10 Most Underrated Bob Dylan Songs

Diving deep into the canon of the American icon.

Bob dylan
Wikimedia Commons

By now, Bob Dylan has ascended to a status beyond legendary, and with a 60 year and counting musical career, an Oscar, and a Nobel prize to name but a few accolades, it’s fair to say he’s a revered figure.

The man’s back catalogue is immense - there’s undeniably some chaff in there, but his hits are among the world’s most beloved in genres from rock to folk to protest to country.

With a discography this stuffed, though, some gems are always going to fall by the wayside. We’re not talking here about his duff tracks, of which there are plenty, nor his filler, of which there is plenty more. These are the diamonds that even the most ardent Zimmerman fans don’t get around to praising, being as there is so much great music to discuss first.

Some of these tracks are hidden deep on legendary albums, their shine diminished by the sheer stature of some of the records’ other songs. Some come later in his career when Dylan had slipped from the spotlight, others still from soundtrack work in the artist’s truly prolific days.

The argument over Dylan’s finest songs can rage on into eternity, but these are the tracks that will rarely find their way into such exalted company.

10. Bob Dylan's 115th Dream

Bringing It All Back Home is a landmark album for Dylan as he makes his controversial jump from electric to acoustic. The first half of the record contains some of his most famous early rockers, the second half some devastating classic folk.

He actually illustrates the jump at the midpoint on the comical but delightful “Bob Dylan’s 115th Dream”, a wild retelling of the “discovery” of America, with allusions to The Beatles, Moby-Dick, and the singer’s pancake preference.

For most artists, trying to be funny is a big mistake, but Dylan’s lightness of touch, freewheeling lyrics, and joie de vivre makes “115th Dream” the perfect palette cleanser for an album that deals mostly in anger and formal daring.

It also features one of the most charming moments in the singer’s career. Dylan starts off the track as normal, just him and his guitar, before something tickles producer Tom Wilson, who bursts into laughter, stopping the take. Dylan calls an audible, and they restart, this time with a full band backing him up.

It’s a changing of the guard in the most incongruous of fashions.


9. Crossing The Rubicon

That Dylan continues to release albums into his 80s is impressive; that they’re as good as 2020’s Rough And Rowdy Ways is downright otherworldly. Dylan’s latest is one of his best in years, and while the showstopper is his JFK-themed epic “Murder Most Foul”, the stealth classic is “Crossing The Rubicon”.

It’s textbook Dylan - he takes a historical jumping off point, here the endeavours of Julius Caesar, and weaves a wry, rambling narrative over a blues shuffle for seven endlessly enjoyable minutes.

He’s not been so lithe on the mic for many a year, perhaps since “Stuck Inside Of Mobile”-era word salad Dylan. He postures, throws out threats, conjures violent images, and sounds like he’s having a blast doing it.

Musically it’s not his most exciting track ever, but when the song is this downright fun, it doesn’t really matter. He’s an old gunslinger doing precisely what he wants to, and through sheer fortune, it comes out sounding great.


8. Oxford Town

Dylan first found fame as a folk troubadour, and protest music was a large part of his act. His best known political/sociological songs are key to the Dylan canon - “Blowing In The Wind”, “The Times They Are a-Changing” et al.

Less well celebrated but equally powerful is “Oxford Town” from his sophomore Freewheeling album. Written in 1962, the tune concerns a riot that followed the enrollment of a black student in a Mississippi university.

Dylan would write searing songs about racism in the years to come but few more efficient than this. In under two minutes he sketches out the story without ever getting explicit, delivered in a world weary tone that conveys his lack of surprise that a young man would be persecuted so in 20th century America.

It’s sparse acoustic Dylan at his best, with the technically limited singer showing off impressive range.


7. What Good Am I?

Bob Dylan is a man prone to a comeback, but perhaps none have been so comeback-y as 1989’s Oh Mercy. Produced by U2 collaborator Daniel Lanois, the record put a genuinely modern sheen on Dylan’s music, and the stadium friendly vibes were perfectly countered by the artist’s weary, grizzled songcraft.

“Most Of The Time” was the record’s hit, but its even bleaker follow up, “What Good Am I?”, is worthy of major rediscovery. It sounds like a tune written by a man at the end of his tether, a reasonable creative assessment for the Dylan of the late ‘80s. He’s trying to do better, to bring something more out of himself, but doesn’t know if he can anymore.

The sheen Lanois places over the music won’t be for every Dylan fan, but it works wonderfully here, on one of the sparser and less adulterated tracks. Dylan’s voice is ragged and rough as he tries to cling onto an upper register that’s fast deserting him; like a lot of his music, the lack of technical finesse only adds to the experience.

The track was also covered to great effect by Tom Jones, who went full torch song, though the Welshman’s machismo makes the oozing self doubt sound affected. From Dylan’s mouth, it’s achingly real.


6. Oh Sister

1976’s Desire is one of the great Dylan LPs, a great mix of country, protest, and rock, backed by a banging band and with some of his most interesting story songs (the right-on “Hurricane”, the ill conceived but fun ode to a gangster “Joey”).

