10 Most Underrated Drummers Of All Time
Justice for the Masters of Backbeat.
Since the dawn of music history, the drummer has always gotten the short end of the stick (so to speak). No matter how much energy you bring to the band from behind the kit, there have always been people willing to make jokes at the one behind the skins for being "the dumb one." However, there's absolutely no joking around when it comes to the way these guys lay down a groove.
Compared to the more celebrated drummers like John Bonham and Ringo Starr, these minds behind the skins always knew their strengths and came out with a stellar rhythmic foundation for every song they used. While most people think being a good drummer comes down to how fast you play, it doesn't really work out like that. Sometimes it's the attitude in your delivery, other times the speed, and other times where it's just about serving the song that you're playing.
As opposed to technical artists like Neil Peart and Danny Carey, many of these drummers knew how to sit in the song and play just the right fills necessary for the track to come alive. Even though they might not be the most vocal of musicians, these drummers brought the thunder when they needed to as the heartbeat of the band.
10. Phil Collins - Genesis
For all of the prog snobs, Phil Collins will forever be known as the man who destroyed Genesis' career. After Peter Gabriel left to pursue a solo career, the idea of getting Collins behind the mic led them into some of the most commercial stuff they would ever write, which got more and more embarrassing as the years went on. Then again, is everyone forgetting that Collins got his start behind the kit?
For as many memes have been made of Collins as the pop sound of Genesis, he always had an impressive knack as the group's original drummer. Despite the more outlandish ideas from Gabriel, Phil always made everything fit together in a neat package at the best of times, tearing through complex time signatures without a care in the world. A good prog band is always as good as its chops though, and Collins was one of the best in the early days, making some of the busiest drum rolls somehow fit within the context of stuff like Dance on a Volcano.
Regardless of his dad rock status, Collins has gotten a little bit respect from his peers in recent years, with Rush legend Neil Peart calling on his advice in the early days. So next time you think Phil Collins' drum chops begin and end at In the Air Tonight, take a look at the back half of Genesis and prepare to be amazed.
9. Jimmy Chamberlain - The Smashing Pumpkins
The emergence of alt-rock wasn't necessarily the greatest of things for the drummer's spot. Regardless of heavyhitters like Dave Grohl and Matt Cameron providing great drum hooks, the days of Mike Portnoy levels of brilliance tended to go the way of hair metal shortly after the emergence of albums like Nirvana's Nevermind. That is, with one massive exception operating outside of Seattle.
For as much as the Smashing Pumpkins are seen as legendary today, people tend to just flock to Billy Corgan as the heart of the group. It's not that hard to see why either, given his hand in nearly every single song and playing over other members' parts on more than a few others. On the other hand, Jimmy Chamberlain's drumming is absolutely irreplaceable in this field, bringing a huge amount of dimension to every single Pumpkins track. Compared to the other amazing punk rock drumming going on around the same time, Chamberlain made the kind of rhythm tracks that work well in stadiums, and yet came out on the other side with some of the greatest drum performances of the time like on Cherub Rock.
Even the drum machine precision on 1979 is not programmed, instead being a looped performance of Chamberlain's dead-on time for most of the track. While Corgan may have been the spirit of the Pumpkins, you go to Jimmy Chamberlain when you want to hear the group's muscle.
8. Larry Mullen Jr. - U2
It's hard to really consider the idea of U2 being underrated by any stretch of the imagination. Given the amount of lip service that Bono has had over the years as one of the saviors of rock and roll, there are probably people who would prefer to take an axe to their speakers rather than listen to another U2 track. Despite the stadium sounding vocals of Bono or even the Edge's technical wizardry, it's Larry Mullen's drumwork that makes everything really fit together.
Compared to the straight ahead rhythm that you get in stadium sized acts like this, Mullen's work is much more varied than many would give him credit for. As far as his style goes, his rearranging of his kit made for an unstoppable quality to the tom toms, which sound massive on songs like Pride. At the same time, Larry is also one of the few drummers who knows the balance between artificial and mechanical drumming, knowing exactly when to bring in the loops across albums like Achtung Baby.
