10 Rock Cover Songs Better Than The Original

Sometimes, the second time's the charm...

Taking Dawn The Chain
Roadrunner

Living in a world full of reboot culture, it only seems fitting that cover songs are a staple to the music industry and help us to identify with a band right away with a song that is familiar to us. Now, this is a touchy subject because nobody wants to hear that their favorite song or musician was shown up by a later band doing a cover, but when it comes down to it, sometimes, just sometimes a cover turns out better than the original.

This is not to say that the original artists of these songs did not write or play good music, quite on the contrary. If the songs were not good, other bands would not want to cover them or get inspiration from them. With the following list, these are examples of bands that have taken great songs and taken them even further to help them be cemented as iconic music across generations.

With that in said, join me through this list as we discuss 10 bands that swung and knocked these cover songs out of the park.

10. “She” By Green Day – Covered By Mad Caddies

In Mid 2018 The Ska/punk band Mad Caddies released “Punk Rocksteady”, which is a collection of punk songs curated by Fat Wreck chords owner and NoFX front man Fat Mike, for the Caddies to cover. “She” was the first single released and right away took punk fans by storm by giving them a rendition of a Green Day song we can endure.

With tons of controversy amongst fans on the subject of whether Green Day is even a punk band, this cover song at least shows us that they can write songs that can hold up in punk culture. The Ska spin that Mad Caddies gives to this song helps it soar far and above the original by creating an even more catchy version of the song, and one that any ska and punk fan can get behind.


9. "Comedown" By Bush – Covered By Mayday Parade

Anyone who grew up in the 90’s grunge era knows this song and band as being one of the most iconic of the 90’s. While there is absolutely no disputing how great the original is with its undeniable 90’s sound and Gavin Rosdale’s solid delivery on vocals, the cover from Mayday Parade brings a fresh approach to the song.

By delivering clean and smooth instrumentals, including some surprise piano, Mayday Parade took this already amazing song and turned it into a full composition that is worthy of competing with, and in this case edging out the original song with a more power and full composition.


8. "Runaway" By Kanye West, Pusha T – Covered By Silverstein

It is always a good time when a band covers a song way outside of their genre, especially when it is the Ontario based Silverstein, named after children’s author, Shel Silverstein.

This Canadian based pop punk band took on the task of covering “Runaway” for the Punk Goes Pop 4 album and took this hip-hop ballad about being a dirt bag and mashed it into a rock/hip hop song that is even more powerful and enjoyable than the original.

By adding in harder guitar a punk lyrical sound, Silverstein gives the song an edgier and more passionate sound, while still retaining the original sound and flow of the song.


7. "The World Has Turned And Left Me Here" By Weezer – Covered By Punchline

While Weezer wrote a great song, and continue to write great music, their songs never seem to have enough power behind them and always leave me wanting. With the original version sounding like every other pop punk song of the 90’s, the cover by Punchline is a very pleasant update of the song.

Punchline did a great job of covering this song in a way that allows it to still sound very close to the original, but by amping up the guitar and delivering smoother vocals, they have created a more enjoyable version of this song.


6. "The Chain" By Fleetwood Mac – Covered By Taking Dawn

Sure it's controversial to challenge any truly iconic song, but here we are at “The Chain” by Fleetwood Mac, a wonderful British-blues song that is already iconic, and has now been introduced to newer generations by being featured in 2017’s Guardian’s Of The Galaxy 2.

However, just 7 years prior to that movie, the song had been covered by Taking Dawn who gave it a spectacular southern rock/nu-metal makeover. Changing up the overall song to be something more akin to a metal ballad with some twangy southern guitar riffs, Taking Dawn amps this song up to 11, blasting you with almost even more passion than felt in the original.


5. "Real World" By Matchbox 20 – Covered By State Champs

Here is another song known for being an iconic 90’s alternative song, and if you are like me, it lost its charm back long ago from being overplayed on the radio and every store Musak system until the early 00’s.

Luckily, State Champs came around in 2019 to cover this song and give it a much-needed refresh. Putting more emphasis on strong guitar and instrumentals, State Champs took this song that I was sick of hearing and made me enjoy listening to it regularly. By delivering more ear pleasing vocals and more powerful instrumentals in the background, State Champs turned this song from a slow boring 90’s alt song, to a much more enjoyable 00’s pop punk song.


4. "Centerfold" By J. Geils Band – Covered By [spunge]

The original version of this song is definitely a product of its era, being a 1981 release it sounds like every other song in the 80’s, and to me does not stick out as strongest song from that era, but nonetheless it is still an enjoyable 80’s pop song. Sounding more like an Oingo Boingo song than anything that would really stick out as having its own sound or style.

Fast Forward to 2013 and the release of the Greatest Hits Album by [spunge]. Channeling a more 90’s era pop punk/ska sound [spunge] took this song from sounding like any other song rehashed from the 80’s and ended up with a cover that sounds like it should be part of every 90’s and 00’s playlist.

By pulling inspiration from the sound of bands like The Offspring and Zebrahead, [spunge] gave the world a much more enjoyable version of this song.


3. "Loser" By Beck – Covered By Punchline

You will remember Punchline from number 7 in the list, and they are just so good at doing covers that they earned themselves a second spot on the list with their cover of “Loser” by Beck. I am going to come right out with it and say that for me the number 1 reason this song is better than the original is because I can understand it.

While the instrumentals and song sound fairly like the original, Punchline delivers stronger and clearer vocals than Beck, with the bonus of not having the monotone Beck has when he is speak singing. Amping up the sound with electric guitar and fully singing the lyrics as opposed to speak singing, allowed Punchline to deliver a stronger performance and a more memorable version of this song that you can proudly blast while driving around town.


2. "Stand By Me" By Ben E King – Covered By Pennywise

With this song being from the 60’s it is naturally very dated, but like the other songs on this list was a hit in it’s time and has proven to be an iconic song being used regularly in movies, commercials and video games in the last few decades. Having been covered by several bands, there are many great versions of this song, but my personal favorite cover of this song comes from the California based punk band, Pennywise.

Simply put, Pennywise takes this dated 60’s song and turns it into a punk classic. Starting off the song in the standard form to the original, the song transitions into full punk speed, sound, complete with swear words and never slows down from that point. For me, this made it feel like Pennywise really put themselves and their heart into the song, causing it to be more impactful and soulful than the original.


1. "Lean On Sheena" By Joe Gittleman – Covered by The Bouncing Souls

Lastly, we have an original song that pretty much never had a chance. Originally written and performed by Joe Gittleman, the bass player for the Mighty Mighty Bosstones and front man for Avoid One Thing, the original version of this song is boring, bland and does not feel like it has much passion behind it.

Luckily The Bouncing Souls covered this song a mere 4 years after released by Avoid One Thing and have become so synonymous with the song that most fans don’t know it is a cover song. By injecting their tried and true east coast punk sound, The Bouncing Souls blew this song so far out of the water that it could not be anything but number 1 on this list.


Contributor

I love music, video games, pop culture and movies. As a classically trained musician, music is my strongest passion and I love discovering new music and quirky, obscure bands.