10 Great Bands Almost Ruined By Their Frontmen

All it takes is a dodgy front car to derail the whole train.

WikipediaWikipediaRock 'n' roll is a funny game. Those of us not fortunate enough to be paid bucket-loads of cash to travel around the world and play songs to adoring fans are left to simply try and appreciate said rock 'n' rollers, but it's not always that easy. If a band is just comprised of just a few of your average 'blokes' (The Enemy, Ocean Colour Scene, Kings of Leon), then they tend to be frightfully boring and rather square, and who wants to go and watch a bunch of squares? But on the flip-side, if the band is full of hell-raising, anti-establishment prima donnas (remember Towers of London?), most people will think of them as idiots anyway. It's a fine line between humdrum and douchebagery, and unfortunately some have a hard job recognising that, resulting in some pretty childish and petulant behaviour at times. Remember when Liam Gallagher skipped Oasis' MTV Unplugged gig in 1996, only to sit up in the rafters whilst heckling his own bandmates? Or when Billie Joe Armstrong complained about his own show running over its allotted time in 2012? Whether it's turning up late, foul-mouthed rants, preaching religion, drug-addled unreliability, egotistical arrogance, or just the sheer act of being rubbish, there are some pretty poor frontmen out there, and they unfortunately tend to ruin it for the rest of their bandmates (the guys who nobody remembers as it is). Here are ten of the finest idiots in rock today.

10. Lostprophets - Ian Watkins

WikipediaWikipediaLet's get this one out of the way early. It makes for morbid reading, but literally nobody can contest Watkins' place in this list. Convicted of 13 charges of sexual assault in late 2013, the Welsh singer committed crimes that we all thought too awful to be true - many fans were in denial for months - and subsequently destroyed a band once adored by millions. Upon news of his conviction, his bandmates issued a somber statement reading, "It€™s still hard to believe this is happening and that someone we were once so close to has destroyed so many lives, lying every step of the way." The true extent of Watkins' crimes may never be fully made public, but thankfully his sentencing of almost 30 years in jail ensures his removal as a danger to the public, and can help bring closure to what must have been an incredibly traumatic time for his family, friends, and most importantly, his victims. The rest of his Lostprophets bandmates are seeking their own musical closure by forming new group No Devotion with Geoff Rickly, the former frontman of American post-hardcore band Thursday. Hopefully they can find success with their new venture, and not have their own careers ruined by the disgusting acts of one individual.

9. The Libertines - Pete Doherty

WikipediaWikipediaThe recently-reformed four-piece may technically have two frontmen in Pete Doherty and Carl Barat, but it's only Doherty who deserves to be on this list. Frequent late arrivals and no-shows are only bested by his many shambolic, drunken performances throughout his career. Whether he was murdering T. Rex's 'Children of the Revolution' with Elton John at Live 8, or having his other band, Babyshambles, walk off stage within 45 minutes on many of their recent tour dates, Doherty's crimes against music and human decency far outweigh his few contributions to '00s pop culture. Indeed, a legacy that has been formed out of soldier jackets, talking like chimney sweeps, and being crap at your instrument because "that's real, man" has gone a surprisingly long way. Walk down Camden high street and you'll encounter many a brainwashed soul sporting a pork pie hat and a 'Libertine' tattoo - but his public exploits and infamous narcotic-related episodes (including forcing his cat to inhale from a crack pipe, and bringing heroin into a court room) have earned him a dire reputation. Outside of the Libs' faithful/naive fanbase, most have had enough of Doherty's schtick, and the 'Bard of Albion' is gaining irrelevancy by the minute.

8. Bon Jovi - Jon Bon Jovi

WikipediaWikipediaIt takes a special kind of idiot to make an '80s pop-rock band even worse, but if anyone can manage it, it's Jon Bon Jovi. The man that's lived on a prayer, gone down in a blaze of glory, been wanted dead or alive, laid us down on a bed of roses and been shot through the heart (only in a lyrical sense, unfortunately) has done it all; had hit records, sold out stadiums, starred in films, and helped rebuild communities with his charity work. So why is it so easy to hate him? Well, for starters, plenty of people think that the band Bon Jovi is just him on his own, rather than the legendary four-piece that included Richie Sambora, David Bryan, and Tico Torres. He once fired legendary photographer Ross Halfin for "making him look too old". He rips off his bandmates' compositions when writing his own solo albums too, and once said, "The way I look at it is, you're only married within the state lines. There are 49 other states, we can have 49 other relationships." Yes, he has cheated on his wife, as unsurprising as that is. And if that's not enough, he screwed over the musicians that helped him record debut single 'Runaway' by employing a bunch of others without their knowledge. The man is a walking expletive, and has actually managed to overshadow his bandmates' supreme musicality with his own stupid behaviour.

