10 Rock Music Albums That Divided Critics

Weezer's second record took a drastic change in direction from their standout debut. The group were skyrocketed to success with tracks like Buddy Holly, Say It Ain't So and My Name Is Jonas. 1994 was the year that nerds proved they had something to contribute to the world of rock. You didn't need a brooding distain for life or sexual charisma, even wild solos were no longer a prerequisite. You just needed some catchy melodies, a touch of humour and an off-beat allure.

But all the adulation lauded upon Rivers Cuomo was too much for the 20 something year old. Extensive touring and near instant idolisation left him in a world of isolation. He channeled his disillusionment into the group's follow up. Pinkerton was far darker in tone and the humour was far less apparent. On top of this the group made the decision to self produce. The result was a bunch of self deprecating songs, with a visceral and gritty tone, more inline with grunge. But, 'pop-grunge' wasn't something people were into. The sound was ridiculed by critics. Cuomo's musings were seen as the immature thoughts of a spoiled brat. The negative reception caused Cuomo to sink further into self-loathing, resulting in a longterm hiatus from the group.

But, time heals all... , eventually the record drew devoted following and is now considered one of the group's most honest and celebrated works.