10 Musicians Who Hate Their Own Songs

Liam Gallagher absolutely despises Wonderwall.

Madonna Like A Virgin
Epic

Have you ever heard a certain song so many times that you ended up absolutely sick of it? A song that you maybe once loved, but now you get triggered with anger every time it comes up on the radio? Now imagine that you actually wrote that song.

Artists are funny creatures, aren’t they? They’re the only people that can create something that is loved by millions of people around the world and that brings them incredible fame and fortune, and STILL absolutely hate it.

That is the case with the ten musicians featured in this list. All of them have written and performed songs that became smash hits and were loved by almost everyone…except for them. Some of them didn’t like the songs to begin with, or grew to hate them because they were overplayed, while others resented that their words got misinterpreted and became symbols of the very ideas they set out to make fun of.

Whatever their individual reasons might be, one thing is for sure: do not go to these artists’ concerts and expect them to play those songs.

10. The Beastie Boys - (You Gotta) Fight For Your Right (To Party!)

A couple of years ago, The Beastie Boys released a documentary called Beastie Boys Story, and one of the things that got mentioned there is how much the rap group hate their first big hit song.

(You Gotta) Fight for Your Right (To Party!) was the fourth single to be released from their classic 1986 debut album License to Ill, and it was really the first track to get them significant exposure on MTV and the entry point to the group's music for a lot of people.

The song was written as a sarcastic parody of the partying lifestyle and of songs that celebrate it, but it got terribly misinterpreted and adopted as an anthem by the very people it was supposed to be mocking.

"The only thing that upsets me", said Mike D, "is that we might have reinforced certain values of some people in our audience when our own values were actually totally different. There were tons of guys singing along to Fight for Your Right who were oblivious to the fact it was a total goof on them."

You could say that Fight for Your Right became the very thing it swore to destroy.


9. Miley Cyrus - Party In The USA

Miley Cyrus first recorded Party In the USA for her debut EP titled The Time of Our Lives in 2009, when she was just 17 years old. The track, which was originally written by Jessie J and intended for her to perform, was later released as a single and became a massive hit.

Now, I think we would all agree that the things we do at 17 do not define us as a person for the rest of our lives. But when your entire life and career are under the spotlight, some of those early impressions are difficult to shake off.

Cyrus began to dislike the song's bubblegum pop sound, saying that's not what she wants her voice to sound like.

"I can never say that I don’t love Party in the USA", she explained in an interview with V Magazine in 2013, "and that I’m not appreciative of it. But that’s not who I am, that’s not where I want to sing, that’s not what I want to sing."

Looking at how her career has developed from there, it's admirable how much she was able to evolve as an artist and escape the labels that were attached to her in her teenage years.


8. R.E.M. - Shiny Happy People

When R.E.M. released their 1991 landmark record Out of Time, they reached a level of success and popularity that was previously foreign to them. The alternative rock classic was packed with great songs, and one of the most iconic and recognisable is certainly Shiny Happy People.

Apparently, the track was originally written as a dry satire of the Chinese government's propaganda after the Tiananmen Square protests, but its intended irony completely missed the mark. The song's cheerfulness was taken as genuine by a lot of people, and the message was not coming across.

Frontman Michael Stipe was not happy with how Shiny Happy People turned out, describing it as "a fruity pop song written for children" and flat out refusing to include it on their greatest hits album.

In a 2016 interview with The Sun, he elaborated: "I don't want it to be the song R.E.M. are remembered by in 100 years' time, but it should be recognized as one of our minor hits."

I think it's safe to say that Stipe doesn't consider the song as one of the band's shiniest moments.


7. Lorde - Royals

Artists hating their early work seems to be somewhat of a recurring theme in this list. Lorde's debut single Royals took the pop world by storm in 2013, garnering widespread critical acclaim, shooting up the charts, and launching Lorde's career into the stratosphere.

It is still remembered as one of the finest tracks to come out that year, but the singer herself does not remember it that fondly, going as far as to compare it to a "ringtone from a 2006 Nokia". Can you imagine your old Nokia 3310 vibrating to that smooth hip hop beat... in polyphonic.

"I listen to people covering the song and putting their own spin on it — and I listen to it in every single form except the original one I put out — and I realize that actually it sounds horrible," she said while talking to the Daily Record. "None of the melodies are good. It's disastrous. Awful."

That is some harsh self-criticism, and she should probably go a bit easier on herself. After all, she was only seventeen when she recorded Royals. What were the rest of us doing at 17?


6. Madonna - Like A Virgin

The list of her own songs that Madonna can't stand is a pretty long one, but it is somewhat understandable given her massive back catalogue. God only knows how many times she's turned on the radio in her car or walked into a grocery store only to hear her own voice blasting out of the speakers.

While she's on the record saying that she hates songs such as Material Girl and Holiday, for the purpose of this list we are choosing one of her biggest early hits -- Like a Virgin. The 1984 hit became Madonna's first number-one song in many countries (including the United States), selling over six million copies worldwide and establishing the singer as a pop superstar.

It was truly a defining moment in Madonna's career, but she is not so keen to look back on it. This just seems to be a classic case of an artist getting absolutely tired of hearing one of their songs too many times and ending up hating it.

In a 2008 radio interview, she stated: "I just can't [sing it] unless somebody paid me, like, $30 million or something." To be fair, there probably are people in the world who would pay her that much just to hear her perform it.


