10 Most Depressing Songs Of All Time

Johnny Cash Depressing songs are, paradoxically, great fun to listen to in many cases. Especially if you have had your heart broken and you can sit and wail along to 'All By Myself' by Celine Dion or 'Without You' by Nilsson. But these are just your average typical heartbreak songs. The songs that I have chosen below go beyond being 'sad' songs, they venture into 'depressing the heck out of you' territory. These songs are epic in the scale of their misery, one of them has been virtually accused of inciting suicide. When you get to that stage with a song, you know you are onto a good melancholy fest. Hopefully the list below contains some sorrowful songs you know and 'love'. If you want to contribute your own depressing songs below, hopefully we can get a part two list going with even more misery to wallow to.

10. Sylvia's Mother - Dr Hook

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wrMbPGmluEw "And the operator says 40 cents more for the next three minutes! Pleeeaase Mrs Avery I just got to talk to her!" Dr Hook are extremely popular in Ireland, a nation inclined to country music - especially among the older generations. I grew up listening to Dr Hook and Sylvia's Mother reached number 2 in the British charts, number 5 in the Billboard top 100 and number 1 in the Irish charts in 1972. The song deals with a young man who is pleading with Mrs Avery to let him speak to her daughter Sylvia with whom he had been in a relationship with. The relationship broke up and now he is begging to speak to Sylvia who is getting ready to leave town and go to Galveston, Texas where she is going to marry another man. He is unsuccessful in his badgering of Mrs Avery, he can hear her talking to Sylvia but he never gets to speak to Sylvia himself The song was written by Shel Silverstein and is based on autobiographical fact. Silverstein, who wrote the majority of Dr Hook's lyrics, had been in a relationship with a girl called Sylvia Pandolfi, but they broke up, he tried to revive the relationship but her mother Louisa told him the relationship was over. Sylvia's Mother is a classic country ballad which is probably one of the best songs ever to sing along to, especially whenever you have had a tipple or ten. It is however, a very depressing song which if you listen to the lyrics carefully will have you crying in your pint however cheesy you think Dr Hook are.

9. Total Eclipse Of The Heart - Bonnie Tyler

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lcOxhH8N3Bo "Once upon a time there was love in my life, but now I'm only falling apart. There's nothing I can do.. a total eclipse of the heart" Apparently the nation's favourite song to sing in the shower and it was my late father's favourite song, Total Eclipse of the Heart is a depressing power ballad par excellence written and produced by Jim Steinman for Welsh chanteuse Bonnie Tyler's album Faster Than the Speed of Night. It was released in 1983 and hit the number one spot in both America and Britain. I think I read something years ago about the song costing a fortune to produce. It is heart rending stuff with Tyler basically having a nervous breakdown over a man on vinyl ("Turn around every now and then I get a little bit tired of listening to the sound of my tears"). She pleads with him to come and hold her tight but really deep down, I reckon she knows that her love for this man is redundant and he is not coming back despite her desperate pleas - "I don't know what to do, I'm always in the dark. We're living in a powder keg and giving off sparks. I really need you tonight! Forever's gonna start tonight!" - thus implores Miss Tyler. But there is no hint of a reconciliation and she is left with her "total eclipse of the heart". Total Eclipse of the Heart is a very depressing song and its misery has captured the imagination of recording artists worldwide with many artists covering the song, converting it into different languages etc. An absolutely horrible dance version of the song was released in 1995 by Nicki French. Nobody can beat Bonnie's version - they cannot inject the right powerful misery that Bonnie gave to the song. Turn around bright eyes!

8. At Seventeen - Janis Ian

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhFnOAwr96o "The Valentines I never knew. The Friday nights charades of youth, were spent on one more beautiful. At seventeen I learned the truth" Bitterly depressing fare from Ms Ian, it lingered close to the top of the US charts and won a Grammy. Ms Ian received 461 Valentine cards the year it was released due to her singing about the paucity of Valentines she received as a teenager. The song is basically a lament about being an ugly duckling at high school and all of the misery that it brings. This involves being alone, inventing boyfriends, not being picked for the basketball team. But Ian intimates that the 'beauty queens' do not stay happy for long - they may have the men, but the men are useless and looks fade. So being popular is an illusion and you are maybe better off being a wall flower to retain your integrity and reach realistic goals. Young women and girls who perceive themselves to be unpopular and 'ugly ducklings' have taken great succour from Janice Ian's song over the years. I don't believe what she tells us about love being solely for beauty queens, maybe American High School is tougher than Northern Irish High School. But the song still a fabulously downbeat anthem for the dateless.

