10 Musicians Who Almost Joined The Wrong Band

Slash's replacement in Guns N Roses was almost INCREDIBLE!

Guns N Roses Zakk Wylde
WC

It's always a hard road for rock musicians when they're starting out. As musicians cut their teeth, they usually find themselves floating from one act to another until they hit on the right group of people. Though things tend to fall into place for these legendary bands, there are many occasions where history could have been written very differently.

Whether it was at a turning point in the band's career or trying to hit upon the right lineup at the band's inception, many legendary performers missed out on opportunities to be in fantastic groups. Thankfully, these musicians in question don't have to lose sleep at night since most of them landed on their feet with their own successful groups.

It's never an easy decision dealing with rejection in a band, but these musicians were not only able to take it in stride, but also build a musical legacy of their own without having to compromise to another band's vision. Even if we may never here what these musical incarnations may have sounded like, the idea of these groups having another musical legend among their ranks has fueled fan speculation for decades.

10. Eric Clapton - The Beatles

As the 60's were coming to a close, The Beatles were not in a great place as musical collaborators. In an attempt to get the band back to their roots, Paul McCartney hit upon the idea of making their next movie about them creating their next record. From the start, the film captured some of the most raw-nerved footage of the Fabs.

One particular session was so bad that George Harrison abruptly quit and walked out, casually remarking "See you round the clubs." With Harrison MIA, John Lennon's bitter retort to the rest of the band was "If he's not back in the next week, we'll just get Clapton." Guitarist Eric Clapton had been a good friend of the band's and a collaborator on Harrison's earlier song "While my Guitar Gently Weeps."

Before Clapton's services were required, Harrison returned to the fold and the band washed their hands of the film project, which would later become the Let It Be album and movie. Even Clapton today laughs at the idea of being a Beatle, knowing that the group's aura of four minds working together would never be the same if he was in the fold. After reconciling, the Beatles hunkered down and created Abbey Road, capping off one of the most perfect careers in modern music.


9. Dimebag Darrell - Megadeth

With over 30 years of hindsight, it's no secret that the drum and lead guitarist spot in Megadeth is like a game of musical chairs for metal musicians. After releasing their third album So Far So Good So What, Dave Mustaine decided he needed some new blood in the band to replace star guitarist Jeff Young.

Mustaine's search ultimately led him to Texas, where he was impressed by Darrell Abbott, not yet known as Dimebag. Darrell was ecstastic when offered the job, but agreed to join on one condition: his brother Vinnie Paul join with him on drums. Since Mustaine had already hired new drummer Nick Menza for the band's next project, Darrell ultimately stepped out and agreed to stay in a band with his brother.

In losing a potential guitar hero, Mustaine found further success with Marty Friedman, whose licks on Rust in Peace were absolutely stunning. Back in Texas, Darrell and Vinnie quickly found their main man in Phil Anselmo, with whom they revolutionized the metal landscape on the Pantera albums Cowboys from Hell and Vulgar Display of Power. Even if it seems like metal history could have been something spectacular with this team-up, maybe things ended up exactly where they were supposed to.


8. Corey Taylor - Velvet Revolver

Sick and tired of the rockstar antics of Axl Rose, ex-GNR members Slash, Duff McKagan, and Matt Sorum formed a new band with Stone Temple Pilots frontman Scott Weiland with Velvet Revolver. While the initial creative process was fruitful, the band saw some of the same trappings of Rose's antics manifesting in Weiland.

After their second release, the band parted ways with Weiland and began searching for other singers. Among other rock heavyweights like the Cult's Ian Astbury, Slipknot's Corey Taylor was one of the few singers who was flown down to collaborate with the group on a few jam sessions. Even though the ideas seemed to have enormous potential, the band quickly dissolved with Slash embarking on a solo career and Duff making his own music with his band Loaded.

With Slash and Duff now back in GNR, it's anybody's guess as to what will come of Velvet Revolver. Though the demos still exist in their primitive state, it is unclear whether the hard rock pubic will ever hear what Velvet Revolver could have sounded like with Taylor at the helm. However, Slash has spoken that the band has some unfinished business to tend to, so maybe a new incarnation of the band could manifest itself after all.


7. Zakk Wylde - Guns N Roses

The Mid 90's for Guns N Roses was a chaotic haze of ego for almost everyone involved. With Axl Rose leading the group with an iron hand, almost every original member jumped ship before the inevitable crash. Once star guitarist Slash walked out on the band, Rose wanted to find an equally competent guitarist to replace him.

Instead of trying to find an ideal candidate, Rose was looking for star power and got in touch with Ozzy Osbourne's six-stringed maniac Zakk Wylde to come down for a jam session. While Wylde has gone on to say that he had a lot of fun jamming with the band, much of the collaborations were no more than vague sketches at the time. By the time Wylde's services with the Prince of Darkness were required once again, Axl's stalling caused Zakk to quickly go back to his main gig.

Ironically enough, Wylde would strike out on his own with Black Label Society a few years down the road, leaving some to question why Guns N Roses couldn't call upon his guitar fireworks once again. While GNR fans had to wait many more years to get any new material from the band, an incarnation of the band with Zakk Wylde remains a fleeting fantasy for hard rockers.


6. Les Claypool - Metallica

Metal fans across the world were absolutely gutted when the tragic report of bassist Cliff Burton's death in a bus accident was announced. Burton's style of bass playing fit in so perfectly with Metallica's headbanging tunes and would be impossible to replicate.

When the band got together back in the States to attend the funeral, they immediately began the search for a new bass player. In their searches, one of the names that singer James Hetfield remembers standing out was Les Claypool, whose insane fretwork was unlike anything the band had seen.

