10 Replacement Hard Rock Singers That NAILED It (Or Just Didn't Fit)
Changing your lead singer is always make or break.
We’ve seen the rock music phenomenon twist and turn its way through the decades, creating movements of iconic musical genres. In the early days of the 1970s, bands such as Black Sabbath laid the blueprint for what would become heavy metal.
The early 1980s gave us the likes of Iron Maiden, who would influence the emergence of US thrash metal led by Metallica, while in California the party hard rock of Motley Crue rose from the success of bands such as Van Halen.
In the 1990s alternative rock was king with the emergence of the Seattle grunge scene, while bands such as Pantera took metal into a new heavier groove orientated direction, leading to many new styles that would arrive in the 2000s.
Over the years, a number of bands have found themselves having to alter personnel with the biggest impact always coming with a change of vocalist. The front man is usually the identity of a band, and sometimes a change can either take the music to another level, or send it into obscurity.
10. Blaze Bayley - Iron Maiden (Never Quite Fit)
Iron Maiden were the British kings of heavy metal, rising to prominence during a success fuelled 1980s. But by the end of the decade, their charismatic singer Bruce Dickinson was becoming disillusioned with the mammoth touring schedule the band would embark on for each album.
With the rise of the alternative music scene in the early 1990s, Dickinson began to concentrate on launching a solo career, and after their 1992 album Fear Of The Dark, announced he would be leaving.
A search for a replacement was conducted with the band eventually deciding on Blaze Bayley, singer for the mildly successful rockers Wolfsbane who had previously supported Maiden on tour. But fans were never quite convinced that his baritone voice would ever work with the band’s classic material.
With Bayley, Iron Maiden released The X Factor in 1995 and while not a bad album it charted poorly and featured some of the darkest songs of their career, clearly written with Blaze’s limited range in mind.
This was followed with Virtual XI in 1998 which is generally considered by fans as the weakest material in the whole of their catalogue. The resulting tour was also somewhat of a disaster for Maiden with Bayley experiencing voice problems throughout, and the decision was made to let him go.
The eventual return of Bruce Dickinson in 1999, would see Iron Maiden embark on their wildly successful resurgence across the new century.
9. Ronnie James Dio - Black Sabbath (Absolutely Nailed It)
Black Sabbath all but invented heavy metal as we know it and remain hugely influential on the sound to this day. Guitarist Tony Iommi, bassist Geezer Butler and drummer Bill Ward were all masters their crafts, and in the early 70s, released a string of legendary albums with notorious singer Ozzy Osborne, including their self-titled debut, Paranoid, Masters Of Reality, Vol.4 and Sabbath Bloody Sabbath.
But by the late 70s their wild partying and heavy drug use was beginning to take its toll, especially with Ozzy. The music suffered and their following albums were not so well received. The difficult decision was taken to fire and replace Osborne.
Rainbow’s Ronnie James Dio came in and although he was undoubtedly a fine singer, fans were understandably sceptical as it was unusual for such a successful band to replace a beloved front man.
However Dio’s arrival reinvigorated the rest of the band and they went on to create the classic return to form album Heaven And Hell in 1980, quickly followed with the equally as fine Mob Rules in 1981.
Ronnie James Dio left the following year, but proved it was possible for a band to experience success after parting ways with an icon. Dio would go on to play concerts with Black Sabbath from time to time, and also recorded the album Dehumaniser with them in 1991.
8. Gary Cherone - Van Halen (Never Quite Fit)
Van Halen had been a band at the top of the world for nearly twenty years, experiencing wild successful with two legendary singers by the time Sammy Hagar left in 1996.
Iconic guitarist Eddie Van Halen, his brother Alex (drums) and bassist Mike Anthony found themselves at a cross roads for a second time, but this was a very different stage in their career.
Van Halen were not particularly fashionable in the mid-90s, which was in contrast to their standing a decade earlier when David Lee Roth walked out.
Alternative rock was reining supreme and the decline in traditional heavy rock/metal bands was all to apparent with many such as Van Halen hitting smaller venues on tour, when they had previously sold out stadiums. Principle song writer Eddie Van Halen was also a little strung out around this period in his life.
Mutual management put them together with Gary Cherone who had previously fronted the Boston based band Extreme, who had seen success themselves in the early 90s, having had a huge hit single with the ballad More Than Words.
