10 Greatest Band Rivalries In Rock History

The Rock N Roll Slug-Fests.

Blur Oasis
nme.com

Music should never be considered a competition. For the most part, many people come into the genre wanting to bring their unique take on music to the world. At the same time, some people try to use their platform as a way to play against their contemporaries.

Throughout the years, many bands have fallen in conjunction with one another over who is the better band. Whether it be a personal feud or a legitimate musical similarity, these bands have all had some bad blood flowing through their veins. Rather than combing through personal experiences or follow their muse, it's often just as easy to find inspiration as an opponent rather than a musician. While these guys may have carried on fighting through thick and thin, rock fans typically won out in the end, with each band delivering their best work in an attempt to outmatch the band next to them.

Here are the bands that turned the art of creating music into sonic sport. It's up for debate who did it better, but these bands have brought their kickass songs to the table to stomp out their competition.

10. The Beatles vs. The Beach Boys

In the 60's pop scene, no one exuded the free-spirited nature of the time like the Beatles. The band's endless charisma onstage and off made them feel like fun-loving guys who just happened to be getting No. 1 hits. At the same time, America had their take on the pop rock sound with the Beach Boys' boy-next-door mentality under Brian Wilson's songwriting genius.

Though the marketing departments of both camps had their work cut out for them, things got even more heated once everything started expanding. Starting with 1965's Rubber Soul, the Beatles began to take their pop formula in a more mature direction than the standard love songs of the day. While Brian Wilson said that he loved the record, he wanted to see if he could make a good enough album to compete with his British friends. With the result being the pop masterpiece Pet Sounds, Paul McCartney started to listen in a bit more.

Being absolutely stunned by Wilson's work, McCartney aimed to be even more ambitious and started to put together tracks for what would become the band's grand conceptual work Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band. All from a friendly songwriting battle, the world got some of the greatest album experiences to come out of the rock music genre.


9. Pavement vs. The Smashing Pumpkins

The Smashing Pumpkins were having their golden period in the early 90's. While the sound of grunge was still the order of the day, Billy Corgan's use of big guitars and angst-filled hooks made them fit right in among the Nirvanas of the world. However, not every band was willing to join in on the Pumpkins' fun.

A lot of the alternative godfathers of the genre from Bob Mould from Husker Du to producer Steve Albini felt that the band were using the alternative sound as a means for becoming worldwide stars. Though these guys may have had their grievances, no one was as blunt about their feelings as Pavement, who called out the band on their song "Range Life," where they accuse them of not really having a function in the scene.

While the initial jab was meant in good fun, Corgan was actually hurt by the song and threatened to not play their Lollapalooza date if Pavement was added to the lineup. After choosing to play the next year, Pavement ended up becoming the perfect example of alternative music being washed away for the corporate cash-ins of the scene. Corgan may have been pop's antihero, but at this point, he looked like the pampered rock star who didn't have time to confront critiques of his work.


8. Guns N Roses vs. Nirvana

The latter part of the 80's hard rock scene was dominated by Guns N Roses. While you had bands like Metallica bringing a heavier tone to rock music, there was no escaping the sounds of Slash's leads and the feral shrill of Axl Rose. Once grunge arrived on the scene though, things started to get a lot uglier.

Though Axl Rose was a big supporter of the grunge movement and even wore a Nirvana hat during the band's tour cycle, Kurt Cobain wanted nothing to do with the band's style of rock and roll. When talking about them in interviews, Cobain seemed to get frustrated about GNR getting popular for what he saw as misogynistic lyrics and awful practices from the band members. Given the band's volatile presence, this wasn't something Rose was going to take lightly.

Since the incident, Nirvana turned down dates to open for GNR, which sent Axl into a frenzy. This eventually culminated in the 1992 MTV Awards, where Axl started threatening him in a way Cobain compared to a middle school bully. Once they hit the stage, Nirvana fired right back, with Dave Grohl goofing on the whole thing by sarcastically screaming like a superfan whenever he saw Rose in the crowd. For as much as Rose may have fought back, you couldn't argue that the entire rock landscape was shifting in Cobain's favor.


7. The Smiths vs. The Cure

By the mid-80's, the post-punk scene was not lacking in depressing music. With each passing day, another band was coming to the forefront with a cold melody and even colder lyrics about everything from angst-ridden love to the inevitability of death. Though the Cure and the Smiths thrived in this scene, the context was a lot messier behind the scenes.

The feud mostly started when Morrissey was interviewed regarding his feelings on certain artists. Never one to mince words, the Smiths frontman said that he would be happy to see Robert Smith dead and called the Cure's musical ventures "a new dimension to the word crap." While Smith took the entire thing in stride at first, he stood up for himself once he was called a "fat clown in makeup."

Once he cleared up the fact that he had never even met Morrissey, Smith expressed that he absolutely loathed his "critic's" behavior. Calling out Morrissey's infatuation with the vegetarian lifestyle, Smith said that he would deliberately eat meat every time Morrissey mentioned his animal rights stance. Given all the vitriol they spew out in the press, it's no wonder that each of these bands have put out so much dark material in their songs.


6. Mr Bungle vs. Red Hot Chili Peppers

As the tides in music were changing, Mike Patton felt that his artistic direction seemed too contained in Faith No More. Wanting to expand his musical palette, Patton formed Mr. Bungle, which combined funk rhythms with rapid fire vocals and a hard rock presentation. Sound familiar? Well it should.

Back in his days in Faith No More, Anthony Kiedis had already called out Patton for ripping off his vocal style, but that only proved to be the tip of the iceberg. Patton was so focused on getting a rise out of Kiedis that he was originally going to release Mr Bungle's effort California on the same day as the funk rock gods' album Californication. Though the band eventually acquiesced and changed their release date, that didn't stop the live gigs where Patton mockingly call his band members "Flea" and performed covers of RHCP songs with the wrong lyrics.

