10 Music Videos Banned By MTV
Too much for MTV...
The '80s was the era of Reagan's America, mass consumerism, the Moonwalk, and of course MTV. The music channel revolutionised how music was consumed. It influenced record sales to no end; if you had a repeated video, you had a hit. As the '80s went on, MTV realised they needed to do more to bring in viewers, and so more and more time was given over to reality TV. Music might have been the way to market to the kids, but reality trash kept them engaged. Pretty soon it was all about ratings.
As the channel grew, programmers recognised their cultural sway had not gone unnoticed. By the time the mid '80s rolled around, musicians were having censorship stickers slapped on their records - a way to protect the fragile minds of the youth - and anyone promoting lurid or controversial content was next in the firing line.
Ratings were the main priority for MTV, no doubt a controversial video would pull in views, but it wasn't worth the wrath of Parents Music Resource Center. MTV became just as hot on censorship as anyone else. These are the videos deemed too risqué for the channel that all but spawned the art form.
As a side, due to the nature of some of these videos, you may be required to sign in with YouTube to verify your age.
10. Foo Fighters - Low (2003)
Dave Grohl has never taken the moniker of 'rock star' too seriously. His videos with Foo Fighters have always bordered on the absurd. When the group aren't indulging in their proclivity to dress in women's clothing, they're dressing like old men or attempting to safely land aircraft while inebriated.
The idea behind Low was as ridiculous as any other. Grohl originally wanted an uncut sequence of Jack Black dancing in drag, but he was persuaded to flesh the concept out, so to speak. The result was five-and-half minutes of debauched carnage. Grohl and Black played a couple of southern trucker types, shacked up with an unholy amount of booze and a healthy collection of women's clothing - all good harmless fun. Dave Grohl, in knee high stilettos is quite a sight... Cross-dressing wasn't necessarily the reason these guys got pulled off MTV, though.
As the booze flows more freely, it's pretty strongly implied that the two share a carnal desire for one another. Cross-dressing might have okay by this point, but two drunk dudes going at it, was another matter entirely.
9. Madonna - Erotica (1992)
No stranger to controversy by this point in her career, Madonna had already shocked and wowed viewers a number of times. At the MTV Music Awards in 1984, her sexually suggestive performances of Like a Virgin caused a stir. The now infamous video for Like A Prayer stirred up even more controversy, with its confused imagery of racism, sexuality and Christianity. Still, it wasn't enough bag Madonna a ban from MTV. That came later.
As the title might indicate, her 1992 single Erotica was filled with references to kink-fuelled sexuality. The video was no less suggestive. Plenty of leather whips, chains and flesh were on display as Madonna cavorted around dressed as dominatrix. Much of the B-role footage was taken from the behind the scenes of Madonna's Sex book, which showed the singer taking part in all manor of sexually charged activities. This was a far cry from the Like a Virgin Madonna of the last decade.
MTV played the video a total of three times before mounting pressure forced them to pull it. This stuff doesn't hold a candle to the kind of thing featured in music videos these days, but the '90s was a fragile time for the sexually repressed.
8. Neil Young - This Note’s For You (1988)
The '80s saw a litany of famous celebrities using their sway to help sell commercial goods. Neil Young found the practise the worst insult to musical integrity ever to be conceived. His single, This Note's For You - a parody on the Budweiser slogan "This Bud's for You" - was Young's takedown of the trend.
Besides lyrics that berated capitalism, the video contained a number of scenes that took aim at his fellow musicians. Michael Jackson was famously burned while filming a Pepsi commercial in 1984; a scene Young parodied in his video with a Jackson lookalike. Needless to say MTV's lawyers were hesitant to play the clip, claiming the likeness of Jackson may lead to liable suits. A fairly spurious idea given they were already running the "Weird Al" Yankovic parody of Bad...
Young saw this as nothing more than MTV hoping to stay on the good side of their corporate overlords. In an open letter he wrote, "MTV, you spineless twerps. You refuse to play 'This Note's For You' because you're afraid to offend your sponsors. What Does the 'M' in MTV stand for: music or money? Long live rock and roll."
MTV eventually crumbled when they realised how popular the video was, putting it on heavy rotation. It's not clear who won that one then: music or money?
7. Thirty Seconds To Mars - Hurricane (2009)
By now it's fairly well established that Jared Leto has something of an ego. For the first half of the pandemic he was sequestered at a private resort in Croatia - dressed as white Jesus, with a devoted following of fans (disciples). And, if his music videos are anything to go by, he certainly considers himself as some kind of saviour figure.
Whether he's doing battle in an imperial Chinese palace, or fighting in the Middle East, Leto's always positioned as a character whose moral compass is one we should follow - even if its not clear why. No one can ever accuse Thirty Seconds To Mars for being unambitious in their vision, but often their visions are wildly ambiguous.
Hurricane was the epitome of their pretentious endeavours into the realm of film. The 13-minute video shows the guys running around the city at night, chased by killer cyberpunks. Leto wastes no time showing off his chiseled abs, remaining shirtless for the entire video. We also get to see Leto take part in some kinky S&M scenes. The video is little more than an exercise in artsy cinematography, depicting violence and sex for the sake of it. There's a plethora of shots featuring Leto staring into the distance, as if he's figured out the answer to some unknown conundrum, the rest of us could never hope to.
Needless to say, all the ball-gags, spittle and depictions of murder were enough to get the extended version banned.
6. Queen - I Want To Break Free (1984)
Although the '80s saw hair metal musicians play around with gender-bending - to wild success on the glam metal scene - the idea of men actually dressed as women still felt uncomfortable to an American audience. Queen's arguably most famous video was too much for the fragile minds of the US population.
