10 Major Albums Where Everything Went Wrong
No Hooks, No Fun, No End in Sight.
Sometimes when you've been in the business for a while, you tend to pull the short straw every now and again. No matter how much of a hot streak you may claim to have, nobody's perfect, and you end up putting out something that is treated like a clunker by the audience.
Even though you can pull out bits and pieces of genius from these, you also have those few instances where everything crumbles around you.
Regardless of which genre you find yourself in, no artist is free from being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Across each respective decade, these albums have been...let's say ill advised and just leave it at that. Because if we had time to dissect every single bit of these albums, chances are we'd be here all day.
From the likes of albums with massive potential to projects that were just a bad idea to begin with, each one of these are the kind of glorious failures that are reserved for bad sketches on a sitcom.
Trust us...the only reason that we're laughing is to keep ourselves from crying at how much of a trainwreck we have in front of us. It may have seemed good at the outset, but the final product left absolutely nothing salvageable to latch onto.
10. Two Virgins - John Lennon and Yoko Ono
At the turn of the '60s, any member of the Beatles could put audio of their own farts on record and it would have sold. Compared to the other bands coming out of the British Invasion, you couldn't touch the level of fame the Fab Four got in their prime, even going so far as to become leaders of the next generation of counter culture hippies. Even though things could only go up from here, Two Virgins from John Lennon marked the point where we found out they were fallible.
Being the first in a string of experimental albums with Yoko Ono, this is about as experimental as it gets for rock and roll, with most of the record amounting to Ono and Lennon making random noises and recording them just for the hell of it. Even though there is an experimental bent to the structure, other experimental acts like Captain Beefheart and Frank Zappa are way more engaging than something like this.
It's not like they didn't warn us ahead of time though, given that the original cover was just the couple posing naked in front of a random white backdrop shot just after the album was recorded. Let's face it...if that's already a high bar for you to clear, this record is going to be the moment where Lennon goes fully off the deep end.
9. St. Anger - Metallica
Every single artist can claim to have a slight hiccup whenever going into one of their albums. It's pretty much the nature of the beast to have that one album that has something stacked against it, be it a deadline or just a creative hurdle that you have to jump through. By the time Metallica got to that point though, every single trope came back to bite them on the ass for St. Anger.
Throughout most of the runtime, you can hear the raw frustration that the band had in the studio making this one, as Jason Newsted quit and James Hetfield spent the better part of a year away from the band in rehab. Though the skeletons of these songs would have made for something fairly decent, the god awful production and the shotgun snare is still the stuff of nightmares for any production guru who dares to give this record a listen.
Even the stuff that would have been alright on Metallica standards tends to clock out here, as Hetfield's lyrics feel too artificial for their own good and the riffs sounding some cheap attempt at nu metal. While the band eventually moved on from the sting of St. Anger, this is the kind of metal that would have been laughed out of the room if it was from any other band.
8. 0304 - Jewel
Ever since it's been brought into existence, the adult alternative style of songwriter can always find a home with the public. Though none of these songs are meant to stick around for too long, you can normally expect an audience of a handful of hipsters and/or disgruntled 30 something parents to get a kick out of what you're doing. That's not what Jewel wanted though...she wanted to be the next Britney Spears.
Hoping to put a new edge into her sound, 0304 is the sound of her taking every wrong step to turn into a pop starlet mold, with Intuition being the litmus test for things not going right. While initially balking at this kind of song by saying that it was a satire of the celebrity lifestyle, it clearly makes a few fumbles when you start to hear her adopt the pillowy soft falsetto that acts like Britney were making at the time.
When you sit with the rest of the record, it delivers on the promise the single made too, as most of these songs either sound like blatant homages to Britney and Christina or trying to appease the edgy crowd with a couple of songs that sound like half-baked Avril Lavigne ripoffs. Even though Jewel might claim that it's satire, what's the thing we're making fun of exactly?
7. The Big Day - Chance the Rapper
After the success of Coloring Book, people were dying to see what Chance the Rapper had up his sleeve for his next project. Since most of his independent mixtapes ended up becoming some of the most thoughtful and care free hip hop of the modern age, his first debut album was sure to be one for the ages. Then the Big Day happened and sucked all of the fun out of the room.
With an already bloated collection of tracks, Chance pulls out every corny bar he can think of for this project, complete with some references to everything from the Dimmsdale Dimmadome to every single wretched bar of Hot Shower. While there are a few guests on display here, they add absolutely nothing when you have them alongside Chance's warped delivery across everything.
It may seem interesting to have someone like Ben Gibbard adding his trademark voice to the album...it would also be nice if it was paired with an actual good song though. Then again, it's not fair to bat this thing down too hard, considering most of it was coming from a genuine place of love as Chance was celebrating his marriage to his wife. Kudos to you Chance, but just a fair reminder: just because you're having fun doesn't mean that your audience is having just as much fun.
6. Father of All... - Green Day
Every so often, you get records that seem to be made out of necessity. No matter how much you may not want to make a record at the time, that pesky record contract will keep breathing down your neck until you finally put out something that the label can work with. Though this kind of thing is reserved for the more high profile rock acts, it stings coming from one with a punk rock ethic.
Granted, it's not like Father of All is the worst thing in the world or anything. If you're into Green Day thusfar, this record will probably do the trick for you...if only for a little while. Compared to the rest of Green Day's catalog, this thing is criminally short at just under a half hour in runtime. Though that should be gangbusters for a punk album, this album screams like Billie Joe Armstrong wants to be rid of the major labels for good, as evidenced in lackluster songs like I Was a Teenage Teenager.