Once the band mocked deceased guitarist Hillel Slovak by pretending to shoot heroin, it became too much for Kiedis to handle. When organizing the Big Day Out Festival in 2000, Kiedis was able to remove Mr. Bungle's slot, which Patton said severely hurt their potential going forward. Even with 20 years of hindsight, it seems that the fire between these two bands hasn't quelled just yet.


5. Nirvana vs. Pearl Jam

When Nirvana hit it big, it seemed that no one knew what was popular anymore. With all the 80's fads blown off the map, many people were looking to frontman Kurt Cobain to see what he thought was popular. Though he lambasted the hair metal bands that came before him, not even Cobain's contemporaries were safe from his verbal venom.

As Cobain began being asked about bands like Soundgarden and Pearl Jam, Cobain had a few choice words to say about Eddie Vedder's outfit. In an effort to hold onto his indie credibility, Cobain called Pearl Jam a mockery of the grunge aesthetic, with a sound that was too in line with classic rock to be considered truly alternative. Though PJ were a bit on edge at first, they were able to take it in stride and be mindful of their decisions going forward.

Though it may have gotten nasty, the feud became water under the bridge once everything blew up. When talking to MTV, Cobain said that he actually was very friendly with Eddie Vedder and even danced with him underneath the stage at the MTV Awards during Eric Clapton's performance of "Tears in Heaven." While Cobain would end his life a few years later, it was comforting to know that he had made amends with his hard rock competition.


4. Hole vs. Foo Fighters

For as much joy as Nirvana brought to the rock world, things weren't as rosy behind the scenes. While Dave Grohl was able to move on from his grunge past with the Foo Fighters a few years later, hedid have some pentup feelings about how his old bandmate's widow was dealing with everything.

Ever since the beginning of her time in the spotlight, Courtney Love was always looked at as the crazy girl behind the band Hole. Though she seemed to live up to her insane reputation, Grohl tended to see the more manufactured version of her personality. After some speculation, Grohl eventually confirmed that the Foos' "I'll Stick Around" is actually directed at Love, whose "rehearsed insanity" grated on him.

This started a near decade of Love lambasting Grohl in the press, from disagreeing over the future of Nirvana's music to accusing Grohl of making advances toward her daughter Frances Bean, which Frances has since denied. Though things looked incredibly grim for a while, their reconciliation at Nirvana's Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction seems to show that the two are in a better place. Things may have been turbulent in the 90's, but the amount of good in Good Guy Grohl seems to know no limits these days.


3. Blur vs. Oasis

After the fad of grunge came and went at the start of the 90's, the rock world gave way to a new style of music that threw it back to the old days of rock and roll grandeur. At the heart of this Britpop genre were Oasis, but the band's ongoing feud with rivals Blur made things a lot more tense.

Attempting to seize on their creative hot streak and competitiveness with each other, the two bands decided to release singles on the same day to see who would truly be the kings of the movement. With Oasis putting out "Roll With It" and Blur offering up "Country House," the battle lines were drawn in the August of 1995. The end result showed Blur coming out on top, which frontman Noel Gallagher did not take lightly. In an interview shortly after their "loss," he said that he hoped that the members of Blur would "catch AIDS and die," which he apologized for later down the line.

Ever since their prime in the 90's, Oasis seemed to have made their peace with the matter, with Liam Gallagher calling Blur a "guilty pleasure" and Noel even lending a hand to Damon Albarn's project Gorillaz in 2017. Each bands' golden period may have been a bit nasty, but over time things have been able to sort themselves out.


2. The Beatles vs. The Rolling Stones

If you're even remotely familiar with rock and roll competitions, this is the one that arguably started them all. Once the Beatles appeared on the Ed Sullivan Show in 1964, the British Invasion began its full tilt into America, bringing rock and roll onto the mainstream charts. Though the band were known as the foundational band of the day, they had some contenders for the crown in the Rolling Stones.

From a marketing standpoint, this rivalry had the perfect package. With each passing record, the Beatles were known as the made-up pretty boys, while the Stones were being looked at as a more raucous take on the British Invasion sound. Though a lot of the feud was in good fun, John Lennon did admit that the Stones were stealing a little too much from them with the records they would release.

Even with some sniping back and forth, each band got along quite well with one another, with Lennon and McCartney even writing one of the bands' first hits "I Wanna Be Your Man." With Jagger and Richards marking them down as a primary influence, it seems that the birth of the Beatles gave the world incredible music from two great bands.


1. Metallica vs. Megadeth

As far as hard rock goes, rivalries don't get any colder than the one between Metallica and Megadeth. Ever since its inception in the mid-80's, fans still aren't able to get enough of the verbal sparring sessions between the two titans of speed metal. Though it seems as old as time itself, it all began with one firing.

In the early 80's, Metallica were making their way to the East Coast and guitarist Dave Mustaine was out of control. The entire band drank, but the more raucous side of Mustaine would come out and lead to a lot of violent behavior. As the band prepared to make a deal with indie label Megaforce Records, the band fired Mustaine before going into the studio to make Kill Em All.

After being thrown onto a Greyhound bus back to San Francisco, Mustaine was furious and determined to start his own band. Once he touched back down in California, Mustaine immediately began writing songs and formed Megadeth with David Ellefson to get back at Metallica for ruining his dream. Even if both bands have made up and have played shows together as part of the Big 4 back in 2010, fans continue to get endless entertainment from the metal gods and the spurned guitarist who made his own dream.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97