10 Most Overrated Albums Of 2013

If people are caught up in the frenzy of a popular gimmicks, any song can find itself climbing the charts, quite often reaching number one.

It's interesting isn't it? That 'quality' of music is determined by where an album or song ranks in the charts. It doesn't matter if the only lyric anyone understands is "Gangnam style", or if an artist produces a song about something banal as what a fox says. If people are caught up in the frenzy of these gimmicks, such a song can find itself climbing the charts, quite often reaching number one.

This is exactly the same for albums; if given a particularly positive review by a franchise such as NME or Q Magazine, then social networking sites find themselves awash with people duplicating the opinions contained within these publications. For me, 2013 was a year where people everywhere metamorphosed into one gigantic sheep, with the individual appearing to lose the capacity to think for themselves. Albums such as Kanye West's 'Yeezus' climbed the chart, irrespective of the fact it was nothing more than self-indulgent drivel. Perhaps what infuriates me most about the way the music industry works is the fact some phenomenally talented musicians €“ White Lies' 'Big TV' or MGMT's 'MGMT' - missed out on recognition I believe they deserved. The purpose of this article is to put forward some of the albums that were greatly received in 2013 and knock them down a peg or too. These albums may have charted, they may have won awards. But the question I'm going to be addressing; are they really as good as everyone says they are? I'm probably building my own coffin and nailing it shut €“ especially in taking on the wrath of Arctic Monkey fans - as they can be capital 'D for Dangerous - but if you have any problems with what I have to say please feel free to comment below...

10. Days Are Gone €“ Haim

The 70's and 80's soft rock vibe presented to the listener in Haim's debut album 'Days Are Gone' isn't one that correlates with the "90s R&B" description that was put to music-lovers in early articles about Haim's sound. If you were expecting the latter then I would bet that every track on the album but 'My Song 5' was a disappointment for you. Instead of the promised R&B, the listener is confronted with the former; a series of songs that are laced with aspects of 70's and 80's soft rock. There are admittedly more than a few catchy songs, including "Falling," "If I Could Change Your Mind" and "Honey & I"; but these tracks are remarkably similar sounding. I'd even go as far as to say that it's hard to differentiate between one tracks end, and another's beginning. Haim, consisting of three sisters - Danielle, Alana and Este €“ are a girl band that took the world by a storm in 2013... and 'If I Could Change Your Mind', I'd like to be so bold as to point out why they've been so successful, when perhaps they ought not to have been. These women are feisty, kooky and engage with their fans. In an industry where bands are predominantly male, it's fair to say that they've made their mark; I don't think it takes much prompting to remind you of the sweary Twitter war that occurred between Haim and Los Campesinos! It's nice to see more female bands on the music scene sure, but that said, I think it's important not to let the looks account for musical appreciation. Many male friends of mine have expressed how hot the Haim sisters are €“ but as a straight woman it'd be nice to have something a bit more substantial that 11 same-ish tracks and three attractive women to get excited about. The days are gone where it would be cool to admit to liking Shania Twain (she was a large part of my musical formative years, I won't lie to you), but the third track "The Wire" catapults me right back to dancing round my bedroom with a hairbrush pretending to be a star. It's the epitome of cheesiness; the songs are pretty formulaic €“ reliant upon those oh-so-important choruses that scream for the listener to sing along - therefore needing this enthusiasm to carry you past the bland lyrics. But apparently cheese is one of the nation's favourite foods; if the fact that 'Days Are Gone' reached Number One in the UK Albums Chart (selling 37,005 copies in its first week) is anything to go by, that is.

