10 Rock Music Albums That Divided Critics

How did they get it so wrong?

The Beatles Abbey Road
Apple

Retrospect is a virtue, particularly in the case of how public opinion shifts over time. Things once remembered fondly are now seen as archaic, embarrassing even. The reverse is also true. There are a multitude of albums, now considered classics in their field, that were regarded far less favourably when they first hit shelves.

We have the gift of hindsight. To us, these records have always been considered monumental in the halls of music. To say otherwise would be the talk of madness. But whether because of differing social climates, or due to defying expectations, these records either divided opinion or were outright dismissed.

Some critics just get things wrong, it goes with the job, opinion of course is subjective. But in these cases, it seems almost inconceivable that these records weren't universally praised from the get go...

That's the beauty of rock, though, it takes controversy and uses it as fuel. If rock musicians aren't pissing someone off they're not doing their job...

10. Neil Young: Harvest (1972)

With the news that Neil Young has recently removed his music from Spotify in protest of Joe Rogan, there's a buzz around the ageing folk rocker again. Young has never shied away from making his opinion known, and he's no stranger to dividing opinion. Indeed some of his most highly regarded records were once considered less than subpar.

Neil Young released a string of albums during the early '70s, all of which received a lukewarm reception. After the Gold Rush was initially seen as a tired interpretation of an America, Young seemed vaguely bemused by. It has since gone on to be considered one of the greatest commentaries of the country reeling after the Summer of Love.

Similarly, Harvest was given the cold shoulder by many critics. Even the corner stone of music journalism, Rolling Stone Magazine, slated Young's efforts. They thought the album lacked focus and was derivative of his earlier works. Taking fault specifically with the track Alabama, which they claimed was a lazy rehash of Young's earlier number, Southern Man.

But Young's scolding commentary on racism, his musings on drug culture and his yearning for salvation weathered the critics storm. This record had Heart of Gold, Needle and the Damage Done and Old Man on it, what were they thinking?


9. Pearl Jam: Ten (1991)

The debut record from Pearl Jam is a swirling masterpiece of blues inspired guitar leads, augmented by grunge energy and the impassioned ferocity of Eddie Vedder. Ask someone to list the best albums of the '90s, and Ten will most likely come up.

The album hurtled the Seattle based group to the forefront of the grunge seen. Together with Nirvana and Sound Garden, Pearl Jam were responsible for killing off the vapid sentiments of hair metal, welcoming in a new era of moody alternative rock.

Despite this, however, Pearl Jam were one of the more divisive groups on the scene. Accusations that they weren't as sincere as Nirvana or as heavy as Sound Garden were hurled from all sides. NME in particular found the group's debut to be lacking in the same kind of raw energy as their contemporaries, branding it overly commercial sounding. The biggest insult, however, came from the darling of grunge, Kurt Cobain. Although he later came out to admit he had no ill will against the members, he deemed their music shallow.


8. Oasis: (What's The Story) Morning Glory? (1995)

The follow up to a debut is one of the trickier things for a band to get right. You've just captured the minds of a generation, you've given them something fresh and exciting, what's the next move? It's a tough one: do you keep pushing the same thing that made you popular? or do you attempt to try something different now that you have peoples attention?

Oasis's suffered from this conundrum. They doubled down the hard rock sound, leaning into riffs borrowed from the Beatles and T-Rex - plastering a good helping of swaggering bravado over everything. But they also leaned into the power ballad. It's hard to believe now, but both Wonderwall and Don't Look Back In Anger were regarded as the beginning of the end for the group.

Critics saw their efforts as a means to capitalise on their bad boy image for commercial means, rather than acting out of sincerity. The Independent labeled their new music as "laddism of a tiresomely generic kind" and Melody Maker called the brothers "fallen stars" who sound "knackered".

Oh how wrong they were...


7. The Beatles: Abbey Road (1969)

Considered by many to be the greatest album the Beatles ever made, Abbey Road stands as a monument to their legacy. It signalled the end of an era. With Abbey Road the Beatles said goodbye to the world, in a mic drop moment. You've got two of Harrison's greatest compositions, Something and Here Comes The Sun; Lennon's slickest rip-off job ever, Come Together. McCartney's much celebrated ode to a fan, She Came In Through the Bathroom Window; and Ringo's magnum opus, Octopus's Garden.

Still, critics weren't convinced. Rolling Stone Magazine found fault with the production techniques, deeming the material too artificial and lacking in soul. The New York Times thought the album uninspired and "nothing special" as a whole. The overriding consensus was that, despite several stand out moments, the record failed to live up to the prowess of the pool of talent the group boasted.

Soon, however, the critics found they had woefully underplayed the splendour of the album. Fans lapped it up, barely a year after the record hit shelves it was already the group's best selling US record.


6. Weezer: Pinkerton (1996)

Weezer's second record took a drastic change in direction from their standout debut. The group were skyrocketed to success with tracks like Buddy Holly, Say It Ain't So and My Name Is Jonas. 1994 was the year that nerds proved they had something to contribute to the world of rock. You didn't need a brooding distain for life or sexual charisma, even wild solos were no longer a prerequisite. You just needed some catchy melodies, a touch of humour and an off-beat allure.