7. Smashing Pumpkins - Billy Corgan

WikipediaWikipediaEdging out both Thom Yorke and Chris Martin in the 'CHEER UP' stakes, Corgan has repeatedly forced his moaning and whining onto the world for the best part of three decades. Even those around him can't seem to stand him; an ever-changing Smashing Pumpkins lineup and a revolving cast of personal relationships can attest to that. Whilst dating Courtney Love, he refused to even attend Frances Bean Cobain's birthday party, and when two of his band members ended up in hospital after a drug overdose, he fired the one that survived shortly after the other one sadly died. Nice guy. After that, there's the weird half-Christianity, half-Buddhism approach to life that he likes to push onto everyone, and his Twitter page is an inane, rambling recital of religious inspiration/Hallmark poems. He's awfully out of touch too; once describing iTunes as making music 'too cuddly', yet recently starred in an Illinois furniture commercial. Edgy. Besides, who voluntarily shaves themselves bald?

6. Nickelback - Chad Kroeger

WikipediaWikipediaAdmittedly, pegging Nickelback into an article about great bands may be a long shot. But as we collectively mull over their various crimes against music, it might be worth noting: the other three aren't really that bad, are they? They're all well-skilled musicians, and they all keep to themselves, so what's the big fuss over? Chad Kroeger, that's what. Good old Chad has been rasping his way into our eardrums for over a decade, and the smarmy, cheesy, over-groomed singer has just about offended everyone on the entire planet with his mere existence. Let's look at some of their songs. Rockstar, How You Remind Me, Someday, Too Bad, If Today Was Your Last Day, etc...they all follow a fairly straightforward rock formula; a few chords, a catchy hook, a huge chorus, and earwax-melting guitar solos. So how bad can Kroeger really be to entirely destroy all of them with his mere contributions? Very bad. Very bad indeed. Whether it's his excruciating lyrics ("Your mom don't know that you were missing//She'd be p*ssed if she could see the parts of you that I've been kissing"), his overly-botoxed face (he's starting to look more and more like a caricature everyday), or the fact that he married Avril Lavigne in what is surely a coupling that could well unleash the apocalypse unto the world, Chad Kroeger has a lot to apologise to the human race for. Hopefully the other three Nickelbackers can seek musical retribution in another band, à la Alter Bridge. Which brings us nicely to...

5. Creed - Scott Stapp

WikipediaWikipediaSure, Creed are another band that might not be too involved with the word 'great', but hang in there with this one. When Creed broke up in 2004 in the most heartbreaking of fashions (a statement via their website about a lack of 'creative juices'), the three members with actual talent (Mark Tremonti, Brian Marshall, and Scott Phillips) went on to form the brilliant Alter Bridge with Myles Kennedy, who is also famed for his contributions to Slash's solo project. That nicely swept their former band under the rug, seemingly forever, as Alter Bridge enjoyed multiple successes, arena tours, and critical acclaim. Their former frontman Scott Stapp finally fell by the wayside after a failed solo career, and the whole world finally breathed a sigh of relief as the Floridian warbler vanished from sight. That was, until 2009, when Creed got back together. Amazingly, after just five years away, Stapp was back to irk us all once more. His Eddie Vedder-impersonating vocal style, his God-bothering lyrics, his absolute stupidity (he once said that he doesn't view oral sex with another woman as cheating on his wife), and the still-fresh image of that sex tape with Kid Rock, it was all back in the forefront of our minds. Unbelievably, he's managed to ruin both his own band and the band his ex-colleagues formed to get away from him. There's no justice.

4. Razorlight - Johnny Borrell

WikipediaWikipediaJ-Bo's crimes against music/humanity/decency/modesty/intelligence/logic almost go unbeaten. The man who once uttered the words, "Well, put it this way; compared to the Razorlight album Dylan is making the chips. I'm drinking champagne", has done little to distract the world and his wife from the arrogant, self-worshiping image that he has created for himself. Whether it's through claiming to be, "the best songwriter of generation", "a genius, musically, culturally, everything", or just plain old "f**king brilliant", this is a man who once turned up unannounced at SXSW whilst riding a Harley Davidson. The man then got dumped by Kirsten Dunst for riding said motorcycle through A HOUSE. The man whose solo album included such insightful song titles as 'Pan-European Supermodel Song' and 'Erotic Letter'. The man who once said that whales were more important than the people that died in 9/11... the list goes on. Razorlight started out as a reasonably promising, tuneful and exciting young indie band. But after three albums that, at best, were fit to soundtrack an Inbetweeners episode, Borrell's over-confidence had more than worn thin on the public, and it's no wonder that the rest of the band have all walked out over the years, while the aforementioned solo album sold a whopping 595 copies in its first week of sale. At least he's shown some self-awareness in recent years, saying, "I'm sure there were times when I was obnoxious. But that's rock'n'roll, you know?" Right.

