10 Darkest Rock Music Masterpieces

Hear some of the bleakest and most brilliant songs rock music has to offer.

Funkadelic Maggot Brain
Westbound

At what point did rock music embrace the darkness? It's an intriguing question. Folk music, of course, has long recorded both the joys and the sadness of life, the triumphs and the tragedies, but it's arguably not until we reach the 1960s, when the scope of popular music expanded thanks to far-reaching artists and bands such as Bob Dylan and The Beatles, that the first of rock's bleak masterpieces slouched forth from the shadows.

What was behind this? A disillusionment with politics, perhaps. The Cold War, Vietnam, the assassination of JFK, rising civil unrest in both the UK and USA - these elements, together with the vital ingredient of LSD, all seem likely contributing factors.

This should not be taken as meaning that foreboding thoughts and outputs of bleak creative expression did not exist until this point. The worlds of literature and art had long sought to embrace, and thereby understand, the darker side of human thought and existence. It simply took popular music longer to catch up.

Given that rock music, as we know it, didn't really exist until the 1950s, it should be no surprise that it took some time for more nuanced works to emerge. When they did, however, rock once again proved itself one of the most potent and direct forms of communication. The ten songs listed below represent some of the best, bleakest music ever cut into vinyl.

10. Beautiful Child - Swans

Never noted for their accessibility or their optimism, New York band Swans, who formed in the early '80s, managed the enviable accomplishment of earning a loyal fan base over their 15-year life-span, despite (or perhaps because of) their ever-changing sound. With a new Swans album, the only thing you could be sure of is that it would, at the very least, be interesting and earnest.

Beautiful Child comes from their fifth studio release, 1987s Children Of God. Built upon an unsettling, uneven rhythm which sits somewhere between a funeral procession and grand opera, Beautiful Child contains more jagged edges than a smashed bottle. Singer Michael Gira declaims like some desperate evangelist from a deranged cult as the song strides forward with the terrifying inevitability of a Viking longship heading towards an unguarded settlement.

As with every track presented here, you can't deny the craft and vision behind Beautiful Child. Swans, as ever, tackle the song with complete commitment and belief. Are those gunshots or firecrackers at the beginning of this track?


9. Jonestown - Chrome

San Francisco may not be especially noted for its contributions to post-punk, but Chrome, who formed there in 1976, represent some of the best elements to be found in that genre, namely a refreshing, no-nonsense attitude blended with articulate, wide-ranging vision and a willingness to explore every avenue available

Chrome are one of those outfits whose self-created world never sounds anything but original and immediately identifiable. Unsurprisingly, their music, which verged towards industrial and refused to conform, found little commercial success, although they did build up a cult following in the UK and Germany.

Jonestown hails from Chrome's fourth studio album, 1980's Red Exposure. It's a eerie, unnerving piece, which lurches along like a grave-robber creeping through late-night streets. Perhaps only The Residents can equal Chrome for such inventive madness. Chrome could certainly up the energy when required, spitting out motorik rhythms and punk vocals, but Jonestown displays the dark heart which beats at the centre of this innovative band,


8. Frankie Teardrop - Suicide

Treading the maddening boundaries between installation art and art-music, US duo Suicide, who released their self-titled debut in 1977 (but were active from the start of that decade) were totally committed to their sound, which included proto drum-machines, synthesizers, skittering, ghostly vocals and experimental production techniques.

The band became infamous for its confrontational live shows during which, according to legend, vocalist Alan Vega would sometimes bolt the doors to prevent the audience from leaving. Frankie Teardrop, which hails from that debut record, is the perfect example of a Suicide track – unsettling, challenging and fascinating.

The song concerns the story of an impoverished young father who murders his wife and child before committing suicide. Quite apart from the decidedly bleak lyrics, Frankie Teardrop unnerves the listener thanks to its circling buzz-saw keys and piston-like electronic beat. Vega's deeply unsettling screams and unflinching lyrical detail make for a hard listen. Nevertheless, Suicide's legacy of influence on all manner of bands to come remains indisputable.


7. New Dawn Fades - Joy Division

It may seem like something of a cheap shot including a track by UK post-punk outfit, Joy Division, given the much-publicised suicide of lead singer, Ian Curtis, on the eve of the band's first US tour in 1980, but the fact is Joy Division recorded some of the most brilliant, artfully made, yet darkly emotional music to come from that period or, in fact, any other.

Alongside Curtis, Bernard Sumner handled guitar, Peter Hook bass, and Stephen Morris drums. Following Curtis' death, Sumner, Hook and Morris went on to form another legendary post-punk band: New Order. New Dawn Fades, which received renewed attention in the mid-90s thanks to a creditable Moby cover, is taken from Joy Division's debut album, Unknown Pleasures, released in 1979.

Joy Division were masters of doing a lot with a little, and their spectral, skeletal sound influenced a host of great bands to come. Starting with a drawling, backwards sample, New Dawn Fades evolves from a rattling, skittering drum-beat and twin-layered guitar riffs which seem to summon up the entirety of human pathos and drama.


6. The End - The Doors

Was there ever a band more destined to spiritually tear itself apart as The Doors, or a frontman so mystically alluring and repulsively self-destructive as Jim Morrison? Morrison, a poster-boy for dorm-rooms across the world, was far from a peaceful prophet, and his yin-yang nature lies at the heart of every great Doors' track.

Equal parts narcissist, wise-man, misogynist, lover, poet, drug fiend, embracing and insular, Morrison spurred The Doors to some incredible dark-tinged psychedelic heights. The band conjured up many pop-rock gems full of invention and hooks, but for every sparkling Moonlight Drive, there exists a disturbing detour into Horse Latitudes.