5. Led Zeppelin - Stairway To Heaven

Stairway to Heaven might just be the most famous song in all of rock, and its history has no shortage of controversies, from allegations of hidden satanic messages to copyright lawsuits by bands claiming it was plagiarised.

All that aside, it still stands as one of the most iconic and greatest rock songs of all time... unless you ask Robert Plant. His disdain for the 1971 classic is well-documented and it has often brought him into disagreements with his bandmates. He simply did not want to perform it live anymore.

"I'd break out in hives if I had to sing that song in every show," Plant said to the New York Post in 1988. "I wrote those lyrics and found that song to be of some importance and consequence in 1971, but 17 years later, I don't know. It's just not for me."

Okay, Robert, we really don't want you to break out into hives.

He always praised the instrumental part of the song, but he would never really connect to the lyrics again. However, he did perform it once in 1988 at the anniversary of Atlantic Records, and then again in 2007 for Led Zeppelin's reunion concert, if only to appease the fans.


4. Nirvana - Smells Like Teen Spirit

If it's in any band's nature to hate their most successful song, then it's certainly Nirvana. Their anti-commercial ethos was at odds with Smells Like Teen Spirit's incredible popularity and it made performing it live uneasy for their legendary frontman.

"Everyone has focused on that song so much," Kurt Cobain said to Rolling Stone magazine in 1994 after they explicitly asked him why the band ended their performance without Teen Spirit in their setlist.

"The reason it gets a big reaction is people have seen it on MTV a million times. But I think there are so many other songs that I've written that are as good, if not better. I can barely, especially on a bad night, get through Teen Spirit. I literally want to throw my guitar down and walk away.”

What started as one of Cobain's favourites was eventually ruined for him by too much mainstream exposure. He felt like there was more to him and the band than that one song, and ultimately he was right about the fact that he has written many songs that are just as good. However, Teen Spirit still remains as one of Nirvana's, and rock's, most iconic and important songs.


3. Kanye West - Gold Digger

This entry is different from all the others on the list, in the sense that the artist never liked the song, to begin with.

While the other musicians wrote the respective songs for mostly genuine reasons, Kanye West wrote Gold Digger specifically because he knew it would bring him money and success.

"I never really liked that song, but I knew I would get paid for doing Gold Digger", he told Zane Lowe in an interview for BBC Radio in 2013. And he was definitely right, because the song went on to become one of his biggest hits, breaking download records and helping him win two Grammy Awards in 2006.

Interestingly enough, Kanye first wrote the song from a woman's point of view and it was supposed to be performed by rapper Shawnna and included on her 2004 debut record Worth Tha Weight. She eventually declined to use it, so Ye adapted the lyrics and added it to Late Registration, his sophomore album that came out a year later.

Kanye has maintained that the track doesn't suit his style and he barely ever performs it in his live shows. Now, I ain't saying he's a gold digger, but he clearly wrote the song just to make money.


2. Oasis - Wonderwall

Wonderwall is Oasis' arguably most well-known song, at least when it comes to American audiences. It was the single that really broke them across the pond and made them global rock gods. To this day, (What’s the Story) Morning Glory? remains a cultural touchstone and remarkably timeless piece of music, and Wonderwall deserves a lot of credit for that.

With that in mind, you'd think the band would love it, right? But things are never that simple with the Gallagher brothers. Liam has said that it "makes him want to gag" every time he has to perform it live and it seems to be the only thing he hates more than his own brother.

This is what he had to say about it during a promotional interview for Dig Out Your Soul, the band's final album (so far!): "Problem is, it was a big, big tune for us. You go to America and they’re like, ‘Are you Mr Wonderwall?’ You want to chin someone.”

Ah, Liam. Always so charming and measured. Clearly, it's not so much the song itself that irritates Gallagher, as the fact that it became so synonymous with the band and himself, almost like it's the only good one they've ever made. And that, of course, is far from being the case.


1. Radiohead - Creep

This is probably the most famous case of a band having nothing but disdain for one of their own songs. Thom Yorke and co's feelings on Creep have been anything but secret, with the band unofficially renaming the song 'Crap' among themselves.

While most fans are in on it, there are those who genuinely love the song, and one of those was attending Radiohead's concert in Montreal in the mid-2000s. When they requested to hear Creep, they were met with a stern “F**k off, we’re tired of it" from Yorke. Now that's a great concert-going experience!

Creep was officially released as a single in 1992, and it quickly exploded in popularity, making the Oxfordshire band overnight sensations. However, they quickly grew tired of it and by 1998 it was all but gone from their setlists.

"It was frustrating, being judged on just that song when we felt we needed to move on," Yorke said. "We were forced on tour to support it, and it gagged us, really. We were on the verge of breaking up."

In recent few years, the band seem to have softened and now they occasionally play it live. At times, it almost seems like they are playing it ironically, with the audience and the band both being in on the joke and enjoying themselves.


Radiohead Quiz: How Well Do You Know Thom Yorke?

thom yorke drowning
XL Recordings

1. Which Radiohead Song Is Inspired By Thom Yorke’s Car Cash?

Contributor
Contributor

Big fan of TV shows, music, and indie films. Gets too emotional when watching football. Secretly thinks he could run a Premier League club based only on his time spent playing Football Manager.