10 Most Blatant Ripoffs In Rock History
The Art of Stealing.
The idea of actually writing a memorable song isn't exactly the easiest thing in the world. For all intents and purposes, you have to try and hit upon a good beat, a tight groove, and some riff or lyric that's going to win over the rest of the masses regardless of what stripe of music they're into. It's never an easy decision...but it does get a little less hard when the road work is already done for you.
On the opposite end of the spectrum, artists have made it to the top of the charts by making songs that are blatant retreads of what came before. This isn't just from the sample community either, considering that many of these songs were recreated with actual instruments in order to sell something completely new. Even some of the greatest artists of all time aren't safe from the occasional idea of stealing music, as most of the classics have been known to borrow from the greatest in history.
Then again, it's not like the music industry has been known to be the most wholesome of businesses throughout culture. No, this kind of thing tends to be the Wild West...and these are the bandits that managed to con their audiences by ripping off someone else.
10. Come Together - The Beatles
The idea of the Beatles' actually taking inspiration from any one in particular just feels wrong. Especially with all of the layers upon layers of fantastic music coming from their glory period, stuff like Here There and Everywhere and Hey Jude are so omnipresent that they feel like they've existed since the dawn of time. But yes, even the Beatles do steal...and from one of the biggest names in music no less.
When the Fabs were up against the ropes to deliver one last stunning album with Abbey Road, John Lennon came forward with Come Together, which turned into one of the funkiest tracks that the group would ever record. With the exception of Paul McCartney's amazing bassline though, 95% of the original idea was based on Chuck Berry's hit You Can't Catch Me.
Don't believe it? Lennon even goes so far as to use Berry's opening lyric "Hear come old flattop" verbatim in his own lyrics, which ended up getting him in a bit of trouble once the lawsuits started coming in. Seeing how different the end products were, Lennon was originally commissioned to make a covers album during his solo career, with the proceedings going to Berry's publishing company. As much as the Beatles might look like god-tier melody men, everyone gets their magic from somewhere, don't they?
9. Footsteps - Pearl Jam
When you're ripping off someone, usually its best if you don't really know the artist personally. After all, you never want that awkward conversation the next time you hang out and they realize that you've stolen their song from under their nose. In the case of Temple of the Dog, is it considered stealing when the riff is on lease from a completely different band?
Once Stone Gossard started to put together demos in tribute to Andy Wood for Temple of the Dog, the song Times of Trouble really set the tone for Chris Cornell's vocals, having a certain lonesome quality in the riff. While shopping tapes around though, it landed in the lap of Eddie Vedder, who used it to record the first batch of Pearl Jam songs under the working title of MamaSon.
Though Times of Trouble became one of the standout tracks with Cornell behind the mic, Gossard actually shoehorned it into the Pearl Jam B-side Footsteps, as Eddie tells the story of a killer driven mad and awaiting execution after going on a shooting spree. Despite having two completely different connotations, it actually works pretty well playing off both subject matters. Insanity and grief don't always go hand in hand, but there is a common thread when it comes to the great unknown that awaits you in the future.
8. Life on Mars? - David Bowie
It's strange looking back at how close David Bowie was to becoming a one hit wonder. As much as the Ziggy Stardust character may have been making waves in the rock underground at the time, Bowie was still known as the "Space Oddity" guy, expected to write about weird space travel songs for the rest of his life. Though we did get a sequel of sorts with the Life on Mars?, the ownership of the melody may be the reason why that question mark is there.
During the interim between Bowie deciding to pursue music full time, he had originally turned in time as a songwriter writing lyrics for melodies he was given. Originally starting off with a French melody that he morphed into a song called Even a Fool Learns to Love, Bowie was upset when his original lyrics were co-opted into the song My Way, which would later become the classic by Frank Sinatra.
Looking to take his spite to the top, Life on Mars? is practically a bastardization of what the original melody was, down to the fact that Bowie even credits "Frankie" in the liner notes of Hunky Dory for the inspiration. As much as Bowie could make mindblowing music out of thin air, it sometimes pays to have something that's a little bit borrowed.
7. Some Nights - Fun.
Up until the early 2010's, the rock world wasn't really lacking in the indie rock boom coming from the underground. While you could normally expect acts like Neon Trees and even the sellout rock of Kings of Leon to grace the charts every now and again, Fun.'s album Some Nights really hit the indie rock ceiling, turning Jack Antanoff into one of the most in-demand producers of the modern age. That's not to say that he hadn't turned in his pop nerd card though.
For most of the title track, Some Nights is a thrilling ride, as these three guys look to do what appears to be the post modern hipster version of Bohemian Rhapsody. Though Nate Ruess clearly has the vocal chops to pull off something like this, the origins of it feel much more indebted to the folk rock side of the spectrum, particularly Paul Simon's Cecilia.
Originally appearing on Bridge Over Troubled Water, the wordless chant that is the backbone of Some Nights is almost ripped exclusively from the melody of Cecilia, which is made even more apparent when some videos on YouTube play the two back to back or in conjunction with one another. So next time the boomers complain about how far music has come as a form of expression, just remember what we took from their glory days.
6. The Lemon Song - Led Zeppelin
In the years before the song lawsuit became widespread, Led Zeppelin were practically the posterchildren for ripping off songs. Hell, even in their early days, it's hard not to see Jimmy Page's vision as anything more than a blues cover band at the best of times. Then again, even when you're not all that original, you still have to cover your tracks.
Using the traditional blues song Killing Floor as their template, The Lemon Song ballooned into one of Zeppelin's greatest sleaze rock tunes, having just as much swagger in Robert Plant's vocals as Page had in his guitar arsenal. Though they seemed to have put the old traditional tune in an entirely new context, that didn't stop the major lawyers from calling once Led Zeppelin II started selling like gangbusters.
