10 Masterpiece Albums From Supposedly "Terrible" Bands
The good from the bad and the ugly from Metallica, Kiss and The Kooks...
Deeming a band to be bad is pretty subjective. One man's Nickelback could be another man's Weezer - and here we are, being all subjective again. But trying to find ten bands that lots of people openly proclaim to be irksome on the ears isn't really too difficult.
So, preamble aside, the purpose of this rocking piece of writing is to find a collection of bands that we can all sort of agree are terrible. But somehow, by some stretch of talent, managed to compose a solitary masterpiece album. It's a tricky endeavour, as easy targets like Coldplay, Stereophonics, The Monkees and dozens of others didn't or haven't ever actually gotten around to releasing their opus and are instead relegated to decent greatest hits territory. What we're looking for is a real work of art from bands often cited as being "the worst of the worst".
But fear not, in this article there are a motley crew of Mercury Prize and Grammy nominees, as well as Brit Award botherers and a whole load of others that will forever remain a blot on music history - but by god didn't they release a collection of bangers at one stage in their careers.
10. Hybrid Theory - Linkin Park
The Album
There's no doubting that Chester Bennington was a powerhouse lead singer who had the ability to channel raw emotion and loud wails against the backdrop of some club-thumping riffs. But oh boy are Linkin Park bad, a band that struck big with this debut only to dull with every LP that followed.
Nevertheless, Bennington's abilities were never channelled better than in Linkin Park's debut album, a mega-million dollar-selling collection that wasn't shy of a nu metal banger or two. This was an album released in at a time when the world was sobering up from a Brit pop invasion and gave something teens to edgier to relate to than the masturbation-joking melodies of pop punk. From Crawling's spine-scratching ferocity to the stadium-bound melodies of In The End, this was an album bound for greatness.
What followed, though, was a lacking follow up in Mereora, a ropey mash up album with Jay-Z and a clutch of forgettable studio albums before Bennington's sad demise in 2017.
Best Track
Nothing captures this band better than One Step Closer, a very literal journey to the edge of danger, powered by a screeching, catchy chorus. Raw and brilliant.
9. Oracular Spectacular - MGMT
The Album
Distracted by the advent of smartphones and Twitter culture spreading across the globe at a fair old click, music fans had their attentions caught momentarily in 2006 by a little-known Brooklyn outfit. They arrived with a bagful of psychedelic tunes, replete with swirling hooks that had ability to make you feel like you were dripping in acid, without even licking a tab. Yeah, for a time MGMT were the real revolution of a the decade, a band that made you feel lost in a fantastic daze for 40 hazy minutes.
But the real beauty of this album is the danger it hinted at in its songs, where tracks like 'Weekend Wars' and 'Kids' hit you with a beat while at the same time having something to say.
But the comedown for MGMT was a brutal one, with three experimental follow-up albums displaying none of the hooks and trippy beats of their debut. It seems that Oracular Spectacular was the one time they got the formula right, but there's no sign of that happening again.
Best Song
'Electric Feel' and 'Time To Pretend' are trippy treats, for sure, but the essence of this album is in 'The Youth', a haunting trip into the unknown.
8. Alive! - Kiss
The Album
Known for big hair and even bigger excess, Kiss were never going to saddle up alongside Zeppelin in the rocking hall of fame. This was a band that has been defined by putting on a good show and not being too fussed on what the music sounds like. This shows in pretty much all of their noisy studio albums. But it's easy to forget that in 1975 their fourth and first live album slashed through radios and pretty much defined what a live album should sound like.
Debut album bangers 'Deuce' and 'Stutter' shatter the lobes straight away and the album doesn't let up, with other highlights like 'Parasite' and 'Black Diamond' keeping the album's momentum flinging forward at a heady pace. Kiss would quickly go back to being bloated caricatures after this album, but if you want a lightening in a bottle moment, check out this classic LP.Best
Best Track
Was it ever going to be anything other than Rock And Roll All Nite?
7. Employment - The Kaiser Chiefs
The Album
2005 was quality. You could chuff away on a John Players at a Wetherspoons pub, stuff was cheaper and your mates weren't online politicians. Swanning through this air of complacency were The Kaiser Chiefs - formally known as Parva before they fancied robbing their name off a South African footie outfit - a band always destined for the big time but perhaps not deservedly so. Lead by gobby lead singer Ricky Wilson, the band stomped into the social conscious of the time with a debut that was bursting from the pack with banger after banger.
The assault started with 'I Predict A Riot' and continued with the beery, anthemic 'Oh My God' and more Kinks-esque numbers like 'Time Honoured Tradition'. The album helped the band reach stratospheric heights of fame, but following up Employment was a big ask and although the badly titled Yours Truly, Angry Mob was a big seller, it showed a band that had run out of ideas very quicky and they soon slipped into indie mediocrity.
Ever the band's poster boy, Wilson is now some kind of ambassador for weight loss and is a talented raconteur in ushering viewers over to uber s**te fest, The Voice.
Best Track
They'll always be known for the big tunes, but in 'You Can Have It All' you have a Brit pop-esque ditty for the ages.
6. Inside In / Inside Out - The Kooks
The Album
Preppy in an oh so British kind of way, this little indie outfit from Brighton grabbed Britain by its dancing shoes in 2006 and didn't let go until Arctic Monkey mania took over that same year. Yeah, you read between the lines, they ended up being deathly dull.
