10 Greatest Acoustic Rock Albums

Unplugged but unbeatable.

Nick Drake Pink Moon
Island

Ever since the music studio was perfected, bands and artists have expanded their sonic possibilities exponentially. With as many tracks and takes as you like at your disposal, anyone can make a colossal, musically adventurous song, provided you’ve the imagination.

Sometimes, though, less really is more. There’s an old musical truism that, if you can’t make your song sound good on an acoustic guitar, you’ve not got a good song, and these 10 acoustic albums go to show that there’s some truth there.

Whether coming from the old guard before electric instruments really took over or those looking to shuck the trends of modernity, these bands and artists show that a simpler, stripped back approach is often the best. Without obfuscating layers of noise, their songs can shine all the more, and allow listeners to forge a deeper connection with the person singing.

These entirely or primarily acoustic albums give the songwriters nowhere to hide, no bells and whistles to mask or disguise shoddy songwriting. They rose to the challenge of a totally blank canvas, and created some legendary music.

10. Nirvana - MTV Unplugged in New York

As the biggest stars to emerge from the grunge scene, Nirvana will forever be synonymous with volume, aggression, and distortion. And while that was a big part of their sound, it’s always worth remembering just how tuneful and melodically accomplished they were, both as musicians and songwriters.

This live acoustic set perfectly evidences this. Some of their canon is ready-made for a stripped back rendition - “Something In The Way” and “All Apologies”, most notably, whose album versions are sombre and string-assisted. More interesting are the rockers. The explosive “Pennyroal Tea” is stately and emotional, and the up-tempo, poppy “On A Plain” almost sounds like a good time country tune here.

Perhaps most notable of all are the covers. The band are joined by Curt and Cris Kirkwood to belt through some Meat Puppets covers, and Cobain re-ups his Vaselines fandom. It’s an all round remarkably dynamic performance from Nirvana, who can play delicate stuff or wrangle the acoustic instruments for all they’re worth.

It’s Cobain’s show, though, and he ends things with a version of the traditional "Where Did You Sleep Last Night". It might just be his definitive performance, growing from a bluesy wail into a bloodied roar. Recorded not five months before his suicide, it remains utterly haunting.


9. Cat Stevens - Tea for the Tillerman

Yusuf Islam, then Cat Stevens, is very much the folkster’s folkster. His fourth album, arguably his best, is packed with songs rich in acoustic instrumentation, positive messages, words of caution and joy. It’s a giddy, packed sound which compliments some career-best songwriting.

"Miles from Nowhere" shows Stevens and his band in full force, as he grows from a calm vocal low in the mix to a belting performance as the track swells around him. Opener “Where Do The Children Play?” is particularly lovely, with sparkling keys punctuating the chorus.

The album is best remembered for its two downtempo tracks, “Wild World” and “Father And Son”. The songs touch on similar themes, family and the fear of the unknown. The former has an incredible chorus and riff combo, a proper earworm. The latter is nakedly, almost ludicrously emotional, but Stevens sells it so well that it stops short of being corny.

He ends it all with the title track, a beautiful and strange snippet of a song. It’s a minute of Stevens, a deftly played piano, and the record’s most oblique lyrics, a playfully arty diversion in an otherwise straightforward album.


8. Elliott Smith - Elliott Smith

Does any album start with a more depressing track than this one? Perhaps not. Elliott Smith’s self titled sophomore solo effort leaves the listener with no illusions, kicking off as it does with “Needle In The Hay”, one of the single bleakest tracks ever recorded.

It’s also a magnificent tune, from its wrong-footing chord sequence to Smith’s desperate falsetto. Things get a little sunnier from there in part. The warm, rolling guitar of “Clementine” is genuinely lovely, and “Coming Up Roses” even adds a brief full band feel for a shot of energy.

But Smith true to form fills his record with the gloomier side of things. The skittish “Southern Belle” has ghostly vibes, from the piled up, heavily strummed guitars to Smith’s voice, multitracked just off kilter for a disconcerting feel.

Smith evolved significantly as an artist, with later records allowing him to showcase a more maximalist, Beatles-indebted approach, but his great songwriting and beautiful, much-missed voice are fully formed on this 1995 release.


7. Violent Femmes - Violent Femmes

Your stereotypical acoustic album is calm, safe, coffeeshop fodder. Violent Femmes went in somewhat of a different direction with their self titled debut. This is the sound of three bratty punks grabbing whatever they could find and making a racket.

Opener (and continued alt-radio favourite) “Blister In The Sun” starts things off at pace, with an instant earworm riff and the frantic percussion of Victor DeLorenzo, who often has nothing more than a snare to work with. The album has pop hooks for days, from the plaintive harmonising of “Please Do Not Go” to the xylophone-led “Gone Daddy Gone”, later covered by Gnarls Barkley.

The band - specifically frontman Gordon Gano - come into their own on the biting, bitter tracks, though. “Kiss Off” and “Add It Up” form a perfectly adolescent duo, with Gano the whining, lovesick soul simultaneously whining and snapping at the girls who won’t give him the time of day.

By “Good Feeling”, though, they’ve grown up, closing off the record with a pretty, simple, sincere ballad. From the rattling bass of Brian Ritchie to the perfectly pitched adolescent lyrics, this is a totally distinct album that sounds as fresh today as it did in 1983.


6. Tracy Chapman - Tracy Chapman

Few artists have put their best foot forward quite like Tracy Chapman, who opens her debut album with two of her biggest songs. The second of these is “Fast Car”, her signature song and one that’s somehow still not played out, lyrically vivid, musically heartbreaking. The first is the rabble rousing "Talkin' 'bout a Revolution", and between the two, they set out exactly what Chapman’s self titled debut is all about.