9. Wolf €“ Tyler The Creator

Tyler The Creator Wolf Prior to writing this I had to google how old Tyler is. Apparently he's 22. And yet he could easily be pre-pubescent, for the album is anything but mature; the Erykah Badu collaboration 'Treehome95' being the only exception to this statement. Instead of coming across as an adult, Tyler comes across as a petulant child, hurling insults at his absent father and making sexism and homophobia "ironic" so that it's "okay" (apparently having Frank Ocean as a gay friend gives him precedent to say such things). He has a gay friend everybody. Radical. Maybe he would be better off listening to his own track 'Rusty' and taking the advice "purchase a shrink" €“ a real one, not just the fictional therapist, Dr. TC, that his work alludes to. Talking through his childhood issues with a paid professional would certainly be more effective than talking the listener's ears off, not to mention more pleasant for everyone involved. As well as this, the track 'Tamale' seems to be built on the idea of capturing a woman's reaction upon finding him mid-coitus with her sister. That's definitely not normal; and his boasting about receiving oral, reeks of infantile school kids boasting to their mates in the playground about their sexual endeavours. But the problem is, I'm not Tyler's "mate", and I certainly don't want to be either. "Controversial" appears to have become synonymous for "talented" - the latter being something which individuals such as Robin Thicke, as well as Tyler the Creator have certainly benefitted from. He's come a long way from talking about rape and murder (the themes for his other two albums, 'Bastard' and 'Goblin') and yet he's still got a long way to go before he'd be someone you'd want to introduce to your parents. Vulgar is an understatement; if you had to censor the profanity you'd end up with songs comprising mainly of "and", "you" and "I". You could probably listen to the Jeremy Kyle show and receive the same proportion of aural enjoyment. His third album 'Wolf', seems to suggest that Tyler has no intention of breaking from releasing records oozing with angst and frustration with the world. A one-trick pony, his egotistical lost-teen approach may have worked for 'Bastard' and maybe 'Goblin' but by 'Wolf', this trick has got old. Tranquilised piano and synthesised strings are all that his craft relies upon, and frankly, I'm sick of hearing them. Perhaps the clearest indicator that 'Wolf' isn't all that great is the fact that it's self-produced. Is this out of choice? Or do all the smart people in the music business realise how damaging to their career it would be to work with the artist? I'm hoping that people will see the light and stop buying similar self-indulgent drivel in 2014.

8. Vampires Of The Modern City €“ Vampire Weekend

Ezra Koenig, frontman of Vampire Weekend, abandoned a teaching career in favour of making it as a rock singer, and I can bet he's glad he did. The third album 'Vampires Of The Modern City' saw the band win "Best Alternative Music Album" at the 56th Grammy Awards, on the 26th January of this year... but it was by no means the best alternative music album of 2013, it's not even Vampire Weekend's best work. This album marks a distinct shift in tone for the band, when contrasted with their indie-pop album "Contra", which was incontestably infused with African influences, a perfect match for the band's nervy urban sound. This album sees the eradication of a lot of the pretentiousness in Koenig's lyric writing €“ discussion pertaining to Oxford commas usage is nowhere to be seen - therefore the hyper-literacy that was always endearing, rather than irritating, has been eradicated. Instead the listener is left with a lamenting, more mature lyricist that makes incredibly poignant statements "wisdom's a gift / but you'd trade it for youth". In such a way, the fun and ease-of-listening of Vampire Weekend has disappeared completely, along with its Calypso groove. The listener is left with a cynical, twisted commentary on life in New York City. A host of questions without a whole lot of answers are given to the listener. New York is constructed as a place where various characters attempt to understand life, death, American foreign policy, love and religion €“ all this happening beneath the blanket of smog that conceals the city from view (seen on the album artwork). The old Vampire Weekend has been shrouded by a blanket of smog as Batmanglij and Koenig preach to the listener; it's impossible to ignore the religious undertones to many of the tracks, especially 'Worship You' which is a rollicking battle hymn. These undertones surmount until Koenig addresses God directly. It's clever, yes. But it's more wistful, more adult than anything they've done before, and the rate at which the band has evolved has been simply too quick. No longer is the listener bopping their head to a song about drinking Horchata in the winter; instead they are forced to tackle the big questions about life, death and the in between €“ questions that we haven't been able to answer for as long as human beings have been sentient ... so what on earth makes Vampire Weekend think they can provide a satisfactory discussion of these themes in merely 45 minutes?

7. Settle - Disclosure

Everyone appears to have 'latched' onto the 19 and 22 year-old Lawrence brothers, who perform as Disclosure. Not only did 2013 see them score a trio of Top 20 hits; it saw them play Glastonbury twice and be nominated for a Grammy: 'Best Dance/Electronica Album'. Amongst their successes was the fact I enjoyed their live performance at Leeds festival. However, I suspect that the festival environment enabled the sheer repetitiveness of their material to escape me... sober, sitting alone in my bedroom, it's hard to see what is special about this "ground-breaking" record. 'What's In Your Head', general public?

