10 Rock Bands That Survived Key Members Leaving
Sometimes you have to keep on jamming.
Ever since the rise of John, Paul, George and Ringo in the early '60s, there's something about bands that we've all fallen in love with.
Music that comes from a group, as opposed to something produced by someone going solo, just has a different feel to it. There are dynamics and energies that come through in songs that could have only emerged because of the time a band as spent together, and the psychic-like understanding they carve out.
Personalities start to become more recognisable and we, as fans, come to know a band's lineup on a level that we usually reserve for family members or close friends.
However, the cut-throat world of music has shown time and time again that it rarely remains like that for as long as we would like. Being such a creative passion, ideas and feelings about styles or direction have constantly led to arguments among band members and broken up even the most successful of groups.
Sometimes, great rock bands lose a key member, but still manage to churn out the hits without them...
10. Glen Matlock - The Sex Pistols
The driving force behind Britain's punk movement in the 1970s, The Sex Pistols are one of the most influential bands in the history of music. Glen Matlock was an art student who worked in Sex Pistols manager Malcolm McClaren's clothing shop and was introduced to Pistols guitarist Steve Jones and drummer Paul Cook in 1974.
He helped to write 10 of the 12 songs on the Pistols' only album, Never Mind The !*$%, and toured regularly with the group during their first year or so of their stint. Glen was generally seen as being something of an outcast in the group, clashing with Johnny Rotten over the Pistols' controversial lyrics and regularly being accused of not being punk enough for the band.
Glen was replaced by Sid Vicious in February 1977 and the band continued their upward trajectory to becoming the world's biggest punk band. They publicly signed with A&M records in front of Buckingham Palace in March, signed with Virgin Records in May and released God Save The Queen in the same month. The band were at the height of their power and commenced some seriously hyped tours of the UK, Netherlands and North America before eventually disbanding in 1978.
9. Blondie Chaplin - The Beach Boys
Hailing from Durban South Africa and making his name originally with The Flames when he was just 13 years old, Blondie Chaplin joined up with American group The Beach Boys in 1972 after drummer Dennis Wilson suffered a hand injury. The Beach Boys had soared to superstardom in the 1960s with their innovative and lighthearted summer hits that reflected the teenage California generation who were all into surfing, cars and romance.
Blodies's arrival coincided with a huge restructuring of the group's musical direction however, releasing the more soulful sounding albums Carl and the Passions - So Tough in 1972 and Holland in 1973. Blondie would take over singing duties throughout his time in the band, however an argument with business manager Steve Love resulted in Blondie departing in late 1973.
The Beach Boys kept going however, releasing 10 more studio albums following Blondie's departure. Active in the music world pretty much non-stop for sixty years now, they have amassed sales of well over 100 million, were inducted into the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame in 1988 and would produce 9 films of some of their very best shows from across their career.
8. Stuart Cable - Stereophonics
Raised in Cwmaman, a tiny village in Wales, Kelly Jones, Richard Jones and Stuart Cable had been playing music at local clubs and bars for years together before they formed Stereophonics in 1995. In fact, Stuart and Kelly had lived on the same street in Cwmaman and it was only through hearing him playing the drums in his dad's garage that led to Kelly inviting Stuart to jam with him.
Stereophonics would break the UK market with their debut album Word Gets Around in 1997, commencing a world tour and winning a BRIT Award as best new band. With Stuart in the lineup, Stereophonics would release four acclaimed albums and score some big chart hits with songs like The Bartender and the Thief, Just Looking and Have A Nice Day.
However, by 2003 it was clear that Stuart was losing interest in the group. He routinely missed practice rehearsals and live shows and openly stated that he couldn't see the band getting much bigger. He was fired on the eve of Stereophonics releasing their best ever song Dakota and they remain heavily active to this day.
7. Joey Jordison - Slipknot
Since their formation back in 1995, Slipknot have not been a band that have shied away from a reshuffle in personal; the iconic Iowa heavy metal outfit have fielded 16 different members over their 7 unique studio albums and 16 live tours. Arguably no departure hit the Maggots harder than the firing of drummer Joey Jordison in 2013.
Living and breathing everything Slipknot since arriving at rehearsals in the mid '90s, Joey was the fuel behind the band's crazy-paced, aggressive style that has since become so iconic. His infectious energy behind the kit and memorable moments on stage has helped make him a real favourite with metal heads right across the community.
Maggots all around the world were shocked when they woke up to the news that Joey had left the band in December 2013. Work had just begun on a fourth studio album, however it was revealed that Joey had not contributed anything to the release and would not be appearing on it.
The band have gone on to recover from Joey's absence however, releasing 2 albums since his departure with another more experimental record set to be released soon. They remain arguably the most influential heavy metal band in North America and still continue to pack out their live shows with passionate fans from all around the world.
6. Peter Hook - New Order
New Order were formed after Joy Division lead singer Ian Curtis' death in 1980, with Peter Hook reprising his role on the bass and even picking up the microphone for Dreams Never End and Doubts Even Here in 1981.
Peter's unique plays style developed further with New Order, utilising his infamous high bassline and gradually exploring more synthesised effects as the group delved more and more towards their iconic electronic sound. Whilst Peter reunited with the band following their hiatus in 1998, by 2007 he had announced that he was no longer working with lead singer Bernard Sumner.
