10 Key Elements To The Paul McCartney Is Dead Theory
I Buried Paul!
The "Paul McCartney is dead" theory has been around since the mid-60s. Although many believe it to be a ridiculous hoax concocted by fanatic Beatles fans with nothing else to do, there are certain key elements to the rumor that just can't be ignored.
Sure, we all know it sounds stupid. How likely is it that Paul McCartney died in a car crash only to be replaced by a lookalike? The chances are low, but anything is possible in the wonderful world of music. All you need to do is look a little closer, conspiracy theories don't just appear out of thin air and they always have a little element of truth.
The Beatles back catalog is chock block full of hints and signals that the legendary bass player popped his clogs. Plus, it has been suggested that The Beatles played on the ridiculous notion that Macca had died, egging on the rumor and gaining record sales as a result.
We all have our own opinions when it comes to the supposed death of Paul McCartney. Even if he did die his replacement still wrote "Hey Jude" so it wasn't all bad.
10. The Butcher Cover/The Trunk Cover
By 1966, The Beatles were fed up with their clean-cut image. To ruffle a few feathers they decided to shock the world with a provoking album cover.
The album in question was "Yesterday and Today" a collection of random songs built for the North American market. The cover to the album included a bunch of decapitated dolls draped over the band who were all appropriately dressed in butcher coats.
Unsurprisingly, audiences weren't quite ready for butchered babies, especially ones that were covered in fake blood, raw meat, and cigarette burns. Despite the band claiming that it was an abstract representation of them as real-life people, the world was outraged.
Due to a large amount of money spent on the album's production nothing much could be done apart from sticking a new image, the "trunk cover" over the offending picture. This then led to thousands of fans peeling off the pasted-on covers to see what they would find underneath.
The "trunk cover" was also controversial as it featured Paul McCartney in a coffin-like trunk with the rest of the band surrounding him. Was this The Beatles trying to tell us something?
9. The One And Only Billy Shears
When the iconic White Album was released fans were treated to some intimate Beatles photography. The photos included a picture of Paul McCartney being submerged in water which many claimed was a real-life image of Macca being washed before his autopsy. Dark, right?
To make things even more mysterious a photo of a Mr. William Campbell Shears was placed underneath. So who was this man? Why did he resemble Paul McCartney? And what did he have to do with the band?
The theory goes that William Campbell Shears was drafted in to replace Paul McCartney after Macca had perished in a car crash. When the band first heard the news that their beloved bandmate had died, they quickly held a McCartney lookalike competition which Campbell Shears eventually won.
Campbell Shears was also sometimes referred to as Billy Shears. The same Billy Shears who was mentioned during the opening track of the Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band album.
The plot thickens...
8. The Walrus Was Paul
The Beatles loved to mess with their fans especially the ones who read too much into their lyrics. For a laugh, the band often inserted hidden messages within the walls of their songs, something that contributed to the eventual "Paul is dead" theory.
One of the most famous clues belongs to Lennon's masterpiece, "I am the Walrus" a song that was fittingly inspired by an acid trip. The tune is full of nonsensical lines and silly noises that refer to previous Beatles records and the lyrics that they contain.
The photoshoot that was used to accompany the track was also clouded in suspicion mostly because John Lennon, George Harrison, and Ringo Starr were all dressed in white while poor Paul McCartney was draped in black. What could this mean? Death of course.
Lennon referred to the song a couple of years later in the magnificent, "Glass Onion" a track that also referred to previous Beatle tunes. In one part of the song, Lennon can be heard singing, "Well here's another clue for you all, The Walrus was Paul."
The result? Hardcore "Paul is dead" theorists going into overdrive.
7. He Blew His Mind Out In A Car
The details of Paul McCartney's supposed death are extremely intricate. Everything from the way he died to his time of death, along with who died with him and what day of the week it happened on has been documented in musical form, apparently.
Firstly, McCartney was said to have died in a car crash. We "know" this because Lennon referred to the crash in the epic, "A Day in the Life" wistfully singing, "He blew his mind out in a car." Secondly, it has been suggested that McCartney died on a Wednesday at 5 am. How do we know this? Because the imposter McCartney sings "Wednesday at five o'clock as the day begins..." in the ballad, "She's Leaving Home."
Thirdly, the car accident was supposedly caused by a hitchhiker named Rita who McCartney had picked up while driving home. Could it be "Lovely Rita" who fake Paul sings about in the song of the same name? And what about "Good Morning, Good Morning" or should we say, "Good Mourning Good Mourning..."
Get it?
6. 28IF
The Abbey Road album is responsible for a lot of things. For one, it is the best album The Beatles ever released. Secondly, it is probably one of the best albums in the entire world. Interestingly and annoyingly, it is also responsible for many "Paul is dead" conspiracists.
The album cover is filled to the brim with clues and hidden hints regarding poor Paul McCartney's untimely death. The biggest one being the order of the band as they walk across the notorious zebra crossing. First, you've got John Lennon acting as the pallbearer dressed in white, then you've got Ringo Starr donned in black so obviously he's the undertaker. Then comes George Harrison lagging at the back, dressed in work clothes behaving like the gravedigger.
