10 Perfect Hit Songs That Are Insanely Long
Getting Epics to Chart.
The world of popular music has never really lent itself that well to the long song format. The rules of the game have always been to not bore us and get to the chorus, and some of the greatest songs in the world have been able to reach the top of the charts and get everything finished in 3 minutes or less. The charts are unpredictable though, and sometimes bands like to mess around with something that’s a bit stranger than what the pop crowd expects.
Rather than just make the same cookie cutter song over and over, these artists took a risk by making songs that were a bit more lengthy, taking their time and stretching things out from anywhere to 5 minutes to even breaking the 10 minute mark in some cases. This should have spelled disaster for any radio station, but that’s not what happened. Almost changing the game through one song, every one of these bands actually were considered forward thinking for making this stripe of song, letting people immerse themselves in the experience and dance all of their cares away most of the time.
While most other pop songs became flashes in the pan, these songs have become modern classics, becoming influential on just what you can put on the radio at any given moment. You can say that pop has gotten stale, but you’re always going to have artists like these that make it that much more interesting.
10. We Are the World - USA For Africa
For as much as Live Aid has been dogged on in the past, there was at least a good idea at the heart of it all. Despite the millions of punks bashing it for being a bunch of celebrities being self absorbed with themselves and trying to boost their own sales figures, you could tell that they really were coming together to try and help the world. So when you have that many people spread out over a few days, how do you translate that kind of energy to a single?
Operating almost concurrently with Live Aid, USA for Africa gave us We Are the World, which brought together every single living legend you could imagine at the time. Though the actual hook of the song is pretty basic, that gives every single vocalist room to flex their chops, going from the smooth sounds of Michael Jackson and Lionel Richie to Steve Perry from Journey to bringing in Bob Dylan to kind of speak-sing his way through his own separate verse.
In between some of the more iconic people though, you also have Dan Akroyd in the mix as well. Though this was assumed to just be a representation of the Blues Brothers, Akroyd has said that he had no intention of being a part of things, just walking into the wrong studio one day and setting up shop behind the rest of the living legends. The premise of the song and even the structure may be a little bit too basic, but there’s a fine line between coming off as trite and becoming universal.
9. Tainted Love/Where Did Our Love Go - Soft Cell
Every original goth probably has most of the lyrics of Tainted Love etched onto the side of their brain. Though synthesizers may have been fairly primitive at the time, the icy sound of these keyboards mixed with the shaking emotion coming out of Mark Almond’s throat beat acts like the Cure to the punch in terms of putting goth on MTV. The original is a classic, but hearing Tainted Love is only giving you half of the story.
If you go back and listen to the album version, the whole track is twice as long, working as a mashup of Tainted Love and The Supremes’ hit Where Did Our Love Go. Looking at both of these songs beside each other, they feel like they shouldn’t really work, especially with Diana Ross’ show stopping voice on the latter song. When they sync up on the back half of the song though, it almost makes too much sense, as Almond’s voice gets even more emotionally dense as he talks about his heart being shattered into a million pieces.
If anything, this whole thing practically acts as its own mini contained soap opera, with Tainted Love being the jaded lovers and Where Did Our Love Go being our boy trying to pick up the pieces of his shattered relationship. So next time you go through this song at ‘80s night, just remember where our sad sap ended up on the proper version.
8. Funeral For a Friend - Elton John
Towards the mid ‘70s, Elton John was slowly entering into his classic phase. Though he and Bernie Taupin had a knack for penning classic hits as far back as Your Song, his next string of albums were the stuff of pop music history, culminating in the massive double album Goodbye Yellow Brick Road. Every album has to put the right foot forward though, and Elton made the kind of pop journey that was worthy of royalty.
In between all of the classic songs like Candle in the Wind and Saturday Night’s Alright, Elton was very particular about starting things off with an almost dirge like atmosphere. The title really makes sense, as Elton was trying to envision the kind of music that he would want played at his own funeral and making a pure melancholy piano showcase before going into Love Lies Bleeding.
