10 Most Underrated Nu Metal Albums
Undervalued gems from the fallen phenomenon.
Arguably starting with Korn's classic debut album in 1994, nu metal gradually took over as the number one trend in the headbanging world as the '90s rolled on. With fashion senses one can't even really describe, rockers inspired by everything from grunge to hip hop started churning out riff-heavy, solos-non-existent hybrid music.
For the first time in metal's grumpy, mosh pit-loving history, turntables were in the house and the mainstream was buzzing more than ever before. While the late '90s proved to be an improbably huge boom period for the new urban scene, the noughties saw it crumble under the weight of its own success.
Over-saturation took a heavy toll as every band under the sun tried to quickly cash in while the cashing was good. By 2002, nu metal was the past, a place it remains mostly trapped in to this day. It lives on predominantly in the subgenres it helped inspire such as the once unthinkable emo rap.
Groups like Korn, Limp Bizkit and Linkin Park dominated nu metal at its peak, often leagues ahead of everyone else. Under these titans' long shadows lay many exciting records deserving of more hype and recognition. Here are 10 of the best.
10. The Workhorse Movement - Sons of the Pioneers
Bursting onto the scene in 2000, The Workhorse Movement wowed listeners with their diverse, hybrid sound. Blending nu metal conventions with funk, rap and groove metal, the group put together a thrilling, nuanced sound. In the UK, they gained a surprise explosion in traction, garnering acclaim and the beginnings of a cult following.
While their lyrics weren't exactly intellectual, they had a certain wit and sharpness to them that bigger rap metal outfits like Limp Bizkit rarely displayed. There was a level of creativity and eclectic heaviness here that had many wondering for a split second if The Workhorse Movement would eventually catch fire and take nu metal to new heights.
Unfortunately, their debut LP proved to be their final LP. Three members went on to form Dirty Americans, another underrated outfit and The Workhorse Movement quietly faded away.
It's a shame as rollocking, genre-blending tracks like 'Livin' Evil' and 'Keep the Sabbath Dream Alive' showed real promise and audio power in arguably the peak year for new urban mayhem. Despite the blink-and-you'll-miss-it lifespan of the group, 'Sons of the Pioneers' is an eccentric masterclass in the perks of the once titanic nu metal genre.
9. Chimaira - Pass Out of Existence
The Ohio headbangers are not really considered nu metal these days, nor do they themselves seem very fond of their 2001 debut LP. Frontman Mark Hunter has criticised the album's approach to samplying and electronica in the years since, two traits that very much lodged their first album in the nu metal category.
Released hot off the heels of Slipknot setting the world on fire with 'Iowa' two months prior, Chimaira's sound here has a lot in common with the masked menaces. That's not to say they're a total rip-off though. The group's blend of death metal ferocity with groove metal riffs give the otherwise-nu-friendly sound a certain backbone and aggression many such acts struggle to attain.
Andols Herrick's drums are blistering here, taking inspiration from the machine gun, rapid-fire style more commonly found in speed and thrash metal. Hunter's voice, as guttural and demonic as ever, beats you over the head with frequently brutal, nihilistic lyrics. The guitars are hectic, moving from shredding to scratchier, moodier fare. The LP as a whole is the musical equivalent of a fast-paced horror film: thrilling, absorbing and rather unpleasant.
While Chimaira really only found their signature sound in the albums that followed, this release from the tail end of the nu metal boom is an under-valued gem.
8. Fear Factory - Digimortal
Going all in on high concept science fiction, Fear Factory examined the fusion of man and machine in their fourth LP. It's the grand finale in a conceptual trilogy that started with 1995's 'Demanufacture' and continued in 1998's 'Obsolete'.
Released in 2001, the final year of nu metal's chart-topping dominance, the album saw the normally industrial crew take a stab at the new urban craze. Unfortunately, they left their nu metal entry a little too late in the game and the album failed to secure major commercial success.
Lead single 'Linchpin', a disturbing, hot-tempered track about a narrator terrified of their transhumanist setting, did garner the group some notice. However, the rest of the album, while thrilling, felt like a step backwards at the time for a group who'd been so instrumental in the rise of industrial metal in the '90s.
As was so often the case with nu metal at the time, Fear Factory even teamed up with a rapper, B-Real from Cypress Hill, for 'Back the F**k Up'. It's not a a bad song by any means but it's a vast departure from what fans of the group were hoping for at the time.