Finally, you've got a shoeless Paul McCartney walking out of synch with the rest of the band along with a splattering of blood behind him. Plus, he's also smoking a cigarette with his right hand (Paul was a lefty).
But that's not all. Behind them is a car with a license plate that reads 28IF. Does this mean that if Macca had survived he would have been 28? Hence, IF28? Probably not because McCartney would have actually been 27 but let's just forget about that tiny detail.
5. The Sgt. Pepper Hand
The Sgt. Pepper album changed rock music forever. Not only did it certify just how cool concept albums could be but it was also a masterpiece that schooled other bands around the world on how to make actual decent music.
It wasn't just the content that blew everybody's mind away the album's design also set the benchmark for iconic album covers. In fact, the album's design is almost as famous as the songs.
The cover includes a colorful collective collage of cardboard cut-outs all representing famous and iconic figures from history. In the middle, The Beatles stand center stage dressed as the elusive and fictitious, "the one and only..." Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band.
As expected, the album cover brought a lot of theories. Many of which alluded to Paul McCartney being dead. One of the main things pointed towards the mysterious hand that can be seen hovering over Macca's head. It was later suggested that the hand was a symbol of death and that it was placed there to confirm the rumors that poor old Paul had passed away.
4. Miss Him, Miss Him, Miss Him
Over the years, many people have claimed that when playing a Beatle tune backward you can find special messages and signs that point to various things. The main one being that Paul McCartney is dead.
For instance, during The White album classic, "I'm So Tired" Lennon can be heard mumbling at the end of the song, "Paul is dead man, miss him, miss him, miss him." And that's not all. In the already strange and freaky, "Revolution 9" a backward message can be heard whispering, "Turn me on, dead man, turn me on, dead man, turn me on."
The Beatles would often get annoyed when asked about their backward bumblings and denied all knowledge of it. In fact, John Lennon was so angry with the accusations that he once claimed, "It’s the most stupid rumor I’ve ever heard. It sounds like the same guy who blew up my Christ remark. I don’t know what Beatles records sound like backward; I never play them backward."
The Beatle doth protest too much, methinks...
3. Cranberry Sauce!
We all know that John Lennon likes a laugh so much so that he decided to mess with Beatles fans that little bit more when referencing Paul McCartney's supposed death in the classic, "Strawberry Fields Forever."
The track really showcases Lennon's strong abilities as a songwriter. During the song, Lennon takes listeners on a journey through his childhood and teenage years, and in some parts, it actually gets rather emotional. It's a deep song with deep meaning and a glimpse into Lennon's often upsetting past. Then, in typical Lennon fashion, the song ends with Lennon speaking the words, "Cranberry sauce" bringing back the classic nonsensical element to his music.
But did he really say "Cranberry sauce"? Apparently not.
According to avid listeners, Lennon actually dropped one of the biggest "Paul is dead" clues of all time with many suggesting that he said "I buried Paul" instead.
2. The Infamous Scar
One of the biggest clues to the "Paul is dead" theory is a scar that hovers just above McCartney's top lip. McCartney acquired the injury after falling off his moped while visiting family in Liverpool. The accident was so bad that he also chipped some of his teeth.
As a result, McCartney decided to grow a mustache to hide his scar. Unfortunately for Macca, his mustache didn't grow quickly enough. This meant that Beatles fans were treated to an unusual looking Paul McCartney in the "Paperback Writer" video. For many, this was definite proof that Macca had been replaced with a lookalike. It was then suggested that the lookalike (probably William Campbell Shears) had undergone surgery to look more like the Beatle bass player, hence the scar and mangled gnashers.
Even more suspiciously, McCartney's friend, Guinness heir Tara Browne, was said to have been with him on the night of the crash. The same Tara Browne who died in a car crash not long after and the same Tara Browne who was mentioned in the lyrics to "A Day In The Life."
1. Bass Guitar Wreath
Back in the early days, the band had another bass player, Mr. Stuart Sutcliffe. Sutcliffe was a pal of Lennon's and one of those arty creative types. He was a good guy but a terrible bass player and used to play with his back to the audience so they wouldn't see how awful he was. Sadly, Sutcliffe passed away at just 21 years old leaving the band without a bassist.
Nobody wanted the job because, as we all know, the bass player is the least memorable member of any band. After much pressure, McCartney was lumbered with the instrument mostly because he could play just about anything.
As expected, Macca quickly took the instrument under his wing and became one of the best bass players of all time. So, is this the reason why there is a bass guitar-shaped wreath in the bottom right-hand corner of the Sgt Pepper album? Acting as a sort of symbol to remember their recently deceased band member?
Some say it's a subtle reference to ex-bandmate, Stuart Sutcliffe while others claim it is a direct reference to the best bass player in the world, Paul McCartney. Whatever the case, it sure is creepy.