10 Massive Drops In Quality Between Albums
Dropping the Ball Hard.
There isn't a single artist that can keep that creative fire burning forever. As everyone's favorite band starts to get older, they're bound to release records that aren't necessarily on par with the classics that they're used to giving us. Then again, none of us were expecting the quality to drop this quick in between albums.
For every single one of these releases, these aren't so much a slump as they are a fall from grace. Although these acts may have been on a high for the past few years that they were active, this is where the entire creative process begins to stall and everything starts to get a lot more questionable. Not all of these albums are meant to be following up classics or anything. Some of these bands had been in the game for a long time before making these albums, only to turn in something that sounds like a shadow of what they once were.
On every one of these records, it's not like you're going to get outwardly offended at every single song or anything. No, these are just the albums that just feel a little too boring to even be associated with the acts in question. Considering the average that we grade these bands on, the quality between these records and everything else are like night and day.
10. Slang - Def Leppard
As the Nirvana boom started to sweep across the rock landscape, the traditional sounds of Def Leppard weren't really going to cut it anymore. After everyone was stripping things back, there wasn't a chance of hearing a band that thrived on their larger than life production that was reminiscent of Queen. Leppard was really smart in wanting to shake things up, but Slang may have taken it the one notch too far.
Working without their signature production style, this is considered Leppard's attempt at going alternative, with an extremely mixed result all around. Though they had some great tunes to kick off the '90s on the album Adrenalize, these feel more like ideas than actual fleshed out songs, with Work It Out being the closest thing to a radio hit to come out of this era. You can really tell that the guys are looking to make something that no one had heard from them, but even they haven't really looked back on this era all that fondly.
From the looks from their label, everyone was already fairly mixed on the final album, and guitarist Vivian Campbell recalled thinking at the time that they were spending a fortune making this album knowing that no one was going to buy it. The '90s weren't all doom and gloom though, and Leppard would eventually make a return to their classic sound at the back half of the decade on Euphoria. For these few years though, they were not exactly the greatest when it came to trend chasing.
9. Self Portrait - Bob Dylan
After the '60s, there was a good chance that nothing could have killed Bob Dylan's career. Even though folkies had dogged on him a few years before for going electric, his wordplay and critiques of the way that the counterculture was going was enough to put him in living legend status for the rest of his days. There was nothing that could tear him down, and Dylan tried to test his fans loyalty on Self Portrait.
From the first time you listen to this record, the production is a lot rougher than before, being a double album's worth of material focusing on sketches and obscure cover songs. Coming off of the country stylings of Nashville Skyline, this almost feels like a bait and switch on Dylan's part, almost like you're sitting in on him at a random open mic night, and not one that he was particularly prepared for either. While Dylan's voice is definitely an acquired taste for some, this is where he really tests his audience in terms of what he can get away with, like covering Paul Simon or trying his hand at Blue Moon.
The silver lining to this kind of disaster though is that...it's kind of a joke. After going through the past few years, this was Dylan's attempt to make something deliberately unpolished, in an effort to shake off the 'Voice of a Generation' moniker that he had been given in the past few years. He wanted to show that he was human, and this was where we got a sense that even musical gods can do wrong.
8. Uno - Green Day
As America started to enter some of its darkest days in the '00s, Green Day were one of the few bands that were managing to have a second act. Amid all of the other pop punk bands that had come and gone since they released Dookie in 1994, American Idiot is where Billie Joe Armstrong got more serious about his songwriting, weaving together a narrative of what it's like for a teenager in the Bush era. Right when it looked like we were reaching the operatic years of Green Day, Uno is where things start to hit a brick wall.
Coming off of American Idiot, 21st Century Breakdown was a decent way to double down, as the band got more refined with their taste for classic rock. Once they announced their next project would be a three album set though, fans were concerned when Uno dropped, being just your standard Green Day affair with songs that didn't really have the same punch that came from American Idiot.
