10 Most Frontloaded Albums In Rock History

When first impressions are too strong.

Kate Bush Hounds of Love
EMI

While the album may be a dying format in the age of streaming, there’s still an art to sequencing a record. An LP should be a statement of intent which flows from beginning to end, meant to be listened to as a piece. Recently artists like Adele have spoken out against the practice of shuffling an album - they were designed to be played through from front to back.

Sometimes, though, the sequencing of an album doesn’t quite work. The temptation to put one’s best foot forward is too great, and the artist or record company sticks all the best, most propulsive, or most famous tracks front and centre, making the LP totally top heavy.

Frontloading an album doesn’t necessarily mean the second half is going to be bad - it may just be a lot less immediate or upbeat - but in some instances, the urge to play up to the midpoint and then switch the record off can be pretty great.

These ten records are the most extreme examples of the phenomenon, some of the most imbalanced releases in music history. Some remain great albums, others became half a great album, but they all eschewed a smooth, consistent structure in favour of an impactful start that set a pace which couldn’t be maintained.

10. Beastie Boys - Check Your Head

When the Beasties graduated from cartoonish frat boys to purveyors of the widest sound palette in hip hop, they celebrated their newfound freedom by filling their albums with every idea that popped into their heads. On 1989 masterpiece Paul’s Boutique, this worked wonders, a densely populated but tightly structured album that holds the listener’s attention from start to finish.

While 1992 follow up Check Your Head hits similar highs, it seems that less care is taken in the pacing of the piece. It starts with a sequence of tracks that demonstrate the Boys’ new interests, namely playing instruments harkening back to their hardcore days.

“Gratitude” is fully fledged stoner rock, while “So What’cha Want” and “Finger Lickin’ Good” is some of the least embarrassing rap/rock hybrid music you can ever hope to hear.

Towards the end, though, the Boys lose a little focus. The grooves are still there, but they’re solely grooves, rather than tight tracks built around charmingly loose musicianship. By MCA’s well meaning “Namaste”, the record’s energy has been squandered somewhat.


9. Sufjan Stevens - Illinoise

Pacing is key to any record, but this is never more applicable than when your album stretches past the 70-minute mark and features an almost exhaustingly long list of musicians.

By all measures, Stevens’ 2005 record (the second part of a quickly abandoned project to write an album about every US state) is a triumph, and its length is merited - he’s aiming for epic, and he succeeds in his goals.

Still, the vast majority of the most memorable tracks are packed up top, and in quick succession. The first two sides of vinyl cover “John Wayne Gacy, Jr”, the anthemic “Chicago”, and the beautiful “Casemiro Pulaski Day” along with the terrific title track.

While there are absolutely highlights on the back half (particularly “The Predatory Wasp Of The Palisades Is Out To Get Us!”, Stevens chooses to stick most of his lengthy, instrumental compositions at this point. It’s great music, but leaves the final side feeling like something you’re obliged to play to finish the album off.


8. Paul Simon - Graceland

Though the makings of Paul Simon’s 1986 album - recorded in apartheid-era South Africa - remain controversial to this day, the world music and pop hybrid saw the singer songwriter on inspired form for much of the hit album.

The first side boasts a cavalcade of riches, from the accordion and booming drums of “The Boy In The Bubble” through to the driving rock of the title track and the trilogy of “I Know What I Know”, “Gumboots”, and “Diamonds On The Soles Of Her Shoes”, which sees the best of Simon’s collaboration with African artists, particularly vocal group Ladysmith Black Mambazo.

It’s a run of tunes that few second sides could match, and Graceland’s certainly doesn’t. Indeed the record ends with what are easily its three worst songs, the dated "Crazy Love, Vol. II", "That Was Your Mother" (the only outright dud, a piece of cultural appropriation too far) and the pleasant if unmemorable closer "All Around the World or the Myth of Fingerprints".

Within that second side is megahit “You Can Call Me Al” and “Under African Skies” - probably the record’s best song - but the quality dip between the two halves is a stark one.


7. St Vincent - Strange Mercy

Over the course of a 15-year career, Annie Clark, aka St Vincent, has morphed from art pop provocateur to Grammy-winning arena rocker, without sacrificing her indie cred or outsider ethos. Her most fascinating album perhaps remains her third, though, which seems to bridge the edgy cool of her older work and the more mainstream appeal of the later albums.

The tracks, however, are stacked the other way around, with the record taking off into the pop stratosphere after the spooky, spindly “Chloe In The Afternoon”. “Surgeon” is a skittery earworm of a tune, and “Cheerleader” a stomping rocker that saw Clark take her first step into mass appeal. “Cruel”, meanwhile, made the best case to date that St Vincent was one of the great guitar heroes of our era.

The second half, meanwhile, provides far more of a downtempo sound. From the title track through to closer “Year Of The Tiger”, Clark ditches the ripping guitar solos and infectious choruses for lush soundscapes and oblique lyrics. It’s a record that shows all sides of a great artist, but it’s no surprise she took side A’s sound onward to great success.


6. Talking Heads - Remain In Light

Firstly it should be noted that Talking Heads’ fourth album is one of the all-time greats, seeing the New York outfit continuing to expand their sound beyond edgy, angular new wave and into something polyrhythmic, multicultural, and utterly absorbing.

So it’s not that the second side of the record is at all bad - it’s just seriously oddly structured. The first half starts like a building on fire - without pausing for breath, the band tears through “Born Under Punches”, “Crosseyed And Painless”, and “The Great Curve”. Each of these features an undeniable beat and incredible pace and energy that made the band one of the best live acts of the era. David Byrne yelps and conducts traffic as the expanded lineup brings in brass and backing vocals along with their well established punky sound.

