10 Rock Cover Songs Better Than The Original

Being bold pays off.

johnny cash hurt
Sun Records

In the early days of rock 'n' roll you were more likely to hear a band cover an old rhythm and blues number, then you were to hear them perform original material. Indeed, rock was born out of the development of blues classics, into a more energised and pop centric format.

It takes a certain amount of confidence to cover someone else's music. Sure, that's how everyone starts off learning their respective instruments, but releasing a version of a well established and celebrated track, is another matter.

When it goes well you get Sinéad O'Conner's rendition of Prince's 'Nothing Compares 2 U'. When it goes badly you get Alien Ant Farm's version of 'Smooth Criminal' - what did we do to deserve that piece of garbage? The difference was O'Conner had the talent to create something new, Alien Ant Farm just filtered a Michael Jackson classic through a nu metal filter...

Although the duds might outnumber the successful attempts, there's been enough great covers in the world of rock to warrant an article espousing their brilliance . These are 10 great covers that even surpass the original.

10. The White Stripes: Jolene (Dolly Parton)

Dolly Parton, is the undisputed queen of country music. This women has been recording since she was 13 years old, with a career extending back to the 1950s. With her poetic yet humorous style of lyricism there aren't many country musicians who can hold a match up to Parton.

The notion of Jack White - the king of the garage rock revival - covering the jaunty heartbreak ballad 'Jolene', isn't one that makes all that much sense - that is until you hear it. If anything, he makes the song more emotive, changing the key and delivering a vocal performance that's striking enough cut through you.

White utilised a signature soft verse/ loud chorus approach. The guitar kept things pretty grounded until the chorus, when his furious explorations on the fretboard mirrorord his erratic vocals outcries. When it comes to doing an original take on a very well known track, it doesn't get better to this. From a tender country ballad to an outburst of garage-rock-anguish, this cover version flipped the original on its head, bringing it to an entirely different audience.


9. Joe Cocker: With A Little Help From My Friends (The Beatles)

It almost feels heretical to state that someone could perform a Beatles song better than the Fab Four. It might be a rare occurrence, but it certainly has happened. Forget Hendrix's wildly explosive cover of 'Sgt. Pepper's' for a moment. Joe Cocker's electrified take on 'With A Little Help From My Friends', makes the Beatles' version feel like it's being performed by a fairground covers band on acid - Side note: the Beatles were definitely on acid.

Cocker recorded and released his version of the 1967 track less than a year after it was originally released. It became an instant hit, propelling Cocker to stardom and introducing the world to his erratic onstage demeanour. His live performance at Woodstock '69 gained the track even more notoriety. When Paul McCartney heard Cocker's cover he supposably couldn't believe someone could reinterpret what the Beatles had done and turn it into a soul number.

There's only one version of this track that's worth your time, and that's the Woodstock '69 version; Cocker looks and sounds as though he's possessed by the very spirit of soul music.


8. Iggy Pop: Louie Louie (Richard Berry)

Louis Louis has become a rock standard, covered by everyone from Bruce Springsteen to Patti smith, Otis Redding and Black Flag. The most recognised rendition was the 1963 hit by the Kingsmen. They turned it into a rock n' roll classic, as part of the first wave of surfer rockers to bastardise classic blues numbers. Richard Berry's original recording in 1955 was a far smoother version, in the style of rhythm and blues.

Iggy Pop had been performing the the track since the early '60s, both with his high school group and the Stooges. His rendition was dubbed the 'dirty version' for his insistence on including profanity whenever he sang the lyrics. Although a number of live version exist, the 1993 studio rendition is the one you want.

Pop gave it the punk make over, with grungy guitars driving the melody and dirtbag vocals delivering the attitude. Apart from the chorus, Pop wrote original lyrics to the track, which included references to the fall of the Soviet Union, the AIDS crisis, America's political class and the rise of capitalism.


7. Nirvana: The Man Who Sold The World (David Bowie)

When Bowie dropped 'The Man Who Sold The World' in 1970, he was still several years away from becoming an internationally appreciated icon. By this time he had worked as a producer and a stage performer, and had released several (mostly) unnoticed albums. To those in the industry he was something of an oddity, but not one who was like to bring in the big bucks.

It was only after he debuted his Ziggy character in '72 that people began to take real notice of him and his back catalogue. Eventually his earlier albums became almost as loved as the material that brought him success.

Fast forward two decades and the new icon of rock, Kurt Cobain, was hold up in an MTV studio performing uncharacteristically toned down versions of his raucous grunge numbers. Nirvana's 1994 unplugged performance solidified Cobain as one of the great musicians of the last 40 years. Up until then he was considered a wild and erratic character, delivering an aggressive and raw interoperation of punk and garage rock. Afterwards, it was clear he was a highly sensitive and considered performer. Among the Nirvana hits, the group also performed Bowie's 1970 classic.

Even Bowie himself thought Cobain's take propelled the song into another realm.


6. Guns N' Roses: Live And Let Die (Paul McCartney)

Okay, firstly lets start by acknowledging how brilliant the original Paul McCartney version of this song is. 'Live and Let Die' might be the best Bond theme ever written, excluding maybe Alicia Keys & Jack White's 'Another Way to Die'... , okay and maybe Adele's 'Skyfall'. The point is, it's a damn good song.

If any band was going to take on the ambitious task of covering one of McCartney's greatest arrangements, then it would have to be Guns N' Roses. Axl is the only one with an ego big enough to attempt such a feet, and Slash and the boys are the only musicians talented enough to make it work.

