10 Greatest Ever Story Songs
Dear Slim...
The primary job of any song is that it sounds good. The tune has got to have the right melodic structure and rhythm to get the audience grooving and coming back to it time and time again. However, when it comes to lyrics, songwriters have a unique opportunity at their feet.
There are millions of songs that are written about partying all night long, but that kind of writing can only take you so far. Lyricists start experimenting over time and decide to craft more thoughtful lyrics into their compositions. These lyrics tend to tell a unique story as it takes the listener on a journey through the music. In those instances, the music takes a back seat and provides the audible vehicle as the listener goes from scene to scene.
Spanning across genres from hip hop to rock to metal, the music world has never run short of exceptional wordsmiths who forego trite lyricism for more introspective anecdotes. Across all of the entries found here, we get a look into the lives of these people who live in between your headphones.
10. Into The Great Wide Open - Tom Petty
After the great success of Tom Petty's solo record Full Moon Fever, he decided to use producer Jeff Lynne on his next studio album with the Heartbreakers. Each song had a certain amount of gravitas added to it with a cinematic-like atmosphere. The title track, "Into the Great Wide Open," is a perfect example of this movie-like scope.
Petty details the story of a boy named Eddie who goes through all the trials and tribulations of becoming a rock star. After getting his first tattoo and moving to Hollywood, he becomes an overnight sensation as he sees his record go up the charts. Once Eddie has tasted fame, he slowly starts to dwindle as he deals with problems with his record company before being left out to dry by his contemporaries.
What holds the song together is the chorus as the Heartbreakers sing about Eddie's journey in the unknown as "a rebel without a clue." The story is an great warning for fame-hungry who have stars in their eyes. As such, the song remains a wistful look at the romanticism of celebrity while also being a condemnation of its pitfalls.
9. Polly - Nirvana
In Nirvana's alt rock catalog, "Polly" stands out as one of the group's most sobering listens. Throughout their career, the members of Nirvana had been adamant about their support for women's rights and condemning the horrors of sexual abuse. About midway through the band's foundational record Nevermind, "Polly" is a slow acoustic song about one woman's fight against a sexual predator.
Frontman Kurt Cobain plays the role of the torturer as he ties up Polly and attempts to make sexual advances. As the man makes blase remarks about the woman wanting more food and asking to be released, he has a truly apathetic tone to his despicable actions.
Once the final verse arrives, we see the silver lining as Polly decides to make advances towards the attacker. At that point, the man lets his guard down, giving her the chance to escape from his clutches. The man is only left to say how he is dumbfounded by "the will of instinct."
This song was a fantastic tune that marked an important change in rock's lyrical approach. The lyrical norm of most rock songwriters tended to favor more derogatory references to women, but Nirvana stepped up with a song that knocked down that machismo pretentiousness in one fell swoop.
8. Jeremy - Pearl Jam
While alt-rock had been going strong by the time the grunge 90's hit, the lyrical style behind the genre tended to be hit and miss. There were many fantastic lyricists from bands like the Pixies and the Smiths, but some bands also had nonsensical lyrics like in the early days of Nirvana and R.E.M. When Pearl Jam arrived on the scene, the band decided to experiment with documentation on their smash single "Jeremy."
The story behind this song is ripped straight from the headlines, as Jeremy was the name of a real boy who brought a gun into his school one day and committed suicide in front of his classmates. Eddie Vedder's lyrics are incredibly descriptive as he details Jeremy's life as he is picked on at school and lives as somewhat of a recluse. As the verses build, we see the many turmoils in Jeremy's life from his lack of friends to his parent's apathy. Once we arrive at the line "Jeremy spoke in class today," the emotion is unnerving.
Pearl Jam would take on stories like this on later tracks like "Daughter" and "Better Man," but this first foray into character portrayal is filled with internal pain and hidden darkness.
7. Jenny Was A Friend Of Mine - The Killers
The first song off the Killer's debut album Hot Fuss is an intense look at a homicide scenario. The song builds with a manic speed as the instruments paint the picture of police helicopters hovering overhead.
As Brandon Flowers enters, the account of Jenny's demise begins as he tells officials about the last time he saw Jenny alive. He describes Jenny and the protagonist on a walk, seemingly at the end of their romantic relationship. The pair proceeds to fight as the narrator lets one detail slip up: "She couldn't scream while I held her close, I swore I'd never let her go."
Once the chorus hits, you realize that this account of the murder has quickly transformed into an investigation as the narrator desperately tries to defend himself as unresponsible in Jenny's murder. With every plea that there is no motive for him killing her, the listener sees clearly through the facade that this love-sick lunatic is delivering.
The song ends with the man's agonized screams and fans are left to wonder the inevitable fate of Jenny's killer. However, the ambiguous nature of this ending is what gives the song an added depth of emotional weight.
6. Tracy Jacks - Blur
Blur's seminal Britpop masterpiece Parklife has a fun-loving sound but with a slight lyrical twist. The album is a dark look at how the monotonous tone of everyday life can slowly turn normal people to madness. The first example of this type of wordplay comes in "Tracy Jacks," which follows the life of a typical British businessman.
