10 Hard Rock Bands Who FIRED Important Members

Partying a little too hard.

Foo fighters original lineup william goldsmith
RCA Records

Being in a band is a lot like being in a marriage most of the time. Outside of the millions of shows that you have to put on one year after another, you always have to make sure that you come back to why you loved performing in the first place. If this was a musical marriage, these groups were bound for the divorce court.

Once these bands tasted success, it became clear that there were one or two people who were no longer pulling their own weight.

Whether it was because of letting their ego go to their head or just a difference of opinion when it came to the group's directions, these musicians were sent packing and left without any hope for rock and roll stardom.

These weren't just some random expulsions either. Oftentimes, these musicians were key to the band's sound, and had a hand in writing many of their classic songs.

Although some of them went into obscurity, it's also interesting to take a look back on how these groups recovered and how the musicians rose from being the pariahs of the music industry. These situations are always heartbreaking for everyone involved, but what's rock and roll without at least some sort of drama?

10. Slipknot - Joey Jordison

The dynamic of Slipknot has really started to change as time has gone on. Compared to the 9 maniacs that were onstage night after night, the Knot feels a lot more like a brotherhood now, with each member giving their all to every performance. That doesn't mean that they haven't had stumbling blocks along the way though.

After tragically losing Paul Gray to drugs once the tour for All Hope is Gone was wrapping up, the Maggots were dealt with another blow when they learned that they were parting ways with Joey Jordison as well.

Considering this is a band that's known for having 3 percussionists, losing Joey was one of the biggest bombshells you could have asked for, since he was the one behind naming the group and delivering one assault after another on songs like Psychosocial and the Heretic Anthem.

They did manage to survive though, drafting in Jay Weinberg from Against Me! and moving from strength to strength on .5 the Gray Chapter in memory of their late bass player. Although Joey was always meaning to get back together with Slipknot later down the line, it all became impossible when we lost him back in July.

Still, it's better that they were at least on good terms before everything ended. Whether in or out of Slipknot, Joey will always be a part of the Slipknot family.


9. Pearl Jam - Dave Abbruzzese

If you had to nail down who the least necessary person in a rock band is, 9 times out of 10 people will say the drummer. I mean, unless your name is John Bonham or Neil Peart, being the guy who bangs on things for a living isn't always given top billing alongside those who write the riffs. It also doesn't help when your bandmates have an axe to grind.

When Pearl Jam were shuffling through drummers in the early days, Dave Abbruzzese tended to get picked on the most. Whereas Matt Cameron and Jack Irons fell into place perfectly during their stints with the band, Dave was starstruck with all of the attention, which drove Eddie Vedder up the wall. If that wasn't bad enough, Dave also talked frequently about his nonmusical habits of owning guns, which Vedder sarcastically immortalized in the song Glorified G.

By the time that they got finished making the album Vitalogy, Abbruzzese started to feel more and more unnecessary in Eddie's mind, leading to Irons taking over midway through the recording process.

Even though Pearl Jam could have probably turned any riff into gold in the mid '90s, the fact that they kept shuffling around behind the drummers stool was enough to put them on shaky ground.


8. Queens of the Stone Age - Nick Oliveri

If all that you have to deal with is some moody bandmates during your career, you'd still be doing a damn good job.

Since the worst bands tend to fall out over everything from business to managers trying to screw them over, having the occasional fight over creative differences is almost tame. And then you have Queens of the Stone Age actually having to get the police involved.

That's not selling short what Nick Oliveri did either. As the tour for Songs for the Deaf was wrapping up, things were already starting to go a little haywire with Oliveri's antics, but that was nothing compared to what was happening back home.

Once getting off the road, fans were shocked to learn of the different abusive tendencies that Oliveri was having with his wife, which got the FBI involved more than a few times.

While most bandmates try to forgive and forget, Joshua Homme didn't waste a second sending Oliveri packing from Queens. In his own words, Homme was shellshocked by his behavior and honestly felt that he was talking to a completely different person than the bassist that he had known for all those years.

Then again, the devil is always in the details no matter what kind of person you are.


7. Rush - John Rutsey

For any band that's known as a trio, replacing any one member is going to mess up the formula on principle.

Since there's only three of you guys on stage, how are you supposed to sound the same when you have a completely new person working with you? Although John Rutsey wasn't necessarily a bad drummer by any means, Rush letting him go led to one of the greatest tradeups in rock history.

It's not like Alex Lifeson and Geddy Lee wanted Rutsey to leave...it was just a conflict of interest. As they started to branch out musically, Lifeson and Lee's interest in bands like King Crimson and Genesis weren't gelling with Rutsey's style anymore, who wanted the band to focus on the tried and true rock bands like Bad Company and Cream.

What really broke the band up though was the physical toll that John's body was taking on the road. Being diagnosed with juvenile diabetes, the tour manager was the one who needed to read them the riot act. Either John had to be let go or he was probably going to be brought back from the tour in a box.

Despite being heartbroken to leave their friend behind, Rush's rebirth with Neil Peart changed the course of prog rock forever, ushering in more ambitious concepts for the group.

Rush's early days were still great, they just needed to lose some of the dead weight though.


6. Guns N Roses - Steven Adler

You don't get the name of being the World's Most Dangerous Band by accident.

By the time that Guns N Roses had come off tour promoting their first album Appetite for Destruction, it was clear that Slash and Duff McKagan were as much a danger to themselves as they were to people around them, getting trashed every night and dancing a bit too close to the fire. In Axl Rose's eyes though, they were necessary. Steven Adler was not.

Although Duff and Slash had the habit of hitting the booze, Steven Adler's growing dependence on heroin was getting too much for the rest of the band to take. After working like a dog on the road, Adler was barely able to get his act together when going into recording the Use Your Illusion records, oftentimes screwing up in between takes and relapsing at his house.