Even if he's just going over a basic shuffle or backbeat, the amount of punch in his delivery of songs like Bullet the Blue Sky can go toe to toe with the most technical of craftsmen. For as much as you hear their songs on the radio, it might be possible that you've been listening to U2 for the wrong guy after all these years.
7. Chad Smith - The Red Hot Chili Peppers
The journey to find a drummer for the Red Hot Chili Peppers was virtually impossible to track in the early days. Despite having some prime candidates like Jack Irons and D.H. Peligro from the Dead Kennedys, Flea and Anthony Kiedis' search for the perfect guy almost seemed like a lost cause as the '80s came to a close. On a whim though, they found what may be one of the most accomplished skinsmen they had ever seen.
While you can call Chad Smith's style pretty by the numbers for the Chili Peppers, that's only because it has become so synonymous with their sound over the years. Ever since the release of Blood Sugar Sex Magik, Smith has given a masterclass on how to sit in the song with every subsequent Peppers record. Compared to the typical funk stuff everyone recognizes, Smith really knows how to lean back, like having nothing but the bare essentials for almost half of Under the Bridge.
There are some times when he goes off the rails though, like being able to juggle the genres of funk, punk, and arena style rock throughout Give It Away. Most importantly though, Smith's connection with Flea has made them the tightest rhythm section in the business, playing off of each other and striking gold nearly every time. Chad Smith is not nearly the first guy you think of when you think of the Chilis, but he really is the rock and roll energy that ties them all together.
6. Ginger Baker - Cream
Many tend to hold Cream in high regard as the first real supergroup, and it's not hard to see why. Though Eric Clapton was the real musical god among his contemporaries, there was still a lot of musical genius at play between this power trio. Whereas Jack Bruce might have had the soulful voice and bass chops, Ginger Baker really brought an added sense of chaos to Cream's sound.
As opposed to just playing the straight beat, Ginger's background in blues and jazzier territory led him to take unconventional approaches in his drumming style. Look no further than songs like Toad, which shows basically everything a drummer needs to know across almost 10 minutes. That's far from where his chops end though, with Sunshine of Your Love being a masterclass unto itself. For as classic as the riff from Clapton is, Baker's the one who gives the tune its charm, focusing heavily on the tom toms to create an almost primal sounding foundation for everything above it.
Most of these tracks became completely different beasts once they played them live as well, with Baker taking the reigns from behind the kit and transforming these songs into amazing exercises in rock and roll badassery. While people may go on and on about the beginnings of heavy metal starting with Black Sabbath, heavy metal drums actually started a few years earlier than that.
5. Roger Taylor - Queen
It's no real secret that people tend to think about Freddie Mercury whenever they bring up Queen. I mean, when you have one of the greatest frontmen in the history of music, it's easy for even guitar wizards like Brian May to get overshadowed from time to time. Despite the massive amount of musical eclecticism from both Mercury and May, the real rock and roll soul of the group was always in Roger Taylor.
Being in the background for most of Queen's material, Taylor's amazing way of making the audience react whenever he played was virtually unrivaled. Even though May may have written the foundation for something like We Will Rock You, Taylor is the one responsible for making it into the massive chant that we know and love today. Hell, Taylor even managed to break the curse of drummers not being able to write songs.
Across Queen's records, Taylor would step up to the front with the more straight ahead rock tunes, with his husky voice taking lead instead of Freddie's more high end wail. While this wasn't something you saw a lot in Queen's music, Taylor also deserves credit for his amazing adaptability, making his drumming fit into opera on Bohemian Rhapsody and funk on Another One Bites the Dust. Queen may very well have fallen without Freddie Mercury, but don't let that trick you into thinking that the other guys are any less important.
4. Andy Hurley - Fall Out Boy
There's a lot of people probably shaking their heads at the travesty that's taking this spot. After all, Fall Out Boy's more deplorable hits on the radio these days and sell-out albums as of late may even put them in consideration as one of the most overrated bands of our time. For as much as Pete Wentz might relish in the spotlight, it's come at the expense of a monster behind the kit.
