10 Rock Music Albums No One Understood At First
How to Get It Wrong.
It’s never easy trying to find your audience in the music world. When you sit down to write something that comes from the heart, there’s almost a stroke of luck that goes into it, almost praying that someone else out there will understand the kind of emotions that you’re dealing with in your songs. It’s nice when they do, but you also shouldn’t be surprised when people don’t really know what to make of it either.
Because even though these albums might be praised to high heaven these days, it wasn’t always like that. If you look back at the way some of these were treated upon release, they were given a pretty good beating, either by the fans who didn’t like the new direction that they went down or critics who thought that these records would tarnish the band’s career.
Everyone’s a critic though, and most of these bands ended up having the last laugh on every one of their haters. As the years have gone by, time has been fairly kind to these records, with the imperfections giving the records character and making them sound much more relevant for what the current music scene is up to. Some of them may have been a little bit ahead of their time, but maybe we just needed to listen a little closer to see what was really there.
10. McCartney II - Paul McCartney
After the dissolution of Wings, Paul McCartney seemed a little bit lost creatively. Although he had been known as the force and the good time spirit behind the Beatles, his new band was starting to fall apart and his infamous drug bust in Japan certainly didn't help matters, with him being detained for a few weeks. The whole lifestyle he was leading just seemed to be too much, and the biggest way around it was for Paul to just be himself when he went into the studio.
Much like his first solo album, McCartney II is the result of Paul just messing around in a recording studio, using different electronic effects to make some wildly zany sounds at the time. Even if something like Temporary Secretary may still be hit and miss for some people, Coming Up sees Paul tapping into the sounds of a band like Talking Heads, along with the back half of the record where he puts together different instrumental sections that are reminiscent of what David Bowie was doing just a few years earlier on Low.
As much as some of Paul's critics were harsh on this record and preferred the now classic sound of Wings, McCartney II has seen a much better reappraisal over the years, with different indie bands commandeering its strange style and even catching the attention of John Lennon, who was inspired to make some new music after hearing it on the radio. Paul may have been a little bit lost trying to find his muse at this time, but his knack for writing melodies never left him in that time either.
9. SAP - Alice in Chains
Everyone flocking to the sounds of Seattle in the early '90s were looking for something a lot more grimy than what was coming out of the Sunset Strip. Around the time that the lower tier glam acts like Warrant were making waves, Alice in Chains were kicking ass and taking names on Facelift, making the best hybrid of metal and alternative music that the world had seen thus far with tracks like Man in the Box and We Die Young. So when those guys suddenly decide to turn all the distortion down, you can understand why people might be upset.
To be fair, Alice never intended to promote SAP all that much, just tucking it into record store shelves and never doing any press for the EP. When they started putting songs like Brother and Got Me Wrong into the set though, they were greeted with boos from the audience, with some fans even throwing things at them until they turned up the guitars again.
Maybe it was just a visceral reaction from one too many years of hair metal ballads, but Alice had something a lot more primal and sad in their acoustic work, where Layne Staley and Jerry Cantrell could harmonize a lot better over the sounds of gentle acoustic playing. Most of the hardcore fans got the picture around the time of Jar of Flies, but for those few years, it looked like the band that was responsible for bringing the heaviness back was about to piss it all away again.
8. OK Computer - Radiohead
For all the styles that rock music has gone through for the past quarter century, OK Computer still feels like it is the future of rock and roll. Much like Nirvana's Nevermind had done at the start of the '90s, Radiohead made a statement with this record about where we could go next as a genre, talking about the dangers of technology while also tapping into what makes most of us human and compassionate to one another at the end of every day. If you had asked their higher ups though, this was just teetering on career suicide most of the time.
Although the Bends help them steer clear of one hit wonder status with songs like High and Dry and Fake Plastic Trees, their label didn't really see the same kind of appeal on a record like this, and the idea of releasing a 6 minute epic like Paranoid Android as a single certainly didn't help matters. Almost to cushion the blow, the label anticipated that this record was going to bomb and figured they would lower their sales expectations to make sure that they earned their money back on this record once it inevitably tanked.
