10 Music Artists Who Quit In Their Prime

Unlike most, these musicians knew the value of quitting when you’re ahead.

Gotye Somebody That I Used to Know
Eleven

Whether you’ve learned to play an instrument and slogged around the country, played in dive bars for pennies or simply sung your heart out into a hairbrush for the benefit of your bedroom mirror, most of us have dreamed of pop or rock stardom at one point or another.

We might mock famous musicians for their outrageous demands, crazy behaviour or outlandish outfits, but who amongst us wouldn’t gladly swap the nine-to-five for the life of adoring fans, vast wealth and creative fulfilment that a successful career in music seems to offer?

It stands to reason then, that should anyone actually manage to perfect that magical, alchemical mixture of hard work, talent and luck needed to make it in the music industry, they would cherish that success and hold onto it with both hands. At the very least making the most of their moment in the sun, milking the success before fame starts to wane and record sales begin to slide. Strangely that isn’t always the case.

Who on Earth, then, would walk away from fame and fortune, whilst still at the peak of their commercial or creative powers? Read on to find out.

10. Russell Senior

While Oasis seemed to burst into the public consciousness fully formed and Blur found mainstream success with their third album, Britpop peers Pulp had an altogether more protracted gestation period. The Sheffield band originally formed way back in 1978, long before they found fame in the 1990s.

Russell Senior joined as part of the band’s third line up and played a central role, contributing guitar, violin and vocals. He was with group for over a decade before before their breakthrough album His ’n’ Hers in 1994, which was followed by the massive success of ‘95’s Different Class.

Having stuck it out with his bandmates through their years in obscurity, you might think Senior would revel in their hard earned success. Instead, he soon found himself disillusioned with fame and the treadmill of touring, recording and promotion he found himself on.

He wasn’t the only member of Pulp finding out success wasn’t quite what he’d imagined. The subject made up much of the lyrical content of the band’s next album This Is Hardcore. However, Senior was all finding himself unfulfilled creatively. He disliked the band’s song Help The Aged so intensely that he attempted to sabotage its recording.

He left the band entirely soon afterwards, worrying his unhappiness would create a poisonous atmosphere within the group. Though he remains friendly with his former bandmates and briefly reunited with the band for a comeback tour in 2011, he now devotes much of his time to antique dealing alongside other musical projects.


9. Tom Lehrer

Perhaps best remembered for chemistry-nerd classic The Elements, Tom Lehrer was a top notch musical satirist. His witty piano tunes inspired a devoted following as proven by the raucous live albums that round out his meagre back catalogue. After building his reputation with darkly macabre and risqué material, his increasingly topical works made him a fixture of the US version of pioneering satirical TV show, That Was The Week That And Was.

He gained popularity overseas as well, with successful tours in Australasia and Europe and contributing songs to The Frost Report in the U.K. but by 1965 his recording career was done. By 1972 he had also given up touring and returned to teaching mathematics and musical theatre.

Bored of touring, he claimed simply to have lost interest in writing and recording songs and that he’d said everything he wanted to say. Though it might be argued we could still have used his satirical barbs in the ensuing decades.

In 2020 he donated all his music and lyrics to the public domain. Of his own career he said,

"If, after hearing my songs, just one human being is inspired to say something nasty to a friend, or perhaps to strike a loved one, it will all have been worth the while."

8. Lauren Hill

Many musicians struggle to find their feet after the break up of the group that brought them success, but Lauren Hill hit the ground running. Her acclaimed solo debut The Miseducation Of Lauren Hill debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard 200 and sold by the bucketload, and Doo Wop (That Thing) gave her similar success as a singles artist.

She received a record ten nominations at the 41st Grammy Awards, winning in five categories. The album went on to sell 20 million copies worldwide, nearing the success of her former band The Fugees’ biggest hit, The Score. In fact, The Miseducation of Lauren Hill actually outsold The Score in the US.

Despite having conquered the world of pop music and being inundated with acting offers, Hill began to find the pressures of fame underwhelming and decided to opt out of the spotlight. She dropped out of movie projects, fired her management team and stopped doing interviews.

Instead her time was taken up with bible study classes, which she started attending five days a week. She later told Essence magazine:

“I had to step away when I realized that for the sake of the machine, I was being way too compromised... For two or three years I was away from all social interaction. It was a very introspective time.”