The second half sees the pace on a continuous downward slide, with each track slower and ultimately more ominous than the last. “Once In A Lifetime” is the hit, but by the time we get to “Listening Wind” and “The Overload” it’s like the dance party’s atmosphere has been punctured.

It’s clearly a purposeful decision and a bold one, but the juxtaposition hits strangely.


5. Walker Brothers - Nite Flights

While some of these albums are front loaded by virtue of poor structuring or artistic choices, the Walker Brothers’ final record is top heavy almost by necessity. The 1978 release took an experimental approach and saw each member of the group in turn writing a chunk of the songs. One of the members is Scott Walker; the other two are not.

Accordingly, and unsurprisingly, Scott’s selection is a great deal stronger than the rest of the record. “Shut Out” and “Fat Mama Kick” bridge the gap between the Walkers’ torch songs and Scott’s increasing taste for the dramatic. The title track is brilliant, soaring art pop, inspired by Bowie’s Berlin period and later inspiring Bowie himself, who’d cover the song. And the deeply sinister “The Electrician” serves as a taste of things to come for Walker, who’d turn to the truly bizarre the next decade.

While Gary Leeds and John Walker contribute some solid material - Leeds’ "Den Haague" in particular - the rest of the album doesn’t come close to Scott’s opening tunes, in turn workmanlike or striving for the same distinctive weirdness that came effortlessly to Scott. It’s a great collection of music that opens the album, but there’s little that could follow in its wake.


4. Kanye West - Late Registration

Kanye West is a man who’s keen on long albums, and - unsurprisingly - he had the confidence to do so from the off. His first release, The College Dropout, is a spottier collection of tracks, but dots the good stuff throughout its 76 minute runtime.

Follow up Late Registration, while the better record on the whole (and arguably West’s masterpiece to date), is beset with pacing issues that leave it severely imbalanced. The singles plucked from this record were perfect, and he stacks them all up top, throwing away “Heard ‘em Say”, “Touch The Sky”, and the ubiquitous “Gold Digger” in rapid succession.

These tracks show young Kanye at his best, joyfully cutting up soul samples and showing off his sense of humour. As the album wears on, though, we’re given the less interesting “Roses”, the sweet but saccharine “Hey Mama”, and the forgettable “Bring Me Down” and “Addiction”.

The ambition is laudable, but the pace drops badly in this stretch, though he brings it back with the incredible “Gone”, which would be an all time great album closer if he didn’t then whack on a further two bonus tracks.


3. Kate Bush - Hounds Of Love

It’s arguably the defining work of one of Britain’s greatest ever artists, and to that end it feels sacrilegious to critique Kate Bush’s 1985 opus. As great as Hounds Of Love is, though, there are some structural decisions that can’t help raising an eyebrow.

Namely, that first side, whose pile up of bangers could be straight off a greatest hits compilation. The variety on display impresses, too, from the spooky synth pop of “Running Up That Hill” to the anthemic roar of the title track and the blissful “Big Sky”. Indeed all four of the album’s singles are stacked up on that first half.

So the second side isn’t disappointing - this is a great album all the way through - but jarringly different on first listen. Bush expands her sound with the likes of "Hello Earth" and "Jig of Life", and the progressive elements certainly help to elevate the record after the sheer pop perfection of side one.

There’s no need for an album to maintain a steady tone throughout - it’s just a little tricky to find your bearings when Bush takes such a sharp turn as this.


2. NWA - Straight Outta Compton

It’s an album that changed hip hop, frightened mainstream America with its street knowledge, and made lifetime stars of Ice Cube and Dr Dre. In ways both good and bad, it’s all too clear that this was a band riding a wave of sudden success and looking to capitalise on it as quickly as they could.

Straight Outta Compton hangs together as a piece - the songs all bear stylistic and thematic similarity, to wit huge booming beats and tales of life in L.A’s underbelly. But they play their hand incredibly hard with their opening salvo and the album simply doesn’t have enough material to ever return to that point.

As a trio of songs to start a record, the title track, “F*** The Police”, and “Gangsta Gangsta” are nigh untouchable. In these three tunes we’re introduced to Dre’s much imitated production, the verbose brilliance of leader Ice Cube, wildcard Eazy E, and the (less important) rest of the team.

It’s always going to be downhill from there, and while there are gems elsewhere on the album, cuts like "Quiet On tha Set" are filler, and “Express Yourself” gives Dre a chance to grab the mic that he doesn’t really merit.


1. U2 - The Joshua Tree

On the album that propelled them to world conquering megastardom, U2 didn’t just open proceedings with the biggest songs on the record, they kicked things off with four of the most famous songs they’d ever record.

The A side of 1987’s The Joshua Tree is ludicrously stacked. The anthemic “Where The Streets Have No Name” runs into the soulful “I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For” and the plaintive “With Or Without You”, then kicking up a gear with the bombastic (and slightly embarrassing) “Bullet The Blue Sky”.

The rest of the album isn’t too tonally different from this sequence, but The Joshua Tree’s back half doesn’t have the strength in songwriting as this unimpeachable quartet of tracks. “Trip Through Your Wires”, for example, is solid roots rock but can’t compare with the transcendence of the early tracks.

U2 were on a mission to become the world’s biggest band, and the intention is clearly to capture listeners early on this album. When you get the job done with the first side, it’s fine to relax a little on the second.


Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)