She flits from personal insights to a state of the nation address with ease. She’s not making searing political statements here, but it’s bright and heartfelt protest music, all with the benefit of her incredible, powerful voice. “Why?” is the most overt activism on the album, delivered directly and honestly; she knows she doesn’t have the answers, but demands a change all the same.

There are electronic flourishes across the album, but the more pared down it is, the better it tends to sound. This is taken to the extreme on Behind The Wall, an acapella track that few artists would dare even attempt, let alone pull off to this degree.


5. Bob Dylan - The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan

While the former Robert Zimmerman was almost a finished product on his first album, his 1963 follow up took gigantic steps forward. Freewheelin’ is one of the best showcases for Dylan’s earliest persona, with all but one song penned by the prolific talent and the tracks illustrating his ability with the personal and political in equal measure.

Dylan was at this time pigeonholed as a protest singer, and Freewheelin’ contains some charged gems. “Blowin’ In The Wind” remains one of the greatest pleas for peace ever recorded. “Oxford Town” is a tightly wound denouncement of racism, and “Masters Of War” a snarling condemnation of the powers that be.

The romantic stuff, though, is better still. “Girl From The North Country” is one of the sweetest, most sincere melodies Dylan ever wrote (though the Johnny Cash improves it). Better still is "Don't Think Twice, It's All Right". Easily a top 10 Dylan song, the fingerpicked guitar glitters, and the wearily delivered lyrics are utterly heartbreaking and wise.

With such sparse instrumentation and a charismatic but limited voice, Dylan manages to explore all sides of his personality, from impish to insightful. It’s remarkable to release an album that’s so of its time and yet totally timeless.


4. Bruce Springsteen - Nebraska

It takes a bold artist to completely throw away the formula at any point in their career; to do so when riding a wave of immense success feels almost crazy. In 1982, Bruce Springsteen was two years removed from ambitious double album The River when he decided to sideline his band, hole up in his bedroom, and record a sparse, bleak, occasionally frightening album that was about as un-commercial as it gets.

Nebraska features only Springsteen as a player, mostly just him and a guitar. He sets out his stall with the title track, sung from the perspective of teenage murderer Charles Starkweather. As per, Bruce writes songs from those on the bottom rung of society, but they’re a saltier bunch than normal: a hopeless gambler on “Atlantic City”, an impulse killer on “Johnny 99”.

The best track is “State Trooper”, a song that sounds like madness itself. The narrator is an oblique character driving at night, urging the cops not to stop him; what he’s done, and what he will do if pulled over, are left to the listener’s imagination.

Springsteen went back to the big time with Born In The USA after Nebraska’s inevitable flop, but he’s returned to the sparse, spooky sound on occasion, and without exception he’s always the better for it.


3. Van Morrison - Astral Weeks

After finding success as a member of Them and a solo R&B powerhouse, Van Morrison quickly made the swerve to something completely different. The mesmerising, bucolic Astral Weeks was met with some confusion despite its hippy-era 1968 release, but it wasn’t long before it was reappraised as a classic.

The title track is awash with flutes, droning strings, and mandolins, all under Morrison’s textured vocals and insistent guitar strumming. It sets the tone for an album of loosely structured tracks, ebbing and flowing like nature as the players follow their instincts.

The closest the record gets to a conventional hit is “Sweet Thing”, a track built on a swirling, repeating sequence of chords while the folk track builds behind it and Morrison lays out a sequence of devotional, upbeat lyrics of love.

Things are less straightforward - but even more wildly ambitious - on “Madame George”. Morrison seems to abandon any rhythm in his vocals, rolling all over the track for nearly 10 minutes as a roaming violin similarly ventures wherever it pleases. It sounds, in the best way, unrehearsed, like these musicians came together, sat down, and happened to record a masterpiece.


2. Nick Drake - Pink Moon

Drake’s first two albums were primarily stripped back, though with the occasional explosion of horns and strings, particularly on sophomore effort Bryter Layter. On his swan song, Drake took his fragile, sorrowful sound down to the bone, with just guitar, occasional piano, and his weary voice.

That’s not to say Pink Moon is a miserable listen, though; indeed it’s often beautiful. The title track shows off Drake’s range, as he floats over the verses then sinks breathily into the chorus. “Which Will” is lyrically heartbreaking but features some of his finest guitar work to date.

It’s often a haunting record, too. “Know” stands out for its buzzing guitar and Drake’s wordless humming, which finally gives way to a brief, despondent lyric. Indeed Drake’s words become less comprehensible as the record goes on, and it’s hard not to hear this as an insight into the artist’s mental state.

Drake passed away two years after Pink Moon’s release. His final album ends on the delicate “From The Morning”, a light and lovely conclusion to his arguable masterpiece.


1. Joni Mitchell - Blue

Mitchell’s albums up to this point had been a wild melange of styles, with reserved, minimalist numbers and sprawling, jazz-influenced tracks sharing record space. 1971’s Blue was a more focussed affair; it’s one of the best break up albums ever made, and with the mournful palette that suggests.

“All I Want” opens things in familiar fashion, with unusual instrumentation (here a dulcimer) and melodic choices. The first truly heartbreaking track is “Little Green”, a song of loss and longing for the past, with Mitchell keeping to an uncharacteristically low register, her voice strong and strident.

“California” opens side two on a more hopeful note, with James Taylor enlisted to help fill the sound on guitar and a far more playful performance from Joni as she free-associates about her adopted home state. But then there’s “River”, the most devastating Christmas(ish) song put down on wax, with a delicate but thumping piano performance and mystical but mournful lyrics.

It’s not a sad album per se - it’s much more textured than that - but it’s about as ripe with feelings as a record can get, and whatever moon you happen to find yourself in, somehow it’s fit for purpose.


Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)