10 Hard Rock Albums Critics Were Completely Wrong About

Nirvana's Nevermind was called "too polished"...?!

Nevermind Album
DGC

Critics tend to have a reputation as the snooty sort of music fans. When all the rest of us want to enjoy the albums that we have in front of us, these guys have come to the forefront to say that these jams aren't as great as we think they are. However, even the most dignified critics weren't right all the time, and nowhere has this been more apparent than with hard rock.

Throughout the years, it's almost become a trend that critics don't take a liking to the heavier side of rock. For the more pretentious sort, the thought of rocking out to loud riffs may seem like the most barbaric thing a listener could imagine partaking in. When these guys aren't tearing these classic records to ribbons, they are normally missing out on some of the greatest music of their generation.

Whether it be lambasting something classic or praising something abysmal, no critic is safe from the keen eye of hindsight. With a lot of material to sift through, let's take a look at just a small helping of the artists that got endless amounts of ridicule without deserving a single shred of it.

10. Drones - Muse

It's pretty hard to make a call on a rock album so close after its release date. For as much as critics may like to slog anything new, they don't typically have the benefit of hindsight to see how the record has held up. However, even with just a few years behind it, Muse's Drones is the one record in their catalog that continues to be misunderstood.

At the time, the critics' opinion of the album was fairly mixed, oftentimes singling out individual tracks as good but nothing too spellbinding overall. Upon further inspection though, Drones is probably one of the more ambitious undertakings that this power trio has ever done. Centered around a dystopian society (like most Muse albums), this one shows the band honing their craft as mainstream rock giants, with songs like "Mercy" and "Dead Inside" stacking layers of vocal harmonies while the bass foundations thunders away at the bottom.

While a single like "Psycho" can seem a bit basic, it doesn't really matter if the riff is this captivating. Complete with a few stomper tracks like "Reapers" and "The Handler," this is not just Muse striving to make a good rock record, but to make one of the best rock offerings the 2010's had ever seen.


9. In Rock - Deep Purple

It almost goes without saying how much Deep Purple has effected the rock landscape. With their use of classical and jazz backgrounds, these guys brought a level of sonic sophistication to the typical hard rock and blues coming from the British club scene. Even though the band's 4th record In Rock is heralded as one of the greatest in the genre, not everyone was exactly head over heels.

Way back in its heyday, Rolling Stone reviewer Lester Bangs was having absolutely none of the band's fury, as he tears into them about their lack of expertise on their instruments and criticizes the band's riffs as some of the most poorly-thought-out of the genre. It's almost comical looking back on these kind of harsh words nowadays.

Not only did In Rock change the game in hard rock, but also expanded the palette for what a rock band could do, like on the manic 10 minute journey of "Child In Time" or the precursor to heavy metal with "Speed King." For every fan that a band makes, they're going to make their fair share of enemies, but it seems that time is a lot kinder to Deep Purple than Bangs could have ever imagined.


8. Are You Experienced - Jimi Hendrix

Jimi Hendrix's debut is one of those rare moments in rock music that we may never see again. Blasting through the rest of the rock scene, Hendrix's unique songwriting approach and god-like guitar playing became the blueprint for every hard rock guitarist that was to follow. It's almost impossible to find anything wrong with this record, but the music press was actually thinking a lot differently.

As opposed to heaping this album with the praise it rightfully deserves, the response from the music critics of the time were actually mixed. Whenever you look over the reviews for this album, you will find just as many reviews that are on the fence as you will find raving reviews. While none of them tend to say anything too nasty, the general consensus coming from critics was normally boiled down "You'll either love him or hate him."

There may be a fair argument there given Hendrix's laid back vocal approach and abrasive sound, but there was a lot more to this album than anyone could have predicted. Given all the innovations this album made, it's almost understandable that the music business didn't understand it. This was music that was both of its time as well being miles ahead of everything else.


7. A Thousand Suns - Linkin Park

Bands making a transition are always difficult for the music press to grasp. Whenever an artist undertakes a genre pivot, you can bet your ass that it'll be noted by music critics if you come up with something lackluster. However, for as drastic a change that Linkin Park made in 2010, the results have actually held up pretty well that many might remember.

A Thousand Suns does admittedly suffer from a few too many interludes, but the different approach on songs like "Robot Boy" and "Waiting For the End" still have that same energy that they did when they were first released. Sure, the conceptual side of the album may have been a tough sell, but when talking about something like war and destruction, the pain in these songs is definitely palpable.

Even though the fans were definitely not having any of these new electronic soundscapes, the band's ability to firmly embrace the synthetic side of their sound ended up paying off in the long run. As the 2010's unfolded, many artists would be using the model of A Thousand Suns and bringing that electronic approach to their own songs.

Linkin Park may have gotten a mixed reception for their grand vision, but even when they had mixed reviews, they were still ahead of the curve.


6. Relationship Of Command - At The Drive In

At the Drive In was a complete shock to the hard rock world when they burst onto the scene in the early 2000's. Off the strength of their album Relationship of Command, the band created a controlled sense of chaos that seemed to both reject and embrace every rock genre and mold them into one unique ball of noise. It may have been a musical call to arms, but the music business seemed to be more perplexed than anything else.

Upon release, this album was certainly given praise for singles like "One Armed Scissor," but most of the critics at the time were still getting used to what they were hearing. Given that this was one of the first post hardcore releases of the millennium, many of the musical big wigs were a bit skeptical when giving praise, as if they weren't entirely sure if they liked it or not.

