10 Manic Street Preachers Hidden Gem Songs
They've been telling us for years that we love them, so who are we to argue. Long live the Manics.
The Manic Street Preachers may have been forever delayed but they have never gone away.
Since their debut album in 1992, the band have made it their business to do things their way, and have succeeded in creating fourteen studio albums that have beguiled, angered, delighted and moved fans in almost equal measure.
There have, undoubtedly, been ebbs and flows, peaks and troughs in the Manics' career. The last 20 of their 30-year career has seen them drop in and out of the public consciousness, but their faithful fanbase have stuck with them through thick and thin; from their decreasing from a four-piece to a three-piece in '95, to the Brit Award wins and the Glastonbury headline slot in '99, to the wilderness years of the mid-2000s, to the comeback of the late-'00s, and everything thereafter.
You never quite know what you're going to get from a new Manics record, so it's easy for a few bangers to pass the listener by. To that end, here's a list of ten such hidden gems that you just might have missed over the decades.
10. Black Holes For The Young
A B-side to 1998 single The Everlasting, Black Holes For The Young features Sophie Ellis-Bextor on co-lead vocals and is one of those songs that makes you wonder what the band were thinking keeping it off This Is My Truth Tell Me Yours. It would have been a fine addition to the record.
The song swirls like the '60s throwback it is intended to be. It was the '90s after all, we were all pretending to be back in the Summer of Love. Ellis-Bextor herself was a member of indie band theaudience, a group that could very well have been the next big britpop band had the Spice Girls not ushered in the renewed mainstream interest in cheesy pop, thereby killing the britpop scene's UK chart dominance for good.
This Is My Truth Tell Me Yours was much darker and introspective than its predecessor, 1996's Everything Must Go, so perhaps that might explain why this relatively jaunty number was excised. It wasn't included on the band's B-side compilation, Lipstick Traces, either.
9. 1985
The opening track from 2004's Lifeblood is reminiscent of The Smashing Pumpkins' 1995 hit, 1979 and sets the band's most disappointing album off to a decent start, as singer James Dean Bradfield and lyricist Nicky Wire find themselves in nostalgia mode (something that became more frequent in their later career). The record's '80s synth pop stylings don't get this good again, which probably explains why it's a forgotten gem.
The song is almost unfussy and so matter-of-fact in its delivery that the usual melodrama of the best Manics tracks is entirely absent. At least until the guitar solo kicks in.
The Pumpkins comparison is particularly appropriate, as this is a song about memory and reminiscence. Wire and Bradfield are remembering their youth with the melancholy one's late-30s can bring about as youth begins to fade and middle-age beckons. Wire has perfected this subject in his later years and this appears to be the start of his preoccupation with the idea of the ageing rock star.
8. Door To The River
As was the trend in the CD era (yeah, it's an era now), when a band would release a Greatest Hits compilation, there would be a new song included for release as a single.
In the case of 2002's Forever Delayed compilation, that song was There By The Grace Of God, and it was a bit rubbish, but nestled somewhere in the middle of the disc was another new song, Door To The River, and it's a lovely ballad that brings to mind the similarly-titled Springsteen track.
At this time in the band's history, they seemed to be moving away from the rambunctious, snot-nosed, sixth form poetry-spouting brattishness of their early work, and even appeared to be disregarding their position as one of the biggest bands in the UK by stepping away from out-and-out rock and from singalong anthems.
This song, and the compilation it was featured on, was released between the lo-fi mess of 2001's Know Your Enemy and the '80s synth-pop of 2004's Lifeblood, a period in which band appeared to have lost their way, and it's hard not to see this song as an introspective play on that very subject. James, singing Nicky's words, even suggests that maybe he's "lost his way, following a star".
7. Judge Y'rself
2003's Lipstick Traces was chiefly a collection of B-sides and covers, but the opportunity was taken to also include two previously recorded and unreleased tracks (more on the other one later).
Judge Y'rself has its place in Manics lore as the last track the group recorded with Richey Edwards still a member of the band. It was recorded in 1995 with the intention of it being used on Sylvester Stallone's much-maligned Judge Dredd movie. Due to Richey's disappearance and the ensuing question marks over the band's future, it was not included on the film's soundtrack.
It took eight years before Judge Y'rself was released as a promotional single for the compilation, and, coming as it did in the wake of singles like There By The Grace Of God, Let Robeson Sing and So Why So Sad, it was a shock to the system. The Manics hadn't rocked this much since, well, since Richey disappeared.
Nobody will ever call Everything Must Go a disappointing release or a bad album, but if this song is a glimpse into what the next record with Richey might have been, it wouldn't have been as big a mainstream hit as Everything... but it would have rocked hard.
6. 4 Ever Delayed
The other "new" track from Lipstick Traces, as the title suggests, was actually recorded for the previous year's Forever Delayed hits compilation. It is, in your humble writer's opinion, a far better song than that album's single and it was a baffling decision to not release it.
Much like Door To The River and 1985, this is the band in a melancholy mood. The title references a line from their earlier single, Roses In The Hospital, but also clearly brings to mind Richey's disappearance and the idea that the band will never forget him or be the same without him. A feeling that has no doubt tainted their lives and any successes they have enjoyed in the years since.