When fans got to hear that 6 minute epic though, it felt like listening to the '90s version of Bohemian Rhapsody, with fans coming out in droves to listen to the record. It may have been a tough lesson to learn, but the label got the message of what Radiohead were about that day. Nothing these guys put out on a record are written with the suits in mind, but the fans will always keep coming back if the band just follows their muse.
7. Load/Reload - Metallica
There tends to be a common debate among thrash fans as to when Metallica got bad. Although the clearest example of them doing wrong is something like St. Anger or Lulu, there were fans who were none too happy with them going all mainstream with the Black Album, even though songs like Sad But True still held their heaviness intact most of the time. If they thought that was bad, no one could have been prepared for what happened after the alternative scene took over.
Almost as a response to the new sounds in rock, both Load and ReLoad were hated upon release, with Metallica having the gall to cut their hair and make songs for the alternative market. If you listen to the actual tracks here though, they tend to be more on the hard rock side of the spectrum, while occasionally throwing in a song that sounds like Alice in Chains here and there. When these albums shine though, they do tap into a different kind of heavy than what we were used to.
Despite an overabundance of ballads that will ruffle some metalhead's feathers, songs like The House that Jack Built and Devil's Dance have a certain bluesy swagger to them, along with some of the more revealing lyrics that James Hetfield would write about his demons before checking himself into rehab. Thrash can only take you so far when trying to write from the heart, and you can't blame Metallica for wanting to follow their muse and make something that was a little left field by most metalheads' standards.
6. A Thousand Suns - Linkin Park
When the nu metal empire started to crash pretty hard, Linkin Park made the best move they could possibly make by going alternative. Although some of the sounds of Minutes to Midnight may have been a bit hit and miss for those who were looking for the heaviness behind songs like Place for My Head or Don't Stay, they needed to shed some of their old skin if they were going to survive for the long haul. When they decided to get more ambitious though, you could see the clear line when metalheads started to jump off the bandwagon.
For all of the risky moves that Linkin Park have made, A Thousand Suns got a pretty decent thrashing by their peers, who thought that the band was going in a more electronic direction and had left rock and roll behind altogether just to make movie soundtrack fodder. While there are some bits and pieces of that sound in this record, their attempt to write a concept record centered around nuclear fallout is actually a lot better than people give it credit for, putting you in the center of the mayhem and making you feel lost in a sea of smoke trying to make sense of everything.
If you had asked the band about what they were trying to do, even they were talking about moving outward from this record, taking inspiration from bands like Radiohead and inadvertently creating a sound that would be copied for decades to come. A Thousand Suns is certainly still a polarizing record, but chances are the more seasoned veterans of pop rock like Twenty One Pilots saw this album as a blueprint when cutting their first tracks.
5. Warning - Green Day
One of the biggest problems with being a pop punk band in the early years of the genre is eventually having to grow up. Just when Green Day started to look like one of the biggest bands in the world in the wake of Dookie, the next few years saw them treading water with both the fans and the critics, with gems like Nimrod and Insomniac never really reaching the same magic as a Basket Case or Welcome to Paradise. Just before they reinvented themselves as storytellers on American Idiot though, fans had really started to question what they were doing on Warning.
As much as the idea of folk rock doesn't feel like it belongs in the same area as Green Day most of the time, this is probably one of the most organic records they have ever made, breaking out the acoustic guitars and Billie Joe Armstrong writing more from the heart about hollow living on songs like Macy's Day Parade and Fashion Victim. Whereas the first handful of Green Day records had their roots in people like The Jam and The Ramones, this feels more in tune with the sounds of people like Tom Petty and even the Kinks, as Billie looks out at an America that seems to be slipping away.
This album should really be credited for its lyrics though, with songs like Minority being the first few times where Billie tried to write something deliberately political and coming out with a classic. Some of the staples of this album may just feel like stop gaps for the band, but the band needed to have songs like Minority under the belt before they even tried to write something like Holiday or American Idiot.
4. Black Sabbath - Black Sabbath
When Black Sabbath first strode onto the rock scene, there was no real way to put them into a box. While the idea of heavy metal may exist now, it was a different story all the way back in 1970, with Sabbath being looked at as the ugly cousins of rock and roll with their devilish music. Once people got the chills running down their spine, they wanted nothing to do with whatever the likes of Ozzy Osbourne were working on.
