10 Musicians Whose Careers Were Destroyed By Just One Song
The lyrics that went too far, videos no one wanted to see, and flat-earth rapping...
WhatCulture recently ran a list of musicians whose entire careers, in some cases decades-long success stories, were derailed by one bad album. But not every artist is one terrible CD from sliding into infamy or obscurity.
After all, sometimes it doesn’t even take a FULL flopped record to end a career.
Sometimes it’s as simple as one bad track, with a few minutes of terrible misjudgement putting an end to an entire career in a matter of minutes.
Some of the songs on this list are perfectly good, and not what fans wanted from the band. Some are so atrocious it’s hard to imagine the artists recording them wanted anything to do with the finished product.
But whether it’s a too-ambitious overlong dirge that alienates fans, a tasteless lyric that leaves listeners cringing, or a misunderstood classics that the masses simple weren’t ready for, this follow-up to our recent run-down of disastrous albums which derailed artist's entire careers is here to list spotlight the songs so maligned they put an end to the potential success of their creators.
Whatever did become of that comedy rapper from LMFAO?
10. UOENO — Rick Ross
As rap fans can attest, there was a period circa 2010-2014 when Rick Ross was everywhere.
The Maybach Music Group rapper seemed all but unstoppable, racking up a string of massive hits with his albums Teflon Don and God Forgives, I Don’t. Glitzy over-the-top records, the albums and their many hits saw Ross’ larger-than-life persona merge the corny excess of glam rap with the ludicrous braggadocio of gangsta rap, reviving both sub genres at once.
The BMF rapper was near the top of the rap pantheon. Amongst the most broadly popular performers in the genre, Ross looked set to become a mainstream hitmaker alongside the likes of TI and Future, a name as recognizable to casual music fans as the likes of Kanye, Lil Wayne, and Jay Z.
Then he dropped UOENO.
A hit in 2013, the song brought together artists across Ross’ MMG label to rap about sex, drugs, clubbing… and in Ross’ verse, to make a glaringly tasteless reference to date rape. Whilst Ross later apologized for reference “slipping molly” into his date’s champagne, the damage was done. Clothing label Reebook soon dropped his endorsement, and the rapper never returned to his 2013 heights in the years since.
9. Karate Chop — Lil Wayne
At the height of his powers, there were few lines that New Orleans/ Greatest Rapper Alive candidate Lil Wayne couldn’t get away with. The rapper’s rapid fire delivery, as well as his strange sense of humour and often dark non-sequitors, left listeners ready for surreal bars that matched Eminem’s intense obscenity, Nas’ thoughtful introspection, and Andre 3000’s trippy invention.
Unfortunately, the height of his powers didn’t last forever.
After the failure of his rock album Rebirth Wayne never recovered his position as a leading voice in mainstream rap. Meanwhile, health issues alongside addiction and personal problems saw the quality, if not the quantity, of his lyrical output drop off.
The ignominious end came in 2014, during a brief feature verse on then-rising star Future’s Karate Chop. The Atlanta legend acquiring a Wayne feature was impressive even long after his prime, but few listeners recalled the song fondly due to one ill-judged lyric.
Weezy was far from able to pull off a shockingly misjudged line (which won’t be repeated here) that mocked the murder of Emmett Till, a disturbingly visceral “joke” that appalled long-time fans and casual listeners alike. The backlash was immediate and deservedly intense, and added another nail to the coffin of Weezy F’s once unstoppable career.
8. Literally I Can’t — Redfoo
Remember LMFAO?
Some party music can withstand the test of time, and its messy charm hides the plentiful potential in the later careers of its creators (shout out to the Beastie Boys, Cyndi Lauper, the Red Hot Chili Peppers, etc).
Some party music is a fun dumb time, and that’s all it will ever need to be (shout out to Iglu and Hartly and the always-underrated 3Oh!3).
And some party music is so intensely annoying, so intentionally depthless and uninvolving, that it almost seems like the creators want you to hate it.
That’s where Miami sort-of-EDM, sort-of-hip-hop, “party rock” creators LMFAO come in.
(Okay Party Rock Anthem is maybe great, but only because it features in the dumb fun classic 21 Jump Street).
