10 Rock Collaborations That Made Absolutely No Sense

Team-Ups That No One Knew They Wanted.

Aerosmith Run DMC
YouTube

Music has always been about the more collaborative spirit. Especially in this age where every genre is concaving in on one another, it's almost the order of the day to have songs that feature different guests appearing on every major event record. Some might be the peanut butter/chocolate comparison...and other times you get stuff like this.

Compared to some of the more obvious choices, the decisions that these artists made to collaborate with each other almost feel like oil and water when you look back on them. Whether it's because of an obvious mismatch of influences or just no real chemistry on and off the stage, these collaborations left more than a few of us scratching our heads as to why they would even want to work together in the first place. Some of these just shouldn't work, and yet they ended up succeeding with flying colors.

Though some of these aren't necessarily among the best work from the respective artists, they still have the same workman-like spirit and a genuine sense of fun whenever you hear them. Not only were these a rare feat in their day, but they also proved to be influential later down the line, eventually founding whole new genres of their own. At the very least, you can tell they had fun making these songs, and they're damn fun to listen to as well.

10. Blink-182/The Cure

Throughout most of pop punk's tenure, you could usually count on artists making songs that are more tame and family friendly than the glory days of punk. No matter how edgy they may have sounded like when we were kids, it's not that easy to divorce the soundtrack of something like Simple Plan and New Found Glory from the pool party you hosted in the 5th grade. So to have one of the stalwarts of the genre actually go down the goth pop route is still mindblowing.

Granted, it's not like getting to this point was a relative cakewalk for Blink-182. Across their untitled record, Tom DeLonge was clearly getting on a different creative page than the rest of the group, wanting to explore more atmospheric sounds apart from songs like All the Small Things. Though there wasn't a lot of common ground, they did have one shared interest in the Cure on All of This.

Segueing perfectly out of Easy Target, this is the kind of plodding rhythm that the golden age of synth pop would have loved, which is made even more heavenly when Robert Smith appears and lays his shaky voice on top of it all. As much as this is a new flavor of Blink that what we expected, it's still smooth all the same.


9. John Lennon/Frank Zappa

After the Beatles' breakup, every single member of the Fab Four used their newfound independence to get delightfully weird. While Ringo's solo outings were being treated as nothing more than a novelty in the years since, it was a trip seeing Paul McCartney reignite the magic with Wings and George Harrison writing odes to the Eastern spiritualism that he had adopted. John Lennon though...he got cues from the CEOs of weird rock and roll.

Being one of the many collaborative efforts that Lennon did with Yoko Ono, Some Time In New York City really felt like he was trying to capture a moment in time, with an album cover and song topics that seem ripped from the headlines like Attica State and New York City. Though the album itself is fine, the ultra weird bits are saved for the second disc, where we are treated to a live gig recording featuring Frank Zappa performing with the Lennons.

This was in prime Zappa territory too, where he was just starting to reach that kind of organized sense of strange that Lennon gravitated towards. While the resulting shows were a bit mixed between both the fans and the Lennons themselves, this is still a nice peek into the creative process and seeing the other side of what made the Smart Beatles' mind tick.


8. Foo Fighters/Zac Brown

Most fans who are engrained in the sound of the Foo Fighters typically know what they are getting. From the loud guitars that populate every single track to the heady introspective moments that pop up every now and again, Dave Grohl's tried and true approach to rock music has a few more common patterns revealing themselves as the years go on. With Sonic Highways though, they still had a few right turns up their sleeve on Congregation.

Looking to go to different studios around the country and record a song in them, this was the product of going into Nashville, Tennessee, which is almost palpable when listening to the shimmery guitars on display here. As much as that could have been the country flair starting up, the real shock comes in the back half when you hear a sort of classical solo brought into the mix.

At first, this kind of thing feels like it fits in the wheelhouse of Chris Shiftlett, until you see the video and realize that it is country superstar Zac Brown behind the fretboard. Aside from his jam band style, Brown was always a bit of a monster behind the fretboard, and this understated take on more classical pieces is a welcome switch up where the Foos would have just put a regular solo. Though Sonic Highways doesn't hold up as coherent as it could have been, this was a good example of when that experimental side worked.


7. Nick Cave/Kylie Minogue

Whenever you throw on any album by Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, you aren't really expecting the most cheery of experiences. After all, with over fifty different shades of black in his songwriting arsenal, why would you come to the guy who wrote songs like Red Right Hand for something optimistic and hopeful? Well...why not take that guy...and put him together with one of the biggest pop stars of the '80s?

For the duet Where the Wild Roses Grow, Cave enlisted Kylie Minogue to guest with him on the track, which makes about as much sense as if Angus Young contributed a verse to a Kendrick Lamar track. And yet through some miracle, these two play off each other so well, as Cave dives back into his lower register and manages to have a shred of levity and empathy in his voice.

As much as this makes for a weird sonic cocktail, Minogue actually manages to meet Cave at his level, going for a much more subdued approach to her own vocals to create a duet that almost seems indebted to the days of classical music. Considering how much moroseness is coated throughout all of Nick Cave's music, it's almost through a work of dark magic that this song was actually able to make it to the final cut.


6. Metallica/Marianne Faithfull

During the interim period between St. Anger and the Black Album, Metallica had gone through one of the more drastic tonal shifts of their entire career. As much as the Load/ReLoad era has its fan, the idea of the thrash metal legends selling out around this time still is a point of contention for longtime aficionados for decades. Then again, when you experiment like this, you occasionally get some highlights from the most unexpected places.

Being the big pop single off of ReLoad, the Memory Remains was a bad omen for most fans when listening to the rest of the album, signaling that the sell out territory hadn't worn itself out just yet. Once the chorus hits though, we get a bit of a departure when we hear...what's that?....A WOMAN'S VOICE???