Despite being considered a step back from the stylings Fear Factory were best known for, this is a fun and engaging entry in the nu metal genre.
7. Bloodsimple - A Cruel World
The Dashiell Hammett enthusiasts were an unlucky case of too little, too late in the nu metal scene. Born from the (eventually resurrected) ashes of hardcore legends Vision of Disorder, Bloodsimple slipped in under the radar as a sort of epilogue to the late '90s-early noughties new urban boom.
By the end of 2001, the nu giant had fallen. The damage from over-exposure ultimately proved irreparable which, for Bloodsimple, was something of a death sentence to their commercial chances.
Their 2005 debut LP, 'A Cruel World', was greeted by relative quiet in the music world. It's blend of nu metal stylings with hardcore rage lends it a metalcore flavour that serves troubled, bleak tracks such as the Iraq War-focused 'Straight Hate' well.
The album sifts through many of the angsty, grim, personal themes that were commonplace in nu metal '90s acts such as relationships issues, drug abuse and antisocial behaviour. While it's all been done before, the group infuse it with some new life thanks to their groove-laden, hardcore-focused tweaks to the classic nu sound.
It's an action-packed effort from a group that likely could've been massive had they put this out several years earlier.
6. Five Pointe O - Untitled
There's so much going on in this short lived Joliet outfit's one-and-done LP that it requires a few listens to really, fully appreciate.
Signed with heavy metal kingpin label Roadrunner Records, Five Point O evidently weren't really sure what to call their first album. There's hints of several seminal '90s rock and metal fads throughout, from politically charged, Rage Against the Machine-style rap rock in 'Freedom' to death metal-laden contempt in 'Purity 01'.
The expansive, often hectic guitars take a page out of the progressive book, giving us the closest thing we ever had to progressive nu metal. The elaborate riffs and compositions complement frontman Daniel Struble's versatile vocals, alternating between harsh screams and refined singing, perfectly. The combination reflects the diverse, often crazed lyrics neatly as well as nailing down the colourful but visceral blend of metal subgenres on offer.
A passable success, 'Untitled' likely could've swelled with acclaim had the band stuck together and released a sophomore LP. Instead, Struble and guitarist Sharon Grzelinski buckled under the weight of high-intensity touring in the year that followed. Burnt out, both quit the band. Needless to say, despite promises from the remaining members that Five Point O would return, it never did. Considering the sizzling tracks on offer here, such an early split is a massive shame.
5. Sepultura - Nation
Derrick Green's second adventure as the frontman of Sepultura sees the groove icons fully embrace the nu metal craze at the tail end of its peak.
Green's debut, 'Against', had been well received but decried as nothing special compared to the madness of 'Roots'. Previous frontman Max Cavalera's shadow hung heavy over the group following his departure and many wondered if the Brazilian crew would ever reach the highs of their debut LP again.
While 'Nation' reaching the power of 'Roots' is debatable, it did reveal Green's true potential. Boasting a selection of furious, headbanging anthems, the high-energy effort benefits from the group's openness to nu metal stylings. The blend of their more death and groove-friendly sound with hardcore and metalcore jazzes up the predictably hot-tempered meditations on rebellion and oppression.
The LP also sees three intriguing collaborations. The group get the frontmen of Dead Kennedys and Hatebreed on before enjoying a head-spinning instrumental duel with Apocalyptica to close out the album. All in all, 'Nation' is like a variety show of what makes Sepultura great.
The lack of promotion for the LP has often been cited as a primary factor in its disappointing sales. Frustrated, the band eventually left Roadrunner Records over it, claiming a music video for 'One Man Army' had also been nixed.
4. Project 86 - Truthless Heroes
The post-hardcore cult favourites turned out their most polarising effort in 2002 with 'Truthless Heroes', a moody, complicated concept album about fortune and fame. Signed to Atlantic Records by way of Tooth & Nail Records, the group found themselves in a frustrating creative zone at the time.
Frontman Andrew Schwab came to scream, determined to infuse the group's third LP with the same punky, vicious tone their first two had enjoyed. The studio, however, wanted something a little more commercially friendly, demanding Schwab sing properly whilst also moving the group's instrumentals into nu metal territory.