Composed bizarrely of a nephew/ uncle duo, this pair won over partygoers and no one else with a string of “satirically” stupid hits from 2009-2012. It’s impressive that the pair never attempted to be taken seriously, but their music nonetheless straddled the line between annoyingly catchy and annoying… Until 2014.
Split off from his bandmate, LMFAO party rocker Redfoo lost the crowd with Literally I Can’t, an unfunny and terminally un-catchy track from 2014. Widely derided as charmless, sexist, and utterly outdated upon release, the song saw its artist fast-track his way into obscurity as he attempted to defend its cringeworthy “humour” and embarrassing “message”.
7. White Privilege II — Macklemore
The writing was really on the wall for this one the moment that Macklemore beat Kendrick Lamar for Best Hip Hop Album at the Grammys, then proceeded to text him and apologise for the travesty.
Beloved by indie hip hop fans for much of the noughties, Macklemore was a hard-to-categorise rapper best described as the human embodiment of Internet culture from 2010-2013.
Sincere and well-meaning, childish in his humour but often surprisingly thoughtful if ham-fisted in his lyrics, the technically superb rapper had a string of wildly different cult hits from 2011-2014. Thrift Shop was a goofy self-parody slice of pop rap, Can’t Hols Us was an anthemic club banger, and Same Love was a corny but good-meaning attempt at LGBTQ+ ally-ship.
But it had to end eventually.
The too-sincere rapper released White Privilege II in 2016, and the well-meaning but tragically overlong and cringeworthy track it spelled the end of his brief tenure as a massive mainstream rapper. Needlessly lengthy and overstuffed, the song attempted to be a hard-hitting critique but ended up a limp softball, and the hip hop community’s derisive reaction landed the rapper an impossible-to-shift reputation as a cornball.
6. I Want To Break Free — Queen
Okay let’s get one thing clear, Queen’s career never really ended. One of the world’s best-selling bands and often rightly named one of its greatest, the glam rock icons enjoyed tremendous success in their lifetime and even more posthumous acclaim after the death of their iconic frontman.
But…
Although vocal titan/ walking embodiment of charisma Freddy Mercury and his band never entirely lost their careers and remained well-loved even after his untimely death, they were dealt a crushing blow by the release of I Want to Break Free.
Coming hot on the heels of the band’s early success in the states, American television’s wholesale refusal to broadcast the music video for I Want to Break Free limited their international success and hastened the band’s unofficial break up. Unfamiliar with the culturally specific soaps being spoofed (and just broadly culturally homophobic at the time), US censors couldn’t get past the video’s cross-dressing content.
And so it was that, much like a certain pyjama-clad singer later in this list, Queen’s potential success was doomed by an ill-fated promo lacking sufficient machismo. If only a loveable slacker and his mates could revive interest in the band with a backseat karaoke rendition of Bohemian Rhapsody…
5. Get Her Back — Robin Thicke
Blurred Lines may have been his controversial break out hit in 2013. But years before that song split audiences, Robin Thicke had been a reliable under-the-radar hitmaker in the world of R+B, featuring on more widely-known artist’s songs and boasting respectable album sales of his own.
Thicke was once even the opening act for Beyonce, and by 2013 it was inevitable that he would eventually have a crossover hit. In summer of that year, Blurred Lines brought him fame and infamy at once. But, despite a later lawsuit over its sample, it’s not the track that merits his inclusion on this list.
No, the track which bring us here is 2014’s Get Her Back, the lead single from his album Paula.
The once-ubiquitous hitmaker did not win back his ex-wife, or any former fans, with this tragically embarrassing and misjudged slice of cheesy, maudlin R+B. The unsubtly titled song was an attempt to win over Thicke’s own ex-wife after years of infidelity led her to leave him, and both the song and its parent album were disastrous failures that spelled the end of the world’s brief infatuation with him (as well as Paula Patton’s).
4. Flatline — B.O.B
Rappers have a little leeway when
it comes to conspiracy theories. From Killer Mike of Run the Jewels’ unsparing
solo effort Reagan to all of Immortal Technique’s discography, rap’s place
outside the mainstream has always allowed its edgier artists an opportunity to
speak truth to power whilst disregard the risks of addressing controversial
subjects.