A 2001 MTV unplugged performance drew largely negative reviews as she performed unfinished, acoustic folk tracks that seemed to abandon her former blend of hip-hop, soul and reggae. The show was released as a platinum selling live album but a studio follow up failed to emerge, despite Columbia records sinking millions of dollars into the project. Ever since, her musical performances and releases have been haphazard and sporadic.


7. Garth Brooks

It takes unusual talent and exceptional dedication to make it to the top in any given sport, let alone succeeding in two. Both Usain Bolt and Michael Jordan both struggled to transfer their skills to football and baseball, respectively, and the pair are world class athletes. So you’d have to think a country would have no chance.

Then again, selling more records than Elvis obviously instilled a bit of self belief in Garth Brooks who decided to give a career in baseball a try. He joined two different teams for spring training camps in 1997 and ‘98 but understandably struggled against the pros.

The following year, Brooks ditched country and tried his hand at rock and roll under the guise of new alter ego, Chris Gaines. The move left most fans underwhelmed and bewildered and a movie about the Chris Gaines character was never released.

With the benefit of hindsight, Brooks looks like a man increasingly restless, with little left to achieve as the world’s biggest country music star. The Friends In Low Places singer had talked about walking away from performing and recording as early as 1992 but in 2000 he officially retired to spend more time with his family.

Though he eventually returned to the stage and studio, he took nearly a decade off bar the odd charity performance.


6. Daft Punk

Like some kind of 21st Century update on Kraftwerk’s Man Machine aesthetic, Daft Punk are almost as well known for their robot outfits as their groundbreaking music. Nonetheless, the French duo remain one of dance music’s most successful and influential proponents.

Released in 2013, the pair’s fourth album, Random Access Memories, was their most successful yet. This was an impressive achievement given the acclaim and popularity already achieved by their earlier work. Lead single Get Lucky, featuring Pharrell Williams, became the most streamed new song in the history of Spotify and Daft Punk won five Grammys including album of the year.

The same year Daft Punk Co-produced Kanye West’s Yeezus and looked set to go from strength to strength. However, with fans eager for new material, no new album emerged. Instead the band have focused on projects such as documentaries, a pop-up shop selling the band’s memorabilia and an art exhibition.

The only new music from the band being two 2017 tracks in collaboration with The Weeknd. One of those tracks, Starboy, topped the Billboard Hot 100, giving the band their only US number one and confirming the remaining appetite for Daft Punk music.

Sadly, February of last year saw the band release a cryptic video featuring one robot exploding and the other walking away. Later the same day their publicist confirmed the pair had split. The reason behind the split remains as mysterious as the men behind the robot masks.


5. Captain Beefheart

Since the late Sixties, Don Van Vliet, recorded and released music under the stage name Captain Beefheart. While never a mainstream success, Beefheart enjoyed a cult following and remains a hugely influential figure thanks to albums such as Safe As Milk and Trout Mask Replica.

After a recording career stretching over a decade, Beefheart decided to make his 1982 album Ice Cream For Crow his last, deciding to focus on painting instead. While Ice Cream For Crow isn’t Don Van Vliet’s most beloved album he obviously believed himself to be operating at his peak as a musician. The Captain claimed he was retiring from music because he had become “too good at horn.” Plushe decided he could make more money from painting.

In 2003 his former backing group, The Magic Band, reformed, touring abs releasing albums to general acclaim. Their erstwhile leader opted out, continuing instead to focus on his career as a visual artist.


4. Fred Neil

While hardly a household name, singer-songwriter Fred Neil is something of a legend of New York’s Greenwich Village folk scene. Working in the famous Brill building as a songwriter for the likes of Buddy Holly and Roy Orbison. He was also co-host of a regular hootenanny at the Village’s Cafe Wha? and when Bob Dylan first arrived in the city it was Neil he was advised to seek out.

Jefferson Airplane considered Fred Neil a major influence, with both Airplane and The Lovin’ Spoonful paying tribute to him in song. Neil’s own songs, including The Dolphins and other side of life have been covered by the likes of Linda Ronstadt, Tim Buckley and Billy Bragg but he’s probably best known for Harry Nilsson’s take on his song Everybody’s Talkin’.