To put it in perspective, the same year this was released we got a project from the Green Day side project the Network, which was miles better than what we got with the proper band. Despite the quasi edgy title and cover art, there's really not much to get worked up about with this latest offering from pop punk's founding fathers.
5. Jesus is King - Kanye West
90% of the reason why Kanye West is followed these days comes from the controversial things that he puts out in the media. Though there has been a bit of a firestorm towards him as of late, most of the great work to come from My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy and 808s and Heartbreak have as much to do with Ye's personal life as the music itself. As much as you felt like you were getting a peek into his mind, Jesus Is King is the one project where Yeezy feels at arm's length.
Looking to reinvent himself with the Sunday Service Gospel Choir, this entire album feels like the solar antithesis of what Ye had served up with the Life of Pablo just a few years earlier. Rather than trying to rationalize his difficult relationship with faith, this is just a praise and worship album with Ye appearing just enough times to constitute him having full ownership over it.
Even the songs that almost work like Closed on Sunday are reduced to nothing when you hear him sneaking in references to Chic Fil A. If there's anything that warrants criticism in hip hop, it's being unconvincing, and you can practically feel the cynicism through the speakers here. Also, if this is any sign of Ye's new religious conversion going forward, we may be in for even more halfhearted gospel records coming down the pipeline. Yay....?
4. Saturday Night Wrist - Deftones
In the age where nu metal felt like it was breathing its dying breath, Deftones still stood out as pretty damn good amongst their peers. Then again, Deftones were always nu metal adjacent ever since they started, incorporating everything from shoegaze to alternative rock into their sound ever since albums like Around the Fur. Though their self-titled record showed them moving in even more experimental territory, Saturday Night Wrist starts to show the years wearing on them a bit.
It doesn't really look that way on paper though, considering the background that was happening for this album. Looking to write lyrics as a dissection of the overuse of drugs, this felt like an extension of what we had gotten used to on records like White Pony. With super producer Bob Ezrin in tow, Saturday Night Wrist ended up going through a bit of a production hell, as everyone failed to get on the same page for a majority of the record.
This would only prove to be the start of the decline for Deftones too, as the months following this record would involve the tragic car accident of bassist Chi Cheng, which would ultimately claim his life in the years that would follow. Diamond Eyes may have been just around the corner, but those kind of records always tend to come from a place of great pain first.
3. Encore - Eminem
It always sucks when an artist has to deal with people pirating their material. Since you always want to ensure that you're putting your best foot forward when making a record, who the hell wants to deal with some hacker who decides to leak some of your best tracks online just for the hell of it? Most artists can roll with the punches, or if you're Eminem, take one of the biggest Ls of your career with Encore.
Coming off of the more bombastic the Eminem Show, this felt like it was going to be the part 2 that most of us were waiting for, which all turned to sh*t once we heard the finished product. Though some of the leaked tracks like Bully seemed to be fairly captivating in their original form, Marshall decided to get his "payback" by writing an entirely different bunch of tracks, most of which wouldn't have even made it past the first draft stage on any other Eminem album.
Instead of the usual intimidation and occasional dark humor we would get on earlier albums, we have songs like Just Lose It and Ass Like That, each of which show Eminem in his worst light and trying way too hard to shock people. While Marshall would eventually duck out of the spotlight for nearly half a decade after this album to focus on himself, it might have also been just to hide out of pure shame.
2. Invincible - Michael Jackson
All of the worst records in the world are paved on good intentions. No matter how much people may put out some weapons-grade trash in their time, it's not like they were deliberately trying to screw up their sound. There is a right and wrong to market yourself though, and the King of Pop really deserved a better fate than what happened with Invincible.
After getting way too self indulgent in the '90s and coming off of the child abuse allegations he was dealing with around the same time, Michael Jackson really needed a showstopping album to put him in good favors with the public again. It would seem like an easy fix with Invincible's embrace of electronic and dance features...except when Sony decided to put it through the woodchipper.
In the months that followed the album's development, Sony managed to keep Michael from releasing the album how he wanted it to, only limiting the press to one single music video. Think about that for a minute...one of the greatest music video auteurs of the modern day and you only let him produce one for his big comeback...that's some insanely harsh treatment. Instead of the grand return that most Jackson fans might have expected from him at this point, Invincible just felt like an album that was sent kicking and screaming out the door.
1. Van Halen III - Van Halen
If there's any band that knows a thing or two about career resurrections, it would have to have been Van Halen. After losing one of the almighty frontmen in rock with David Lee Roth, the kings of glam metal proved that they had what it took to last, drafting in Sammy Hagar and going on to even more critical acclaim in the years that followed. With Sammy gone at the tail end of the '90s though, they could do it all again...right?
While the idea of bringing in Extreme frontman Gary Cherone wasn't the worst idea on paper, Van Halen's third self-titled release is still one of the most baffling fall from graces in rock music. Just leaving Cherone to copy Sammy's singing style, the entire album just runs like a scatterbrained amalgamation of riffs that add up to nothing by the end of every track.
Though the skeletons of decent Van Halen songs are in here somewhere, it's hard to sift through everything when you're dealing with some of the most befuddling lyrics in the hard rock canon and a singer who's singing sounds like a broken air conditioner at the absolute worst of times. Although we eventually got a return to form of sorts with a Different Kind of Truth in 2012, this was looking like the dark final chapter in Van Halen's evolution for a long while.