Slash and Duff couldn't even help him at this point either, saying that they went to his house and would find stuff behind the toilet. Since this was going to be the Guns' ambitious double record, Steven was out the door and replaced with Matt Sorum.

It only got worse for Adler though, who would eventually suffer a cocaine induced stroke as the years went on. While he's been on the road to recovery for years now, the chances of him coming back to GNR are probably slim to none.


5. Def Leppard - Pete Willis

Any band worth its salt is going to have to bring their A game into the studio. No matter what kind of hangups you might have in your personal life, it all comes down to when you're in the vocal booth and are able to let it rip so you can get your songs on vinyl.

Especially when you're working with a producer like Mutt Lange, you're gonna have to come correct. And Def Leppard were on board...with one small exception.

Trying to outdo High N Dry, Pyromania was meant to combine Leppard's hard rock sound with a polished sheen, which involved cutting take after take of guitar tracks upon each other. While everyone found their way to the other side, Pete Willis' reliance on drinking wasn't gelling with the rest of the group, which led to the band giving him a leave of absence to cool out.

Or...that's what Pete was told. At the same time, Girl guitarist Phil Collen was brought in to play the solos on the album that Pete wasn't able to pull off, leading to him joining the band shortly after the album wrapped.

Even though Pete does get credit for the rhythm guitar tracks on the album, it has to sting knowing that the real guitar hero moments were added well after you were gone.


4. Van Halen - David Lee Roth

As far as rock band dynamics go, there's no doubting that the frontman is the one that people focus on. It's kind of right there in the name.

Since you're the one singing the songs and eating up the crowd out IN FRONT of the stage, there's no reason why people would want to focus on the bass player instead of you. When you get up on that pedestal though, it gets a little bit difficult to come back down sometimes.

As Van Halen were making their way into the '80s, they were already gaining traction as one of the biggest bands in the world, having kickstarted the glam rock movement on the Sunset Strip. As their touring schedule got more and more hectic though, Eddie Van Halen wanted to explore new sonic avenues for 1984, which really didn't mesh with David Lee Roth's hard rock aesthetic.

While the album ended up selling like gangbusters, it would prove to be the last with Roth, with his ego becoming much too big for the Van Halen's to take anymore. Even though that kind of loss would have killed any other band, drafting in Sammy Hagar gave them a completely new lease on life, going from strength to strength with a completely different feel.

Any frontman can come and go in rock history, but if the music still kicks ass, what's there to worry about?


3. Metallica - Dave Mustaine

As the years go on, it feels like Dave Mustaine's contribution to Metallica keeps getting wiped out of the metal community's collective memory. And for good reason too, since Dave has proven that he could make it on his own with Megadeth no matter how big his older band seems to get.

Then again, how do you find yourself in a band nicknamed Alcoholica and then get shown the door for drinking too much?

Well, alcohol always affects people differently, and Dave's behavior on the first few tours with Metallica were getting more and more out of hand. When the band finally got a chance to sign with Megaforce Records on the East Coast, their trip to New York was marred by Mustaine trashing people's houses and getting into fights that got them into serious trouble.

By the time they had gotten to New York, Mustaine was handed a Greyhound bus ticket back to California, with Kirk Hammett coming on for Kill Em All. Having written a good chunk of the material, it became more of an issue when Dave's riffs started showing up on some Metallica classics like The Call of Ktulu and The Four Horsemen.

At the same time, it takes a special kind of metalhead to start all the way back at square one and make it to the top of the food chain twice.


2. Foo Fighters - William Goldsmith

For all of the work they have done keeping rock alive over the past few years, can we all acknowledge that Foo Fighters was never meant to be a band?

When Dave Grohl was first starting to make a name for himself after Nirvana ended, this entire project was supposed to be a placeholder album for him to just let out his songwriting chops.

So when you have to fill out the band around you, how can you not run into some trouble?

Although the original version of the Foos worked well with Pat Smear and Nate Mendel, William Goldsmith began to feel more and more out of step when it came time to record The Colour and the Shape.

Since you have a drumming legend like Grohl looking over your shoulder throughout the entire process, Goldsmith was getting more and more frustrated about not being able to express himself, especially when being called "the rhythmless section" by the producer.

If you think that's bad, it only got worse when Goldsmith realized that the band actually rerecorded the entire album behind his back, with Dave playing the drums on the record instead.

While these are the kind of hangups that come with putting any band together, Goldsmith didn't really deserve to be humiliated on such a grand stage like this.


1. Black Sabbath - Ozzy Osbourne

Out of every other musician in metal music, Ozzy Osbourne has had one of the oddest career trajectories. From the looks of raw album sales, it looks amazing, with him coming from the end of Black Sabbath to having one of the greatest solo careers in history with albums like Blizzard of Ozz.

Just before he got Randy Rhoads in tow though, he was looking like the punch line of the entire hard rock community.

As Sabbath came off of albums like Sabotage, it was becoming clear that the iteration of the band with Ozzy wasn't going to pan out, with Ozzy becoming more and more blitzed out of his mind on cocaine at every turn.

By the time that they actually went on tour for albums like Technical Ecstasy, Ozzy could no longer be considered the frontman anymore, often appearing off to the side while Tony Iommi grabbed the spotlight.

After teasing leaving the band for so long, Sabbath eventually relented and decided to let Ozzy go after the release of Never Say Die, eventually trading up with Ronnie James Dio for the album Heaven and Hell shortly afterward. Considering that Ozzy found another guitar god in Randy Rhoads though for his first few solo outings, it's safe to say that both parties found themselves on stable ground afterward.


In this post: 
Foo Fighters
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97