Nilsson’s hit version of the song won him a Grammy and was prominently featured in the film Midnight Cowboy, earning its writer millions of dollars in royalties. However, by the start of the Seventies the revered folkie had abandoned his lucrative songwriting career.

He continued to perform sporadically but only to raise money for The Dolphin Research Project, an organisation he had Co-founded with the capture, trafficking and exploitation of dolphins worldwide. He was content to step out of the spotlight but his legacy remains as a profound influence on subsequent generations of singer songwriters.


3. Cindy Birdsong

Cindy Birdsong found success in not one but two Sixties girl groups, first finding fame with Patti LaBelle and The Bluebells, appearing on hits like Down The Aisle(The Wedding Song), before jumping ship to join Diana Ross and The Supremes.

Leaving her former band mates behind caused a rift that lasted decades, but The Supremes were far and away the biggest girl group of their era.

Weirdly, Birdsong’s voice scarcely appears record for her first two and a half years as a supreme. Though Birdsong performed live with the band, Diana Ross generally relied on different backing singers in the studio. Nonetheless, publicly at least, Cindy Birdsong was one third of her generation’s Destiny’s Child.

After Ross departed the group, Birdsong’s vocals were more prominent on the band’s records and, barring a brief break to give birth to her first child, enjoyed another seven years with the group.

In 1977, frustrated with the group’s manager, it was Cindy’s turn to leave the group. She didn’t go solo or join another group at this point. Instead, she returned to her original ambition and dropped out of music entirely to work as a nurse. Not many people could make the transition from fame, success and adoring fans to helping the sick and changing bedpans.


2. Gotye

About a decade ago, Gotye’s hit Somebody That I Used To Know was everywhere, winning awards, breaking chart records and dominating radio. After slowly building up his music career for a decade, Wouter André “Wally” De Backer had a massive, breakout, worldwide hit that led to him being handed a Grammy by his hero Prince.

Then? Nothing. Or close enough. He seemed to disappear so completely that speculation began online that he had died. In 2014, via an online newsletter De Backer announced, “There will be no new Gotye music”. Though he didn’t rule out a new Gotye project in the future, so far there has been been no follow up to 2011 album Making Mirrors.

Instead De Backer has made a handful of guest vocal appearances and concentrated on drumming and singing with his pre-fame band The Basics. He has also dedicated much of his time and effort to preserving the legacy of electronic music pioneer Jean-Jacques Perrey and the early electronic instrument the ondioline.

De Backer didn’t quit music but he did seemingly quit the fame and fortune it had brought him, in favour of continuing to work as a creative artist on his own terms.


1. Bill Berry… And Then The Rest Of R.E.M.

Far from just a drummer, founding member of R.E.M Bill Berry was a multi-instrumentalist, contributing various piano, keyboard guitar and vocal parts in the studio. He was also responsible for writing some of their most captivating music, including hits like Everybody Hurts and Man On The Moon as well as fan favourites like Perfect Circle.

The band spent a decade as alternative radio darlings before breaking into the mainstream and indeed the big time, becoming the sort of band who could schedule a massive world tour to bring their big hits to the masses. But it was on that 1995 world tour that Berry collapsed after suffering an aneurysm.

Though the multi-talented sticksman made a full recovery, he took stock of his life and decided life as a hay farmer would be preferable to schlepping around the globe with his bandmates.

After Berry’s 1997 departure the band carried on for another fourteen years. Despite a subsequent commercial and creative lull, the band maintained a devoted following and most recently enjoyed critical praise for their last album, Collapse Into Now.

While they were no longer quite at their commercial or critical peak, they could easily have carried on releasing records and playing concerts around the world like some sort of alt-rock Rolling Stones. Instead, they split up, amicably, in 2011 to focus on solo projects.


Pop Music Quiz: Can You Match The Hit Song To The Singer?

Columbia

1. Who Sang The Song, Genie In A Bottle?

In this post: 
REM GOTYE
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Chris Chopping is a writer, YouTuber and stand up comedian. Check out his channel at YouTube.com/c/chrischopping. His dream job would be wrestling Manager and he’s long since stopped reading the comments section.... Follow him @MrChrisChopping on Twitter.