10 Songs With Meanings That Are Completely Misunderstood

Some things aren't so open to interpretation...

Madonna Like A Virgin
Epic

One of the greatest things about music as an art form is that it's open to interpretation. This is one of the reasons why many songs become as popular as they do. Songs dealing with the many facets of love, for example €“ happiness, heartbreak, resentment €“ often have very general lyrics, filled with sweeping statements that are applicable to many.

But that doesn't mean that listeners can't be wrong, or that songwriters don't have specific intentions. Once a song is released and the public has collectively decided on its meaning it's practically impossible to correct or change it. And sometimes musicians are purposefully vague, withholding context until many years later.

What this means, then, is that there are a bunch of extremely notable tracks out there with completely misunderstood meanings. From cheery-sounding songs that are actually heart wrenching laments to one of the most famous power ballads in the world actually being about vampires, here are ten incredible examples.


10. John Lennon's Imagine Is "Virtually The Communist Manifesto"

AP

John Lennon's Imagine is one of those songs that crops up everywhere. It's a fantastic piece of music, cherished in a world of endless conflict for imagining a future in which none of the things that tear humanity apart exist. Since its initial release in 1971 it has sold millions of copies around the world and was named by BMI as one of the one-hundred most performed songs of the twentieth century.

But Imagine isn't just the free-spirited, idyllic anthem that everyone thinks it is. According to Lennon himself, the song is €œvirtually the Communist manifesto€ and that because the song is €œsugar-coated it's accepted€.

Though Lennon was quick to distance himself from the party (saying he's €œnot particularly a Communist€), he did note that sweetening up a message, regardless of what it actually is, is the most effective way to have it championed. Even, it seems, Communist ideals.


9. Bonnie Tyler's Total Eclipse Of The Heart Is About Vampires

When it comes to ballads, Total Eclipse Of The Heart is one of the most famous in the world, managing to sustain relevancy and popularity for over three decades since its release in 1983. It was written by long-time Meat Loaf collaborator Jim Steinman, and has sold more than six million copies worldwide.

While most people think it's nothing more than a rather melancholy love song about loneliness and insecurity, the truth is actually very different. In 2002 while promoting his Broadway musical Dance Of The Vampires, Steinman stated in an interview that the song is actually €œa vampire love song€ and its original title was €œVampires In Love€.

Steinman claims he was working on a musical of Nosferatu when he wrote it, and that the lyrics are actually being sung by a vampire. Which certainly changes the meaning of €œI don't know what to do and I'm always in the dark / we've living in a powder keg and giving off sparks€.


8. Queen's Somebody To Love Isn't About The Search For A Romantic Partner

Not really, anyway. Though it's undeniably about trying to find love, the central meaning of the song is incredibly commonly misinterpreted.

Throughout the song the narrator lists all of their redeeming qualities, like the fact that they €œwork hard every day€ of their life, they work until their bones ache and that they take home all of their €œhard earned pay€. Nevertheless they €œjust can't get no relief€.

But the repeated lyric €œcan anybody find me somebody to love?€ isn't asking for someone to find the narrator a partner. It's wondering whether or not anyone could ever deem him deserving of love. In essence, it's: Can anybody consider me somebody who is worth loving.


7. You Are My Sunshine Is Not A Cheery Love Song

The authorship of the traditional country song You Are My Sunshine is still hotly debated. Jimmie Davis and Charles Mitchell are credited as the songwriters, but Davis never actually claimed authorship, stating that he had bought the rights to the song and merely put his name to it, a practice which was fairly common in the pre-World War II music business.

Regardless of who actually wrote it, You Are My Sunshine has been covered so many times that it's regarded as one of the most commercially programmed songs in American popular music. Notable covers include those by Nat King Cole, Tina Turner, Johnny Cash and Brian Wilson.

As for the meaning of the song, it's frequently misunderstood. This is generally owing to the fact that most people only know the lyrics to the chorus, which begin €œyou are my sunshine, my only sunshine / you make me happy when skies are grey€. But lines in the later verses like €œI dreamt I held you in my arms / when I awoke, dear, I was mistaken / so I hung my head and I cried€ and €œbut if you leave me to love another / you'll regret it all one day€ provide the tune's much grimmer reality. The singer is literally begging their partner not to leave them, despite the fact they clearly no longer feel the same way.


6. There She Goes By Sixpence None The Richer Is About Heroin Addiction

sixpence none the richer
Go! Discs

Though it was actually written by English rock band The La's, There She Goes was made popular by Sixpence None The Richer. Released in 1999, their cover was one of the last massive hits of the nineties.