That’s right, kids, this is another 2-for-1 song, since the actual pop song part doesn’t come in for well over 3 minutes in as Elton opens his mouth. For being an 11 minute song, there’s never a moment during the production where it feels like it’s dragging, going from one dramatic high to another, whether that’s Elton’s virtuoso piano skills or a nice meaty guitar riff to tie everything together. The man was always known for being over the top, and this is one of the few Elton songs that feels like it belongs on Broadway much more than a rock album.
7. What Goes Around - Justin Timberlake
In the wake of Rock Your Body and SexyBack, the Justin Timberlake that you knew from NSYNC and the Mickey Mouse Club was officially gone. In his place now was a seasoned veteran of the pop scene, and he was looking to turn his sound inside out now that he had Timbaland as one of his main producers for FutureSex/LoveSounds. These guys would throw anything at the wall and somehow make it stick, and What Goes Around practically feels like it deserves its own mini movie.
Justin rarely ever strikes out when taking on love songs, but this is the kind of jaded goodbye song that is definitely a step up for him, talking about a woman who played him for a fool and how time is going to teach her a lesson. Like all songs like this, this could have easily just been a bounceback song like Return of the Mack, only for the track to keep playing out as the strings get more and more haunting on the back half of the song.
We don’t hear the falsetto as often here, and you feel like you’re talking to the real Justin, as he tracks his ex’s moves and sees her slowly fall apart, trying to come back to her sideman and only getting a busy tone. Spanning across 7 minutes, this feels like the kind of revenge scenario playing out in real time, as Justin sees his ex fall apart and trying not to go back to her in the process. If anything, this should be more of a lesson than a song. You may try to have it both ways in life, but time can play you for a fool as well.
6. All Too Well - Taylor Swift
By this point, anyone interested in talking about the meaty gossip behind Taylor Swift’s songs about her exes have really missed the point. Taylor wears her heart on her sleeve most of the time, and these songs are just a reflection of who she is as a person, not just some tabloid drama that she thinks is going to sell records. She tended to not share as much after Red though, but she had some unfinished business when the re-recording process started.
In the first stages of writing All Too Well, Taylor was just using a traditional piano ballad setup, as she talks about her ex tearing her heart to pieces and recounting the specific times she went out with him and her scarf that he still has at his house. You have to remember that you’re only looking at the surface level on the original album, and the re-recorded version is the real deal, sprawling it out to over 10 minutes as she adds more and more verses.
This was originally supposed to be the version heard on the original album before the higher ups came in, but this version of the song packs much more of a punch. You can almost feel that anger from beyond the speakers, seeing Taylor in the studio and bringing in one more verse because of just how much pain she still feels towards this guy. It may be a little excessive, but emotions demand to be felt, and this 10 minute version almost feels like a creative catharsis.
5. American Pie - Don McLean
If there’s any genre that should really pride itself on its storytelling, it would have to be folk music. Since you don’t really have the most sophisticated instrumentation on every single song, most people rely on their quick wit and silver tongue on their songs to make the audience engaged. Don McLean was no different than any other songwriter at the time, but his recounting of his first life changing musical moment was years in the making.
Though released in the early ‘70s, this is actually a recounting of the day that Buddy Holly passed away in the late ‘50s and the aftermath of what the rock world has come to as a result. Compared to most other story songs that come on the radio, this practically feels like you’re being given a history lesson in the headphones, with every verse going through a different portion of rock history, making characters that reflect the sound of the times.
It’s pretty clear to put together that the King would be Elvis Presley, but that’s just surface level, from the Jester being Bob Dylan stealing the crown from the King and Sergeants representing the Beatles during their psychedelic period. By the time you reach the end of the song, you see how the rock and roll dream of the ‘60s never fully got realized, with people taking the last train for the coast, never to be heard from again. There was no one to fall back on in the ‘70s, and Don McLean let us know that the fate of rock and roll was in our hands now.
4. Paradise By the Dashboard Light - Meatloaf
Pop music has never really been that far away from showtunes at the best of times. Long before you had things like rock and roll and jazz taking over the charts, some of the biggest singles of all time normally came from stage shows, with people more than happy to sing along with songs that had intricate storylines behind them. So when rock became the new norm in pop music, who said you couldn’t put some of that bombast back into the picture?
