10 Failed Albums That Became Cult Classics

Not every classic earns the title straight away.

The Ramones
Sire

Some say that each generation of music is best defined by the amount and quality of classics that it produces. Occasionally, an album may seem like it's on track for legendary status, then it suddenly falls off the face of the earth. In the opposite incidence, an album may fail to make even the faintest of splashes on the music industry at first, then it suddenly explodes in popularity and earns the right to call itself a cult classic.

A few bands in music's complex and detailed history have had the great fortune of falling into immediate fame with a critically acclaimed international smash hit record. Bands like Guns n Roses, Sex Pistols and Linkin Park for example. Some iconic bands did not have this luxury however and had to wait years, even decades, before their work received the credit and praise they deserved...

10. Megadeth - Killing Is My Business... And Business Is Good!

When Dave Mustaine was kicked out of a young up and coming thrash band called Metallica in the early 80's, it seemed that he would become a footnote name in the careers of an ultra famous metal band. Evidently, this proved to be completely false, as Mustaine struck back at his former band mates by forming the now legendary thrash tyrants, Megadeth. Although, Megadeth's rise to fame certainly did not get the same flying start as Metallica.

With a budget of just $8,000, Megadeth had to write, record and produce their debut record in a matter of months. The low budget of the album was reflected by the original cover art, which Combat (Megadeth's label) made using a plastic skull and tin foil shades despite protests from both Dave Mustaine and David Ellefson. Even with such a low budget, the record failed to return a profit or any notable success, peaking at #169 in US Billboard charts and #149 in the UK album chart.

'Killing is my Business' didn't start to gain a more worthy reputation until as early as 2002, when the re-mastered and remixed version of the record was released (with an alternative cover of course). The original fuzzy and cheap sounding recording had been replaced by the crisp, roaring Megadeth sound we're all familiar with today and the legacy was finally solidified.


9. Nine Inch Nails - Pretty Hate Machine

'Pretty Hate Machine' is the humble debut record from the industrial rock behemoths, Nine Inch Nails. As the album that kick started one of the biggest careers in industrial music history, it seems hard to believe that this record had such a mixed reputation for so long.

Nine Inch Nails front man, Trent Reznor, was initially signed by TVT Records as a solo act after they received his self-recorded demo in early 1989. Reznor worked with a number of producers and recruited a handful of musicians for the official recording (although he did most of the recording by himself), which mainly consisted of re-recorded versions of the demo tracks.

'Pretty Hate Machine' peaked at #75 on the US Billboard chart which certainly isn't bad for an independently released debut record. But, the records issues were more deep rooted than this with one critic calling the album a 'parody' of New Order. When talking about the recording process in a 1991 interview, Reznor went on record saying it 'totally sucked' and that it made him feel withdrawn and introverted.

However, the album quickly gained a huge underground following and in 1995, it became one of the first independent records ever to achieve platinum certification in the US.


8. Magazine - Real Life

Released among a thick cloud of punk rock classics in 1978, it's easy to see why 'Real Life' struggled to gain much notable attention or praise upon its unveiling to the world. Even though calling this album a failure is possibly quite harsh, it's initial impact on the scene is still dwarfed massively by its current cult classic stature.

As the debut record from post-punk and new wave band, Magazine, 'Real Life' took the idea of punk rock and completely changed its perspective and message. The raw, adrenaline pumping two-minutes of fury punk rock aggression had been replaced by an atmospheric, broader sounding tone. At the time, this was an extremely progressive record and it still holds up today.

Peaking at #29 in the UK albums chart and the lead single, 'Shot by Both Sides' just missed out on a place in the UK top 40 singles chart. The legacy of this album has grown far beyond this initial moderate success, and is considered by many music journalists and critics as an essential record in music history. It is also viewed as an integral release in the history of post-punk and a key figure in the sub-genres formation in the early 80's.