It's a shame that this and the previous two tracks were tucked away on compilations as it minimises their power and gives the impression that they're lesser products. This song in particular is a fine example of how much James' vocal delivery can add meaning to Nicky's sometimes opaque lyrics. You might not always know what the hell he's talking about, but you know he means it.
5. Send Away The Tigers
The title track from the band's 2007 comeback record has the triumphant swagger of their first comeback album, Everything Must Go, and kicks the album off in confident style. In truth, any track from this or the next two records could have been included in this list, as 2007-2011 saw the band on a creative winning streak that matches their '90s heyday.
The title supposedly comes from an oft-used phrase by comedian and consummate drunk Tony Hancock, usually uttered just before he downed his drink. It was a battle cry for a man constantly at war with his demons. For a band who were just coming out of a creative and commercial slump it's not hard to see this song as their own battle cry, screamed as they enter a fight for their future.
Musically, the band sound like they've turned the clock back a decade, and the record as a whole sounds like it should have been the follow-up to Everything Must Go. It's also worth mentioning that James released his solo record, The Great Western, a year before this, and that album also shared a similar sound. Which all adds to the feeling that this was the band getting back on track and not trying to be something they're not.
4. Peeled Apples
Another banging opening track, this time from 2009's Journal For Plague Lovers. The chorus' melody sounds suspiciously like a certain Heaven 17 hit but Richey's lyrics, Nicky's grimy bass line and James' howling voice have never sounded so haunted.
Journal For Plague Lovers' lyrics were taken from Richey Edwards' notebook, discovered after his disappearance, and, following him being declared legally dead in 2008, the band decided to dust them off and make, what they described, as a middle-aged follow-up to their 1995 album The Holy Bible. You can certainly hear that they achieved their goal, and Peeled Apples, more than any other track on the record feels like a segue from one to the other.
Some argued at the time that the album was a cynical attempt to cash-in on Edwards' legacy, but those curmudgeonly types were missing the point. The band were paying tribute to their comrade at a time when they finally had to admit that he had, indeed, fallen.
Any previous mentions of Richey in Wire's lyrics were more-often-that-not denied by him and, amazingly, this record was the first time that the Manics had paid tribute to him in such an open way. It took them 14 years but, evidently it was worth the wait.
3. Rewind The Film
After what Nicky Wire called the band's "one last shot at mass communication" with 2010's Postcards From A Young Man, the Manics came back in 2013 with the first of two records that experimented with what the trio were capable of being.
The first, Rewind The Film, was a sombre folky affair that favoured acoustic guitars and brass bands. The title track also features Richard Hawley on co-lead vocals and tells you everything you need to know about the album in one six-and-a-half-minute burst. The song was released as a promotional single and, while it doesn't capture the pure working-class joy of the album's first proper single, Show Me The Wonder, it does dispense the band's ageing melancholy quite perfectly.
Once again, in what seems like a running theme, the lyrics capture the nostalgia and melancholy of remembering. This time, the subject appears to be less down to Wire's preoccupation with the passage of time, and more of an intentional study of the act of reminiscence and its power to overwhelm the senses.
If nothing else, Nicky is becoming a master of conjuring up those feelings in words, while James and Sean manage to find new musical and sonic means of emphasising them. Hawley's voice is a great fit here, too, his lower register playing off of James' higher voice in a way Nicky's occasional vocal performances might not have managed to convey.
2. Europa Geht Durch Mich
And then, in 2014, the other Manics experiment, Futurology, was released. Those fans who had been hankering for the band's inevitable new wave krautrock, dance-punk phase could rejoice, as their time was nigh.
Beginning with a driving bass line and what almost sounds like a siren, this track is somehow no-nonsense whilst, at the same time, being complete nonsense. Which, some might argue, is when the Manic Street Preachers are at their best, anyway. Never has a band been able to flit between navel-gazing pretentiousness and exuberant silliness with such aplomb (at least, whisper it, not since The Beatles).
This track features German actress Nina Hoss on (German-language) vocals in what has been described by the band as a celebration of the influence they get from travelling Europe and seeing different cultures and art. It is a beguiling track from an infuriating record, which, it could be argued, speaks to the band's ambition as artists. Surely art is supposed to attract a range of strong emotions. This record certainly does that. You may not always like what you get from the Manics but they're always interesting.
1. International Blue
Finally, to the current era, the elder-statesmen of British Alternative Rock. There is an argument that 2016-present is the band's least interesting era, with it's two records, Resistance Is Futile and The Ultra Vivid Lament, showing the Manics to be comfortable resting on their laurels for the time being. International Blue is the best track on either of those records and reminds us of why we loved the Manic Street Preachers in the first place.
James is on point, carrying the song on his shoulders with his vocal and guitar stylings. If anything, the song stands out as one that would have been comfortable on Send Away The Tigers a decade previously. The fact that the rest of Resistance Is Futile didn't really live up to that promise, only adds to its power.
The band have always had their ups and downs, and time gets us all in the end, but, as we've learned, the Manics are more than aware of how age can and has affected them over the years and are more than capable of wielding that knowledge as a weapon. Here's to the next era.
Hardest Rock Music Quiz On The Internet