But all the adulation lauded upon Rivers Cuomo was too much for the 20 something year old. Extensive touring and near instant idolisation left him in a world of isolation. He channeled his disillusionment into the group's follow up. Pinkerton was far darker in tone and the humour was far less apparent. On top of this the group made the decision to self produce. The result was a bunch of self deprecating songs, with a visceral and gritty tone, more inline with grunge. But, 'pop-grunge' wasn't something people were into. The sound was ridiculed by critics. Cuomo's musings were seen as the immature thoughts of a spoiled brat. The negative reception caused Cuomo to sink further into self-loathing, resulting in a longterm hiatus from the group.

But, time heals all... , eventually the record drew devoted following and is now considered one of the group's most honest and celebrated works.


5. The Rolling Stones: Exile On Main St. (1972)

The story of Exile On Main St. falls right out of the book of rock 'n' roll madness. In a huge villa in the south of France; with thousands of pounds worth of heroin; a litany of icons dropping in and out, and with rising tensions within the band, the Stones to created their masterpiece.

The Stones were quite literally on the run at this point. Notorious music mogul, Allen Klein, had just released them from a less than savvy contract. With their release came the revelation that they were indebted to the UK taxman for over seven years worth of payments. The answer was to seek refuge in sunny France were they could make music and indulge in hedonism. After months held up in Keith Richard's rented mansion, they travelled to LA with reels of tape. With somewhat clearer minds, they assembled all the usable material into an album.

But the ram shackled and tumultuous approach to recording, did not go unnoticed by critics. Many thought the record embodied the hit and miss nature of the sessions. The overriding consensus was that the group had a handful of hits tied together with uninspired filler material.

Maybe they weren't entirely wrong. It is one hell of a long album...


4. Radiohead: Kid A (2000)

It's no surprise that Kid A caused something of a stir, both among fans and critics. Radiohead had fast become the rising stars of alternative rock. Ok Computer solidified them as the best thing since sliced bread. But Thom Yorke become disenfranchised with his own prowess as a song writer. He found he no longer connected with the sounds that had made his group popular. In his eyes, rock was dead.

Kid A saw the evolution of Radiohead, from an alt rock group to an experimental force of ambient sound. To the critics of the day, it was pretentious, too experimental, lacking in focus and altogether a sorry follow up to the record that had made Radiohead a household name.

Can they be blamed? Even today Radiohead exists in a realm of musicians that do require a certain degree of patience to get into. Along with Nick Cave and his Bad Seeds, their music is far from commercial. It is the embodiment of music as an art form. And that was the issue with Kid A, people wanted a follow up to Ok Computer but got something from another realm entirely.


3. The Stooges: Fun House (1970)

The Stooges were a slow burn for music critics. They were a far cry from groups like Cream and Led Zeppelin - who's energy, although wild and raw, was matched by a technical proficiency. The Stooges were lacking in the latter, but they made up for it with attitude and unfiltered noise.

Their second album, Fun House, was exactly what it said on the tin: this was rock for the good times, forget the intricate guitar solos and melody changes; three chords played with venom was all that was required. The Stooges made a name for themselves playing alongside fellow garage/punk pioneers MC5, but it wouldn't be until their third album that critics finally got where these guys were coming from - even then, they didn't perform well commercially.

For the most part, critics found the raw guitar sounds and the sluggish vocals lacking in direction. It's divergence from the usual rock of the day made it inaccessible. Avant-garde jazz style jams, mixed with psychedelic proto-punk was a sensory overload. It was only in retrospect that critics hailed Fun House as the forerunner to punk rock.


2. The Velvet Underground & Nico: The Velvet Underground & Nico (1967)

Let's set the scene: it's the Summer of Love - the year the Beatles drop Sgt. Pepper's. Blissful psychedelia is exploding from the finger tips of Jimi Hendrix and free love and unity are the words on everyones lips. Right in the middle of all this, an avant-garde group from New York drop an album exploring the seedy and sordid underbelly of New York's bohemian scene.

Surprise to say, the graphic nature of the lyrics and the ominous sound of the music wasn't in keeping with the trends of the time. Moreover the references weren't veiled behind metaphor. These songs were forth coming in what they were getting at. Musically, Venus In Furs, sounded like a warped decent into drug fuelled depravity. Lyrically, the song spoke openly of sadomasochism. Both Waiting for The Man and Heroin shamelessly discussed the relationship between an addict and their drug of choice. Radio stations were turned off by the notion of peddling such material. And critics, for the most part, couldn't understand where it stood within the wider musical context of the day.

The fragile minds of America just weren't ready for the Underground.


1. Pink Floyd: Wish You Were Here (1975)

When you create an album as groundbreaking as Dark Side of The Moon you're always going to have a hard time following it up. This pressure plagued Pink Floyd to no end.

The production of Wish You Were Here was riddled with difficulties. The group struggled to match the same enthusiasm with which they had approached Dark Side. Drummer Nick Mason, was coming to terms with his divorce. And, Gilmour and Water's were starting to disagree more and more about the direction the group should be going in. On top of that, they had a sound engineer who was unfamiliar with the Abbey Road studio - at one point, completely ruining the original take of Shine On. The boys weren't off to a good start

After almost six months of tortured recording, and several more of mastering, the group eventually released one of the greatest records of all time. Contemporary critics were far from convinced, however. The attacks on the music business were dismissed as overt and unsubtle. Even the references to their former band mate Syd Barrett were taken as insincere due to the bluntness of the sentiment. In all, the concept was deemed unsophisticated and the music was labeled derivative.


 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Before engrossing myself in the written word, I spent several years in the TV and film industry. During this time I became proficient at picking things up, moving things and putting things down again.