10 Mistakes Purposefully Left In Classic Rock Songs
Not sweating the small things.
Whenever entering a studio, an artist has a chance to create something unprecedented. With nothing but time, tools, and creative ingenuity at their disposal, plenty of acts have tried to move the earth and stars to achieve perfection on the final take. Though some might fall just shy of perfection, there are plenty of songs that become classics that are actually a bit of a mess.
While you might recognize these songs whenever they are played on the radio, there are a few weird extracurriculars going on just beneath the surface. From internal band drama to just technical foul-ups, there are certain parts of these songs that weren't necessarily supposed to be in the final cut. Many could see these little screwups as a case of rock bands being unprofessional, but they actually end up giving these songs a lot more character.
Other times it gets so pronounced that you can't even think of the song the same way without going to the little imperfections that are right in front of your face (or ears). Despite not having the most spotless track record in the studio, these screwups have remained as classic as the songs they are associated with. No human is perfect, but even in the mistakes we can find little bits of brilliance.
10. Acquiesce - Oasis
A lot of songs from Oasis' glory period in the '90s were notorious for being a bit messy. Given that producer Owen Morris pretty much invented the technique of enhancing the sound for maximum impact, it's no wonder that even the most subtle details end up slipping through the cracks. Then again, this is a more overarching issue that stems more from what happened after the song was recorded.
On the surface, Acquiesce has all the power to be a phenomenal Oasis single, complete with a call and response vocal from Noel and Liam between the verses and choruses. However, there's something about the second verse that has sort of been lost to history. When you come out of the first go around, the actual lines about Liam singing his soul to sleep and bringing him back to bed have never really been performed live outside of a few occasions.
So is this a mistake on the recording or on the live stage? While Noel has made mention of Liam never singing it live when Oasis were still together, Liam always half-jokes that the person who gives him the teleprompter always screws it up. Okay... so which is it then? Even though there have been many parts of Oasis songs that can stick with you for decades, it's almost like this section is intentionally getting buried before it had time to grow.
9. The Sidewinder Sleeps Tonite - R.E.M.
It was a sight to behold when R.E.M. finally got the praise they deserved at the turn of the decade. After years of becoming one of the greatest college rock bands in the world, their run of albums from Green to Monster turned into some of the greatest alternative adventures the rock world had ever seen. Automatic for the People does tend to hold the spot as the group's most "grown-up" album, and yet no one seemed to tell Michael Stipe that when cutting one of the album's biggest hits.
Across the album, songs like Nightswimming and Man on the Moon wear their emotions on their sleeve, but The Sidewinder Sleeps Tonite occupies a bit of a different lane. As Stipe sings a rapid fire "call me when you try to wake her," you almost find yourself trying to play catch-up with what you just heard.
However, it seems like Stipe himself is having a little too much fun doing this, as he breaks character right at the tail end of the final verse. After making allusions to the almighty bars of Dr. Seuss, you can hear Stipe crack up into laughter as he goes into the next verse. Even though a punch-in vocal would have sufficed here, the subtle tonal shift actually gave the track a whole lot more character. Despite alternative rock having to grow up, it didn't have to be dark and dour all the time.
8. Rearviewmirror - Pearl Jam
For all the success that came with the grunge explosion of the early '90s, none of it seemed to sit all that well with Pearl Jam. While many of the band members were just happy that people were enjoying their music, the sudden rush of attention led to internal disagreements in the group and Eddie Vedder trying to minimize the weight of his celebrity. Whereas most musicians leave their emotions at the door when recording, that anger came out in spades at the end of Rearviewmirror.
When cutting the tune in a posh studio in California, drummer Dave Abbruzzese was getting no feedback from any of his bandmates as to whether the drum track was coming together. Seeing how this was Eddie's song and Abbruzzese was the one with the most stars in his eyes, it didn't really help matters when Vedder kept pestering him to make it as perfect as possible.
Though we did end up getting the take that the guys wanted, you can hear the aftermath right at the end of the song. Just before all the faders are pulled down, you can hear Dave get frustrated and hurl his drumsticks at the wall, which made for a more ominous conclusion to this song about internal destruction. While this song may be in the rearview nowadays, it's hard to forget the scars that came with getting there.
7. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others - The Smiths
The Queen is Dead is one of those few foundational records in the world of alternative rock. While the rest of England was still getting immersed in the new wave scene, the smooth baritone of Morrissey and the amazing guitar inflexions of Johnny Marr turned these angsty teen anthems into some of the best tales of woe to come out of the underground. Even though the tone had gotten a bit too serious for some to stomach, the closing track to the record made for some creative in-studio hijinx.
Having to find a good way to open the song Some Girls are Bigger Than Others, the group kept fiddling around with different intro cuts before deciding on a fade in. This certainly wasn't a new technique at the time, but what made it stick out was the way it keeps pulling you in. As the track fades in, it fades back down again before getting into the proper song.
When asked about the reasoning behind this, Marr had talked about wanting to mimic the sound of a door shutting and opening again, as if you're seeing these guys play the song during a rehearsal. As opposed to the more rudimentary mistakes found on other records, this song does the adverse effect and makes you ache to hear more every time you hear it.
6. Crossroads - Cream
Whenever people bring up the greatest guitar songs of all time, Crossroads by Cream always seems to take a prime spot. One could argue that this is one of the few songs that instilled the "Clapton is God" myth in rock fans' minds, as Slowhand weaves in and out of the time changes with almost minimal effort. However, Clapton has actually exposed the secret of this fantastic solo: rhythmic incompetence.
During the live recording of this song, Clapton has discussed never locking in on the timing of the initial groove, instead playing most of his solo on the offbeat. Even though this kind of thing would be cause for a trainwreck live on stage, the note choice actually goes in a bit of a different direction and gives the track its unique character.
