10 Delayed Hard Rock Albums That Weren't Worth The Wait
All That Wait For Nothing.
It's always a shame when a record needs to be pushed back again and again. Here you have a band that just wants to release their music, and some circumstances over money or some diva in the group is preventing it from seeing the light of day. Then again, once the hear the album they were going to release, maybe it was for the best that some of these were kept in the vault.
Compared to what we were used to from these acts, these are the records that feel hollow next to the classics of the genre. Since most of the delays for these albums got fans eager with anticipation, this is where the record is too underwhelming for any of the fans to even care anymore. And at the worst points, some of them are even downright treasonous to what you know these groups for in the first place.
Hell, some of the records don't even have to be all that bad. Some of them might end up sounding pretty good, but when you take into account how long you had to wait, it's not nearly as good as it could have been. While it's good to keep your fans itching for more, these are the records that make us scratch our heads and ask what all that time was spent on.
10. You're Welcome - A Day To Remember
It almost stings putting the most recent entry on this list to something that came out this year. We can all agree that A Day To Remember certainly took their time with this one though, going so far as to delay the album once the pandemic started and than leading off with one lackluster single after another. Once we actually had the album in front of us though, it was liking listening to a totally different band.
From the opening of songs like F.Y.M., this is clearly a quantum leap from the group who brought us albums like Homesick or Common Courtesy just a few years before. While many people have been pointing the finger at them for selling out, it also has a lot to do with them switching labels to Fueled By Ramen, which isn't necessarily known for the millions of metal leaning acts on their roster or anything.
That's not to say that the entire album is without a few bright spots. The amount of love and care that's put into songs like Brick Wall definitely show you that the band still has the chops to make something with the potential to tear your head off. Coming after a record like this though, ADTR definitely have their work cut out for them if they're hoping to transition back to the hard rock side of things.
9. .5 The Gray Chapter - Slipknot
No one can claim to be ready for the release of a new Slipknot album. Compared to the other bands that take their time in between releases, you would swear that these maniacs from Iowa end up going on sabbatical before giving us a nice piece of mayhem to digest. Then again, being away for a while also means having to start from scratch again, which doesn't always yield the best results.
It's not like Slipknot weren't up against adversity here. After firing Joey Jordison and losing Paul Gray to an overdose, this was bound to be a bit shaky from the outset. And the truth really sets in once the songs start, with most of them feeling more like the band purging their emotion rather than focusing on making a new version of Iowa. There are even some more pop leaning material such as Killpop, which was probably disheartening for people still pining for a sequel to the Heretic Anthem.
When you look back on the development though, that wasn't really the point of this album. Looking to pay tribute to their fallen bandmates, this feels more like a way to get one last connection with one of the most important people in your life. In that respect, .5 the Gray Chapter is a necessary chapter in Slipknot's discography...just not something to be repeated again.
8. The Trilogy - Green Day
Green Day have more than earned their right not to be rushed through the recording process. Since they have reinvented what the look of punk was going to be two times over on Dookie and American Idiot, these are clearly guys who are only making music for themselves at this point. Still, selling a trilogy of albums in this market feels like way too much Green Day all at once.
Being in production hell for the better part of 2 years, most of these tracks tend to feel half finished, which is definitely not a good sign when you realize the combined length of these things is two hours long. While the Green Day that everyone knows is still in there somewhere, this is some of the most underwhelming songs that they've offered, and in the worst cases some of the worst songs they've made like Nightlife.
By the time that Billie Joe Armstrong checked himself into rehab, the idea of stretching the release dates out didn't make any sense, with Tre being rush released towards the tail end of 2012 without so much as a proper music video to go with any of the songs. That says more about what they thought than they probably realized. These weren't albums that they had too much heart and soul. They were albums that were sent kicking and screaming out the door.
7. Nostradamus - Judas Priest
The idea of Judas Priest going in a more conceptual direction sounds like it should be the easiest lay up in the world. Since they have already crafted their legacy on some of the most epic songs in metal history, the idea of them making a double album experience all centered around the idea of Nostradamus is the foray into power metal that fans were waiting for. So why is Nostradamus so flabby at the end of the day?
Don't get me wrong. You can still tell that those extended hours in the studio went to good use, with different symphonic elements brought into the mix and sweeping orchestral arrangements across a few tracks. When you break down some of the songs though, there's not nearly as much to hook onto when put against stuff off of Screaming for Vengeance back in the day.
There are a few bright spots to be sure like on Pestilence and Plague, but the title track tends to feel a lot more sludgy than the Priest were intending. By the time you actually finish the record, Priest don't really sound like masters of the universe...they just sound tired. We get that making an album like this can be a rough ride, but if you're sounding tired by the end, just imagine how the audience must be feeling.
6. Carnival Of Souls - KISS
Once the original version of KISS decided to reunite in the late '90s, it felt like their entire career hit the reset button. After over a decade of being out of makeup, the glam rock band that we knew in the midst of the hair metal revolution was washed away in favor of the superheroes who started it all again. They did have one album in the can though, and fans tried their best to actually get it released.
Being the final album recorded by the makeup-less version of the group, Carnival of Souls catches KISS at a strange point of transition in their career. Since their usual party rock sound wasn't en vogue anymore, this is actually one of the few instances where we see what a grunge KISS could look like, with Paul Stanley trading his guitar sound in for licks that could have come off of an Alice in Chains record.