The album is best summed up as being like a pizza. Yes, they both have bases (with 'Help Me Lose My Mind' having a particularly downbeat 'bass' part) but that's not the only similarity. I'm thinking if you ate pizza fourteen times in a row, even altering the toppings slightly, you're going to end up extremely bored (as well as doing nothing for world obesity statistics). 'Settle' consists of fourteen very similar-sounding tracks that do nothing to push the boundaries of sonic territory. Sure, the toppings are changed slightly by adding synths or vocal hooks. But fundamentally, each track is still a pizza. The more you try and eat of the hour and thirty-seven seconds long album, the harder it becomes to stomach. The variety of these 'toppings' is dependant of the smattering of guest artists who feature on over half the tracks on the album. The fact that this much of Disclosure's creation is reliant on guest artists to disguise the bland flavour suggests how weak they are. Further to this, the choice of artists that features on their tracks detract from claims that 'Settle' is "house" music; Jamie Woon's involvement suggests that the record leans more towards R&B. Artists such as Jessie Ware are more familiar to the clubland scene and you might wonder what Eliza Doolittle is doing on such a record. Did she roller-skate her way into 'You & Me' or did the Lawrence brothers have her in mind when they built the track? The decision to co-operate with such a broad-reaching range of artists has resulted in an eclectic mixture of tracks that don't quite gel together. The brothers have mashed together the best features of electronic sub-genres in an attempt to convince the listener they are radically changing the face of dance music (when really, they're copying and pasting the best bits), a fact which has not escaped my notice. Sure, Howard could play bass from an early age, and Guy plays drums, but so do lots of teens. What can be said in their favour - to their credit - is they do perform live, it's not simply pressing play on a Macbook. A further thing that can be accredited to the Lawrence brothers' is the fact that they can create immaculate hooks; I've had 'Stimulation' in my head ever since I first heard it. But like most songs that have the capacity to stick in your head for weeks at a time (look no further than Carly Rae Jepsen's 'Call Me Maybe'); they also have the capability to become extremely annoying in a very short space of time.

6. The 1975 €“ The 1975

Hailing from Manchester, The 1975 have an impressive musical legacy to live up to ... but from first glance, the album artwork is dull; and surprise-surprise the debut album from The 1975 is also bland, boring and monotonous. 'Sex' is one of the only full sounding tracks on the album €“ and you would hope so, given the amount of time the band have had to play around with it. This song was re-recorded, from when The 1975 were named the Slowdown. Did you know that? Well, regardless of whether you did or didn't, the fact that the band didn't make it the first time round but did with re-branding suggests to me that they're lacking the wow factor. That's not what everyone else seems to think though, as the self-titled album charted No. 1 in the UK Albums Chart on 8 September 2013 €“ ahead of Nine Inch Nails' comeback album. It's not their music that fails to convince me. Matt Healy has been transformed into an "indie" fashion icon, especially by the Tumblr community; yet I can't see past the greasy hair and his voice. Sure, it's a unique look. But is unique always good? Looking past the band's image and the single 'Sex', the rest of the album is underdeveloped, consisting of similar sounding tracks that reek of the band's desperation to "make it big". Amongst the limited tracks worthy of mention is 'The City' which built on a chunky drum loop which is evocative of Bloc Party (which most people will know from the FIFA soundtrack) €“ beyond 'Sex' 'The City' and 'Chocolate', there is very little worthy of discussion. Bland tracks like 'Talk!' suggest that the band included them to make up numbers for the track list, and the cynic in me suspects the exclamation point was included to excite the listener in a way that the song itself fails to do. The electro-pop feel to a lot of their material suggests that The 1975 would be more aptly named 'The 1985' €“ and their album's tone correlates with the fact they don't appear to have thought much about their sound. Possibly one of the worst tracks on the album is 'Robbers' €“ I think it's meant to be a power ballad ... but it's so lacking in 'oomph' that it's quite hard to tell. They've certainly taken the world by a storm €“ much like One Direction €“ in the sense that they have adoring fan girls. My Instagram feed is adorned with drawings and black and white photos of Matt Healy smoking. Nowadays, the music industry is as much about band image as it is the quality of music produced; and this is the sad but true reality. Will The 1975 last as Matt Healy's looks deteriorate? Probably not. One thing that can be said in the bands favour, however, is their live performances, they put on an absolutely cracking show.