It's not like Andy Hurley doesn't really get to shine though, with the drum solo during Fall Out Boy's sets being one of the standout moments of every show. At the same time, Hurley's greatest strengths as a drummer have come whenever he's outside of the pop punk lens, like when he's serving as the muscle behind the supergroup the Damned Things. Instead of the traditional pop rock stuff he's used to, this is an all-out metal outfit where Hurley can really show his stuff, even giving some metal luminaries a run for their money in the process.
Also, it's not like every one of Fall Out Boy's drum breaks are bad, with songs like Sugar We're Going Down practically living and dying on the mammoth performance from Andy. For as much as stans may like to drone on about the wonders of Save Rock and Roll, there's a good chance they're missing the single greatest part of the group.
3. Stevie Wonder
I mean, what more is there really to say about Stevie Wonder? With him being practically the soundtrack for most of the '70s for a generation, the amount of artistic brilliance he has brought from behind the keyboard has given him free reign over almost any genre he lays his hands on. At the same time, that same brilliance doesn't only apply to the keyboard.
Instead of the usual synth lines on tracks like Superstition, Wonder was also responsible for most of the drumming on his classic records. Making albums like Music of My Mind and Talking Book by himself, Wonder's timing was amazing from the first bar he comes in on, always laying into the groove and make everything breathe within the confines of his song. For as many hits he has played on, many forget about the sounds he's able to get out of the kit, whether it's shuffling or just hanging back.
In fact, many people tend to forget songs like Superstition start with the drums, as Wonder accompanies his now classic keyboard lines without a care in the world. Given his hand in many other people's classic hits, this is one of Stevie's trademarks that is much more suited for his own music. There's no need for another reason why Stevie Wonder kicks ass at music, but in case you needed another one, check out the low end and prepare to be amazed.
2. Phil Taylor - Motorhead
Most of the metal world was a bit shellshocked once thrash metal started to pick up steam. As opposed to the typical mammoth drum performances coming out of someone like John Bonham of Led Zeppelin, this insanely fast double bass and relentless rhythm was definitely a game changer for aspiring metal drummers. However, all those who learn their drumming chops from Metallica don't realize they're learning it second hand.
Long before thrash became the go-to genre for extreme drumming, Phil Taylor was really the litmus test that everyone should have been looking at. Pairing just alongside Lemmy in Motorhead, "Philthy" was just the shot of adrenaline to take these songs to the heights that reached, coming in like thunder on tracks like Ace of Spades and Damage Case. The greatest contribution to metal music has to be Overkill, whose intro features one of the greatest showcases for double bass drums ever in rock music.
That's before you even get to his chemistry with Lemmy himself, oftentimes being in lock step with the thick bass grooves coming from out front. Though a lot of Motorhead songs suffer from sounding like one another from time to time, when you have someone like this behind the kit, do you really need to change anything else?
1. Cozy Powell - Various
Cozy Powell has been one of the few faceless legends to come out of the '70s era of rock music. Being primarily a session player for most of his career, Powell's short-lived time in the spotlight never really could be tied to a single band. Nevertheless, even if you don't know the man's name, you sure as hell have heard his drumming countless times.
Being at the forefront of hard rock, Cozy's approach to drumming seemed ripped straight out of the John Bonham school of drumming, with the focus being on some of the most immense sounding percussion ever conceived. Originally starting out sitting in with Jeff Beck, the first real classics came when he sat in with Rainbow, which made for one of the greatest drum intros of all time at the start of Stargazer. However, Powell always seemed to never fit in well with one set band, instead electing to flip flop with acts like Whitesnake and even a stint on a Black Sabbath album over the years.
That wasn't able to stop his wild man status though, with him perishing in a car crash at the age of 50 during some downtime in between tours. For as much of a wild presence he may have been, you don't get asked to be in some of the heaviest acts of all time and not have the chops to actually pull all of them off like this.