10 Rock Songs That Were Written By Accident
From Flukes to Faves.
Not every classic song has to be written in the same way. For the more seasoned songwriters, it normally takes a while to get the song to just where it needs to be, as you continue to finetune until you find something that’s going to stand the test of time. Then again, it’s sometimes just a matter of being in the right place at the right time to make something special.
For almost all of these bands, these songs were never meant to be written to begin with, being just sketches that they were messing around with or just demos that were never meant to see the light of day. Once they reached the rest of the band though, they started to take on their classic form, adding the different bells and whistles that would become synonymous with the version that we know today. Even though these may have been done by accident, that’s not to say they didn’t put their heart and soul into them either.
Part of the appeal of these songs comes from just how much they put their blood, sweat, and tears into making it, fleshing out this little joke of an idea until it was ready for primetime. In the words of the great Bob Ross, there’s still a whole lot of potential that can come out of the happiest little accidents.
10. Elderly Woman - Pearl Jam
After the colossal success of their debut album Ten, Pearl Jam had the momentum of a freight train. Even though Eddie Vedder had his reservations with the idea of fame, the band were already hard at work trying to make something that was even heavier than the record they had just made. There was no time to waste, and Eddie found a song out of just dusting the cobwebs out.
During one of the breaks between playing live and recording, Eddie had picked up an acoustic guitar he had lying around and started messing with a few chords to get his chops back up. With Stone Gossard in the next room, Eddie started to vocalize different melodies until hitting on something that was a lot stronger than what they were working on. Aside from just a few chords, the concept of Elderly Woman is much closer to a folk tune mostly, telling the story of two friends meeting up after a long time, one who has moved on with their life and the other never being able to escape the small town that they tried to run away from in their youth.
It sticks out more like a sore thumb on Vs. though, with this and Daughter being the only two low points on the record alongside some of the more abrasive cuts like Blood and Go. These were tense times for Pearl Jam’s future, but it’s songs like these that kept them above ground most of the time.
9. Even the Losers - Tom Petty
During his lifetime, Tom Petty was always wary to understand what drew him to write songs in the first place. Whenever he was asked about it in interviews, Tom never really was too keen to reveal what his songwriting process was like, thinking that if he tried to understand then it would probably not come as naturally as it had been. While recording Damn the Torpedoes though, you have to chalk up Even the Losers to just dumb luck.
Going through most of the record, Tom had written each song by himself or with Mike Campbell before bringing it to the rest of the band. The crux of this song was already intact, but there was no chorus to be found, with the now famous chorus line being just scat singing for the most part. Tom certainly had time to flesh it out if he wanted to, but he decided to just roll the tape anyway, not telling any of his bandmates that he didn’t write anything for the chorus. Once the moment eventually rolled around, the now iconic “even the losers get lucky sometimes” just fell out of Tom’s head, which linked up perfectly with the melody that he had already worked out.
Even with decades removed from that recording session, Tom was still knocked out by how quickly it came together, saying that he captured a moment in time and how those words completely tied the song together with the verses, already being about a kid trying to get back together with an old flame. You can have a lot of classics under your belt, but there’s got to be something supernatural going on when you hit upon something this easily.
8. That's All Right Mama - Elvis Presley
No matter what brand of rock and roll you like, chances are it always comes back to Elvis Presley. Even if you don’t necessarily like the man’s music, The King of Rock and Roll has been a staple in the lives of every single rocker that has paved the way since, from the Beatles to Led Zeppelin to The White Stripes. And from the first note that he ever sang, he was never meant to be taken all that seriously or anything.
In his pre-royalty days, Elvis didn’t even fashion himself a singer most of the time, just looking like a misfit in his hometown and trying music on the side every now and again. When he was joking around cutting some old familiar blues jams with his friends though, Sam Phillips entered the control room as they were playing an impromptu version of That’s All Right Mama. After asking them what they were doing, Phillips demanded that they play it again as tape rolled, with Elvis playing up the trademark hiccup in his voice and getting more in tune with the kind of persona that would become Elvis’ signature in later years.