7. She's Lost Control - Joy Division

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QVc29bYIvCM "Confusion in her eyes that says it all. She's lost control. And she's clinging to the nearest passerby. She's lost control again" Classic gloom mongering song from Joy Division which appeared and was recorded several times from 1978-1981 and showed up in their seminal album Unknown Pleasures. The title of the song was referred to in the film biopic of Joy Division singer Ian Curtis which was entitled Control. Everything is the song - the bass, drums and guitar are minimalist and Curtis tells a story of a young woman having an epileptic fit (Curtis himself suffered epilepsy and lived in terror of his fits) and how powerless and confused it leaves her. When I first heard the song many moons ago, I thought it was a tale of a woman having a psychotic breakdown, because the words perfectly describe that experience, but no, the song is about epilepsy. She's Lost Control is a dark and despairing song. If that is the way Curtis himself felt about epilepsy, he must have been in Hell. It remains one of Joy Division's most popular songs (along with Love Will Tear Us Apart and Transmission - both of which could have rightly taken up place on this list). This eerie song will make you feel disturbed after listening to it.

6. The River - Bruce Springsteen

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEOiV5eadQk "Now all those things that seemed so important. Well mister they vanished right into the air. Now I act like I don't remember. Mary acts like she don't care" 1981 hit for Bruce Springsteen from his album of the same name. It marked a change in direction for Springsteen - his songs got a lot darker after The River and it paved the way for Nebraska - an album full of depressing ballads and it was inspired by Hank Williams - Godfather of the depressing song. Basically the narrator comes from a small conservative town and economic times are hard. He enjoys going "down to the river" with his sweetheart Mary and swimming in the river with her and then getting jiggy with it. Unfortunately he impregnates Mary and for his 19th birthday he got a "union card and a wedding coat". So he has to marry her and get a job. There is no celebrating of the wedding and the narrator and Mary have to get on with things although their dreams have been crushed. The river remains a symbol of hope for the narrator The River is a great misery filled depression inducing song, from the opening melancholy harmonica to the last lyric. Nobody can tell a story as well as Springsteen - he is the Master Balladeer. It was inspired by his sister and brother in law as a portrait of their early marriage. Springsteen's sister Ginny recently confirmed this in a biography of Springsteen. The miserable story has a happy ending - the pair are still together.

5. Strange Fruit - Billie Holiday

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4ZyuULy9zs "Southern Trees bear a strange fruit. Blood on the leaves and blood on the root. Black bodies swingin' in the Southern breeze. Strange fruit hanging from the poplar trees" In 1999, Time Magazine named it the best song of the 20th Century. It was originally a poem written by a white Jewish school teacher called Abel Meeropol who was a Communist Party member and came from the Bronx. He was disgusted at the lynchings of African Americans in the deep south of America and the poem was his way of expressing his extreme antipathy towards that crime. He set the poem to music and it became something of a protest song. There are conflicting reports on how Billie Holiday was introduced to the song, but she began to sing it in an integrated night club called Cafe Society in 1939. The whole place would come to a standstill when she sang the song. She would close her eyes whilst singing - almost as if she was in prayer. Eventually, after a lot of record companies rejected her, Billie was allowed to sing the song for Commodore Records in 1939 and then again in 1944. The critics loved it and the 1939 version sold over a million records. It remains a terribly sad piece on an horrific time in history where racists could openly get away with the crime of murder. The image of bodies strung up on a tree will surely haunt the listener for a long time. A great song but you wouldn't play it at a birthday party.

4. Tell Laura I Love Her - Ray Peterson/Ricky Valence

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8HIHdCJA8f8 "Tell Laura I love her. Tell Laura I need her. Tell Laura not to cry, my love for her will never die" Teenage tragedy song that captured the public's imagination back in 1960 with different versions coming from Ray Peterson and Richie Valence. The latter singer's version topped the British chart. Peterson's original version was deemed too vulgar and tasteless for the British public and 20,000 copies of the song were destroyed. It certainly is a morbid little song. The basic premise is - a young teenage couple called Tommy and Laura are deeply in love. Tommy wants to propose to Laura and to get the money for a ring, he enters a car racing competition. However his car crashes, explodes and he dies in the race. Laura is sitting in the chapel hearing the words "Tell Laura I Love Her" - which he uttered before he died. If this song doesn't cheer you up, I don't know what will. The song is probably the best known of the teenage tragedy genre which peaked in the late 1950s and early 1960s. If you like Tell Laura I Love Her, check out Teen Angel by Mark Dinning and Last Kiss by Wayne Cochrane (later covered by Pearl Jam) - they are so morbid, I can't wipe this great big grin off my face.