One infamous Pitchfork review actually ended up giving the record a 6/10, but even in the review they admit that the album probably deserves more than that lukewarm score. Regardless of its weird breaking in period, Relationship of Command has gone on to become one of the most important releases for hard rock and some of the greatest examples of sonic chaos you will ever hear.


5. Nevermind - Nirvana

Every so often, there are those records that just seem to hit a nerve with an entire generation. Regardless of whether the music is good or not, these albums stick with the listener throughout life and end up shaping the entire rock world around it. Nevermind by Nirvana is certainly an album worthy of that kind of title, but seeing what some critics were saying about this record back then seems almost sacrilegious.

In one of the more famous cases of a reviewer dropping the ball, Rolling Stone columnist Ira Robbins initially panned Nirvana's sophomore effort, calling it the result of the band getting too polished too fast. While there's a certain amount of sonic sheen to the entire record, the actual poignancy in the tracks overcomes any type of glittery production values.

But he's not done yet, folks. Robbins also goes on to say that this record is not only a disappointment, but the result of the band squandering their potential as songwriters. Even with every objective argument in the world, a song like "Smells Like Teen Spirit" is a feat of musical genius, with Kurt Cobain using disassociated phrases to bring across the apathy of Generation X.

Rolling Stone may have corrected themselves by calling Nevermind the greatest album of the '90s, but sometimes it's hard to hide from your past.


4. St. Anger - Metallica

Throughout most of this list, these records are comprised of songs that never really got a fair shake. Over the years, thousands of bands have come through with albums that don't deserve the harsh criticism they receive. Once in a blue moon though, you get an album that is granted praise where it doesn't deserve it.

Though Metallica had been going through a rough spot leading up to the recording of St. Anger, the resulting album is one of the harshest listens in the band's catalog, with songs that feel half-finished and ear-grading at their worst. However, that didn't stop the big wigs of the record industry from piling on the compliments when it came to this record. While every other reviewer was raving about this being the heaviest in the band's catalog, they were ignoring the fact that said heaviness was the exact reason that fans were turned off by it, with one of the worst snare drum sounds in recorded history.

Many would place this in the bottom half of the band's catalog, but all those blind praises ended up winning the title track a Grammy the next year. For any other band, this record would have gotten torn to shreds, but when it's Metallica, most critics were quick to look past its flaws.


3. ALMOST EVERY ALBUM - Rush

Usually when you look through the back catalogs of classic bands, there is normally that one album that fans love but critics despise. No matter how much people defended it then and now, that didn't stop the critics from ignoring every other opinion so they could trash a record. Whereas it's normally just one album for classic bands, Rush has had to deal with this kind of scrutiny with every classic album they released.

From the band's first prog outings on Fly By Night to the wild experimentation of albums like 2112 and Hemispheres, critics were not really feeling this band's blend of heavy sonic movements. When talking about the negative backlash, hard rock businessman and longtime Rush supporter Cliff Burnstein mentioned that the one thing that critics hate more than anything was progressive music and heavy metal, with Rush sitting right in the middle of those two camps.

The easy targets have always been the arrangements being "too complicated" and Geddy Lee's voice being compared to everything from a deathly howl to a shrill dog. Though there have been countless bad press given to Rush over the years, the band remained strong for over 40 years and carved out one of the biggest legacies in hard rock music.


2. Black Sabbath - Black Sabbath

Black Sabbath's debut record marks a pivotal moment in the world of hard rock. With the perfect combination of blues fury and demonic howling, the album set the precedent for heaviness in rock and marked the beginning of metal music as we know it today. Such an album would be cause for celebration, but this initial offering was met with outright contempt by some of the top music critics.

Coming from Lester Bangs once again, the legendary Rolling Stone reviewer couldn't bring himself to say anything except the music being passable, with the rest of it feeling like a rerun of something like Cream. In one of the most apocryphal instances of the review, Bangs dares to call the vocals from Ozzy Osbourne sparse at best, with Tony Iommi bringing criticized for being a Clapton wannabe.

Legend has it that one negative review gave the new genre its name, with one reviewer likening their sound to "a load of heavy metal being dropped." In retrospect though, this was the moment where heavy metal began taking shape as a serious force in the music world. No matter what was said back then, these scraggly kids from Birmingham were about to become legends of the hard rock world.


1. Led Zeppelin II - Led Zeppelin

Whenever you think of anything hard rock, there's a good chance you're thinking of some band that ripped off Led Zeppelin. Every group after Zeppelin from Pearl Jam to Aerosmith to Deep Purple all owe their careers to these four English rockers who lit the world on fire. The band's sophomore effort is seen as an essential mix of hard rock music, but the critics had a lot more to say.

Though Rolling Stone initially had some harsh things to say about the band's debut album, it's a musical sin of the highest order once you hear their review of this record. Throughout the entire thing, critic John Mendelsohn proceeds to mock Zeppelin for their lack of talent, sarcastically framing the entire review as if he's a burnout kid talking about his favorite band.

While sarcasm certainly has its place in music journalism, Mendelsohn couldn't have been more off the mark when talking about one of the greatest rock bands in the world. Not only is this album far from bad, but it's partly responsible for rock evolving the way it has, from the riff based writing of Jimmy Page to the relentless sonic assault of John Bonham's drums. Zeppelin's legacy may not have been secure at the time, but once the entire rock tribe started walking in their footsteps, they became one of the genre's most legendary bands.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97