Nestled among the record’s more muscular tracks is the sweet, sensitive “Oh Sister”. A duet with the great Emmylou Harris, this was a live favourite of the time when Dylan hit the road on his Rolling Thunder Revue tour (as captured by Scorsese’s excellent documentary), but fell out of favour as he stripped back his band to the simpler, more rocking troupe he’s favoured of late.

Dylan’s admittedly limited vocals are as good as they’ve been on Desire, and they mesh wonderfully with Harris’ Alabama lilt. This is a downbeat album all told, and “Oh Sister” continues that vibe with its pessimistic love story, but that doesn’t stop it from sounding beautiful.


5. Main Title Theme (Billy)

Bob Dylan and the movies are so intertwined that Belle & Sebastian wrote a song about it. His big screen efforts haven’t always gone too well - see the incredibly odd Masked And Anonymous (or actually, don’t) - but when the maestro meshes with the right project, magic happens.

Dylan has a small part in Sam Peckinpah’s Pat Garrett And Billy The Kid, and frankly he’s not great. His score, though, is sublime. It’s best remembered for “Knockin’ On Heaven’s Door”, but more interesting is his instrumental work, particularly the main title theme.

A beautiful, subtle piece of guitar music, it perfectly sets up the elegiac nature of Peckinpah’s film, as well as distancing it from the previous generation of westerns. There’s no room for bombast or triumph here - the shuffling tune is delicate and melancholy. This isn’t a film about heroes and villains, but about people, with all their complexities.

Dylan would go on to win an Oscar for his contribution to 2000’s Wonder Boys, but his early foray into film music - like the film itself - still doesn’t get the credit it deserves.


4. Long And Wasted Years

Tempest isn’t the cheeriest or easiest going of Dylan’s impressive run of ‘00s albums, with songs drenched with death, most of which sail close to the 10 minute mark. By far the highlight of the album, perhaps not coincidentally, is one of its shortest tracks, the lovely and particularly tuneful “Long And Wasted Years”/

It’s no less mournful than a lot of the songs on the record, with Dylan touching on an unhappy relationship, familial strife, ambitions unfulfilled and folk who just won’t understand one another. Musically speaking, though, it’s one of his best for many a year. The song is built around a descending, incredibly catchy riff which continues across the whole tune as Dylan free associates, weaves an aura of sadness, and cribs from “Twist And Shout”.

It doesn’t sound like much if anything else in his canon, and his continued musical invention at the ripe old age of (then) 71 is beyond impressive. It’s a quietly devastating tune in a collection that tends to go for quantity and gusto.


3. All The Tired Horses

Fifty years and change after its release, people still aren’t clear exactly what to make of Self Portrait. The album was released to a critical mauling, with songs sounding dashed off and flimsy. After the fact, Dylan claimed the album was a joke on those who deified him, which simultaneously sounds like something he’d do and a handy excuse.

“All The Tired Horses” starts the album off with unmatchable quality. One of the most beautiful tracks Dylan has ever recorded, it doesn’t feature his voice at all (hence the beauty), but rather a trio of women who repeat the song’s two line mantra for its three minute duration.

The instrumentation is warm and varied - guitars strum, a string section introduces itself piece by piece. It’s a strange song, one of the most conventionally pretty melodies Dylan has ever engaged in, but it’s quite clearly neither a spoof nor a throwaway.

Indeed it’s in many ways the least Dylan-esque track in his oeuvre, minimising his greatest power - language - and allowing a gorgeous, simple tune to do his talking for him.


2. Nettie Moore

2006’s Modern Times saw Bob embrace his old age. The title preaches modernity, but the contents see Dylan assemble a band and blast out rock and roll, regardless of the fashions of the day. But it’s the album’s softest track, “Nettie Moore”, that leaves the most lasting impression, a near seven minute composition that sounds like a piece of traditional music but allows the singer to reflect on his history over one of his most beautiful backdrops.

The song posits Dylan in his natural role: the wandering troubadour whose life is given over to music and the road. As he travels the world he pines for his titular love. Dylan’s vocal rhythms stick close to the lurching guitar and bass, the spacious track allowing his particularly comfortable vocals the room to breathe.

It’s a standout track from a seriously strong album, restrained but full of meaning, an old time song by a guy no longer feeling the need to reinvent himself or chase continued relevance, but instead entirely confident in his position in the pantheon.


1. Fourth Time Around

1966’s Blonde On Blonde is one of Dylan’s truly unimpeachable records. The album’s foundations are Nashville pickers, carnival horns, sprawling tracks and gaudy maximalism. But the hidden gem is the delicate, thoughtful “4th Time Around”, nestled towards the back end of the LP and taking a subtle approach that makes it so distinctive on this raucous album.

The track is primarily acoustic, a swaying waltz comprised of harmonica, beautiful fingerpicking, a propulsive snare, and Dylan’s vocals. He’s in a playfully obtuse mood for the entirety of the album, and while it’s no different here, the melody is no less sweet for the singer’s often charmingly odd turns of phrase.

The song was thought to be a response of sorts to John Lennon’s “Norwegian Wood”, but the rage and misogyny of the Beatles track is here tempered with humour and deft lyricism. Whatever the inspiration, it’s a gem of a track, old school singer songwriter stuff from an album of full blown rock.


In this post: 
Bob-Dylan
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)