Outside of the obvious genre hopping, it almost makes sense why this album was delayed coming out. Considering that the makeup was about to come back on and the original foursome was going to reunite, why the hell would you want to compete with yourself with two totally different sounding bands? It's definitely a different view of the band who wrote Detroit Rock City, but did we really need to start a petition for glorified grunge B-sides?
5. The Weirdness - Iggy And The Stooges
If the Stooges had decided to just never reunite after the early '70s, they would have gone down in history as one of the most legendary bands in hard rock. With just three albums to their name, the intensity that Iggy Pop displayed across each album paved the way for everything from punk to alternative music later down the line. When the nostalgia bug caught them though, the nightmare that went into the Weirdness was more than most fans could handle.
For most of these albums, you can normally point to one member making a bad decision or a project being doomed by a bad production job. Where the Weirdness falls flat is the oldest excuse in the book: if you don't use it, you lose it. While Iggy could still deliver on the live stage every time he went on, the amount of chaotic noise on this album just feels amateurish rather than something actually fun to listen to.
Even having the inclusion of legendary bassist Mike Watt wasn't really enough to save this album, with most of the lines being either indecipherable or too lackluster to even care about for more than a few seconds. As much as every band deserves a second chance, you need to make sure that whatever gets in your way prevents you from sounding like this.
4. 13 - Black Sabbath
There was more hype and buzz surrounding Black Sabbath's 13 before the record even had a name. Although the actual album didn't come out until June of 2013, the record was in talks ever since the dawn of the '00s, where Sabbath just couldn't get it together long enough to make it into the studio. When we finally got the end product though, it was...fine.
Yeah, there's nothing really more to say about Sabbath's final take with Ozzy behind the mic. This is exactly the kind of Sabbath that you fell in love with back in the day, only more seasoned and with Tony Iommi showing off a few more chops than you would expect from a man who lost the tips of his fingers before even deciding to continue with music full time. The only issue is...that's really all there is.
Compared to the other entries on this list where everything went wrong, 13 is a return to form that plays it a little too safe, often staying in its lane and never really breaking any new ground. Then again, when you have guys who have been in the game this long, you work with the best that you have, and Sabbath should be commended for sounding this good in their old age. Still, with over a decade of anticipation, this is nothing more and nothing less than the Sabbath you know.
3. A Different Kind Of Truth - Van Halen
Van Halen didn't deserve to have their third self titled outing as their swan song. Since their move to something new with Gary Cherone went over about as well as an atheist at a church rally, the kings of glam metal were looking like they were about to slowly fade away into irrelevance. Even when the unthinkable happened when David Lee Roth rejoined the band, the accompanying album was a lot more spotty than you probably remember.
Considering this would be the next Roth fronted album since 1984, there was pretty much no way that A Different Kind of Truth could have worked on that level. When you listen to the record though, there's still that magic in there, with a lot of these songs being relics from the early days dusted off and put into a new context. Now we have a classic Van Halen album...just with all the trappings of a modern Van Halen record.
That's not putting it lightly either. The songs on here sound like they could have been absolutely amazing, but the production doesn't give many opportunities for the bass to shine through and hearing Roth squawk his way through some of the higher passages is a little disheartening for the die hards to really accept. While it doesn't come close to the early days of Van Halen, this is still the best the band could have hoped for for going out on their own terms.
2. St. Anger - Metallica
Since Metallica had just achieved legendary status after the success of the Black Album, the late '90s were the time to get weird. After having a few lackluster releases with Load and Reload, we got everything from an album of cover songs to a complete symphonic live album...just no new album on the horizon. Turns out that there was a reason for the wait though. Metallica were absolutely cratering.
That's not an exaggeration either. In the months leading up to recording St. Anger, everything came to a head at once, from Jason Newsted quitting the band after being mistreated to James Hetfield ditching the rest of the guys to go to rehab and get his life straightened out. By the time everyone was back on firmer ground, the album was more or less completed to make sure that the band still worked as a unit.
Though that would make the album sound like a triumph, St. Anger is by far the worst Metallica record ever made, complete with some of the most questionable production choices that Bob Rock has ever made and the most abrasive drum sounds ever created this side of hitting actual garbage cans. There's no disputing that this album was a necessary endeavor for Metallica to stay alive, and there's also no disputing that half of Metallica's fanbase never wants to hear these songs again.
1. Chinese Democracy - Guns N Roses
And now we've come to one of the biggest delayed albums of all time. The album that stands almost like a legend in rock history for how long fans waited for it to finally be released. Even diehard fans of Tool who complain about the wait for Fear Inoculum can't hold a candle to how eager fans were to hear Guns N Roses Chinese Democracy.
Considering that Guns N Roses had made virtually nothing since the mid '90s, hearing that a new album from Axl Rose and friends should have been a slam dunk. But that phrase "Axl Rose and friends" should have triggered alarm bells, since none of the original GNR swagger is accounted for on here, instead leaving room for Axl to pour over his genius to find something that's worth including on a Guns release.
That's not to say you can't hear the money on the CD, with overdubs on top of overdubs and Axl's voice varying depending on which song you're listening to. There are even a few amazing guitar solos from people like Robin Finck and Bumblefoot, and yet it just feels like something that shouldn't have the name Guns N Roses anywhere near it. You shouldn't judge an album by its backstory, but when you spend over a million dollars over 17 years and deliver an album that's just okay, you totally blew it.