The group had only intended to parody British soap operas, but the connotations behind the lyrics - alluding to a man wanting to come out - coupled with Freddie Mercury in a tiny little mini skirt, just seemed like too much of an endorsement of homosexuality.
A guy with a moustache and a pair of fake breasts was enough to scare conservative parents into thinking the end times had come. It seems absurd now, but this sentiment was the reason I Want To Break Free originally performed fairly badly in the US charts. If only we could go back and show MTV's execs a few episodes of Drag Race...
5. Nine Inch Nails - Happiness Is Slavery (1992)
Nine Inch Nails are hailed as the musical project that brought industrial rock to the mainstream. Trent Reznor is one of the more unique talents in the music business. His exploration of the tortured mind has yielded tracks as hard rocking as Terrible Lie, and as tender as Hurt.
But his fixation with the darker confines of the psyche has led to the creation of some fairly disturbing pieces of art. He's never shied away from finding the most visceral visual representations for his music. Closer might be his most well known video, and it's considered to be one of his most controversial, but it pales in comparison to this.
Happiness Is Slavery was so widely criticised that it was banned outright. Even today it's hard to come by, with only the opening sequence available on YouTube. That's probably no bad thing, even the written description is enough to make you wince. The video depicts a man undergoing some ritual form of flagellation and sadomasochism. After lighting a candle in front of an alter, the protagonist strips off before strapping himself into a torture device. Mechanical arms proceed to tear the guy apart as he derives pleasure from the experience...
From the sound of it, Reznor might have gone too far on this one.
4. Twisted Sister - Be Chrool To Your Scuel (1985)
If you were a glam metal band in the '80s and your music videos didn't involve some kind of 'kicking against the pricks' sentiment, then you weren't doing your job. There was a formula to this type of video. Usually an oppressed character morphs into a given rock star. Then some authority figure is beaten down with the liberating virtues of rock and roll.
Twisted Sister's We're Not Gonna Take It (1984) was exactly that. The video was a huge success for the group; one they tried to capitalise on. They recruited Dee Snider's idol, the vampire count of rock, Alice Cooper. Blending the original concept of We're Not Gonna Take It with a take on Cooper's hit, School's Out, was sure to be a winner in their eyes.
The resulting video saw two downtrodden teachers morph into Snider and Cooper, who then attempt to liberate the zombified students from their oppressive education. The video cost a bomb. A number of expensive prosthetic techniques were used to dress dozens of extras like zombies. Unfortunately the group failed to capitalise on their endeavour, when MTV banned the video for being too gruesome. You'd think after the success of Thriller in '82 they'd be down for this kind of thing...
3. Mötley Crüe - Girls, Girls, Girls (1987)
If you want to get an idea of how debauched the '80s was, then listening Mötley Crüe is a pretty good way to start. There was just three things on their mind, girls, intoxicants and girls - laid out so eloquently in one of their best selling singles.
The song detailed the group's escapades as rock star cowboys: in place of horses they rode Harleys; in place of cattle they corralled strippers. It was all about cheap thrills and fast rides. The accompanying music video depicted the group lapping up what was on offer at one of the regular haunts, The Seventh Veil. The group preceded to get so wasted during the shoot they could barely stagger to their motorcycles after things wrapped.
The first cut submitted to MTV was outright rejected due to all the topless women parading about in every other shot. The channel refused to run it until a heavily edited version was provided - all this meant was cutting out a few nipples, however. Men dressed as women, dancing with hoovers was too much for MTV, but women dancing in thinly veiled lingerie was just fine... as long as you didn't show any areola.
2. The Prodigy - Smack My Bitch Up (1997)
It probably wont come as a surprise that this track garnered a degree of controversy when it was released. The lyrics were accused of misogyny, resulting in lyrical versions being banned from many radio stations.
The video also caused far amount of outrage; even now it's fairly difficult to find in its entirety. Filmed from a first person perspective, it chronicles a sordid night out. The protagonist starts off in their apartment, getting their buzz on with a couple whiskies and a few lines of the white stuff. They then drive (presumably while intoxicated) to a bar, where they accost several women, fight several men and take intravenous drugs in a bathroom stall. Next on the night's agenda is a strip club, where our protagonist picks up one of the dancers, takes them home and has intercourse. The video ends with the reveal that the main character was a blonde female.
All the drug use, violence and sex resulted in a further ban from most stations. MTV opted to play the video only late at night until criticism led them to ban it outright. They did, however, cash in on the video's notoriety by featuring it on one of their specials entitled Most Controversial Videos.
1. Tool - Prison Sex (1993)
Tool frontman Maynard James Keenan has never been one to steer away from controversial or difficult subject matters. In fact that's sort of his calling card. Although Keenan has never been open about whether or not he was abused as a child, he's been vocal about his distain for his stepfather. His lyrics have often made references to child abuse, rape and emotional manipulation.
Whether this track is a fictitious account or based in fact, it's a stark examination of how abuse manifests and is able to continue unchecked. The accompanying video symbolically represents the cycle of abuse. Shot entirely in stop motion, a puppet doll is shown trapped in a room. Throughout the video, it is subjected to manipulation by a strange humanoid creature. At one point the doll is left paralysed while the humanoid uses a paintbrush to probe its body. As the video continues the symbolism only becomes more troubling.
Unsurprisingly, the subject matter was deemed unsuitable for a wider audience and after MTV received a number of complaints they pulled it indefinitely.