5. A Long Way Down €“ Tom Odell

Tom Odell Long Way Down Packshot From the outset, the twenty-three year old invites the listener to grow old with him; a prospect that I couldn't possibly begin to entertain mainly because of Tom Odell's gratingly-annoying voice that becomes progressively more-so over the duration of the album. He's a talented pianist and guitarist, granted, but the tone to his voice doesn't make me swoon or want to spend the rest of my life listening to him, by any stretch of an imagination. He has great fashion sense, is attractive in a dishevelled kind of way, as well as doing an admirable job of interacting with his fans on Twitter. But just because he's an attractive or nice person doesn't give him an automatic claim to having produced one of 2013's best albums. He also asks us to "tear me down" in Sirens, a request I have no problem in obliging. The lyrics to every one of the ten tracks on the album are cheesy and generic enough that they've managed to convince Heart FM's listeners of Tom Odell's talent. But really the utilisation of the same basic song structure with emotional crescendos - reminiscent of Arcade Fire or Keane €“ and exploitation of every cliché under the sun is uninspiring, not to mention predictable. Not only relying on the same formula for every track, the album is extremely self-indulgent; the songs are all about how 'small' Tom Odell feels; how he 'can't pretend'; how he thinks he 'cares'. Newsflash: I don't care about 'how many tears' you've shed Tom. Grab some Kleenex and be a man about it. He comes across as a whiny teenage boy as opposed to the deep and soulful musical genius I suspect he aspires to be, and it's exhausting. If I had any advice to give the songwriter, it would probably be to stop being such a drama queen; having claimed to be incapable of remaining in a relationship for "more than 6 months" to journalists, Tom Odell needs to be told that 10 songs about failed relationships (if we're to put stock in his 6 month theory) suggests that he's on his way to becoming the male equivalent of Taylor Swift. Maybe Tom, "she got a new boyfriend/a little too soon" (and no, we're not asking you) was because of your tendency to be dull and predictable. Also, the fact your Dad complained to NME about the ranking 'A Long Way Down' was given seems like you really ought to stop being such a Daddy's boy, too. Sure, it's cute and all. But cute is boring - especially when you times cute by neediness and factor that all by whininess (coincidentally, the mathematical formula for 'Long Way Down').

4. Yeezus €“ Kanye West

Recording in a hotel room is apparently an adequate excuse for not adding depth and substance to your music; with West having been said to have opted for minimalism because "too much bass or complexity would simply overpower the room's poor acoustics". The fact he couldn't be bothered to find a room with good acoustics is in keeping with the rest of the album; it's simply plain lazy.

Leaked four days prior to release, Yeezus is an album that caused divide between the general public in 2013. But it was mainly the critics who are to blame for the album placing in this list of 'overrated albums'. Nothing more than a publicity stunt, West chose not to release singles prior to the album's release; and the non-existent CD art has been described to be "artistic" and symbolic of the album's "minimalist" theme, as opposed to sloppy craftsmanship and a transparent gimmick. What we have here is a simple record, that simple-minded people are tricked into thinking is a work of artistic genius. It really is as overwhelmingly simple as that. The album is comprised of a mash-up of styles and genres and sounds randomly put together; not surprising when you incorporate Indian film scores and rapping, really. Even Daft Punk's input to 'Yeezus' is no saving graze; it's evident that they saved their 'best material' for their own "Random Access Memories". Every single song is listed as being "Explicit" and that doesn't feel like an adjective that's quite strong enough; his lyrics are contradictory, misogynistic and not to mention factually incorrect: "I keep it 300 like the romans" springing to mind. It's hard to understand why people would voluntarily listen to what is fundamentally a self-indulgent rant, he has nothing to do but complain. Even when he's addressing serious cultural problems, West comes across to the listener as acrimonious. Does Kayne West really care about politics? Questionable. Does Kayne West care about himself? You might as well ask if the Pope is a Catholic. Speaking of religion, the title of the third track "I Am A God" epitomises what Kanye West thinks of himself; and I suppose it's whether or not you appreciate Kanye West as an individual as to whether or not you appreciate having your ears talked off for 40 minutes. A condensed religious service in "Kanyeism" I suppose. But I'm not a believer.