However, when it came time for the band to jam, the different playing styles clashed drastically as the others struggled to find a footing behind Claypool's signature tone. After discussing it, the band broke the news to Claypool that although they loved his playing, it wasn't a great fit for what Metallica would be doing going forward.

With each party going their separate ways, Claypool bounced back with his own outfit Primus, whose zany form of prog and hard rock blew minds in the 90's alternative scene. Meanwhile, Metallica's desperate search for bassists finally came to an end when they acquired Jason Newsted, a lifelong Metallica fan who worked with the band to reach great heights with And Justice for All and The Black Album.


5. Joe Satriani - Deep Purple

Though Deep Purple are known as one of the greatest bands in hard rock, their ability to keep a lineup together had plagued them since their inception. However, things seemed to be turning a corner as the 80's rolled around, with classic members Ian Gillan, Roger Glover, Ian Paice, Richie Blackmore, and Jon Lord joining forces once again. Then again, old habits tend to always flair up.

As the band were in prime form for the better part of a decade, growing tensions in the group reached a high yet again on the touring cycle for the band's 1993 release The Battle Rages On. After a show in Finland, Blackmore packed up his guitar and left the band for good, leaving the band with scheduled dates and no guitarist.

In a brilliant display of damage control, the band brought in guitar virtuoso Joe Satriani to fill on the last run of dates through Japan and Europe. While the door was open for Satriani to come on permanently, his commitment to his record label prevented him from working with the band in any other professional capacity. Even though Deep Purple picked up guitar technician Steve Morse, the days of Satriani as a potential guitarist for Purple cannot be forgotten.


4. Mark Storace - AC/DC

AC/DC's loss of Bon Scott was one of the heaviest blows they could have been dealt. Not only had Scott had an undeniable charisma and snarl, but he was also a key contributor to every song the band had penned.

Determined not to let the band die with him, brothers Angus and Malcolm Young promptly searched for singers to fill the spot that Bon had left vacant. Their first choice for a singer was Mark Storace, who was making waves in the hard rock scene with the band Krokus. In a shocking turn of events, Storace outright refused to collaborate with the Young brothers, thinking that he would fare better with his home band.

While this may seem like a strange move in hindsight, Storace explained later that the idea of AC/DC having a future without Bon Scott seemed absolutely ridiculous at the time. Add to that the fact that Krokus was finally seeing success and you really start to understand Storace's logic.

As we all know, the band quickly found a replacement for Scott in screamer Brian Johnson, with whom they created the ultimate comeback album in Back in Black. Though AC/DC went from strength to strength after Scott's death, the future of the band with Mark Storace is now lost to history.


3. Keith Moon - Led Zeppelin

After quickly getting fed up with the straight-ahead blues system of the Yardbirds, guitarist Jimmy Page left the band to start a project of his own. What Page envisioned for this new group was still bluesy, but had a more hard-rock tinge to its sound.

As Page scoured the local scene for potential bandmates, he reached out to legendary rock drummer Keith Moon. Once getting in contact, Page told Moon about the new project's plans of being a revamped blues outfit that was tentatively being called the New Yardbirds.

Being the smart ass he was, Moon was quite content with the Who and jokingly told Page that his idea had as much potential as a balloon made of metal...a lead zeppelin, if you will. Taking it in stride, Page knicked Moon's jab for the band name and quickly found a true drumming beast in John Bonham.

Once the band was rounded out by session player John Paul Jones and blues belter Robert Plant, the chemistry in the room was undeniable. The band quickly got to work on their first album, where they began to define what became known as hard rock. Though the Who and Led Zeppelin have both attained legendary status, the idea of a supergroup with members of both bands is still surreal to think about.


2. Slash - Poison

As the glam rock movement reached maximum capacity, Poison were the most straight ahead glam band of them all, whose songs were full of pop hooks rather than metallic aggression. Moving to LA from Pennsylvania, the band were dealt a bit of bad luck when guitarist Matt Smith decided to travel back East.

In searching for a band, guitarist Saul Hudson (not yet known as Slash) auditioned for the open guitarist slot. While Slash affirmed that he nailed the audition, he was not completely sold on the glam look the band was cultivating. According to the guitarist, everything was going smooth but then he started to get confused when the conversation shifted from music to what shoes the band were supposed to wear onstage.

Looking at the moccasins on his feet, Slash left the audition knowing that his fashion sense would not sit well in the Poison aesthetic. As he headed out the door, guitarist CC Deville was next in line dressed to impress, which led him to eventually snag the gig as Poison's six-stringer. Luckily, Slash's rejection led him to Guns N Roses, whose straight-ahead approach to rock and roll was about to flip the glam rock scene on its head.


1. Dave Grohl - Tom Petty

By the time Kurt Cobain took his own life in April of 1994, Dave Grohl did not want to be a part of the music business anymore. In an attempt to run away from his pain, Grohl traveled through Greece only to find grim reminders all around him.

After returning to the States, he started cutting demos when he got a call from Tom Petty asking if he could play drums with the Heartbreakers on Saturday Night Live. The shows went off so well that Petty offered Grohl the job of permanent drummer if he wanted it. Though everyone was in good spirits, keyboardist Benmont Tench listened to the demos Grohl had been carrying with him and encouraged him to pursue that sound.

Caught between a rock and a hard place, Grohl finished his demo tape and had to make the decision of playing drums for a legend or create a new project from the ground up. Throwing caution to the wind, Grohl called up Petty, politely declined his invitation, and went on to produce what would become the Foo Fighters' debut album. While being the power behind Nirvana and the heart of the Foos, it doesn't hurt for Grohl to have the title of Honorary Heartbreaker.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Guns N' Roses
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97