Since the first one had filler though, fans were getting bored to tears for the rest of the album rollouts, featuring songs that were either too generic to be considered classic or in the worst cases too offensive to be called good. For the opera years, every song felt like a new creative risk that the band wanted to try out. The only thing that this album managed to give us was a lot of anxiety for what the next years of Green Day had in store.
7. Wild Life - Paul McCartney
For all of the fantastic songs that he wrote with the Beatles, Paul McCartney was actually becoming the least success solo star once the Fabs broke up. While George Harrison was riding high off of his double album All Things Must Pass and John was making classics like Imagine, Macca got a lot of flak for the experimentation he made on RAM, with a lot of critics not understanding what he was doing. RAM would go on to become one of his best records, but the critics back then probably had a field day once Wild Life was put out.
Looking to be part of a group again, Paul assembled a band with his wife Linda and ex Moody Blues guitarist Denny Laine, and kicked things off with an album which is...let's called it primitive. Compared to the wild sounds of RAM, this feels more like a jam session that somehow found its way onto the tape, especially since two of the songs barely even have any lyrics to them. From the critics' perspective at the time, the closer Dear Friend was one of the only highlights, being an apology of sorts to John Lennon for the shots that he took at him on Too Many People from the album before.
Then again, Wild Life is by no means a terrible album. If you listen to it in the right headspace, this is a great album where you can get a glimpse at what the band was going to become. But from the sounds of these jams, we are a long way away from something like Live and Let Die or Band on the Run.
6. One More Light - Linkin Park
Linkin Park really had struggled with what they wanted to be for most of the 2010's. Although their album A Thousand Suns proved to be a lot more forward thinking in the coming years, the cold reception at the time made them want to strip things back to basics, from the classic sounds of Living Things to going even more aggro on The Hunting Party. When they got the itch to making something even more outlandish though, the nu metal fans were ice cold to whatever happened on One More Light.
If you look at this album back to back with The Hunting Party, you'd swear you were listening to two separate bands, going full pop and dipping their toes into modern production on songs like Heavy. While Mike Shinoda had made a point of trying to make this record for his kids, the translation of those feelings tend to get lost in the mix a lot of the time, especially when the guys known for Numb and Place for My Head hop on a track that sounds like it should be background music in a retail store.
This was just an experiment for the band though...it's just unfortunate that it happened to be the last one they got to make together, as Chester Bennington would commit suicide a few months after the record was released. Every band goes through their fair share of shakeups, but leaving things on such a polarizing release was definitely a heavy blow.
5. The Final Cut - Pink Floyd
Coming into the '80s, Pink Floyd were on top of the musical world...and no one was happy about it. For as much money and artistic integrity went into creating the album The Wall, it led to a separation between the band and Roger Waters, which would go on to destroy the band in the next few years. Roger had more to get off his chest though, and the Final Cut is basically him using the rest of the band members as sidemen for his vision.
Though The Wall had been Roger's baby from the start, the beauty behind it was how every other member put their stamp on things, like the piano textures of Richard Wright or David Gilmour's calming vocals leading the story along. On this album, that collaborative spirit is just gone, with practically the entire album being a Roger Waters solo outing with the Pink Floyd moniker slapped on it. We're still working with the mastermind behind The Wall here though, so there are still some decent tracks to be found, some of which even reference back to characters we had heard about the album before.
As it stands though, you can really hear the tension on this record as David and Roger start to drift apart, and it wasn't a shock when we learned that Roger Waters was going to go off on his own to pursue different solo projects. We all wanted to believe that the foundations of Pink Floyd could move past these hangups, but from listening to this one record, the writing was on the wall.
4. Cut the Crap - The Clash
How the hell did punk manage to die at the turn of the '80s? Even though we had bands coming out of the underground thriving well into the MTV generation, all of the heavyhitters like the Ramones and the Sex Pistols were either done or irrelevant to the starlets that were selling out on television. For a brief moment, it looked like the Clash were going to stay the course, only for everything to unravel right before Cut the Crap.
