10 Musicians That Saved Their Careers By Changing Genres
The True Musical Chameleons.
When you finally find success in music, it can be oddly restricting. As opposed to finally getting your freedom, you also start to feel the added pressure of trying to reproduce the same type of magic over and over again on each record. However, it's the risk takers who end up paying off in the long run.
Throwing caution to the wind, each of these artists managed to move outside of their respective genres and come through with great records anyway. Instead of being dead in the water, these artists used these new sounds to their advantage, turning into completely different musicians as a result of it. While the foundations of their earlier work is still accounted for, the difference in musical construct from one song to the next is almost like night and day. That didn't come without it's fair share of pushback though, with most of the core fanbase of each of these artists chastising them for daring to step out of their comfort zone.
Considering these artists are still being talked about as the greatest in their field, it's fair to say that they've had the last laugh on their critics in the end. This might not be the sound you're looking for, but it might just be the sound that you need.
10. Bruce Springsteen
Ever since making it big with Born to Run, Bruce Springsteen has certainly carved out a unique voice for himself. Being as relatable as your average Joe across the street, the way Bruce puts real life grit into his songs all but invented the heartland rock that we know and love today. You'd say that now though....not so much when he was just getting the ball rolling.
While still in the realm of rock and roll, Springsteen's early bids for the top were a lot more word-y and rambly than many would have preferred. On albums like The Wild The Innocent and The E Street Shuffle, Springsteen's real voice hadn't been fully dialed in yet. Though the actual stories are still amazing, the delivery seems to have a bit too much in common with Bob Dylan, which the critics absolutely loved.
That wasn't really a lane that Springsteen was all that comfortable with though, which led to him kicking down the door of rock and roll with Born to Run, bringing with him an added sense of drama and some of the greatest stand alone stories condensed into just a few minutes. Even though his first records were beautiful for what they were, it took a bit more effort before Springsteen was actually appointed to the Boss.
9. The Strokes
Few rock bands can really find too much wrong with having a great debut album. Given that most first efforts can seem to be a bit rough around the edges, the fact that you are able to make it work on your first try is the stuff of miracles. Then again, it can also become an albatross around your neck sometimes.
Ever since their first record Is This It, The Strokes were almost constricted into being the same garage rock revival band that they were known to be. While Room on Fire was more of the same schtick, you could tell that these New York kids were trying to flex their muscles a little more, so much so that Julian Casablancas would flex his chops on a Daft Punk record to dust out the cobwebs. After careful consideration though, the Strokes found the best way to top Is This It: make the polar opposite of a Strokes record.
Across their latest record The New Abnormal, The Strokes' way of slowly picking away at their sound led to their greatest songs since the debut, from the '80s pastiche Bad Decisions to the mammoth jam Eternal Summer. For as much time as it may have taken, the Strokes can never really be faulted as being a one trick pony anymore.
8. Red Hot Chili Peppers
From day one, funk rock has been the bread and butter for the Red Hot Chili Peppers. Long before the days of their big MTV hits, the sounds of records like the Uplift Mofo Party Plan is what something like Parliament Funkadelic would have sounded like had they been reborn as a punk outfit. Even though the energy may have stayed the same, the Peppers' rise to the top has made for some drastic changes.
As much as albums like Blood Sugar Sex Magik sent them into the stratosphere, the first move towards something accessible ended up coming at the expense of Hillel Slovak, who died of a drug overdose after their third album. Although there was nothing inherently wrong with Slovak's funky melodic side, the inclusion of John Frusciante into the mix gave us some of the most memorable guitar parts in the Peppers' catalog like Under the Bridge and Give It Away.
Since then, the Peppers have carved out some more elaborate melodic material than most people originally gave them credit for, going from funk to classic rock to full on metal, sometimes within the span of a single song like in Around the World. Instead of just sampling one kickass genre like in their heyday, the Peppers decided it was more fun to bring everything into an elaborate musical stew.
7. My Chemical Romance
It would surprise absolutely no one to think of My Chemical Romance as one of the more campy bands of the '00s on first glance. Along with their first album I Brought You My Bullets, most of MCR's early catalog had more to do with the emo mindset than fleshing out the actual music. While it might have sounded sophomoric then, no one could have predicted the amount of raw talent on display here.
Starting with Three Cheers, MCR started to morph into something a lot more accessible for your average rock fan, dabbling into melodic material that was indebted as much to the Beatles as it was to the Cure and even the Germs. Once the Black Parade came out though, the entire band went nuclear, with every single instrument brought to its loudest conclusion. Chronicling a rock opera of sorts, the added sense of dramatic heft brought into something like Welcome to the Black Parade and I Don't Love You is like night and day compared to their earlier stuff.
Regardless of the amount of eyeliner donned on at any one time, no one can argue with the amount of solid hooks that MCR had until their inevitable breakup at the start of the 2010's. Seeing how they're coming back on the road again in the near future, here's hoping that that same creative ingenuity hasn't weathered after all these years.
6. David Bowie
It almost feels unfair to say that David Bowie changed genres throughout the duration of his career. Compared to other artists who tend to find their own niche, Bowie practically made a career out of taking any genre that would suit him and turning it into solid gold. However, if we're breaking down the Bowie that most of us now and love, it tends to come back to glam rock.
Aside from his vaudevilian leanings at the start of his career, the true rise of the Starman in the early days came from his androgynous side, which culminated in characters like Ziggy Stardust and Aladdin Sane. Much like his personas though, Bowie was never meant to stay in that lane for much longer. After a brief experimentation with soul music, Bowie's first big move between genres was working with Brian Eno, bringing in lush soundscapes and almost robotic sounding riffs for his album Station to Station. Going further with Low and Heroes, Bowie's artful side made for the beginnings of what would become post rock along with the art rock coming down the pipeline with acts like Talking Heads.