While Clapton may find shame in not doing justice to one of his heroes Robert Johnson, perhaps the actual execution of the solo he heard in his head would have hurt the song in the long run. As such, the version as it stands now feels like watching some of the greatest musicians in England at a sweaty club, putting every single ounce of their energy into shaking the walls with the raw sound of blues rock. It's still great... but you might want to put in a few more hours with the metronome, Eric.
5. Polly - Nirvana
Nirvana's lyrics were never really known to be on par with Shakespeare. Out of all of their big hits, you were never supposed to figure out the inner workings of something like Smells Like Teen Spirit or Lithium. At the same time, when these guys wanted to get serious, they could - such as the hell of a gut punch they gave you on Polly.
Compared to the rest of Nevermind, this deep dive into the mind of a sexual abuser is a lot more solemn than many were probably expecting. Even though there is a lot of uncomfortable imagery to unpack on here, there are a few little bits of studio banter in between. Recorded in between their sessions at Sound City Studios, this original take actually has Kurt Cobain starting the final verse too early, with him correcting himself after the first "Polly says..."
Rather than just go over the whole thing again, Cobain ended up liking the more stuttered delivery, feeling that it worked better with the ominous tone of the song. This is also one of the few times in which the mistake became intentional, with Kurt doubling down on the screwup on the new wave version of the tune that ended up on Incesticide. You always have to be careful when tackling dark subjects like this, but when even your foul-ups enhance the song, you know you got something good.
4. Aja - Steely Dan
By the time Steely Dan got to Aja, they were one of the most prominent production wizards in rock and roll. Almost abandoning the touring life altogether, each album from Katy Lied to The Royal Scam felt meticulously planned out down to the letter, as Walter Becker and Donald Fagen hand selected session players to get what they needed out of their material. Even so, you can't always count on the more off-hand moments in between the notes.
Right in the middle of their yacht rock opus, the title track veers off into a drum solo by Steve Gadd accompanied by saxophone. The solo itself is absolutely amazing, as Gadd goes through some of the most complex drum breaks to have ever been heard in the '70s. As opposed to some grand finale though, we do get a bit of a subtle fluke at the very end of the solo.
Once Gadd finishes circling his kit and annihilating every single drum head, you can hear the faint click of him hitting his sticks together, almost like he's so thrilled to have nailed the perfect take. Rather than pulling off another take, the drive of the final mix was too good for Fagen or Becker to pass up. Having to celebrate your own drum performance at the end of the take is one thing, but this exquisite use of one last percussion hit shows more taste than any other drum fill could have done.
3. Cathedral - Van Halen
It's no surprise to hear that Eddie Van Halen was a god amongst guitar players. Whether it was at the tail end of the '70s or in hair metal's glory years, almost every single VH release showed Eddie bringing something new to the table, even devoting entire tracks to it like Eruption or Spanish Fly. However, if there's one that really stands out as something special, it would have to be Cathedral.
Recorded during the much maligned album sessions for Diver Down, this echoing swell is all done through Eddie's electric guitar filtered through a chorus effect. While those extensions already sound huge, the real magic comes in when he starts fiddling with the volume knobs, which make each chord sound like disembodied notes being pulled out of thin air. On the other hand, one guitar can only take so much.
Though Eddie is cruising up and down the guitar neck for most of the song, he admits that something went a little haywire towards the end. As the last few guitar passages are fading from the headphones, Eddie had said that the volume knob broke at that point, leaving whatever he played afterward to sound sort of warped. Given how much guitar fireworks he normally added on every other song, this kind of casual trail-off is one of the few VH cases where less is in fact more.
2. Roxanne - The Police
Over the years, The Police have built up a reputation as some of the most professional musical thinkers in the history of rock and roll. As opposed to other acts that get a career off of a fluke hit, this power trio combined everything from jazz to avant garde music to punk and made some of the most magical rock music of the '70s and '80s. That's not to say that every single sound on record was necessarily flawless though.
When taken with the rest of their catalog, the band's debut record Outlandos D'Amour is also their dirtiest, as they lean into their punk rock energy. However, their most enduring hit from this time is actually the roughest recording of the bunch. As Sting was listening to playback for Roxanne, he absent-mindedly sat down only to hit the keys of a piano. After a barrage of notes, Sting can be heard laughing at the top of the song, knowing that he screwed up the take.
While there's been debate as to whether or not this was intentional, the guys at least had a sense of humor about it when it came time to do the packaging, as Sting was credited for "butt piano" on the tune. Even though these songs could be a bit messy, we were just getting accustomed to some of the most talented musicians of the modern age.
1. A Day in the Life - Beatles
There's really no way to pick a favorite Beatles song amongst Fab Four fans. While some might have their personal favorites, there are far too many fine moments in these moptops' discography to single one out as their crowning achievement. Even though some flock to songs like Yesterday or Hey Jude, die-hards always seem to find something fascinating about A Day in the Life.
Arriving at the end of Sgt. Pepper's, this song was quickly picked up as one of their best, as John Lennon and Paul McCartney's songwriting talents are pitted against one another. Most people tend to get shivers when the orchestra builds up, but there's something a tad suspicious about that final chord. Knowing that they needed something epic to follow the orchestra swell, the resulting piano chord was done by five people hitting the chord across three different pianos, with the engineer turning up the faders to get every last second of it.
While nothing screams epic quite like this, it did come at the expense of some worn-in shoes. Though it's unclear as to who committed the crime, the volume was apparently turned up so loud that you can actually hear someone's shoe squeak on the recording floor as the chord is held out. So next time you throw on Sgt. Pepper's, pay close attention to that final sound and decide what it is for yourself.