3. U2 - Bono

WikipediaWikipediaOften overlooked as an actual singer in an actual band (probably due to all the time he spends doing so much other stuff to annoy us), Bono is a rare phenomenon. An exercise in self-belief, or perhaps a 30-year long art installation; nobody knows for sure, but Bono's behaviour and attitude over his all-too-long career have rendered him a frequent target of abuse from...well, everyone. From films titled 'Killing Bono' to bands named 'Bono Must Die', pop culture likes to take its shots at the Irishman, and rightly so. It all stems from his charity work. 'How can such a charitable person be so hated?' you ask? The fact that his investments in the likes of Facebook led him to becoming a billionaire overnight - whilst simultaneously asking all the rest of us for charity money - has earned him a reputation as a hypocritical little idiot whose moral compass always points towards himself. His onstage ranting about all kinds of crap that you don't want to hear at a rock concert actually deters as many people as the music attracts, and the recent revelation that he and the rest of his U2 bandmates have been moving their affairs offshore so as to avoid paying tax have only alienated people further. To be fair, Bono seems to hate us, too, once saying, "You know, God has some really weird kids, and I find it hard to be in their company most of the time". The feeling's mutual, Bono, don't you worry about that.

2. Guns N' Roses - Axl Rose

WikipediaWikipediaPerhaps an obvious pick, but oh-so-justified at that. Axl Rose, for all his riot-inciting, fan-punching, girlfriend-beating behaviour, is one of the most exciting, talented and engaging frontmen of all time. It just so happens that he's also a bit of a tool. For all those points touched upon (jumping into the crowd to take a fan's camera in St. Louis before causing a riot, assaulting several girlfriends and even accusing them of being sisters in a previous life that were now back to kill him...), his attitude towards his fanbase is perhaps his most notable act of douchebagery. Rose turns up - at best - an hour late to almost every gig he plays, he delayed the 'Chinese Democracy' album for almost two decades and cost his record label $13million (it wasn't worth the wait or the cost), as well as engaging in online bullying towards fans that dare to call him out on such childish behaviour, before proving to be so unprofessional that any other band member worth talking about has long since walked away from him. Guns n' Roses, at their prime, were the most rock 'n' roll band going; young, dangerous, and incredibly gifted. But after Slash, Duff, Izzy, and the other 384 former band members went on to happier pastures, Rose got into homeopathy, employed a 'guru' named Beta, grew dreadlocks, then cornrows, and started employing men with names like 'Bumblefoot' and 'Buckethead'. Nice. 20 years after debut GNR album 'Appetite for Destruction' was released, the band were inducted into the Rock 'n' Roll Hall of Fame, offering Axl a final chance to seek retribution, patch things up with Slash and co., and actually show people that he was capable of doing decent, human things. He didn't turn up.

1. Arctic Monkeys - Alex Turner

WikipediaWikipediaControversial, right? Wrong. It's the only logical choice when you think about it. Alex Turner, born in High Green, Sheffield, was once the pinnacle of cool. His formative years led him to write about the things he saw, heard, and experienced on the streets of 21st century Britain, earning him a place as indie's pied piper, playing to a loyal collective of like-minded souls who followed him wherever he went. The band scored chart success, critical acclaim, and sold out every venue they played twice over. Life was perfect for an Arctic Monkeys fan. Then came that haircut. Soon after separating from girlfriend Alexa Chung, Turner engaged himself in a breakup hairdo that made him look like an extra from Grease. It didn't look good. More than just a hair style, his whole demeanour changed. He suddenly started swinging his hips, speaking in a faux-American accent, and yes, combing his hair onstage. He now talks to the crowd as if he's Elvis Presley and this is Las Vegas. He swaggers around with sunglasses on when he's indoors. He has fellow idiot Miles Kane by his side at all times like a handbag dog to his Paris Hilton (the pair have just started writing a 1960s-set film inspired by X-Men, how wonderful). He gave possibly the worst speech ever at 2014's Brit Awards. He's just been caught up in a tax-evasion scheme, because what's more rock 'n' roll than not contributing to the very society that you became famous in, man. Worst of all, he's converted tens of thousands of once-innocent teenagers into an army of Fred Perry-wearing, air guitar-weilding, pint-throwing, 'REAL MUSIC'-cliché spouting oiks with nothing better to do than Instagram pictures of their new parkas. Alex Turner has not only turned into a ludicrous caricature of a rock star, he's actually invented a whole new niche for such a thing. The man who once wrote, "You're not from New York City, you're from Rotherham", should perhaps listen to his own younger self's advice for once. You're not from Los Angeles, you're from Sheffield. Who else do you think is worthy of a place on this list? Chris Martin? Liam Gallagher? Frank Black? Have your say in the comments below!

In this post: 
U2 bono
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Host of Keeping Up With The Kayfabe, Manchester United fan, and always looking for the WiFi password.