When Axl Rose was coming up with ideas for Use Your Illusion, he and Slash had both mentioned loving the Wings song but were unsure whether or not they could pull it off. Supposedly, Slash tentatively suggested it to the other members during a rehearsal session and before long they'd dialled in the main riff, with the bass and drums arranged around it. The rest is music history.


5. Urge Overkill: Girl, You'll Be A Woman Soon (Neil Diamond)

Urge Overkill's only real claim to fame is being featured in a Quentin Tarantino movie. Even then they were performing someone else track... , but damn did they do a fine job. The original Neil Diamond version is pretty similar but lacked that little bit of bite, brought on by a couple electric guitars and a touch of reverb pedal.

Urge Overkill's version also manages to come across far less creepy than the original. The lyrics of Diamond's 1967 single don't leave much room for ambiguity. He's essentially serenading an underage girl who he's got a thing for - promising that once she becomes a women, she'll need a man to look after her. Clearly Diamond thought he was that man, and his proposition was too good for any girl to refuse... Damn the '60s were a creepy time.

Regardless, Overkill's version managed to circumnavigate these issues, somehow. Most likely due to their version being associated with Uma Thurman dancing around in Pulp Fiction, rather that Diamond's underage love interest.


4. JUNIP : The Ghost Of Tom Joad (Bruce Springsteen)

For those who are not familiar with JUNIP all you need to know is that they're José González on/off group. Before González became the internationally recognised face of melodic folk rock, he was in a group named JUNIP. Throughout his solo career he's picked the project up at serval points, each time harbouring some truly atmospheric result.

JUNIP basically involves González doing his usual breathy and pleasant take on world rock, but he's augmented by a bunch of swirling synthesiser and a drummer. It just adds a little oomph to an otherwise laidback sound.

The group's 2005 EP 'Black Refuge' contained a reserved but evocative rendition of Springsteen's 1995 folk ballad, inspired by a character from the novel 'Grapes of Wrath'. Again, the original version is flawless. Some of Springsteen's best numbers are when he exhibits a more reserved and tender side, and this song is certainly that. He delivers the lyrics in such a whispered manor that you almost have to strain to hear them.

The JUNIP version just turns everything up a notch, taking it from a soft-folk-ballad to a dreamy-world-rock number.


3. Red Hot Chili Peppers: Higher Ground (Stevie Wonder)

Stevie Wonder's 'Higher Ground' is a squelchy masterpiece of funk and soul, perfectly integrated into pure vibe. Wonder's another artist its best not to cover. Like Bob Dylan and the Beatles, he's so highly accomplished that you better be damn sure in your ability if you hope to do his material justice.

The Chilis certainly hadn't received widespread commercial success, or even critical acclaim when they took on this cover. By this point they'd been around for 6 years but their studio endeavours had all been met with lukewarm receptions. What they did have on their side was pure and unharnessed bravado and a passion for funk rock fusion.

You only need to listen to the first second and half of this track to realise the bass line was written for Flea. Slap on some heavy metal guitar - courtesy of John Frusciante - and some arena rock percussion from Chad Smith and you're onto a winner.

1989 was the year the Chili Peppers started to show the world they weren't just a bunch of sex crazed, punk-funk madmen, and this was the track that helped them do it.


2. Johnny Cash: Hurt (Nine Inch Nails)

From the 1970s to the 1990s Johnny Cash existed in the metaphorical wilderness. He was active musically, but barely. His most celebrated work was behind him and during the '80s he was mostly considered a has-been. That all changed when producer Rick Rubin decided to help him revive his career with 'American Recordings' (1994). The album consisted of the Man in Black giving well known songs, the husky Cash treatment.

Up until his death in 2003, Cash continued releasing albums as part of the 'American Series' with his most celebrated being 'American IV: The Man Comes Around'. The track list is filled with wildly stirring renditions of other artist's material. From Sting, Martin Gore and Paul Simon, Cash delivered a number of devastating takes.

Non was more emotive than his unlikely cover of Trent Reznor's 'Hurt', however. He took a song about a young man's pain in finding meaning in a meaningless life, and turned into into a reflective account of a man facing death, haunted by his past misdeeds. Reznor's version is powerful in its own right, but Cash's transcended into something else entirely.


1. Jimi Hendrix: All Along The Watch Tower (Bob Dylan)

It's a given that Jimi Hendrix was one of the most important figures in rock music, and perhaps the most important when it came to the guitar. When he arrived on the scene in the mid to late '60s, it was like a technicolored explosion of musical exploration. People like Eric Clapton and Jeff Beck had been leading the charge up until then, but soon enough they were grabbing at Hendrix's psychedelic coat tails.

Another huge rock monolith at the time was Bob Dylan. From 1965 to 1966 he released three albums that changed the face of rock music. He'd gone from being the darling of the folk scene, to an international rock icon. By 1967 Dylan had changed direction again, however. His eighth album 'John Wesley Harding' saw him drifting back to his folky roots, incorporating more traditional country techniques into his sound.

Dylan's original version of 'All Along The Watch Tower' appeared on the album. It was a stirring but sombre folk balled, with haunting lyrics and an ambiguous narrative. It's considered one of Dylan's greatest songs, both for its unconventional structure and evocative lyrics.

Hendrix took Dylan's masterpiece and found ways to manipulate it like no one else could, filling up the space with his wailing guitar lines, and bubbling, wah-infused licks. Dylan was so in awe of what Hendrix did to the song that he stopped considering it his own.


In this post: 
Johnny Cash
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Before engrossing myself in the written word, I spent several years in the TV and film industry. During this time I became proficient at picking things up, moving things and putting things down again.