While songs like the titular track from this album and NIB could be considered modern classics for heavy metal these days, most of the critics were more than happy to give this record a thrashing in their reviews, likening the band to what Cream would have done if they weren't as good. There might have been more than a few low blows from the press, but there was also a growing fanbase bubbling up from the rock scene waiting to be unleashed.
Before Sabbath, the heaviest thing you could listen would be anything from Led Zeppelin to the Rolling Stones, and here we had something that was a lot more in your face and was more than happy to cause a disturbance and unsettle you whenever you turned on the stereo. They may have been a mediocre Cream by their standards, but this wasn't about the blues anymore. This was a new art form, and it was about to blow a hole in the entire rock scene within a matter of just a few years.
3. What's the Story Morning Glory - Oasis
You couldn't really script a more anti establishment act than Oasis in the early days. Even if you wanted nothing to do with their music, The Gallagher Brothers were masters at keeping themselves in the headlines whenever they could, whether it meant their obnoxious behavior at awards shows or putting out a single that consisted of nothing but them arguing and actually having it chart. That may have worked for the kids but not so much with the critics.
After still reeling over the fallout that came with the grunge revolution, there were more than a few critics who were harsh to Oasis for no good reason, seeing them as just being a poor man's version of what the Beatles were trying to do all the way back in the '60s. They may have picked out the Beatles comparisons pretty well, but they really looked out of touch when What's the Story Morning Glory came out, with critics saying that the band had gone soft while their star continued to rise.
This may have been one of the few instances where the hype seemed to kill some of the critics though, making them look more and more old fashioned until they started praising their next record Be Here Now, which both the fans and Noel Gallagher consider to be one of the band's weaker efforts. You can try to predict the future of rock and roll all you want, but the people never really know what they truly want until you actually give it to them.
2. The Stooges - The Stooges
As the '60s started to unfold, the rock scene was starting to get a whole lot more intense on both sides of the Atlantic. The Flower Power generation that had been kickstarted at Woodstock certainly had its place, but there was something a lot more dangerous sounding happening in rock and roll as well, with the British Blues Boom giving us acts like Cream and Led Zeppelin with a bit more power in their delivery. America wanted their say as well though, and the Stooges emerged as one of the biggest horrorshows that rock had seen at that point.
Although the Stooges' first record was meant to be rough around the edges, a lot of critics felt that it was more amateur hour than anything else, with Iggy Pop sounding like some punk kid on the street as the rest of the band strummed basic power chords behind him. That was before you saw them live though, with Iggy raising hell on the stage, which left most of the straight men of rock and roll terrified and running for the doors of the club, with the few stragglers still hanging on every single move that Iggy made onstage.
The public might not have been ready for it yet, but this kind of mayhem that was coming from the stage was the start of a new version of rock and roll, spearheading the punk movement by a few years and also paving the way for the more urgent and disgusting sounds that would come out of metal and even grunge music much later. Iggy may not have been the most likely person to be considered a role model at the time, but it's not a bad title being known as the King of the Punks either.
1. Pinkerton - Weezer
Once the grunge wave started to crater after the death of Kurt Cobain, most of us needed a break from all of the morose feelings that came from that devastating loss. As things started to get a bit more cheery though, Weezer was the perfect band to lead us into the next generation, putting a lot more hooks into their alternative leaning tunes to create a sound that fell somewhere between the Cars and the Beach Boys. So when those guys started to go through their own version of internal angst, most of us were not really having it.
Coming from the same minds that brought us happy go lucky songs like Buddy Holly, Pinkerton was a much different beast, written while Rivers Cuomo was going to college at Harvard and trying to shake off all of the rock and roll hangups that came with their sudden rush of fame. That made for lyrics that felt like way too much information like Across the Sea and El Scorcho, and the public absolutely hated it, leading the band to go on hiatus for 5 years.
Once the emo wave started to gain much more traction around the turn of the century, Pinkerton actually became more of a groundbreaker than even Rivers probably thought it would be, revealing the more vulnerable side of himself and having that uncomfortable side actually become accepted by his fans years later. While Rivers would proceed to spend the next decade of Weezer's existence trying to rewrite the songs on the Blue Album, Pinkerton was the real moment where most fans felt that these nerds could be taken seriously.