10 Greatest Prog Rock Bands
The Musical Masterminds of Rock.
At the end of the 60's, rock looked a lot different than it did at the beginning of the decade. With everybody still submerged in the acid dreams of Woodstock, bands were coming up left and right trying to push the genre forward. Though many were content with the blues or rockabilly, these bands were able to spread the rock genre out into new territory.
Amid all the experimentation, these bands ended up creating what we know today as progressive rock. While not every one of these records sound as gargantuan as something like the math rock prodigies today, they still played a key role in taking the rock genre up a notch. From weird tunings to different instrumentation to playing in every time signature ever conceived, these bands have not only stretched the boundaries of music, but also pulled off some of the most impressive musical feats in the rock sphere.
Even when not behind their instruments, every one of these acts have been able to use studio trickery to bring some of the most eccentric sounds into the world of rock and roll. They might not seem like your typical rock outfit, but these guys managed to blast a hole in rock's future and make progressive music a household name
10. Mastodon
By the time the '00s rolled around, it wasn't necessarily a new thing for the sounds of metal to blend with progressive movements. With many bands already making it their calling card, there were millions of bands trying to play the most complicated solo run they could that just happened to be distorted. Just when things felt like they could get a bit monotonous, Mastodon had all the complexity you'd need with a sound that had the force of a hurricane.
Formed when two of the members met at a High On Fire show, the band channelled that specific brand of heaviness into their sound, with the more intense soundscapes being mixed with some of the fattest guitar tones the '00s had ever seen. Many bands would see their heavy sound as an opportunity to make their playing dirty, but the guitar team of Brent Hinds and Bill Kelliher are one of the tightest guitar pairs in the entire industry, going from close harmonies to leading the six-string charge on one riff.
With early albums being grand tales based around one of the elements to their current approach of making bite-sized epics, Mastodon have almost developed their own lane apart from their brethren. It's one thing to show off your technical chops, but when you can take it to an unbelievable volume, it almost feels like you can shake the Earth's core.
9. Jethro Tull
For many newcomers to the prog scene, Jethro Tull seems like the relic of a bygone era. With a sound that feels like its ripped straight out of the '70s, some of the band's bigger hits like "Living In the Past" have a firm foundation but don't really feel at home in the prog genre. Once you look at what's going on underneath though, the band becomes much more complex.
Formed in England in the late '60s, the band were a eclectic musical force who rubbed elbows with everyone from the Rolling Stones to Led Zeppelin. However, Tull always had a more elaborate plan for their songs, which started around their second album. Under frontman Ian Anderson's vision, the band started employing everything from classical motifs to various sections into a single song.
The whole thing became so ambitious that one of their most beloved albums Thick is a Brick is nothing more than just one track stretched across two sides of one album. Whether they were taking on a grandiose piece or making a sophisticated rock affair on "Aqualung," Jethro Tull offered something that served the more eccentric variety of rock fan. Take a peek behind the curtain and see the subtle genius that's going on behind the flute memes.
8. Tool
At the band's inception, many people probably wouldn't consider Tool as contenders for one of the greatest prog bands of all time. Sure, the band's first step up to the plate with Undertow was a solid metal offering, but it wasn't necessarily overflowing with shifting meters and elaborate production. Make no mistake, Tool were not a great prog band in their early years, but they did turn themselves into one.
As the band went into their next records, the riffs started to become much more varied, with songs that were either set in a weird time signature or had an offbeat structure. If the final song from Aenima "Third Eye" showed the band going into complicated directions, Lateralus was the quantum leap into uncharted territory, where the band won the hearts of both music theorists and metalheads alike with rock solid songs that had everything from Eastern sounds to songs that change time signatures at nearly every other bar.
Knowing what they had cultivated, the band doubled down on 10,000 Days, with songs fitting together almost like individual suites like the Wings for Marie sequence. With Fear Inoculum still bringing the heat in full force, the passage of time has not been a hindrance to this band's thirst for the unconventional musical approach.
7. Electric Light Orchestra
For years, the general construct of the rock band has always been with guitar, bass, drums, and maybe keyboards if you feel so inclined. Other than the occasional weird instrument for the sake of experimenting, the entire rock world has been comfortable sticking to the traditional instrumental formula. Rock would have probably continued on without a care, but Electric Light Orchestra was the first band to bring the rock spirit into the classical realm.
That use of the word "orchestra" in the name is by no means a cheeky pun. Throughout the band's career, leader Jeff Lynne has employed various strings to get the lush soundscapes that he wants for his tunes. Initially inspired by the experimental weirdness of the Beatles' middle period, Lynne used the studio as his instrument, with albums like A New World Record and Out of the Blue sounding like modern-day concertos that just happen to feature guitars.
Not only has Lynne crafted his own unique lane for his music, but his knowledge in the producer's chair has helped revitalize the career of many rock luminaries, from Tom Petty's solo work to being drafted by the Beatles to mastermind their Anthology series. Electric Light Orchestra may not be anyone's first guess as the best prog band of all time, but once you get accustomed to their immense sound, you will find some of the most beautiful pieces in the rock canon.
6. Dream Theater
Metal seemed to be in a bit of a transitionary period at the start of the '90s. With thrash metal getting more mainstream attention and the hair metal sound becoming incredibly stale, the idea of prog making a dent in the metal scene seemed almost unthinkable. Around the same time that grunge was finding its footing in Seattle, a band out of New York rose to prominence with some of the most concentrated musicianship in rock.