Because most of Bat Out of Hell really feels like some sort of dark rock and roll Broadway show, with Meat Loaf being the disenchanted hero of the story hell bent on finding some sort of redemption arc. On Paradise by the Dashboard Light, you’re put in the middle of the action, where Meat comes across a lady friend and tries to…shall we say become a little bit more friendly with her later on in the night.
As we go through the whole song, you can feel the tension brewing in the backing band, all while Ellen Foley plays the girl in the situation. Though the actual sound of this song is enough to get you hooked, the story plays out like a bad one night stand, as Meat is left praying for the end of time with this woman as his wife and becoming more and more unhappy with the domestic life. It’s not necessarily the outcome that he would have wanted, but it’s probably a lot closer to what happens in the real world when these stories play out.
3. Too Long - Daft Punk
For the longest time, there was no way that any type of electronic music was going to be played on the radio that much. While you had acts that put some electronic influences into their sound like the Beastie Boys, this was the kind of music that was reserved for the raves of the world, meant for people to party all night long. Something started to change in the ‘90s with the arrival of the Chemical Brothers, and Daft Punk took it to much greater heights on Discovery.
In between the classic songs of Y2K, you also have tracks like Harder, Better, Faster Stronger getting major airplay as well. When you bought the proper album though, Too Long feels more like a piece of meta-humor about the album itself, considering the song reaches nearly ten minutes as opposed to the tight runtimes of everything else. This is the kind of song that you need to let stir for a little bit longer though, as Daft Punk layer one great sample on top of one another.
Though it’s easy to call this kind of thing repetitive upon first listen, you have to pay attention to everything else that’s going on in the mix every few seconds. One minute you might get tired of Romanthony talking about how he knows you need it, but by the time the rest of the band kicks in behind him, he’s got you hook, line and sinker without you even realizing it. Despite what the robot helmets might imply, Daft Punk’s music always feels like a living breathing entity whenever they make songs like this.
2. Rapper's Delight - Sugar Hill Gang
Right around the start of the ‘80s, hip hop didn’t really have a proper name. Still being a goof around session in the disco clubs around New York, there were people willing to just spit some rhymes over the beat of a song. This may have just been done by DJs to keep the beat going, but Sugarhill Gang knew that they had something here with Rapper’s Delight.
It’s not out of the question to consider this one of the first real rap songs to ever be made, but it also comes with the same disco trappings that happen as well. These were songs that were meant to lull you into a groove, and the original version of this track certainly does, ramping it up to just under 15 minutes on the original version of the song.
While nothing on the charts really has the right to be that long, it never feels boring when Sugarhill Gang are spitting, finding different ways to keep the beat going and even switching up their flow a few times to keep things interesting. One of the main reasons why this had such a crossover appeal was just how weird it sounded, not really having too much in common with anything else on the radio at the time. This wasn’t just a little goof off project though…this was the beginning of a new art form that was about to take over the world.
1. Purple Rain - Prince
There has never really been a set definition of what genre Prince really falls into. Throughout his career, the Purple One was far from a one trick pony, and almost any project he made felt like a different venture for him, whether going into the world of jazz or mining the same R&B that he loved so much. The era of Purple Rain was the pop years though, and Mr. Nelson came up with a song that could put most other rock power ballads to shame.
Which is strange because even Prince considered one of his biggest to actually be outside of his wheelhouse. During his time on the road, he had found himself on a bill with Bob Seger and tried to write a ballad that would fit within the mold of what the heartland rocker had started with. In the context of the movie, this becomes one of the last ballads where Prince tries to make amends with his lover, saying that he never meant to cause her any pain and watches as the rain crashes down all over him.
You can call the lyrics beautiful all you want, but the real key to the song’s brilliance is the guitar solo and outro, where Prince practically makes love to his guitar a la Jimi Hendrix and turns in one of the most memorable solos of all time, as the rain falls down all around him. Prince may have made bold leaps since this one song, but the melodrama behind it really tells you everything you need to know about his music. It’s gentle when it needs to be, it’s a bit nasty at times too, but you can’t really imagine life without it either.