3. Ruby Don't Take Your Love To Town - Kenny Rogers

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C1e9p6J89rQ "And if I could move I'd get my gun and put her in the ground. Oh Ruby, don't take your love to town" Kenny Rogers sings this depressing little ditty about a man who is paralysed after taking part in "that old crazy Asian war". The song was written in 1967, so it's very probable that he is referring to Vietnam. His wife tarts herself up every night and goes out on the town and the man is scared she will "take her love to town" as he cannot sexually satisfy her, this leads to murderous feelings in the man as you can see from the above line of the song. I love Kenny Rogers and I love this song. It was hugely successful upon its release - reaching number 2 in the charts in the UK and number 6 in the Billboard Top 100. It had sold a million copies by the end of the year. Numerous musicians have covered the song including artists as diverse as Waylon Jennings and The Killers. French, German and Czech versions of the song have been recorded as well as an Answer Song called Billy, I've Got to Go To Town was recorded by Geraldine Stevens in which 'Ruby' affirms her love for 'Billy' and assures him she is being faithful. One of the best known country music songs (sure aren't they all depressing anyway?) Ruby, Don't Take Your Love To Town has been bewitching people with its tragic tale of a crippled war veteran and his floozy wife for over 40 years now. The song was a country hit for Johnny Darrell in 1967 but Kenny's version is the best, his voice just sounds totally heartbroken. Kenny owns that song.

2. Hurt - NIN/Johnny Cash

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o22eIJDtKho "And you could have it all, my empire of dirt. I will let you down, I will make you hurt" Taken from the Nine Inch Nails album - The Downward Spiral, Hurt lost out on a Grammy in 1996 by Alanis Morissettes' You Oughta Know. The overall meaning of the song is disputed. Some believe it is a suicide note by the singer and others believe it is an affirmation to keep on living despite being 'hurt'. The lyrics clearly point to heroin abuse and self harm but the song has been covered by people as benign and banal as Leona Lewis! The song was passed into legend by Johnny Cash's version in 2002. Trent Reznor admits that he thought the idea of Cash covering the song was a bit 'gimmicky' but the version blew him away. I think that his craggy vocals and years of hardship with addiction express the lyrics and the sentiment of the song beautifully. It is also pared down to the basics - Johnny with a guitar which makes it even more affecting. It was also a sad farewell from Cash as the video for his version of Hurt shows him looking very ill and frail, and indeed, Cash passed away the next year. A terrific depressing song for drowning your sorrows, hating people, hating the world and just basically to wallow in misery to.

1. Gloomy Sunday - Billie Holiday

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KUCyjDOlnPU "Angels have no thought of ever returning you. Would they be angry if I thought of joining you?" Also known as the Hungarian Suicide Song, Gloomy Sunday was written by a Hungarian composer called Rezso Seress while he was living in Paris in 1932. This was during the Great Depression and political upheaval in Hungary. The lyrics called for an end to man's inhumanity to man and a plea for God for justice. Poet Laszlo Javor, who had just broken up with his fiancee, rewrote the lyrics as a lament for a deceased love one and a pledge to be together with them in the afterworld. The song, recorded by Paul White, was very popular in Hungary but was linked to a rash of suicides. Hordes of people were jumping into the Danube carrying the sheet music. The authorities in Hungary were sufficiently concerned to ban public performances of the song. The whole world jumped on the bandwagon of this notorious Hungarian Suicide Song. It was translated into Russian, French and Japanese. Many different versions existed in the English speaking world but the one we all know and love today was sung by Billie Holiday in 1941. Urban legends abound with this song with stories of suicides and bannings of the song. It was actually banned for a while during World War Two by the BBC as it was thought it was detrimental to public wellbeing and morale. A terrific song to put on and cry your eyes out to if you have just been dumped, Gloomy Sunday is also an anthem for the suicidal and deeply depressed. Few other songs will make such a morbid impact on you (unless you listen to death metal) and a little tear might fall from your eye...

In this post: 
Johnny Cash
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

My first film watched was Carrie aged 2 on my dad's knee. Educated at The University of St Andrews and Trinity College Dublin. Fan of Arthouse, Exploitation, Horror, Euro Trash, Giallo, New French Extremism. Weaned at the bosom of a Russ Meyer starlet. The bleaker, artier or sleazier the better!