10 Rock Bands That Destroyed Their Own Legacies

Black Flag threw it all away with one ill-advised decision...

Black Flag
SST

It's a gift for any musician to have a legacy with their music. No matter how much flak comes your way from those around you, it all fades when you look back on a rich catalog of music behind you. At the same time, leaving that spotless track record can be a double-edged sword.

Whenever bands either take a break or retire from making records, the pressure is always on for the band to either reunite or come back together in the studio. Sometimes bands prefer to leave their legacy the way it is, while some emerge from the dead and end up defacing their older work.

Over the years, there have been many bands who have decided that they still have gas left in the tank only to be shown running on empty when it comes time to record. The records may not be bad nor the tours laughable, but this incarnation shows these phenomenal acts as a shadow of their former selves. The hot streak is always fun, but the victory lap is always when you can see the cracks appearing for these artists. Here are the bands whose recent work made us all want to reach for our older CD's for comfort.

10. U2

At the end of the 80's, U2 started to seem like more than just a band. After dominating that decade with epic shows at Live Aid and classic albums like the Joshua Tree, this Irish group were poised to be the next spokesmen of rock. Even into the 90's, their work on albums like Achtung Baby showed how well they could adapt with the changing musical landscape.

Ever since that decade though, any goodwill that the band may have had seemed to dissipate. The band started the millennium off pretty strong with the album All That You Can't Leave Behind, but nowadays they have taken creative ventures that have led to musical dead ends. Instead of thriving by expanding on their classic sound, some of the band's output like "Get On Your Boots" feel more like Bono and the Edge trying to catch up with the poppy trends of the modern day.

It also didn't help when one of their better records, Songs of Innocence, was practically forced upon all Apple users upon the day of release. Bands will typically do whatever they can to reach the best demographic, but the idea of just giving away your music regardless of whether your audience wants it was bound to backfire.


9. The Doors

The Doors are essential listening for anyone remotely interested in rock music. Their mix of blues, jazz, rock, and avant garde opened the doors for bold new musical ventures down the road. At the heart of all the chaos was always the booming voice and captivating stage presence of Jim Morrison.

So how do you squander the potential of one of the greatest groups in rock and roll? Simple: strip them of what made them great in the first place. After the band's great blues swansong LA Woman, Jim Morrison moved to Paris, where he wrote poetry and spent time him with his girlfriend before his sudden death from heart failure. Rather than call it quits, the band decided to continue playing the same music they had always played.

It's completely understandable for these guys to still grow as musicians, but the following albums they released under the Doors name really put a damper on the band's stellar album run. Whereas most of the early Doors records felt primal and dangerous, these albums were bland caricatures of the music that made the 60's great. The band eventually folded and occasionally reunited to celebrate their early work, but the last days of the Doors made America's most notorious band sound tame.


8. Guns N Roses

Guns N Roses were one of the saving graces coming from LA in the late 80's. In an age when most bands were trying to out-pretty one another with their platform shoes and gigantic hair, these guys brought a certain authenticity back into rock and roll on their album Appetite for Destruction.

Even when the grandiose Use Your Illusion records came out, it still felt like an extension of the sewer rat rock and rollers we always knew. Once the band got back from touring though, no one really felt on the same page anymore. Frontman Axl Rose insisted on going forward with his own musical ambitions, which the rest of the band had gotten completely fed up with.

By the mid-90's, fans were dealt a gut punch when everyone in the band sans Axl left the group, leaving Rose as the only member with the rights to the Guns N Roses name. It eventually took 14 years and a countless musicians roster before Rose finally came through with a new album from GNR, which was met with mixed results to say the least. The band could have certainly gotten back to their roots years ago, but too much time has gone by to expect anything truly spellbinding from this band anymore.


7. Van Halen

At the start of the 80's, Van Halen were quickly becoming one of the biggest bands in the world. From their sellout tours to the amazing live shows, the band were truly masters of their craft and even managed to overcome the departure of David Lee Roth with powerhouse vocalist Sammy Hagar.

After Sammy left though, the initial cracks in the Van Halen ship started to show. The band quickly thought to replace Hagar with Gary Cherone, but the album they made with him out front left many hard rockers feeling burned. Even when the band was still great from a musical point of view, they simply couldn't get it together when it came to find someone to sing the tunes.

Though they may have had a chequered past, the band reassembled with Roth for a tour and album cycle, but the actual results seemed to be the Van Halen brothers resting on their laurels rather than just playing what they want to play. The band even diluted their old magic even further when the rest of the guys kicked out Michael Anthony based on his friendship with Sammy Hagar. There are a lot of bands who live off their previous work, but it seems that Van Halen are more concerned that you only know the past works that they think are important.


6. The Stooges

The Stooges were a gift to the world of hard rock when they burst out of the Detroit club scene in the late 60's. The band captured the essence of rock and roll with some of the most furious guitars of the day and the wild antics of frontman Iggy Pop.

After the release of the album Raw Power, the band fell apart due to creative disagreements and drug problems. While it's a shame to see one of the best acts burn out, the band's back catalog remained absolutely spotless given their limited output. Once the band decided to emerge from the dead in the 2000's, many of those ravenous fans from the early days were absolutely psyched.