Not wanting to take the entire split of the song, the writers of Killing Floor were ultimately given a bit of credit in the liner notes on all subsequent pressings. This wouldn't even be the last time Zeppelin found themselves in hot water, having to attribute When the Levee Breaks from another song by Memphis Minnie just two albums later. As much as Zeppelin filter the blues through their twisted rock and roll lens, you have to do a little better than just giving an old blues song a different name and hope for the best.
5. Sugar Youth - Green Day
If you're absolutely going to steal from another song when writing, you have a few different ways of going about it. While some elect to disguise the trickery through their own warped lens, others find the merit in co-opting an entirely different genre and somehow making it fit within their own context. However, there aren't that many instances where you see bands stealing from...well...themselves.
Granted, it's not like Green Day's music was meant to be the most thought provoking thing in the world, with most of their songs being able to be picked up fairly quickly for those just starting out on guitar. As you look deeper into their discography though, a song like Sugar Youth is an example of Green Day playing on easy mode in more ways than one.
Despite not having that much to the song at just under 2 minutes, this entire track is a blatant retread of She's a Rebel off of American Idiot. Though the original song wasn't necessarily the most advanced song to begin with, there's no question that Sugar Youth started out as She's a Rebel pt. 2, down to the fact that Billie Joe Armstrong almost uses the exact same lyrical hook in both of them. While there are bands like AC/DC who have their formula down to a science, this is the kind of retread that just feels lazy by comparison.
4. This Means War - Avenged Sevenfold
No one can really blame a band like like Avenged Sevenfold for resting on their laurels. I mean, when you have classics like Bat Country and Almost Easy already under your belt, your legacy is all but secure in the halls of metal for the rest of time. You could coax by on easy mode...as long as you don't step on someone else's territory.
For their album Hail to the King, A7X were looking to pay tribute to all of the bands that shaped them as young players, from the sounds of Guns N Roses to Black Sabbath. When it comes to This Means War though, you could tell that they had a bit too much reliance on the kings of thrash metal. From the way that M Shadows' melody flows to the slow and groovy riff that plods along, this is just a runthrough of Metallica's Sad But True with different lyrics.
It didn't really seem like they did too much to hide the similarities either, given that Shadows' melody could be given James Hetfield's lyrics and work just as well in that context. As much as this might be a friendly type of homage from one metal band to another, you have to have nerves of steel if you're going to co-opt a melody this blantantly.
3. Smells Like Teen Spirit - Nirvana
Smells Like Teen Spirit by Nirvana is one of those rare songs that seems to exist outside of time or place. Though you can clearly tell that this is a '90s product from the video alone, the pure allure of Kurt Cobain's melody sounded so modern that it felt like the future of rock before it had even reached the end of its runtime. Then again, even the most modern rock tends to pull from the classics every now and again.
For the longest time, Nirvana attributed to the construction of Teen Spirit to that of the Pixies, who always thrived on the dynamic contrast of a soft verse and a loud chorus. While it's nice for Cobain to at least admit his influence, the similarities between the opening riff feels a lot closer to AM radio rock once you hear it in context. From the root accents of the chords to the way they stop and start on a dime, you can really see that Cobain used Boston's More than a Feeling as his model for rock and roll history.
Even Cobain seemed to be in on the joke once someone pointed it out, going so far as to start playing the iconic Boston hit live on the rare occasion before blasting into Teen Spirit. Rock history may have been set in stone in 1991, but this is one of those instances where it takes a genius to steal this well.
2. Supersonic - Oasis
It's no real secret that Oasis have owed most of their career to that of the Beatles. Hell, even the Gallagher Brothers themselves would probably tell you that the supposed "Greatest Band in the World" couldn't have been brought into fruition without the work of the Fab Four laying the groundwork first. However, there's a fine line between being fanboys and actively ripping off your influences.
As much as the Beatles comparisons have been following Oasis since the beginning, the first real blatant ripoff to come from the lads from Manchester was actually from the Quiet Beatles' solo career. For the majority of Supersonic, you can really feel the Oasis swagger coming into view, with Liam Gallagher showcasing his trademark snideness throughout the track. Once the the main guitar lick comes in though, things start to sound a little too familiar for comfort.
When played side by side, the lead lick that Noel Gallagher plays to connect back into the next verse is the same kind of lyrical guitar part that was found in George Harrisons' My Sweet Lord from his debut album All Things Must Pass. Ironically enough, this was also the song that got Harrison in hot water when he was accused of ripping of He's So Fine by the Chiffons. So there lies the question: how can you call it a ripoff if the song that they're pulling from is a ripoff as well?
1. Why Don't You Get a Job - The Offspring
Part of the appeal that comes with punk rock is taking the piss out of the traditional rock and roll structures of the time. If you had asked anyone from the early days of the punk and hardcore scenes to name their favorite Journey song or something, you'd probably get a rant about the commercialization of rock and roll than an actual endorsement. Then again, sometimes the best way to mock rock and roll is to use their own tropes against them.
While the Offspring were already well on the way to being pop punk titans after their album Smash, Americana had a bit of a departure from their usual sound with Why Don't You Get a Job?. For most of the runtime, it's almost as if Dexter Holland is trying to sound annoying, as the melody has the same kind of awkward cadence that you would find in a nursery rhyme. This wasn't just any catchy tune though...this was one of the biggest bands in the world.
From skin to core, this entire song is a carbon copy of the Beatles' Ob La Di Ob La Da, which is either one of the best or the worst Beatles' songs depending on which fan you end up asking. While the Beatles have done a lot more good than harm for the rock scene throughout their tenure, it's this kind of song that makes you at least see where those naysayers are coming from.