7. The Clash - The Clash

Hailed by some as one of the best punk groups of all time, The Clash were iconic figures in the genre for some years before slowly evolving into a more radio friendly, commercial rock style. The foundations for The Clash's career were laid in 1977 by their self-titled debut record. But, at the time of its release there was little evidence that The Clash had a bright future ahead of them.

The content of the record was considered far too controversial for airplay by most radio stations, meaning the band missed out on vital exposure. Songs such as 'Remote Control', 'I'm So Bored With the USA' and 'White Riot' struck nerves with some fans, but the album still managed good reviews from critics despite missing out on the top 10 in the UK albums chart.

'The Clash' didn't chart in the US until 1979 due to its delayed release date and even then it only peaked at #126 in the US Billboard chart. However, The Clash quickly gained a large following thanks to the records that followed such as 'Give 'Em Enough Rope' and 'London Calling', meaning their debut record soon started to gain traction among fans. 'The Clash' is now a certified gold record in both USA and Britain.


6. Bad Brains - Bad Brains

From 1982, 'Bad Brains' is often hailed as being one of the key albums that brought the hardcore punk movement to life. Alongside titles such as 'Damaged' by Black Flag and 'Fresh Fruit for Rotting Vegetables' by Dead Kennedys, 'Bad Brains' has gradually built a great legacy over the years. It wasn't always this way however, as Bad Brains' debut record struggled in many respects upon its 1982 release.

When the record was first released, it was only available on cassette format which immediately alienated it from the then huge vinyl collecting audience. It gained some interest in the UK however, after the Bad Brains song 'Pay to Cum' was featured on a vinyl compilation album by Jello Biafra's Alternative Tentacles. This compilation titled 'Let Them Eat Jellybeans!' included songs from other familiar punk rock names such as Dead Kennedys, D.O.A, Circle Jerks and Half Japanese.

In the current hardcore punk scene, 'Bad Brains' gets much more recognition. It is sometimes credited as being the first album to merge elements from hard rock and reggae, which evidently opened the door for ragga metal. Because of this, band such as Skindred and Fishbone can trace their lineage back to Bad Brains. Other musicians such as Foo Fighters' Dave Grohl and Beastie Boys' Dave Yauch have also praised the album heavily.


5. The Zombies - Odessey And Oracle

As the oldest record to feature on this list, 'Odessey and Oracle' has had to persevere through multiple decades to earn its reputation as a cult classic. This status is made even more impressive considering the lukewarm reception the album received upon its initial release in 1968.

With the majority of the album being recorded at Abbey Road, expectations for the albums performance upon release were high. Sadly, The Zombies' second studio album bombed with critics and didn't perform much better among fans. The bands debut full-length record from 1965 titled 'Begin Here' had clearly set the bar too high for fans after it was (at the time) compared to albums such as 'Rubber Soul' by The Beatles.

However, 1969 saw the single 'Time of the Season' suddenly become a huge hit in North America seemingly out of the blue. The album itself failed to chart but the single managed to reach #1 in the Canadian singles chart and #3 in the US Billboard Hot 100 chart. This shock success was too little too late however, as The Zombies split up shortly before the album was released and the songs from this record were not performed live by the original line-up until 1997.


4. Ramones - Ramones

Punk rock was an enormous, industry enveloping phenomena in the late 70's thanks to bands such as Sex Pistols, The Clash and The Damned. But, the band who triggered the entire movement didn't enjoy even half the commercial success of the bands they directly influenced.

Ramones kick started punk rock in 1976 with their ground-breaking self-titled record but, the stunning primordial soup of punk went almost entirely unnoticed by the global music scene. However, Ramones started to gain a reputation soon after by supporting the Flamin' Groovies for an iconic show at London's Roundhouse in the same year. Almost everyone in attendance for this show went on to form a punk band including names such as Sex Pistols, The Ruts, The Damned and The Adverts.