The shows were certainly as chaotic as ever, but fans were not really feeling that same spirit once they heard the new material. The band's followup albums The Weirdness and Ready to Die seemed too verge on the wrong side of chaotic and ended up just being ear-piercing to those who preferred the classic garage rock bombast of the band's early works. They could still play their asses off on the live stage from time to time, but the idea of having another great Stooges album may be lost forever .


5. KISS

Whether you or not you even liked the music of KISS, you can't deny their identity as true originals in the rock genre. Inspired by acts like Alice Cooper, the band combined the right amount of shock, horror, and fun to create the ultimate rock and roll show that has remained unmatched to this day.

The songwriting chops on Gene Simmons and Paul Stanley have also produced many bangers throughout the years, but their statements to the press have led to more than a few questionable stances. From day one, Gene Simmons has always been upfront about his more selfish personality, but the actual business practices the band have engaged in make them feel less like a band and more of a brand in the same vein as Nike or Disney.

While the bands was known as a collective outfit in the spirit of the Beatles, the all-for-one attitude quickly faded after the band made their way into the 80's. The music was still intact, but there was no question as to which members steered the ship. In the most glaring insult to their early days, the band are now dressing up other players to perform in the makeup and character personas of former members Ace Frehley and Peter Criss. They may still be rocking and rolling all night, but the initial magic seems to have been tapped a long time ago.


4. Black Flag

After the Ramones took the music world by storm in the late 70's, many young kids took that manic energy and transformed it into hardcore punk. While bands like Bad Brains and Minor Threat held their own on the East Coast, Black Flag were the one hardcore bands that felt like they could lead a cultural revolution.

Under the watchful eye of Greg Ginn, the band expanded their sound to include the heaviest music known to rock, from the relentless energy of Damaged to the feral shrieks of My War. Not only were these tracks great for the hardcore scene, but also signaled the change in musical direction later down the line with the rise of grunge.

After the band reassembled in the early 2010's though, What The... left most fans feeling heartbroken. Instead of having that unfiltered aggression of their early years, this felt like a lurching experience with Ginn just showing up to cash a check. At that point, the Black Flag offshoot band OFF ended up sounding closer to the band's original sound than the ACTUAL BAND did. Bands are ever-evolving beasts, but these days it feels like Black Flag are only around to keep the band name alive.


3. The Smiths

No one's collection of alternative rock is complete without at least one of the Smiths' records. The band were pivotal in bridging the gap between post-punk and alternative rock with their songwriting smarts and the melodramatic themes laced throughout their music.

Though the band called it quits years ago, any ounce of happy memories fans have had from that time have been squandered by the ongoing antics of Morrissey. Regardless of the decade, the Smiths frontman has not minced words when discussing his more outlandish opinions. Ever since the band's single "Meat Is Murder," we understood the man's veganism, but his views verge on the wrong side of preachy when he insists that no stadium he performs in should serve any food containing meat. His ongoing political views have also left to more fans facepalming than he may have wanted to.

While it may still be great to listen to tracks like "There Is a Light That Never Goes Out," it also feels a bit strange knowing who exactly that voice is singing those tracks. In music, it's normally easily to separate the artist from the art, but it seems that with every other day Morrissey finds a way to test that theory with yet another controversial stance.


2. Weezer

It seemed like such an innocent time when Weezer first broke onto the scene with their colorful Blue Album. After months of depression following Kurt Cobain's passing, many rock fans found their way back from the edge with these nerd rockers. Instead of singing about how hurt you were, rock seemed to be a little more fun again.

Though the band's followup Pinkerton didn't fare too well in its time, the record is now regarded as a modern classic. Once the band regrouped after a few years apart though, their vision seemed to be less on their original sound and more on stepping into different territory.

It's perfectly fine for a band to experiment, but the band's ventures into new musical styles have led to many disappointments over the years. For every record like Maladroit, there's a record like Raditude that comes in that leaves Weezer looking like dads trying to catch up with the trendy music of today. The band did seem to be on the upswing with their latest albums, but further screwups like Pacific Daydream have left many fans questioning the band's motives. These days it's a toss up whether the band's latest record will be good or bad, but it seems that the band will continue to go their own way regardless of their past mistakes.


1. Stone Temple Pilots

Stone Temple Pilots always seemed to be dealt a bad hand from the moment they got popular. Though their first few records were great, many just saw the band as copycats of other alternative artists like Pearl Jam, who had just emerged out of the rainy city of Seattle.

With time though, the band seemed to have proven their detractors wrong by making records that stand on their own despite the rip-off connotations. Albums like Purple show the band distancing themselves from their influences and creating something fresh and exciting for the alternative scene.

As time progressed further though, the band were more often than not kneecapped by frontman Scott Weiland's drug problems, which led to some subpar albums in the 2000's. After Weiland's devastating death, the band decided to continue on with a new singer in Jeff Gut.

What could have been a return to form ended up being the sound of a band milking their legacy, with songs that sounded like pale imitations of their earlier work. Instead of sounding like lost relics from the past, these new tunes just sound like a band desperately trying to make lightning strike twice. There have always been drops in quality between albums, but the STP going these days feels more like a tribute act rather than their own creative entity.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97