3. Bad Blood €“ Bastille

I sat down to write this thinking "how am I going to be an optimist about this?": a good question put to us by Bastille frontman, Dan Smith. Featuring the destructive titles 'Pompeii', 'Things We Lost In The Fire' and 'Icarus', it seemed apt for me to attempt to knock the band's debut studio album from the pedestal it's been wrongly placed upon. Judging by the amount of radio airtime the band has received, it's evident that everyone is ignorant to repetitive-sounding the 40 minute runtime is.

Having made the charts on the other side of the Atlantic, there's a part of me that feels the positivity that oozes from 'Bad Blood' better suits the aspirational "American dream" than pessimistic Britons like myself. Lyrics such as "we sure as hell have nothing now" are sung with such overwhelming positivity that it is easy to overlook the negativity of such a phrase. The upbeat tone to the album, for me, is encapsulated in one word: contrived. One positive thing that can be said for the album, however, is the instrumentation €“ programmed beats are seamlessly integrated with live drumming and tuned percussion... which would be great, if it wasn't for the fact that all of this is undermined by the belting voice of Dan Smith which overpowers every track. It's irrefutable that the man can sing; it's just a shame that he has to sing quite so upbeat, and quite so domineeringly because it jeopardises the ease-of-listening of the album. Smith's voice is one-toned and to me, sounds heavily strained. There's also the issue of the "oohs" and "ayy-ayy"s; which as far as I can see, attempt to add depth and dimension to the songs but merely give the impression that the band haven't got enough substance, lyrically or instrumentally. Then again, I suppose listeners of cheesy pop music rarely appreciate the layering in such a track. I also suspect that lyrically, the clever references to Coleridge's "Rime of the Ancient Mariner" in 'Weight Of Living Pt. I'; "there's an albatross around your neck" completely evade the listener. To someone unaware of these subtleties, the lyrics must seem obscure, non-sensical even. Why on Earth would you willingly sing songs about wearing an albatross around your neck without understanding that doing so is meant to be a symbol of bad luck? Then again, why would you willingly purchase a song about what a fox says, despite being perfectly aware that foxes do not have the capacity to interact with humans? People continue to astound me. It's quite clear that Bastille try to appeal to a broad target audience, as there are influences as broad reaching as '80s band A-ha ('Take On Me' having potentially the best music video to come from this era), to Coldplay, to Mumford and Sons and Arcade Fire evident within the album. But the result of such a random mash-up of genre is a band that seems to try and canvas fans from across the board in a desperate bid to become universally popular. It can't possibly last, we'll see what they give us in their next album.

2. AM €“ Arctic Monkeys

Alex Turner once said "don't believe the hype", yet in the context of AM, the Arctic Monkeys' fifth studio-album, his words appear to have been dismissed. A fusion of R&B and rock, AM shows that Turner, O'Malley, Cook and Helders are no longer the teenagers that they once were; having grown into successful rockstars, now emulating many other successful artists.