Just the name Dream Theater tells you that you're going to be in for something epic. From the first time you hear one of their songs, the band's master of their craft is beyond anything most other bands could dream of, with John Petrucci being a combination of every genre of guitar player moulded into one heroic guitar god. The solos may be to die for, but every member from Mike Portnoy to Jordan Rudess can play circles around any other band regardless of what genre they play.
8-minute songs are practically a walk in the park for this band, with their more ambitious tracks sometimes lasting over 30 minutes and riffs that grab you by the jugular. These guys are always about the integrity of the song, but their actual finesse on their instruments have made them the musicians' favourite prog band.
5. Yes
In the early '60s, prog was still just being born. With bands still having a foot planted firmly in the psychedelic genre, it was hard to differentiate the complex bands from the acid rock of the day. Yes may have been cut from that cloth in the beginning, but their vision for their music was a lot broader in scope.
Starting with Time and a Word, the band ventured into areas most bands wouldn't consider touching, as they covered everything from classical chops to jazzier sections. Almost any member of this band could be considered a virtuoso on their instrument, from Steve Howe's beautiful guitar work to Chris Squire's rumbling bass guitar. Albums like Relayer or Close to the Edge may seem like a bit of an undertaking with 20-minute pieces, but when you actually take the dive, you get a taste at just adventurous rock can be.
The band's ability to push the rock genre into more progressive material almost couldn't even be contained in one band. With keyboardist Rick Wakeman filling out Black Sabbath's spacey sound and Steve Howe contributing to Queen records, the guys in Yes are not just some of the greatest players in prog rock. These were the grand ambassadors for the more complex forms of rock and roll.
4. King Crimson
The end of the '60s will forever be known as the years where rock was dipped in acid. Even though countless bands were trying to stay mellow in the hippie mindset, other bands were bringing some of the most feral sounds of rock together to create some of the nastiest rock and roll ever made. It's easy for this kind of sound to divulge into chaos, but listening to King Crimson felt like opening up your third eye.
With the release of In the Court of the Crimson King, the band set up one of the most solid foundations in prog history, as they did everything from jazzy breakdowns to making songs that sounded like they should be soundtracking the end of the world. Beyond the band's beginnings, mastermind Robert Fripp created some of the most outlandish experiments and miraculously made them work, like the song "Frame by Frame" using a meter that is both out of sync and perfectly in sync at the same time.
Keeping the prog tendencies alive, Fripp also found a way to extend his musical prowess to other acts like Peter Gabriel and David Bowie, where he brought different sonic textures to some of rock's most classic songs. King Crimson may not have been the first time prog infiltrated rock, but after their splash on the scene, it had now become a style.
3. Rush
As the '70s reached its midpoint, prog rock had been a major sonic force for a couple of years. Though bands like Yes were opening up the possibilities for more ambitious rock and roll, it was unclear whether the hard rock world had any place in this new genre. Emerging from the snowy depths of Canada, Rush exploded onto the rock scene and became one of prog's most enduring bands.
While you can tell the band's affinity for groups like Led Zeppelin and the Who, there was something much more intricate going on once you decided to listen to these records. Oftentimes containing no more than a handful of songs, each track this band made took you on a journey, as they played with time signatures almost effortlessly to tell their sonic stories. These guys also don't seem to get enough credit for their wordplay, with drummer Neil Peart penning awe-inspiring tales, whether it's cast in a dystopian future or in the depths of J.R.R. Tolkien's work.
At a time when prog seemed to be getting too complex for its own good, Rush came through with songs that not only had killer solos, but also enough riffage to keep hard rock fans headbanging along. No matter how much people slacked them off for being music for nerds, Rush deserve to be celebrated for every single door they managed to open up.
2. Pink Floyd
During the mid '60s, prog rock wasn't even a thought in the casual music fan's consciousness. If you were looking for something that was a bit more off-the-wall than the Rolling Stones or the Byrds, chances are you would find what you were looking for in the psychedelic genre. Pink Floyd seemed to fit perfectly in that scene at first, but things started to get a little bit different as the years wore on.
After the departure of founding member Syd Barrett due to drug-related mental health issues, the band persevered by stretching out their songs to unbelievable proportions. The idea of a 18-minute song seemed a bit daunting at the time, but these guys made every second count by crafting some of the most immaculate sounding records in rock like Animals and Wish You Were Here.
Aside from the long songs, Pink Floyd also expanded the horizons of mainstream rock, from the subtle details of the Dark Side of the Moon to the concept album to define all concept albums with The Wall. Prog may have still been a niche genre at the time, but Pink Floyd took it out of the cult doldrums and showed the music world that this elaborate style of music actually had staying power.
1. Genesis
Genesis has got to be one of the most contentious bands in the history of the prog rock genre. Throughout their discography, prog fans have heralded some of their work as the greatest of all time while bashing other albums as making a mockery of everything progressive material stands for. However, for all the sparring that has been thrown at the band, it has been one hell of a journey.
Originally forming in the late '60s with Peter Gabriel up front, the band had some of the most daring soundscapes of the day, with songs like "The Knife" feeling like the sound of rock being split wide open. Even when drafting new members like Steve Hackett and Phil Collins, the band continued to innovate on albums like Selling England by the Pound, where they invented new techniques in production as well as Hackett's use of tapping before Van Halen on "Dancing with the Moonlit Knight."
People tend to check out shortly after Phil Collins took over for Gabriel on vocals, citing the band's change in sound being his fault. The verge into pop was a bit of a mixed bag, but this was beyond just the idea of selling out. Once Genesis hit it big, prog rock finally had the capacity to take on the pop charts and become one of the most seminal genres in all of rock and roll.