The reunion resulted in the highly uninspired sounding Van Halen III album, a collection of largely forgettable songs and an equally mediocre tour. It was clear the collaboration would not last and Gary Cherone soon parted ways with the band while they looked to reunite with their former singers .
7. William DuVall - Alice In Chains (Absolutely Nailed It)
Alice In Chains exploded out of the Seattle music scene with their hit Man In The Box, lifted from their debut album Facelift in 1990. They were led by Layne Staley, somewhat of an enigma of a front man, while guitarist and principle songwriter Jerry Cantrell was undoubtedly the heartbeat of the band.
Their followup album Dirt in 1992 took their success to the next level, but was a dark heavy and melancholic collection of songs, largely lyrically based around Staley’s drug use.
Over the following few years Layne dived deeper into addiction until he could no longer function with the band, and in 1996 they went on an indefinite hiatus.
Ever the creative, Jerry Cantell pursued a solo career, writing songs he always hoped would see the light day with AIC, before Layne Staley - by this time a virtual recluse - sadly succumbed to his sickness and passed away in 2002. It came as a surprise to many some years later when Cantrell announced that Alice In Chains would be reforming and releasing new music once again, this time with little known singer/guitarist William DuVall taking the place of Layne.
The album Black Gives Way To Blue was released in 2009 and was a superb collection of songs that almost sounded as if Staley’s ghost was all over the record. Although he could never be truly replaced, DuVall had slipped perfectly into the unique sound of the band, and together they have gone onto release a further two albums while experiencing a highly successful second run.
6. Johnny Solinger - Skid Row (Never Quite Fit)
Skid Row arrived at the end of the 80s hard rock revolution, with their 1989 self-titled debut instantly propelling them into the big time.
Their follow up album Slave To The Grind cemented their success in 1991, and huge world tours followed with the likes of Guns N Roses and Pantera. Guitarist Dave ‘Snake’ Sabo and bassist Rachel Bolan had formed the band and wrote the songs, but it was the louder than life front man Sebastian Bach who became their talisman.
By the mid-1990s his antics were grating on the rest of the band who appeared to be resentful of his popularity. Trouble often seemed to follow, and after a lukewarm reception to their third album Subhuman Race in 1995, tempers flared on the subsequent tour and Bach was fired.
It took until 1999 before Skid Row announced they had hired Johnny Solinger and began touring again, and it took a further four years before they released another album, Thickskin.
They followed up in 2006 with Revolutions Per Minute, but the music they were making with Solinger would never see them reach the heights of success they had achieved with Sebastian Bach a decade earlier.
Johnny Solinger would eventually leave the band in 2014 having been with them twice the length Bach was. But to this day if you think of Skid Row, you think of their earlier hey-day, and everything since is unfortunately a little forgettable.
5. Phil Anselmo - Pantera (Absolutely Nailed It)
Pantera transformed the metal genre in the 1990s, flying the flag for heavier music when alternative/grunge was firmly in vogue.
Featuring the guitar wizardry of Dimebag Darrell Abbott and controversial, powerful front man Phil Anselmo, the band epitomised success in the extreme music scene, but it hadn’t always been that way.
Anselmo didn’t join the band until 1986, and before that, Dimebag (then known as Diamond Darryl), his brother Vinnie Paul (drums) and bassist Rex Brown had spent years touring as a hard/glam rock band in their native Texas, with singer Terry Glaze.
They independently released their debut album Metal Magic in 1983, but as the tastes of the band started to change fuelled by a burgeoning love of thrash metal from the likes of Metallica and Slayer, they decided someone new was needed on the mic to lead from the front.
Phil Anselmo came in and helped transform the sound and style, firmly putting them on the path that would lead them in their new heavier direction.
Out went the spandex heavy stage costumes, and in came an attitude that would result in their break through album Cowboys From Hell in 1990. By the time they followed up with A Vulgar Display Of Power in 1992 they were well on the path to glory, carving out a niche for themselves and taking heavy music to a whole new commercially successful level.
4. Tim 'Ripper' Owens - Judas Priest (Never Quite Fit)
Judas Priest are the English rock/metal group that stylistically linked Black Sabbath with the likes of Iron Maiden and the other New Wave of British Heavy Metal Bands. They rose to prominence throughout the 1970s before really finding their style and success during the following decade.