Yeah, instead of James Hetfield singing the unstoppable 'Na Na Na' hook, '60s icon Marianne Faithfull was brought in to deliver the line. As much as this kind of genre whiplash is palpable just saying it out loud, Faithfull actually plays the role brilliantly, almost bringing a sinister edge by embodying the faded prima donna in the lyrics. The chorus has even become somewhat of a fan favorite in the years since, as the crowd normally sings the part whenever it's played in concert. For as wrong as this sounds on paper, sometimes you need a little bit of crazy to steer you in the right direction.


5. Devin Townsend/Chad Kroeger

The entire discography of Devin Townsend might seem a bit much for your fairweather metal fan to really take in. While not being the most complex musical outfit out there, the raw execution of Townsend's solo outings and his work with Strapping Young Lad feels not so much like songs but musical skyscrapers with a melody over the top. Sometimes the foundations are so secure that you don't even notice the butt rock on display right in front of you.

In one of the more questionable decisions that Townsend has ever pulled, his latest solo outing had a guest contribution from Chad Kroeger of Nickelback on the song Hear Me. As much as the title might suggest, you almost wouldn't hear Kroeger's contributions to the song, as most of the track is coated in Townsend's signature brand of sludgy riffs and amazing soaring melodies.

Granted, if you wanted to hide the fact that you did put a member of Nickelback on your album, this is probably one of the more creative ways to pull that off. This is almost a strange form of music flexing on Devin's part, proving that he can put anyone on a record and somehow make it work. See...now you have at least one song that features a member of Nickelback that is actually half decent for a change.


4. Aerosmith/Run-DMC

There's probably a certain stripe of rock fan who wants to take a knife to whoever thought that mixing rock and hip hop was a good idea. Given the amount of dumb music that has come from the likes of Limp Bizkit throughout the years, it's not like the eras of rap rock have been exactly mesmerizing from front to back. However, in the early days of the '80s, Aerosmith and Run-DMC made everything sound like a good time.

During the breaking in period when Run-DMC was first starting to gain traction outside of New York, their producer Rick Rubin turned them onto the song Walk This Way and convinced to cut their own version of it. As much as this idea sounds dreadful on paper, Aerosmith's classic song already has the bones of a great hip hop beat, as Steven Tyler's lines are focused more on the rhythm of the words than their actual carnal meaning.

Flipping the song on its head, the contributions from Joe Perry and Steven Tyler on the final version was enough to bring the Bad Boys From Boston out of the doldrums as well, making them starlets of the '80s for a second time around. Complete with a video of them literally breaking down barriers to perform with one another, this is the kind communal musical vibe that needs to happen more in rock music.


3. Green Day/Tom Petty

Ever since the release of Dookie, Green Day seemed to be in a little bit of a slump. Even though albums like Insomniac and Nimrod had their fair share of amazing songs on them, there was always those lingering pop punk fans who felt a bit cheated out of not getting a retread of something like Basket Case or Longview again. You think that's bad though...wait until Warning when everything was kicked into overdrive.

Being informed by more classic rock, much of this album is focused on folky styles of songwriting, as Billie Joe Armstrong pulls influences from heartland rock and even '60s rock and roll. You don't pull something like that off alone though, and Green Day actually managed to get a little bit of credibility by hiring session musician Benmont Tench to provide keyboards on the record.

Long before being a behind the scenes guy, Tench had always been a founding member of Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers, with a rustic rock sound that works perfectly playing off of Armstrong's Beatles pastiches like Deadbeat Holiday and Hold On. As much as the core fanbase of the band might not have been all that down on a project like this, there's a good chance that the beginnings of Green Day's upswing starts right here rather than American Idiot.


2. Rush/Aimee Mann

Ever since starting out, Rush's music was always centered around an evolving musical idea. Though they always fit in the realm of prog rock in their time, there was no real genre of music that was really off the table for these Canadian icons, going from long prog stretches to the sounds of reggae and synth rock in the '80s. While most devotees were along for the ride, the inclusion of Aimee Mann was definitely a change of pace no one saw coming.

Fresh off of their synth period album Power Windows, the opening single from Hold Your Fire was a real refresher on Time Stand Still, as we get an actual female voice working off of Geddy Lee's already high tenor voice. Then again, it's a stretch to really call something like this a duet though, as Mann really just operates to say the song's title and occasionally harmonize with Ged as he takes the reigns through most of the song.

It does function as a great duet all the same though, as Rush end up using Mann's voice as a garnish in this already delicious music confection that they've created. As much as this song has the '80s tattooed on its forehead, the amount of hooky material on here is enough to save it from being too dumb for its own good.


1. Gorillaz/Lou Reed

It's no secret that Gorillaz has always been about collaboration since day one. In case you're not in on everything, this is actually not a musical outfit made up of cartoon characters writing pop songs. No...Damon Albarn is the mastermind behind the collaborations, and he hit upon a stroke of genius by drafting in Lou Reed on Some Kind of Nature.

For any rock fan though, Reed's 2010's work is not particularly a highlight, considering his lackluster collaboration with Metallica just a year or two later on Lulu. Though still in his low spoken word croon, his inclusion on this track is Reed at his most perfect, acting as a sort of experienced poet trying not to be taken over by the more mechanical aspects of the Gorillaz sound.

Playing off the beat perfectly, Reed's slipshot delivery adds a lot more humanity to the rest of the track, which gets even more mindblowing when his speech starts to get chopped up little by little once his verse ends. Going along with the plastic beach theme, it's almost as if you're hearing the machinery win, as the human side of things becomes more and more mechanical with each passing note. Say what you want to about Lou Reed fading from relevancy, but this is almost on par with anything he did in his glory years.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97