But that's not to say Inside In / Inside Out isn't a stormer of a debut. Kicking off with the stripped back loveliness of 'Seaside' and followed up by earwormy hits in 'Ooh La' and 'You Don't Love Me', the album sold by the shedload and emerging bands today cite this longplay as being an influence.
Time has been kind to this album, released amid the chaos of a fizzling out Libertines and nu indie pomp of The Fratellis and Kaiser Chiefs this one still holds up. Sadly the band's follow up, Konk, was the start of a quiet decline for a band that don't have enough character or heart to release another album anything like this one.
Best Song
The low-fi grooves of 'Naive' will forever drift out from Radio 1's playlist, but the song that deserves to be played on the airwaves over and over again is 'Sofa Song' - two minutes of pure filth.
5. Up All Night - Razorlight
The Album
Before singer Johnny Borrell started wearing white leather and dry humping Kirsten Dunst to the tones of 'I've got a hot body girlfriend', he was the architect behind Up All Night. Born from the ashes of his time as a fellow Libertine, his new band's debut tore through the airwaves with nougties bangers 'Golden Touch', 'Rip It Up' and the heart racing 'Stumble And Fall', sending a generation of greasy indie kids onto the dancefloor. This was the iconic sound of noughties Britain.
Despite aiming for the stadiums with their self-titled follow up and doing pretty well in the charts, this and their future efforts were too self-indulgent to be enjoyable and showed Razorlight to be one of indie's biggest one albim wonder bands. iva Borrell.
Best Song
'Don't Go Back To Dalston' nearly edges it, but to get the full blast of what this band was about back in 2004 look no further than the absolute drainpipe-stretching beast that is 'Golden Touch'.
4. Dookie - Greenday
652081The Album
A tickle of the symbols and some rapid drum beats kick off the opening track to what can easily be held up as one of the best punk albums of all time. But, like said opener, the band behind it never released an album like this again. Total 'Burnout'.
But what a debut Greenday burst out with. From skate park anthem 'Basket Case' to the affirming melodies of 'When I Come Around', every other pit stop throughout this journey through East Bay slacker living sounds as fresh now as it did in the nineties. You can take your Vandels and Descendants - pop punk was born in this blast of breezy genius.
But what of Greenday now? Oh, they're one of the biggest bands in the world. But hey, that doesn't mean they're being wronged here. No album has come close to Dookie and bar some radio-friendly singles, and an album that tapped into the zeitgeist of the time but now just sounds clumsy, they are by no means the band many seem to believe they are.
Best Track
'Longview' is Greenday at their melodic/ ferocious best, a track that will never age.
3. Hopes & Fears - Keane
The Album
Yes, another nougties bunch of indie chancers that put everything they had into a debut album, only to ghost us soon after - but they don't come better than Hopes & Fears.
In 2004 this mega-selling effort from East Sussex's finest pummelled the world into submission with a twee blend of catchy indie tunes, elevated to a new level via some staggeringly impressive vocals from singer Tom Chapman.
Spearheaded by lead single 'Somewhere Only We Know', the album shifted 2.7 million albums alone in the UK and to this day - deservedly - stands as one of the most accomplished albums of the last decade. Roll over 15 years and the band are in a no man's land, with Chapman only recently wheeling out (*gulp*) a Christmas album.
Best Track
There's no hiding it: 'Somewhere Only We Know' is a tuneful indie radio hit that is totally unrivaled. But special mention has to go to 'Bedshaped', with its play dough-clever music video.
2. Joshua Tree - U2
The Album
To some, U2 are Christ-incarnated in a band. To others they are dino stadium rockers who have developed a habit of installing naff albums on our iPhones while we sleep. But with Joshua Tree, their fifth album, you need to put aside the fact the band are overly hyped and guilty of churning out template rock anthems, as Joshua Tree is one soulful rock monster.
Starting with a religious quandary posed by opener 'Where The Streets Have No Name' the album is a whistlestop tour of the Americana the band were - and still are - obsessed with. Helped by pristine production from Brian Eno (only he could turn something like With Or Without You into something as spectacular as it is) the album has only got better with age and, along with being the band's only real good album, it deserves a place up there with one of the best of all time, too.
Best Track
Nothing touches the gospel-inspired beats of 'I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For'. The best track off the album.
1. Metallica (Black Album) - Metallica
The Album
It would take album number five for Metallica to get the acclaim they felt they deserved. A marked departure from their previous, hard-thrashing efforts, this perfect collection of songs had melody as its back bone and crunching riffs and wailing vocals as its muscular exterior.
Owing more to the then raging grunge phase of that era, the album is an absolute joy. Opener 'Enter Sandman' is a rock radio staple, and remains the kind of monster Metallica always threatened to unleash, but its depthful numbers such as 'Nothing Else Matters' and 'The Unforgiven' that show a band that could pen a epic track or two.
Disappointingly, James Hetfield and co would follow this up in 1996 with Load, which saw the band return to their typically uninspired thrash roots and to date the band continue to bore us with this style. They've got the fanbase, for sure, but with the large majority of their music sounding the same, one can't help but agree Metallica are one of music's most overrated bands.
Best Track
Showing just the right amount of thrash and hard rock style, 'Sad But True' is the band at its very peak. This one is best played at LOUD.