Despite this genre launching performance, 'Ramones' still remained an incredibly underrated record and it didn't achieve gold certification in the US until 2014. Sadly, the legacy and influence this record had was not witnessed by most of the masterminds behind it with Joey, Johnny and Dee Dee Ramone all passing away years prior. Only Tommy Ramone from the bands original line-up lived to see 'Ramones' receive gold certification, but even he died less than one month later.


3. David Bowie - The Man Who Sold The World

Few artists in music history can claim to have covered such a diverse range of genres as David Bowie. Throughout his decorated career, Bowie released 27 studio albums in a recording career spanning for almost 50 years. In that time, Bowie made some famously groundbreaking records that had an instant impact on music and pop culture as a whole.

However, one of these instant classic, mainstream radio dominating records was not 1970's 'The Man Who Sold the World'. As Bowie's third studio record, this was his final release before he was launched to super stardom by 1971's 'Hunky Dory'. Upon it's initial release, 'TMWSTW' failed to chart anywhere and received mixed critical reception, especially in the UK.

As Bowie's hidden treasure at the time, this album had to wait a further two years before it started to gain traction, making it to #24 in the UK albums chart upon its 1972 re-release. However, success in the US had to wait further still as the same re-release only managed to reach #105 in the US Billboard chart.

However, the modern music scene views this album as iconic and is seen by some as the first of Bowie's 'classic' albums. It has also been credited as a huge influence on artists such as Gary Numan, The Cure and Siouxsie and the Banshees. On top of this, it is widely considered as one of the earliest inspirations over the eventual rise of the dark wave genre.


2. Nirvana - Bleach

It's hard to believe this now platinum selling release hardly made a splash in 1989 considering the monumental career it sparked. Featuring the bands first single, 'Love Buzz', 'Bleach' was the bands debut album and hit record store shelves on 15th June 1989.

Nirvana's record label, Sub Pop, had only requested an EP from the band following the release of 'Love Buzz' as a single, but the band insisted on releasing a full studio record. Initially, Nirvana's decision to go all out with a full record backfired massively as sales flopped. Despite receiving generally good reviews from the handful of critics who covered it, 'Bleach' managed a meagre return in sales and didn't make it into any charts.

However, the cult classic appeal of this album began when Nirvana broke into the mainstream rock spectrum with their second album, 'Nevermind', in 1991. Naturally, this colossal grunge rock classic not only elevated the band to astonishing heights of fame, but also increased the reputation of their small back catalogue. The 1992 re-release of 'Bleach' made it into the top 50 of album charts around the world, reaching #89 in the US Billboard charts.

Fun fact: Nirvana started recording 'Bleach' on Christmas Eve, 1988.


1. The Velvet Underground - The Velvet Underground & Nico

Originally forming in 1964, The Velvet Underground took three years to finally release their debut record. The banana fronted record might an iconic, offbeat and idolised classic nowadays, but upon its release this album was a financial disaster.

The Velvet Underground experienced a rather uneventful first few years as a band, chopping and changing band members and recording their initial demo music in the loft of Lou Reed's apartment. Their career began to pick up in 1965 when 1960's cultural icon Andy Warhol obtained a copy of their demo. He immediately decided he would be their manager and teamed the group up with German singer, Nico.

However, the mainstream appeal attached to Andy Warhol was not enough to bring immediate success and fame to The Velvet Underground. The album was a commercial flop, peaking at 171 in the US Billboard charts and it was rejected for airplay by almost every radio station it was sent to. The controversial content of the record also led its banning from numerous record stores and magazines refusing to advertise or promote it.

However, over a decade later in the late 70's, rock critics began to change their tune regarding the then underrated release, praising it immensely. This proved to be a catalyst in the record steady rise to fame and its current status as one of the most influential records in rock history.


Watch Next


In this post: 
The Ramones
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Hi everyone, I'm a signed author and journalist. Despite my main area of expertise being rock music, I have an interest in loads of other subjects like films, TV series, sports and of course, wrestling.