Nu metal was very much on the decline by '02 but still held some influence, with many expecting it return to popularity soon enough. For Project 86, that meant turning their most lyrically ambitious effort yet into a new urban headbanger.
Following in the footsteps of POD, Project 86 blended Christian rock and themes with their otherwise heavy, edgy sound. In a gutsy display, the group even threw in some anti-war lyrics and ideas in the midst of the Bush administration's early years, a decision some have argued alienated their more conservative listeners.
Incorporating cleaner vocals and more melodic instrumentals ultimately bolstered the group's sound and versatility both here and in the efforts that followed.
3. Nothingface - Skeletons
Nothingfaces's first three LPs left many writing them off as a rather shameless Korn rip-off. Arguably the founding fathers of nu metal, there were certainly worse groups to take inspiration from than Korn. Regardless, the decision hampered these Washington D.C. rockers' reputation for some time.
With 2003's 'Skeletons', the group, perhaps sensing the end of nu metal as a leading scene, changed up their sound. Proving more creative than ever before, they blended everything from thrash metal to hardcore punk with their new urban focus.
Following 2000's 'Violence', the band struggled with a variety of personal setbacks and tragedies. 'Skeletons' captured them at perhaps their lowest ebb in many ways. For listeners, however, the amount of passion and emotion poured into this troubled album shone through, making it the group's most powerful musical statement.
Frontman Max Holt goes to war with the world on the lyrical front, slamming everything from organised religion to the US government. The heat in his words is bolstered by guitarist Tom Maxwell's most blisteringly impressive work with the group. Tracks like 'Patricide' and 'I Wish I Was a Communist' are as blunt and harsh as their titles suggest. What the band may lack in witticisms they more than make up for in unbridled rage and turmoil-laden riffs though.
Between struggles with loss and addiction in their personal lives and the general fading of the nu metal genre, Nothingface called it quits after this one. They went out on a high note that deserved much more notice than it got.
2. Machine Head - The Burning Red
Machine Head's 1999 tertiary effort was utterly trashed by fans at the time of its release. After going two for two in hard-hitting groove LPs, the Oakland crew committed full scale to the booming nu metal craze of the late '90s.
The album sees Machine Head throw a lot at the wall including Robb Flynn trying out both crooning and rapping at different points. New guitarist Ahrue Luster was pointed at at the time as being a major driving force in the band's evolving sound following the departure of Logan Mader.
Frustrated by critics dismissing their second album for sounding eerily similar to their first, Machine Head threw caution to the wind with one of the heaviest entries in nu metal's history. The album also holds the group's darkest, most infamous track, 'Five', centred on the abuse Flynn suffered as a child. Songs like this one add a deeply disturbing, more personal touch to the often hectic, genre-bending mayhem going on.
Lead single 'From This Day' showcased the band's newer nu-er image with gusto. Flynn, already showcasing some of his cringier, camera-hogging antics, angrily growls his way through a song that left many scratching their heads. In hindsight, the LP is a perfect time capsule of everything nu metal provided listeners. While it may not have been what fans wanted, it proved Machine Head had their finger on the heavy metal pulse better than most.
1. Minus.Driver - Structure of Simplicity
While they never really went anywhere, the frequently renamed Minus.Driver displayed mountainous potential with their first and last LP.
The group initially spent ample time on the often gruelling Atlanta club scene after forming in high school. Their first taste of any real success came when they landed a gig on 'Farmclub.com', a briefly run music series in the early noughties. They performed alongside another fledgling group by the name of Incubus (wonder whatever happened to them). The increased notoriety lead to the release of 'Structure of Simplicity', a complex, thoughtful blend of nu metal angst with post-hardcore sensibilities.
Tracks like 'Everything' and 'Stranded' proved that Minus.Driver had the technical knowhow to craft more melodic beats than what nu metal was accustomed to. When crossed with the headbanging rage of more classically nu anthems like 'Half-Mile', it becomes clear just how versatile these underground cult favourites could be.
Lyrically, there were hints of a far more poetic, thoughtful mind than what was typical among nu metal outfits. Look no further than the intricate work on display in 'Anti-Vanity', a heady, atmospheric track encircling a variety of confronting themes.
Despite being briefly signed to Universal, Minor.Drive ultimately didn't put out much more bar an EP after this. The group disbanded before they ever hit their peak, leaving this fascinating artefact behind.