That said, Killer Mike did his research and can stand by the statement that Ronald Reagan was an employee of America’s “real masters” the oil lobby.
Atlanta rapper B.O.B, on the other hand…
The Nohin’ on You rapper was always corny, but he had plenty of potential back in 2009 when he first rose to prominence alongside the likes of KiD CuDi and Wale. Unfortunately, there’s no better way to lose a few years’ worth of clout amongst alternative hip hop aficionados than writing an entire track about how… The world is flat.
Released in 2016, Flatline was a risible string of conspiracy theories badly disguised as a single, and a career-crushing blow to the rapper’s credibility.
It’s ironic that his biggest hit, the emo-inflected Eminem-featuring smash Airplanes, famously heard him rap “somebody take me back to the days, before this was a job, before I got paid.”
Wish granted.
3. Rock Me Tonite — Billy Squier
This one is an unusual case, as glam rock icon Billy Squier’s song itself was pretty well-received by fans and stayed well within the sonic style he was known for.
The track’s accompanying music video directed by future High School Musical helmer Kenny Ortega, however…
It seems impossible that a flopped music video alone could have ever spelled out the instant overnight end of a superstar artist’s career. But the campy promo for Rock Me Tonite was so spectacularly misjudged that it halted the artist’s career almost immediately.
A misjudged tribute to Tom Cruise’s star-making turn in 1983’s teen comedy Risky Business, the video saw Squier bouncing around on a plush, bright pink bed in his pyjamas, grooving, writhing, and otherwise destroying any hint of toughness to his image. Squier of course insists he never approved of the video’s colourful high camp aesthetic, though Ortega maintains he was all for it until the public scorn started to roll in.
Whatever the case, the video may not have hurt Ortega’s gradual rise from music video cutting to Hollywood stardom, but it certainly spelled the end for Squier’s brief time at the top..
2. National Express — The Divine Comedy
Neil Hannon’s baroque pop outfit The Divine Comedy were always on the outside of major mainstream success.
With a softer, classical-influenced sound and drier wit than the likes of Damon Albarn of the Gallaghers, the Northern Irish singer song writer never quite fit the mould of his more rock influenced Brit Pop contemporaries.
Nonetheless, Hannon’s pleasing ear for composition and witty lyrics won him critical acclaim and comparisons to the likes of Prefab Sprout. This early success even netted him the job of composing the iconic Channel 4 sitcom Father Ted’s opening credits.
It all came crashing down with one of the singer’s biggest hits, though.
The sardonic National Express was read by critics (not unfairly) as a sneering condemnation of working class people, and whilst the aristocratic Hannon argued the lyrics mocked his equally well-to-do brother, the damage was well and truly done and his outfit never shook the image of “posh toff smugly looking down on pop music and the riff raff who listen to it.”
Now, let that be the last time anyone on the Father Ted creative team lets ill-judged tastelessness totally derail their career…
1. This Is What She’s Like — Dexy’s Midnight Runners
Come On Eileen was a surprise smash
hit for Kevin Rowland’s experimental pop/ celtic folk/ new wave band, a
phenomenally successful anthem which remains a favourite one hit wonder for
many listeners decades later.
So why has no one ever heard more from Dexy’s Midnight Runners?
Well, the “experimental pop/ celtic folk/ new wave” description above might be a good lead to follow on this one. British music fans may recall the band’s more minor earlier hit Geno, a catchy track which couldn’t be less like Come On Eileen.
Rowland’s band was a project that underwent constant artistic redevelopment and one whose central creator constantly wanted to reinvent the band’s bizarre, undeniably original sound.
So which song landed the band on this list? That would be the inventive, enjoyable, not-remotely-comparable-to-their-earlier-hit This Is What She’s Like. A twelve minute experimental track is not, it’s fair to say, what fair weather fans of Come On Eileen expected from this surprisingly offbeat and mature band.
It is a beautiful song, though, unlike most of the tracks featured on this list, and Rowland’s decision to eschew fame in favour of more creative freedom is an admirable call that resulted in an unforgettable career for a band too many listeners unfortunately, er, forgot..