Whilst I don't have a problem with bands drawing inspiration from other musicians, I feel like Arctic Monkeys have borrowed slightly too much; a fact which is epitomised by the album title 'AM' mimicking the Velvet Underground's 1985 release 'VU'. The first track 'Do I Wanna Know' establishes the grown-up tone from the outset; built on Jamie Cook's sexy, monolithic riff it has the capacity to get even a nun's hips gyrating, and is extremely catchy. Despite being a great song, it's been unfortunately spoilt by having been turned into the anthem of Alex Turner wannabes everywhere. Apparently having a quiff and wearing a leather jacket is tantamount to having a superpower. 'Mad Sounds' is incontestably similar to Hot Chocolate's 'You Sexy Thing'. There's also "this tune I've found", namely 'The Sky Is Fallin'' by Queens of the Stone Age which contains falsetto-style backing vocals that are copied in 'One For The Road'. This is obviously a result of QOTSA frontman, Josh Homme's contribution to the album, and indeed this song. But I already have Queens of the Stone Age on my iPod - if I wanted to listen to them, I would. I miss Arctic Monkeys' commentary on the humdrum details of everyday life and the distinct Sheffield twang to Turner's words. The fundamental problem with AM is that the LA-based lifestyle the band now leads is not familiar to the listener, whereas songs about taxis with red lights that indicate "doors are secured" once were. Is the album worthy of the 10/10 rating it was given by NME? On such an album, each song should be unique; criteria not met by 'Do I Wanna Know' sounding like a slowed down version of 'R U Mine'. 'Fireside', one the albums weakest tracks, contains grating "shoo-wop shoo-wops" which make me want to skip the song entirely. Then there's the anomalous track 'No. 1 Party Anthem' which feels like it would be more fittingly placed on the Submarine soundtrack. As a wistful ballad it sticks out like a sore thumb and doesn't comply with the sexed-up tone of the rest of the album. Sure, Alex Turner remains a talented lyricist; that much can't be contested...but the lack of cohesiveness in AM leaves it undeserving of its 10/10 rating. Further adding to my disappointment was the mediocrity of my experience at the (re-scheduled) hometown gig at Sheffield Motorpoint Arena. The audience seemed to be made up of a flock of sheep led by a shepherd called 'NME', baa-ing along here and there, secretly hoping nobody would notice that they hadn't actually bothered to learn the words to the band's new material prior to attending the show.

1. Random Access Memories €“ Daft Punk

2013 saw the release of 'Random Access Memories', Daft Punk's first studio album in eight years. It's definitely the duos best commercial and critical success. For confirmation of this fact one only needs to look as far as the awards the album received at the 56th Annual Grammy Awards: 'Album Of The Year', 'Best Dance/Electronica Album' and 'Best Engineered Album, Non-Classical'.

But here's why it's massively overrated:

There are positive aspects of the album, sure. 'Touch' is evocative of classics such as 'A Day In The Life' by The Beatles and the trademark drawl of Julian Casablancas (the Strokes) is appreciated by the listener in 'Instant Crush'. The album sounds expensive; and that's because it was. Bangalter estimated the cost of production to be "over one million dollars". Worth it in terms of commercial success, sure; for it became the duo's first UK number-one album, with 165,091 copies sold in its first week. But worth it in terms of aural satisfaction for Daft Punk fans? No. The album that graced the charts in 2013 was, as a whole, extremely ambitious and wildly inconsistent; the listener was presented with a schizophrenic mess of a record that wasn't a dance album. Well, at least not in the way that 'Discovery' and 'Homework' were. In "Get Lucky", which won a Grammy Award for "Record Of The Year", Williams sings "We've come too far/to give up who we are", and yet that's exactly what the musical duo appear to have done. Their sound has been re-jigged, and the listener is presented with a seventy-five minute eclectic mash-up of genres. Guy-Manuel de Homem-Christo and Thomas Bangalter may have thought that incorporating jazz-infused instrumentals, vocoder, soft rock and pretentious Broadway-esque lyrics was a good idea, but it feels too wide-reaching. It's apparent to the listener that the tracks are devoid of any real substance or meaning. They've "given up" who they are, and the resulting smorgasbord of genres can be summed up in one word: odd. These aren't the only bizarre choices made in the production of this album; the cover art is a confusing homage to Michael Jackson's 'Thriller'. And the closing track 'Contact' features a recording of Captain Eugene Cernan from the Apollo 17 mission; quintessentially a six-minute ode to a spaceship taking off. It's certainly "one great leap" for Daft Punk, a leap from the solid and reliable surface of electronic dance music to a genre to something that's not yet been defined by (musical) science. As a result of this, one can only conclude that Daft Punk certainly "got lucky" in 2013 €“ they didn't deserve "Album of the Year", by any stretch. One thing they did deserve, though, is number one spot on this list of 'Over Rated Albums Of 2013".

In this post: 
video
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Hi I'm Beth, a 17 year old girl from the UK who is most often found sat in front of my computer in my room making no noise and pretending I don't exist*. I like coffee (black, two sugars), old books and I'm currently studying the art of procrastination. On a more serious note, I'm currently studying for my A Levels, taking English Literature, English Language, History and Economics. I intend to study either English or Journalism at university. *that's a Harry Potter reference. If you didn't get that, then shame on you.