This would become the first real break that Elvis got in the mainstream, leading to him becoming the most in demand stars of the day and making him seem more like a deity of rock and roll than an actual live performer. So you have different movies, the holy ground of Graceland, and the Las Vegas residency period all from just a few minutes of Elvis and his pals just goofing off in a studio. You’re welcome.
7. Nothin Song - Alice in Chains
When you’ve been in the studio for a long time, there comes a point where you’re going to start going a little crazy, and Alice in Chains were at their wit’s end. During the recording of their self titled record, Layne Staley was clearly not doing well, getting more and more into his heroin habit and not finding time to write or even show up to half of the sessions. They needed something to work with though, and Nothin Song exists just as an excuse to have a song.
Though this fits pretty nicely with what Alice was known for at the time, the lyrics are the definition of filler, in more ways than one. While most people would call filler material just a bunch of lackluster lines thrown together, Alice seems to be acknowledging that they don’t have any ideas on this song, with the title being an homage to their boredom and writer’s block in the studio. The instrumentation is anything but phoned in though, as Jerry Cantrell creates different licks that almost reach Tony Iommi levels of heavy in some spots.
For all of the dark stuff underneath, this song is actually fairly funny, talking about how this song sticks to you like peanut butter on your brain. These two tones don’t sound like they should work in the slightest, but it’s a great change of pace during the halfway point of the album. The whole mindset behind this record is already fairly sad, so why not have something a little more lighthearted for a few minutes?
6. Murder By Numbers - The Police
After a slowburn in the ‘70s, the Police had turned themselves into the biggest band in the world once the ‘80s kicked into high gear. Starting off with the sounds of Roxanne, every single song felt like a new creative adventure, merging rock and roll with everything from reggae to punk to blues. The synths were coming in on Synchronicity, if not for one song that didn’t even make the track listing.
Being released as a B-side to Every Breath You Take, Murder By Numbers is one of the most singularly weird songs in the Police’s catalog, beginning life as just a little chordal riff that Andy Summers had lying around that Sting thought would make for a good basis for a song. In this case though, the real accident behind the song is the way it was recorded, with very few overdubs and the whole thing sounding like a song that they just recorded on the studio floor as they were finishing up the record. Aside from the way they recorded it, you can hear the subtle nuances that make it seem like they just learned the tune, from Stewart Copeland’s kick going out of time with the rest of the band to Sting actually being out of tune on his fretless bass towards the end of the song.
That actually adds to the song’s vibe half the time though, from the strange eccentricities of the lyrics to the chords that feel like they’re ripped straight out of some contemporary jazz pop record. For all the reasons why the Police decided to call it off after this, it wasn’t because they were lacking in ideas. The ideas had simply gotten too big for all three of them to handle all at once.
5. Whiter Shade of Pale - Procol Harum
Any working musician will tell you how important it is to practice in your downtime. Even when you have a good chunk of musical knowledge under your belt, there’s no limit on where you can go, and you need to make sure to keep your chops up so you’re prepared for anything. That means turning to different genres of music, and Procol Harum got one of their biggest hits out of failing to practice properly.
Looking to brush up on some of his classical pieces, Gary Brooker began combing through his classical pieces on the piano before eventually stumbling on Bach’s Air on a G String. After trying to study it for a while, he admits that he got it completely wrong, only to find out that he liked what he was playing a little bit better than the classical piece that he was working on, Choosing to carry on in his own way, what fell out of it was Whiter Shade of Pale, which turned into the biggest hit that the band ever had, merging the different sides of music by blending the sophistication of classical music with the more simplified songwriting of what was happening in rock at the time.
This was only the beginning of rock’s reinvention though, with more acts taking cues from the world of classical music as the years went on, from the baroque pop era of music to modern virtuoso guitarists citing classical artists just as much as mainstream acts. If anything, this song’s existence should just be a lesson for aspiring songwriters. Even if you screw up, it could lead to something brilliant if you just follow your muse.
4. Under The Bridge - Red Hot Chili Peppers
Once the Peppers went into cut Blood Sugar Sex Magik, you could tell that things were definitely starting to shift a little bit. Even with the addition of John Frusciante being integrated into the band on the album before this, Rick Rubin had a much greater presence than just a producer, looking to simplify the songs and have the band hook into something a bit more groove-based. He had a close relationship with them, but he knew that this one idea from Anthony Kiedis could go even further.