The sprawling, eleven-minute long, The End, taken from the band's self-titled 1967 debut album, maps out a spine-tingling journey into one long bad trip, infamously reaching a crescendo with Morrison's words: “Father? Yes, son? I want to kill you. Mother? I want to...” Morrison himself was always ambiguous as to the true meaning and intent of the song, but what can't be denied is the track's enduring power to both mesmerize and distress.


5. Still There'll Be More - Procol Harum

Best known for their 1967 hit single, A Whiter Shade Of Pale (which sold over ten million copies), the UK's Procol Harum remain a seriously underrated outfit. They embraced the questing nature of prog rock, certainly, together with elements of classical and psychedelic music, but Procol Harum, at heart, were an excellent R&B/blues band full of swagger and invention.

Like many a band with psychedelic influences, Procol Harum's music often ventured into dark waters, charting surreal fantasies which often displayed bleak turns and chilling visions. Still There'll Be More, which comes from the band's fourth album, Home (1970) is something of an anomaly on this list in that, in terms of composition and arrangement, it's an upbeat number.

A close listen to the lyrics, however, and you will understand why Still There'll Be More qualifies here: “I'll waylay your daughter and kidnap your wife, savage her sexless and burn out her eyes. I'll blacken your Christmas and piss on your door, you'll cry out for mercy, but still there'll be more...” For further disturbing adventures, listen also to Dead Man's Dream, from that same album.


4. Permafrost - Magazine

Often overshadowed by their 1978 debut album, Real Life, English post-punk band Magazine's second studio release, 1979's Secondhand Daylight, although not packed with as many memorable hooks as its predecessor, still makes for a potent listening experience. Magazine formed in 1977, with ex-Buzzcock Howard Devoto at the helm.

Devoto recruited John McGeoch on guitar, Barry Adamson on bass, Dave Formula on keys and Martin Jackson on drums. The band's debut album brought a modest hit with the single, Shot By Both Sides but, for their follow-up effort, Magazine upped the synthesizer quotient and aimed, in part, for more slow-burning, introspective material.

Permafrost is a great example of the latter. A glacial chunk of smoldering power, the track drifts like an iceberg pre-destined to collide with a cruise liner. Snarling guitar riffs add tension, minor synth chords appear like storm-clouds, and the song's unsettling, ambiguous lyrics are delivered with icy detachment. “As the day starts dead, at the place where we're lost...”


3. Song Of Joy - Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds

For this list, you could possibly pick a track from any of the many albums by cult Australian band, Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds. One of the most audaciously original post-punk groups to have emerged anywhere in the world, Cave's highly literary and highly unconventional lyrics, together with the band's resolutely idiosyncratic music, place NCATBS high on the list of critically-acclaimed groups.

The ironically-named Song of Joy features on the band's ninth studio album, 1996's Murder Ballads, which consisted of a mix of traditional numbers and original compositions, all fitting within the titular genre – songs which describe the details of violent crimes of passion. This is an old tradition within popular music, and Nick Cave and co provide the perfect vehicle for a such a project.

Song of Joy is shockingly bleak and explicit, containing such lines as: “Joy had been bound with electrical tape, In her mouth a gag, she'd been stabbed repeatedly, and stuffed into a sleeping bag.” In lesser hands, this might have been a crass curio, but in NCATBS's hands, the song is a highly affecting, terrifying, but never sensationalist experience.


2. Seventh Seal - Scott Walker

Setting aside the later albums of unique singer-songwriter, Scott Walker (many of which could fill every slot in this list on their own), 1969s Scott 4 (actually his fifth studio release) is home to one of Walker's most-celebrated and most interesting numbers.

Seventh Seal, inspired by the astonishing 1957 Ingmar Bergman film of the same name, charts the story of a disillusioned knight, returned from the crusades, as he journeys through a land decimated by plague. In both the film and the song, the knight plays, and loses, a literal game of chess with Death.

Walker was an innovative song-writer from the start, tackling subjects and themes few, if any, of his peers ventured to cover. Scott 4 was his first album to consist entirely of original compositions, and Seventh Seal marks an early high point in the artist's long and controversial career. With it's Spanish/Mexican horns, rolling rhythms and beautiful strings, the song makes this list thanks to its doom-laden lyrics and unnerving undertones.


1. Maggot Brain - Funkadelic

Led by the irrepressible George Clinton, Funkadelic (sometimes known as Parliament, or Parliament-Funkadelic) laid down the gold standard for psychedelic funk-rock during the 1970s. Featuring the mercurial talent of guitarist Eddie Hazel, plus a rotating line-up of always-excellent players, Clinton and co constructed a unique and outlandish, groove-laden galaxy of mother-ships, extravagant stage-shows and far-out, theatrical costumes.

Extended jams were bread and butter to these funk-masters but, amongst their sizeable discography, nothing quite comes close to the grand weirdness of Maggot Brain. This ten-minute masterpiece, taken from the band's 1971 album of the same name, has become a part of rock-mythology.

Partly this is due to Clinton's famous exhortation to Eddie Hazel to “play like his mother had died.” Then too, there is the uncorroborated rumour that the song's title references Clinton's gruesome discovery of his brother's dead and decomposed body. Whatever the truth, Maggot Brain deservedly tops this list, thanks both to its deep melancholy and its artistic worth.


Contributor

Chris Wheatley is a journalist and writer from Oxford, UK. He has too many records, too many guitars and not enough cats.