Though the lyrics appear to detail a narrator who is madly in love with a woman, the song is actually about crippling heroin addiction, and the fleeting nature of its high.

The key lyrics that make this apparent are €œthere she blows again / pulsing through my veins / and I just can't contain / the feeling that remains€. But the sweet vocal delivery and upbeat tune have obscured this meaning to many for almost two decades.


5. The Cure's Killing An Arab Doesn't Promote Racism

The Cure Live
Wiki

wikimedia

It doesn't take a genius to work out how this song has been misappropriated over the years. Appearing on The Cure's first US album Boys Don't Cry in 1980, Killing An Arab has been seen as promoting violence against Arabs and inciting general racism.

But what's missing is the context. Killing An Arab is actually about the Albert Camus novel The Stranger, in which the narrator (just like in the song) does in fact kill an Arab on the beach, and is thereafter considered a €œstranger€ for refusing to lie about what happened. According to Robert Smith, he simply tried to detail his impressions of the novel's key scene through song.

Since its release the song has gone through several title changes including Kissing An Arab and Killing Another, but has since been performed as Killing An Arab again.


4. Green Day's Time Of Your Life Isn't Romantic

green day
Wikipedia

It may seem difficult to believe, but Green Day's 1997 Time Of Your Life from the album Nimrod is frequently misinterpreted. In fact, the song €“ which has sold millions of copies in the years since its release €“ has become a massive hit at prom dances, with many graduating seniors interpreting the lyrics as a nostalgic musing on the high school experience.

This misinterpretation is so widespread, in fact, that Billie Joe Armstrong himself has weighed in, claiming that he slightly enjoys the fact he's often misunderstood. Nevertheless the song is actually an extremely bitter break-up song. It's not uncommon for people to mistakenly think the track is titled Time Of Your Life, but that's just the bit in brackets €“ the primary title is Good Riddance, which is much more fitting with the lyrics.

Good Riddance was written out of frustration that Armstrong's then-girlfriend was moving to Ecuador. Throughout the song the narrator laments the loss of his love: €œI hope you had the time of your life€ isn't so much sincere as it is tinged with resent.


3. Every Breath You Take By The Police Isn't About Love OR Stalking

A&M

The Police's Every Breath You Take is probably the most commonly cited example of a song with a misunderstood meaning. For everyone blissfully ignorant of how creepy its lyrics are there's two dozen people waiting to leap in and explain that the song is actually about Sting stalking his ex-wife. Sadly, those people are completely wrong too.

According to the man himself, Every Breath You Take was written in the Caribbean. Sting woke up in the middle of the night with the line €œevery breath you take, every move you make€ in his head, and finished writing it in about half an hour.

Here's where it gets interesting, though. Sting actually claims that he was thinking about Big Brother while writing it, and that the intention was for it to depict a totalitarian surveillance state, in which all of society is watched 24/7.


2. Madonna's Like A Virgin Isn't About Virginity OR A Woman

Madonna concert
Wikimedia Commons

Despite the fact that its meaning is the subject of the opening of Quentin Tarantino's Reservoir Dogs, Madonna's Like A Virgin remains fundamentally misunderstood. This is likely because the song wasn't written by Madonna at all, but rather a man named Billy Steinberg.

In an interview with LA Times, Steinberg explained that he never actually intended for a woman to sing the song, and that it was totally autobiographical. The song details his personal experiences over the years, and how one specific instance of falling in love made him feel totally raw and vulnerable yet amazing, as if it was the first time he was ever experiencing love, much as a virgin might feel.

So there you have it, Tarantino. Like a virgin isn't about dick OR virginity. It's about a man falling in love.


1. The Lion Sleeps Tonight Is About The Inevitable Resurrection Of A Warrior King

Sonoma

When it comes to totally innocuous songs, The Lion Sleeps Tonight by The Tokens is pretty far up there. Known also by €œWimoweh€, €œWimba Way€ and €œAwimbawe€, the song has been covered many times over the years and has become a notable part of pop culture, mainly because it's ridiculously catchy.

But what's it actually about? Ask most people and they'll probably say something like €œI don't know...lions sleeping?€. In actuality, it's about Shaka kaSenzangakhona, or Shaka Zulu for short (thank goodness). Shaka (also know as Shaka the Lion) was one of the most influential monarchs of the Zulu kingdom, who fought against European colonizers.

Apparently, Shaka is the €œlion€ mentioned in the song, and references to his €œsleeping€ are merely another way of saying he isn't truly dead, but will one day rise up and free his oppressed people.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Madonna
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Commonly found reading, sitting firmly in a seat at the cinema (bottle of water and a Freddo bar, please) or listening to the Mountain Goats.