Inviting him into the creative process, Rick spent some time at Anthony’s place in between sessions, combing through different lyrics that he had worked through at home to see if he could find something to work with. Out of his sleuthing, he found the basis for Under the Bridge, which Anthony never meant to be seen by the rest of the band. This was always meant to be a fairly private poem for Anthony, describing what it was like when he was living in the gutter and using it to work through the pain that comes with being a recovering addict.
After a little bit of prying though, Rubin eventually got Anthony to introduce the song to the rest of the guys, which turned into a much different beast. Unlike the usual funky stuff that we were used to, this was a straight up ballad built around the poem, as Anthony wears his heart on his sleeve while the rest of the band hang back and come in at just the right time. For all of the pain that may have been in those lyrics, the creation of this song feels like another part of the healing process for Anthony.
3. Killing in the Name - Rage Against the Machine
If you’re a guitar player, you should never be afraid to go outside the boundaries of what tuning you’re in. There’s a lot that can be done with just six strings, and grunge blew the doors wide open with drop D, using the fattest string to tap into something that was a lot more gravelly in tone. It made for a much deeper tone, and even practicing it yielded one of the most badass riffs of the decade.
In between nights of playing with rock acts in the California area, Tom Morello would also turn in time as a guitar teacher, with drop D being one of the main things that he would teach some of his students during the sessions. After demonstrating how to tune everything, Tom started to play little licks that would give the student an idea of what to work on, until he realized that he hit upon something that was too good to waste on a training exercise. Cutting the session short, Morello halted everything and recorded the riff onto his little Radioshack speaker before it eventually became the main riff behind Killing in the Name.
For all of the hard edged power behind it though, there’s something almost inherently funky about the lick as well, almost sounding like what James Brown would have done if he were fronting a heavy metal band instead of his trademark funk sound. The vibe in California at the time may have still been squarely focused on the Sunset Strip brand of rock and roll, but these were the kind of angry riffs that were destined to fill out arenas.
2. Yesterday - The Beatles
Before most of the Beatles were out of their 20’s, they had already written enough love songs to keep the world satisfied for the rest of time. In between the puppy love songs that they were known for in their early days, the back half of the ‘60s would give way to a more intense form of affection, talking about the healing power of it in All You Need is Love and The End. Of all the love songs that Lennon and McCartney wrote together, Yesterday is where everything changed for Paul.
As Paul was putting the track together though, he was convinced that the whole thing was a fluke. Instead of sitting down to flesh out a tune, Macca got the idea for this song while he was sleeping, waking up in the middle of the night and getting to the piano so he could find where the chords were. When he was working on it though, he kept telling himself that it was probably just an old jazz tune that he remembered from his days when his father played, only to realize that he hit on something all his own.
Crafting a new song from the ground up, Paul used Scrambled Eggs as the placeholder words before Yesterday fell into his head, which turned this song into a sad lament about love lost and what this poor sap could have done to prevent the love of his life from walking out the door. Though the Beatles had reservations about recording it because of their rock credentials, this was about more than just rock. This was a song that was meant for the whole world.
1. Pour Some Sugar On Me - Def Leppard
In the days of making Hysteria, Def Leppard knew that there was no room for filler. After already coming off the massive success of Pyromania, they needed something that was going to equal that album or they would be entering the downward slide of their career. Producer Mutt Lange saw this as making their greatest hits album just on one disc, and the real blockbuster smash actually came from just a few minutes in the studio.
Having worked for the better part of three years trying to make the record, the band were running through the vocals for the song Armageddon It, which they were convinced was the last track that they needed to do before everyone went on a coffee break. As Joe Elliott returned to the control room, he picked up an acoustic guitar and started to sing the melody of what would become the chorus of Sugar, which made Mutt’s eyes light up when he came back into the studio.
Though the label was a bit hesitant to have them delay the album yet again to include another song, the whole thing ended up being worth it, propelling Hysteria into the stratosphere and turning Def Leppard into one of the biggest bands in the world at the time. Pyromania was the kind of success that most artists would never be able to see again, and from just a few minutes with an acoustic guitar, Leppard managed to practically double what they did the first time around.