Although you could hear tension on Combat Rock, Joe Strummer and Mick Jones used that kind of tension to create some of the best songs of their career like Straight to Hell or Rock the Casbah. When that tension became too much though, Strummer decided that he could continue on with the Clash without Mick or even drummer Topper Headon, drafting in a new set of Clash members and making some of the most directionless songs of the band's career.
Across every single track on this record, you can feel that Joe just doesn't have that same kind of punk spirit in him anymore, being more frustrated than anything else and realizing the mistake that he made by firing Mick. With the one exception of the song This Is England, this is considered some of the most inferior songs to be put under the name the Clash. The original Clash songs made you want to start a rebellion from the ground up, but these songs just sound like they were made out of exhaustion.
3. Raditude - Weezer
After their disastrous breakup in the '90s, Weezer really seemed to pick themselves up in the early '00s. Going back to the nerdy alt rock that they were known for, things were starting to look up, with different songs actually getting on the radio until Beverly Hills split the fanbase down the middle. Though Weezer tried to learn from their mistakes on The Red Album, they ended up going right back down the rabbit hole again with Raditude.
Even though Make Believe may have been their attempt to capitalize on the kind of pop punk sound that was happening around the mid '00s, Raditude is a blatant attempt to go pop, down to featuring guest songwriters like the infamous Dr. Luke and even having Lil Wayne contribute a guest verse to the song Can't Stop Partying. Aside from the song If You're Wondering..., each song on this album is everything that Weezer shouldn't be, from songs talking about going to the club to making some really suggestive word choices like naming a song I'm Your Daddy.
For the dyed in the wool Weezer fans, you don't even need me to tell you why that doesn't work. Weezer were always known as the dorks of rock and roll who were always willing to stand up for the little guy. The minute that you heard a line like 'it's Weezer and it's Wheezy' though, you knew that things had started to go horribly wrong.
2. Second Coming - The Stone Roses
The Stone Roses were probably not thinking about what their debut record was going to mean for British music when they were making it. Though they definitely had a handle on the dance centric side of rock and roll, hearing these straight up pop rock songs right before the Nirvana era of music planted the seeds for what would become Britpop once the grunge empire rose and fell. With that much to measure up to though, you can't really blame the Roses for second guessing themselves on the follow up.
For most of Second Coming, the band were struggling to even get on the same page in the studio, as John Squire and Ian Brown kept getting more frustrated with how the songs should take shape. And you can really hear that studio tension on the record, with the songs stretching out to ridiculous lengths and often going nowhere. Though there are definitely songs like Love Spreads which puts you in a trance like atmosphere, you can't help but feel the band trying to equal the kind of bombast they were seeing with bands that had come up after them like Oasis.
They didn't need to change at all though. If they had just kept up being the Stone Roses on the second album, it would have made for something that was fairly decent and kept them in the public eye for a little while longer. For what we got, this feels closer to an EP's worth of great material than an actual great album. There are sprinkles of brilliance...just not enough to go around.
1. St. Anger - Metallica
Throughout most of Metallica's career, fans have had no problem talking about the massive drops in quality between every album. When you look as far back as the '80s, you had people complaining about the lack of bass guitar on And Justice For All, and the thrash elitists were already getting pretty pissed when Load and ReLoad came out, thinking they were leaving their metal roots behind for good. They may have wanted Metallica to get heavy again, but St. Anger might be the best example of being careful what you wish for.
Though Load and ReLoad might not be the best albums that Metallica have ever put out, you can definitely tell the vibe they were going for, looking to put some hard rock into their sound that was more powerful than straight up metal. Considering the kind of atmosphere around this record though, you'd be surprised to hear any kind of cohesion in any of these songs, from one of the worst production jobs on any Metallica record to James really phoning it in with the lyrics, which oftentimes feel like first drafts.
As much as these songs sprawl out, they seem to mean nothing most of the time, just showing the band jamming and hoping to get something made. Then again, maybe this record isn't really for us. If you go back and look at the documentary Some Kind of Monster, this is more of an album that the band needed to make to keep themselves intact. It may have kept the band alive and going strong into the next decade, but it doesn't make a song like Purify any easier to listen to.