10 Nirvana Covers Better Than The Original

A grunge twist on the classics and beyond.

Kurt cobain and the meat puppets MTV unplugged
MTV

Nirvana’s career may have lasted only a few short years, but did they ever make the most of their time. In three studio albums and change they became the biggest band in the world, pioneering a scene whose influence is still felt today. Their records are packed with songs which quickly became classics.

Along with the dynamite originals, though, Nirvana found time to cover a great deal of songs, both by artists they loved and admired and those less obviously inspirational to Cobain et al. Their live shows were peppered with snippets of songs by Boston and KISS to name but a few.

Indeed they were so open about their musical loves that they laid several of their covers down on tape - and in doing so, quite often trumped the originals. Whether the quality musicianship of Nirvana put them ahead of the source material, reinvented older tunes, or simply showed a lighter side of the band, they had a knack of making songs their own.

Performed sincerely or ironically, faithfully or otherwise, these 10 songs were given a new lease of life by the Seattle trio, sometimes to the point that you’d forget they’re not Nirvana originals.

10. Jesus Don’t Want Me For A Sunbeam

Kurt Cobain was particularly vocal about his musical influences, and a key band for the Nirvana frontman was Scottish two piece The Vaselines. Nirvana tackled a few of their tunes, and probably the most famous is this one, found on their much beloved Unplugged album.

“Jesus Don’t Want Me For A Sunbeam” is a wry take on Christian music, and accordingly is right in Cobain’s boundary pushing wheelhouse. The version on Unplugged keeps the melody and melancholic tone of the Vaselines original but adds beautiful texture with subtle harmonies, cello, and a rare accordion turn from bassist Krist Novoselic.

Less well known but possibly better still is their full band version, recorded on a 1991 tour. Played in the typical Nirvana style, it fights right into their catalogue. Whether Cobain is crooning or sneering the lyrics, it’s a song he clearly loves playing, and they make it their own even more when switching out the string breaks for a choppy guitar solo.


9. White Lace and Strange

Recorded long before they hit the big time, this 1987 cut of a fairly obscure ‘60s rock track is closer to the classic “punk band covering an unexpected song” genre than any of Nirvana’s other best covers, but it more than does the job of elevating an also-ran track from rock’s heyday.

The original, by Thunder And Roses, is a run of the mill number that sounds like it could be a Hendrix or Cream B-side; the guitar work, particularly, is heavily Clapton-inspired, though the drums and rhythm guitar have a heaviness that sets it apart from a lot of the era’s music, and is quite likely what drew Nirvana’s ear to it.

The Seattle trio gives it a new lease of life, though, and their process is a simple one, playing it far faster and with a lot more oomph. Krist Novoselic is the star here, carrying much of the melody with his booming bass while Cobain chews through the relatively fluffy lyrics with his knack for making things sound like they have a lot more meaning than they probably do.

A radio session that remained lost for a long time, this was a collector’s item for Nirvana fans that eventually made its way to a collection and gives a great picture of the young band already with plenty of ideas.


8. Turnaround

While Nirvana and Devo don’t obviously share much sonically, both bands had a wry sense of humour and a love of punk and beyond, even if they plucked different influences from the genre.

Their John Peel cover of Devo’s “Turnaround” (a b-side from their signature song “Whip It”) was recorded in 1990 and the sound of Nirvana’s playing clearly places the group between Bleach and the following year’s Nevermind. The overdrive is still turned up to the max, but they’ve figuring out how to milk more melody out of the playing.

The lyrics, while goofy fun in Devo’s hands, are made something paranoid and frightening when delivered via Cobain’s snarl. While Nirvana don’t have to do much with the tune or the rhythm - a skittery, danceable motorick - they add significant weight simply by stripping away the bleeping, blooping decorative notes of Devo’s version.

Played in session for John Peel, it’s a thumping rocker by a band ready to hit the big time. Without changing much at all, they make it their own.


7. Plateau

Nirvana recorded a few novelty or leftfield covers as we’ve seen, but more often than not they were tackling songs that Cobain or the other members had a particular fondness for. One such track, captured on their legendary 19992 Reading Festival set, was “The Money Will Roll Right In” by California hardcore band Fang.

They don’t feel the need to tweak this one altogether too much; the blueprint is there for a song that would suit the playing style of Nirvana. It’s a stomping, cynical punk track about the lure of fame with a cutting, simple riff, which Nirvana essentially play note for note.

The reason their version trumps the original is that the Fang track’s recording is a little lifeless. The song is great, but the actual production is a little lacking. When compared with Nirvana’s booming rendition in front of a rabid crowd in the south of England, it can’t help falling a bit short.

The track has been covered by plenty of bands and artists, but none have bettered Nirvana’s version here. For curios like this and more, it’s a blessing that so much of their brief time as a touring band was captured.


6. The Money Will Roll Right In

Another of Cobain’s much-discussed influences was The Meat Puppets, and it’s safe to say Nirvana did a lot in the early ‘90s to keep the band in the public eye. Indeed they go so far as to invite Chri and Curt Kurkwood on stage to play and sing with them during the Unplugged show as Nirvana cut a trilogy of songs from the seminal Meat Puppets II album.