The news shook the New Order fanbase to the core, and there was plenty of speculation about whether that was the band finished for good. However, original keyboardist Gillian Gilbert and Tom Chapman from Bad Lieutenant were recruited up and the group embarked on a live world tour. Since Hook's departure, the new look New Order have recorded two studio albums with each of them accompanied by a successful tour of North America and Europe.
Peter launched a lawsuit against New Order in 2015, claiming he hadn't been cut a fair deal from New Order's earnings. Everything was settled by 2017 however, allowing both parties to continue on with their successful careers.
5. Tony McCarroll - Oasis
Whilst both Noel and Liam Gallagher have had their fair share out bust ups and walk outs during Oasis' time at the top, Tom McCarroll was the first instance of someone walking out on the group and not coming back.
Tony was a friend of Noel and Liam Gallagher during childhood and was actually a member of the band that would become Oasis before the brothers, having formed The Rain with Paul 'Bonehead' Arthurs and Paul McGuigan. Whilst they might have been friends initially, tensions began to mount between Tony and Noel in particular, with Noel regularly 'forgetting' Tony's name in interviews and claiming that he wasn't up to the task of performing a number one hit.
Tony was however a more than capable drummer in Oasis' early rise, most notably in Supersonic which he helped co-write. He walked away from the band in April 1995 however, and launched a controversial lawsuit against Oasis in 1999 which resulted in an out-of-court settlement of £550,000.
Oasis would go on to become one of the key players in the Cool Britannia Britpop era, reaching their peak in the years immediately surrounding McCarroll's dismissal. They released six more albums, went on seven more world tours and produced arguably their biggest hits in Champagne Supernova, Don't Look Back In Anger and Wonderwall.
4. Lol Tolhurst - The Cure
Whilst Robert Smith has become the face of the band, The Cure owes an awful lot of its to founding member Lol Tolhurst. Having known Robert since they were both 5 years old, Lol was one of The Cure's original trio, starting out life in the band as the group's drummer. His unique style can be heard in some of The Cure's best works, including Boys Don't Cry, A Forest and Let's Go To Bed.
Following the Pornography tour in 1982, Lol continued to flex his musical muscle by moving over to the keyboards, coinciding nicely with the band's increasing popularity Stateside. Lol worked on 7 studio albums with The Cure, however it was clear that by 1989 personal issues were starting to catch up with him. He was asked to leave the band during the recording of Disintegration, the band's eighth album, bringing an end to 13 years of association.
Lol was credited on Disintegration, but did play anything on the album. The album became the band's very best however, selling more than 3 million copies and giving the world hits such as Lovesong, Lullaby, Fascination Street and Pictures of You. The Cure are still going strong to this day, regularly touring across the world and possessing one of the biggest fanbases in the world of rock.
3. Peter Gabriel - Genesis
Formed by Charterhouse School pupils Tony Banks, Mike Rutherford, Anthony Phillips and Peter Gabriel, Genesis were a band that quickly became all about Peter. His charismatic looks, on-stage presence and brash personality might have been too much for his fellow members to handle by the end, but it was the launchpad behind the group's initial success in mainland Europe, the UK and then eventually across the pond to the US.
Critics and incoming fans of the band seemed to be so much more preoccupied with Peter's antics that the idea of there even being a Genesis without him seemed impossible. However, the group still consisted of the undeniably talented core of Mike Rutherford, Tony Banks, Steve Hackett and the legendary Phil Collins on drums.
After failing to find a singer with the natural tone to carry the Genesis direction, Phil Collins volunteered to sing vocals on a couple of the album's songs. When that went well, he was chosen to be the new frontman of the band. From sitting on the brink of extinction, Genesis went on to record their most successful period to date, with 10th studio album Duke alone spending two straight weeks atop the UK charts.
2. Mick Jones - The Clash
The Clash are one of the most important Rock bands of all time, having dominated the British punk world in the late '70s. Having met lead singer Joe Strummer at a squat in 1976, the original group began jamming at an abandoned railway warehouse in Camden Town and made their first stage debut opening for the Sex Pistols later that year.
Mick and Joe were the two driving forces behind the band's entire direction, with the pair splitting lead guitarist and songwriting duties as The Clash were suddenly catapulted to super stardom. The duo easily began to hit their peaks in 1979 with the release of London Calling, still one of the most acclaimed albums ever released, with Mick's own Train in Vain a definite highlight.
A power struggle between Mick and Joe would soon develop however, with tensions mounting to the point where Mick was fired in September 1983. A hugely popular and important individual for both band and fans, The Clash would indeed continue on without Mick, though it's debatable whether they were really at their peak again following his dismissal.
1. Syd Barrett - Pink Floyd
Legendary British rock band Pink Floyd were formed all the way back in 1965 and were absolutely crucial in the formation of progressive rock as a genre. Originally named the Tea Set, frontman Syd Barrett coined the name Pink Floyd Sound when he heard that another band had the same name at a local gig.
Syd was Pink Floyd's original lead singer, guitarist and principal songwriter, wowing audiences with his distinct singing accent and free flowing, innovative guitar techniques. With Syd at the helm, Pink Floyd would write their debut album The Piper at the Gates of Dawn in 1967 and start work on their second release A Saucerful of Secrets in 1968. However, by the late '60s it was clear that Syd's psychadelic drug abuses and mental health were deteriorating beyond control and the group eventually voted to move on without him.
Even without their star frontman, Pink Floyd went onto write 13 more acclaimed albums, open 12 live world tours and establish a legacy of being one of the best bands of all time. On top of their music, the group went on to record scores for films such as Zabrieski Point and The Committee.