Editor in Manhattan. And he still thinks Michael Keaton was the best Batman.