Cobain is deferential to these tunes, keeping his band’s renditions faithful in the extreme. There’s no topping the original “Lake Of Fire”, but there’s certainly a case to be made that their version of “Plateau” tops the 1984 version by virtue of the fact that Cobain’s vocal performance is so strong.

The Kirkwood boys have characterful voices but by no means are they technically great singers. Their music didn’t demand perfection, but on a song with the melodic range of “Plateau”, it doesn’t hurt to utilise a vocalist with the ability of Cobain.

No doubt it was a joy for Nirvana to play with two guys whose music they loved so much, and the guys from the Meat Puppets can only have been impressed when Nirvana pulled out such a slick rendition of a classic song.


5. Return Of The Rat

Of all the bands Kurt Cobain admired and spoke of in interviews, there may have been none that he loved more than Wipers. The enormously influential group, hailing like Nirvana from the Pacific Northwest, were namechecked in interviews for Cobain’s whole career, and to that end it’s almost surprising he plucked up the courage to cover their music.

When they did, though, they did an incredible job (no doubt a labour of love for the band). In tackling “Return Of The Rat” from Wipers’ debut, Nirvana for once cut a cover that was less abrasive and cutting than the original.

They slow down a little from Wipers’ version, with the guitars thicker and less snarling than on display in Wipers’ wiry, cutting music. Throughout the track they oscillate between attempting a religiously faithful reproduction, starting the guitar solo on a note-for-note basis before going their own way.

Ultimately it’s a matter of taste which version you prefer, but Nirvana’s cover is a looser, downright fun take on the paranoid classic, and the band’s efforts pay off.


4. Molly's Lips

Another Vaselines cover and the tune which Nirvana most effectively made their own, this track is by now certainly better known as a song by the Seattle trio than the original artist.

The Vaselines are a band whose music tends towards the charmingly twee and lo fi. It’s a style that works great for them, but the punk credentials of their 1988 track was exploited to the fullest when Nirvana took possession of it.

It’s three chords and a few repetitive lines, giving Cobain a real opportunity to stamp his mark on the material. His grinding guitar and vocals cover the entirety of the track, and they play at real pace like the punk band they always had semi-desires to be.

Indeed for a band so synonymous with misery, gloom, and angst, it’s so enjoyable to hear them clearly having an absolute blast with their music. They keep the throwaway silliness of the song (written about Scottish actress Molly Weir) but add so much heft to it that it can’t help becoming the definitive version.


3. The Man Who Sold The World

There’s plenty to debate on this one, and whether you prefer the Nirvana cover or the David Bowie original, it’s a superb song. The Nirvana version on the Unplugged album, though, seems to find something at the heart of the song that Bowie perhaps buries under the bells and whistles of his 1970 version.

Bowie’s oblique story of a mysterious, all-too-familiar figure features one of his best riffs and conjures the imagery of the song through Eastern sounds and percussion, as well as ghostly, howling coda.

Nirvana simply take the melody and play it acoustically, and allow the spooky nature of the song to speak for itself. Cobain, here racked with health and substance abuse issues, holds himself close to the microphone throughout, his weary vocals adding a great deal of drama to the rendition.

The simplicity of the performance only highlights what a great piece of songwriting this is, and whichever version you prefer, this can stand as an all time great cover.


2. Love Buzz

Of all Nirvana’s covers, this is likely the one that most people don’t realise isn’t an original. Placed on the band’s debut full length, Bleach, its raucous superfuzz sound and Cobain’s tuneful growl along with Krist Novoselic’s bouncy bass fit right in with Nirvana’s first collection of new material.

In fact, the original is a fairly strange song by ‘60s band Shocking Blue. Melodically it’s a fairly faithful cover, with Nirvana maintaining the winding riff and the tune in full. Tonally, though, it’s a world apart.

Shocking Blue’s version sounds like it’s aiming for a far Eastern sound, with the guitar stabs and almost atonal solo played not unlike a sitar, to compliment the riff that carries a similar flavour.

While Shocking Blue’s version is a fun curio in the vein of Jefferson Airplane, Nirvana’s cover is a blast of earwormy, instantly memorable bubblegum grunge, with the jolt of pace and Cobain’s frenzied screams making it the more enjoyable version by far.


1. Where Did You Sleep Last Night?

To close off their MTV Unplugged concert, Nirvana decided to pull out something special. The finale is not just their finest cover (and an all-time great cover full stop) but one of the best songs in their estimable catalogue, made totally their own.

Best known prior to this for Lead Belly’s mid-’40s renditions, “Where Did You Sleep Last Night” - also known as “In The Pines” and several other names - is a traditional American folk song. A murder ballad of sorts, it’s full of horror imagery, regret, and rage that Cobain taps into in a performance of singular power.

The performance starts slowly, with a rolling guitar line and subtle work from Novoselic and Grohl accompanying Cobain’s strumming. But after a brief instrumental break, the song transforms. Cobain’s vocals leap up an octave and turn from a soft melody to an astonishing scream that reflects the narrator’s dwindling patience with the lover to whom he directs the titular question.

By the vocal take’s end, he only has a croak and a croon left, injecting an amazing amount of pain into the final syllables. It was recorded just four months before he died - the emotion in the performance can’t be faked.


In this post: 
nirvana
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)