Tracy Jacks goes through his daily routine without a care until his brain suddenly snaps. As he proceeds to go to work, he instead takes a train to Walton, throws his clothes off and runs through the street before getting arrested by the police. He then caps off the week by bulldozing his house down.
The chorus details Mr. Jacks's mindset through this hysteria, as he feels that his professional life as an adult has reached its end and how he finds it overrated to live the rest of his days sitting in his normal house. In lieu of living in normal conditions, Jacks turned to erratic behavior to put some action back into his life, with catastrophic results. A bittersweet tale of what happens when the meaninglessness of middle class life becomes too much to bear.
5. How Much a Dollar Cost- Kendrick Lamar
After the monumental success of his album Good Kid Maad City, Kendrick Lamar had become extremely desensitized with his newfound fame. Across his followup To Pimp a Butterfly, Lamar returns to his old stomping grounds in Compton to find that everything has changed due to his fame.
In "How Much a Dollar Cost," Lamar comes across a homeless man who asks him for money. Lamar initially refuses and gets in his new luxury car, but the exchange doesn't end. The homeless man proceeds to stare at Lamar's car and Kendrick begins to feel uneasy. Once the final verse hits, the homeless man speaks up and reveals himself to be an embodiment of God who is disappointed in Kendrick's behavior.
The song has Kendrick using this story as an opportunity to look inward and make sure that he keeps his morals while in the spotlight. Lamar perfectly tells about how his fame has become a bit of a cage for him and he must find a way to come to terms with his newfound starpower. This is a poignant look into Kendrick's psyche while also being a cautionary tale about how to treat those that are in a different situation than your own.
4. One -Metallica
Metallica has always been known for their dark lyrics. Throughout the band's 80's output, their approach quickly shifted from songs about demons to tales of injustice, addiction, and even the mentally ill. However, when it comes to setting up a scene in the lyrics, "One" is in a class by itself.
The song opens with the sounds of war while a melancholy guitar softly plays the initial riff. As the lyrics enter, we see a man who has been badly injured in battle, but is unable to voice his sorrow. In the breakdown, he pleads for God to wake him from his coma but is met with resistance. The song builds to its chugging outro as the layers are revealed and we realize just how bad this soldier's condition is. The man has no limbs, and is unable to speak, hear, or see anything.
With the loss of all these basic functions, the man is trapped in a never-ending exile as he pleads for death but can only live in pain due to the life support he is attached to. Metallica's way of detailing this man's inevitable grim fate takes the song from being a sad lament to a modern day Greek tragedy.
3. Stan - Eminem
With the Internet at our fingertips, there has been more exposure for what is now known as toxic fandom. In 2000, Eminem took his newfound fame to shed light on the horrors that come with this sort of obsessive behavior.
Across "Stan"'s runtime, we get to know this eponymous character as someone who is obsessed with Slim Shady. He writes him every day and becomes more and more disgruntled when he doesn't write back.
With each letter, we get a look into Stan's life, as he is an unstable fan who cuts himself and has a pregnant girlfriend who he mistreats. When Slim fails to write back, Stan loses it and proceeds to tie up his girlfriend, throw her in the trunk of his car, and sends a last message to Slim as he runs his car off a bridge into a river.
By the time Slim finally writes back, it's too late and he finds out on the news that Stan had taken his own life before Slim could have gotten a message to him. This look at the dark side of fandom has become one of rap's legendary tracks and is a must-listen for anyone interested in the more macabre side of hip hop.
2. Space Oddity - David Bowie
David Bowie has become a titan in the music industry with his fabulous pop hooks and the endless innovations he made to the rock landscape. While life without Bowie's music seems odd, it all started with "Space Oddity," a marvelous look into the age of space travel.
The song's beginning details Major Tom's ascent into space as the countdown begins and the music builds to simulate a rocket liftoff. Once Major Tom is up in space, he is floored by the Earth's view and realizes he is only a small part of a larger universe.
As he begins to drift through space, Major Tom begins to engulf himself in the journey and proceeds out further into the abyss of space. After a solemn "tell my wife I love her," Tom's circuit dies and the signal to his capsule becomes lost. The listener is left feeling uncertain about Major Tom's future as he drifts endlessly through space.
Major Tom would eventually make returns in Bowie's music like on "Ashes to Ashes" and the video for the song "Blackstar," but this introduction to the character provided a delightfully ominous beginning to one of Bowie's first character portraits.
1. Piano Man - Billy Joel
In the 1970's, rock had become well-known for their singer-songwriters. Everyone from Joni Mitchell to Cat Stevens to James Taylor all were brandishing guitars and telling intricate stories in their songs. Then out of the blue came a singer-songwriter brandishing a piano that blew away all the competition.
With "Piano Man," Billy Joel constructed a semi-autobiographical tale of a man who makes his living as a pianist in a bar. As he goes through the lives of various patrons, he finds that each of them have their own problems, from a waitress practicing politics to a real estate novelist to a wannabe movie star. All of these patrons seem to come together at this bar and establish a camaraderie amongst themselves by watching this piano man perform.
The Piano Man is not one to provide solutions to their problems but to offer musical solace as they drink their troubles away in the bar. This song is a perfect anthem for the Everyman, as everyone feels put down in their lives and are willing to do whatever they can to survive. So kick back, grab a beer, and join in the Piano Man's song.