Their sound was synonymous with that of the operatic vocals of singer Rob Halford, a talismanic frontman who really defined the bands image as he would ride on stage on a Harley Davidson, dressed head to toe in leather.
However in 1992 as the musical tide was changing Halford departed from the legacy band to pursue other musical interests, forming the heavier thrash orientated metal band Fight. In 1996 Priest announced that Tim ‘Ripper’ Owens was joining them, a singer who had previously worked in a Judas Priest tribute band named British Steel.
For Owens, this was the job of a lifetime and his rag to riches tale would inspire the Hollywood movie Rock Star released in 2001 and starring Mark Wahlberg.
‘Ripper’ would record two albums with Judas Priest as they tried to adapt to the changing music tide, attempting to tap into the popularity of modern groove and nu-metal. And although he was without question a fine singer, this period in Judas Priest’s history is just not one the fans fondly remember, having always called for a reunion with Rob Halford and eventually getting their wish in 2003.
3. Sammy Hagar - Van Halen (Absolutely Nailed It)
Van Halen played their way out of backyard parties during the mid 1970s in their native California, to become one of the biggest rock bands in the world by the turn of the following decade.
While the heartbeat of the band has always undoubtedly been the legendary guitarist Eddie Van Halen, the super-ego that was David Lee Roth led from the front always wanting to be the centre of attention. Friction between the two was never far away and their musical differences started to spread them further apart by the time they released their sixth album 1984, the magnum opus of their career.
Roth left to go solo that same year and Van Halen turned to Sammy Hagar, a huge stadium rock act in his own right which divided fans just as Roth had divided the band.
However Van Hagar as they would commonly be known, wasted no time in releasing the album 5150 in 1986, a commercial success which saw them embark on a reincarnation of the group, which as the decade rumbled on would see their most successful period in terms of show sizes and revenue.
Hagar would make three more albums with Van Halen before the collaboration imploded after the 1995 record Balance, and Sammy’s time eventually came to an end, coinciding with a period of middle age where Van Halen were unfortunately no longer considered cutting edge.
2. John Corabi - Motley Crue (Never Quite Fit)
Motley Crue burst out of the Sunset Strip scene in LA, and led the glam/hard rock phenomenon that would take the mid-late 1980s by storm. Every member was an imposing character, wearing a combination of leather, spandex and extensive makeup to create an image that was all about partying, and absolutely epitomised the sex, drugs and rock & roll lifestyle.
Vince Neil was their charismatic singer, a real ladies man who’s image inspired the Aerosmith hit Dude Looks Like A Lady. But as immortalised in the film Dirt (based on the bands memoirs), his relationship deteriorated with his band mates and he left in 1993.
Motley Crue turned to the talented John Corabi to fill in on vocal duties, pinching him from The Scream to record their self-titled album in 1994. The record was a departure from their usual glam sound as Motley Crue took influence from the alternative scene and the likes of Soundgarden and Alice In Chains.
And while the album is actually some of their best and most mature work, the fans just did not take to the change of front man, voting with their feet on the subsequent disappointing tour for the band.
Motley Crue quickly decided to patch up their differences with Vince Neil, and let Corabi go in order to appease their fanbase, and to financially get the band back on track.
1. Bruce Dickinson - Iron Maiden (Absolutely Nailed It)
It's difficult to think of Iron Maiden without Bruce Dickinson on the microphone. His vocal range is legendary and his patter with the crowd second to none.
But in addition to their forgettable Blaze Bayley period in the 1990s, there was also a pre-Dickinson era. Maiden would experiment with handful of vocalists as they played the London bar circuit in the mid 70s, settling on Paul DiAnno who would sing on their 1980 self-titled debut album and its follow up Killers, a year later.
As they started gaining notoriety and were hitting the road for longer periods, DiAnno had trouble adjusting to the lifestyle and by his own admission was using a lot of cocaine and drinking heavily, greatly effecting his ability to meet the standards set by the rest of the band.
They went behind his back and lined up Bruce Dickinson during a clandestine meeting at the Reading Festival, where he was performing with the band Samson.
And the rest as they say is history, as Bruce joined in time to sing on Maiden’s third album The Number Of The Beast, which would catapult them to worldwide stardom and enormous success.
Subsequent albums that followed with Bruce Dickinson in the 1980s included Piece of Mind, Powerslave, Somewhere In Time and Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son, unquestionably among the finest examples of heavy rock/metal music ever recorded.