That's before you even get to his later period, which runs the gamut from dance rock, industrial, electronic, and even jazzy territory on his final album Blackstar. Instead of having to morph the genre to suit his songwriting, David Bowie was the true essence of what makes a good musical chameleon.
5. Paramore
Towards the mid '00s, the idea of you not having some sort of pop punk edge to your sound was virtually unheard of. Unless you were deliberately trying to streamline your sound like the White Stripes, the heavier side of things coming out of the nu metal movement had started to fade from view. Aside from a few heavier moments though, Paramore always had a more radio friendly style to their sound.
On the first record All We Know is Falling, it's clear that this is a more punk led affair, down to the screaming vocals that take place on the back half of the record. As we started inching closer to Brand New Eyes though, something strange started to unfold. Letting go of some members in the process, the resulting album was a lot more pop-friendly, albeit with some punk edge on songs like All I Wanted and Ignorance. From there, the gamble of making hooks resulted in some of the greatest moments of Paramore's career.
On both their self-titled effort as well as After Laughter, Paramore has turned themselves into a full-blown pop affair, almost ditching the grittier side of their sound altogether. While some might cry sell out, Hayley William's natural register feels much more at home in this style, almost akin to something that an act like Tegan and Sara would do. It may have taken its sweet time to transition, but this slow burn has done Paramore a lot of favors in recent years.
4. The Who
It's hard to look back and think of the Who as anything but disposable in the early days. Compared to the more established on the scene like the Beatles and the Stones, Pete Townshend's knack for songwriting seemed to just be the traditional Mod rock, only played at punishingly loud volumes. Though the sheer force of the music may have moved the people, the interesting part was how much Townshend's songwriting chops carried them.
Looking at the big picture of rock music, Townshend envisioned making something that could hit the audience on a much more visceral level than the 3 minute single. Stringing together bits and pieces on albums like A Quick One and Rael, Townshend eventually molded bold new stories into his albums, from the story of Tommy to the down on his luck Mod kid of Quadrophenia. While they may have seemed outlandish for their time, this was the beginning of a much different kind of music.
Although he wasn't the first one to include stories in his songs, these albums would become known as the first true rock operas, giving way to even more groundbreaking work later down the line like Pink Floyd's the Wall and Queensryche's Operation Mindcrime. Considering that Townshend never expected the Who to last that long, it's safe to say that he's created something a bit bigger than he thought.
3. Radiohead
When bands decide to change their sound, it normally comes after years of deciding what to do. No matter how much you might feel stagnant playing the same thing over and over again, the idea of changing up your style has to take time to gestate before becoming the norm. Or if you're Radiohead, just dive head first into the new genre and come out with a hit anyways.
Despite being pegged as one hit wonders at the beginning of the decade, Radiohead's '90s run yielded them as the saviors of rock and roll, with Thom Yorke being the next rock god. After OK Computer left fans speechless though, Yorke's vision for the future was to erase everything that they had been working towards for the past decade. Going into the recording of Kid A, almost everything changed, from the replacement of guitars with synthesizers and an overall more icy approach to songcrafting.
While sounding absolutely dreadful from a marketing standpoint, Kid A turned into the colossal second wind by planting a line in the sand for their fans. From the opening strains of Everything In Its Right Place, Radiohead gave a worthy send off to their old work all while reinventing what they would sound like down the road like on In Rainbows and A Moon Shaped Pool. Thom Yorke probably could have made a thousand more OK Computers at this point, but we would probably be worse off for it if it meant abandoning these gems.
2. Metallica
The transition from Metallica into the world of rock and roll seemed to come out of left field at first. After years of turning the metal world inside out with albums like And Justice For All and Master of Puppets, why would these titans bother with making songs for the radio? Even though simplicity may have been a dirty word, rarely do you get metal that sounds as tight as the Black Album.
Up until that point, Metallica's career trajectory had been about trying to out-heavy everyone else around them, whether it be from the NWOBHM bands or the new thrash scene coming to fruition underneath the surface. While And Justice for All was a hardened metal release, you could tell that there was only so much further you could go with that. With the release of the Black Album, Bob Rock's production brought everything up a notch, daring them to make more melodic material alongside the heavier riffs.
While the amazing thrash riffs are still accounted for on this record, Rock's touch is everything great about Metallica turned up to 10, whether it be the plaintive ballads coming through on the Unforgiven or the blunt force smack that comes from Sad But True. Granted, this may have been a mixed blessing going into the Load/ReLoad projects, but as it stands, The Black Album is the reason why Metallica is still known as legends to this day.
1. Green Day
There was a certain generation of rock listeners who really needed something like Green Day's Dookie in the mid '90s. While still being very much a product of its time, this pop punk juggernaut was a refreshing alternative to the morose songwriting coming from acts like Nirvana and Pearl Jam a few years prior. As time went on though, you start to wonder whether that three chord punk has diminishing returns.
Though records like Insomniac and Nimrod had their more adventurous moments, Green Day's star seemed to wane when other acts like Blink-182 started to reach for the pop punk crown. Instead of just doubling down on what made them great in the first place, Billie Joe Armstrong stepped into the big leagues of songwriting with American Idiot, proving that they were more than just your regular power pop act. Going full experimental, the entire record reinvented Green Day from the ground up, being a rock opera about living in post 9/11 America.
Becoming one of the biggest global smashes of the '00s, Green Day turned into one of those rare acts that managed to actually have a second wind, going so far as to double down on the operatic style on 21st Century Breakdown. For as juvenile as the pop punk sound may seem at the best of times, Green Day proved that even when the punk kids grew up, the music could still kick ass.