10 Strange Music Albums By Mainstream Acts
The strangest and most unexpected albums which showed a new side to some big acts.
Any significant change in direction by an established act with a large fan-base is always going to result in controversy. This remains, though, one of the more fascinating areas of popular music history. There are many reasons why an artist might drastically alter their sound. For some, it's a gradual process, a result of their desire to explore new territory and absorb new influences. For others, it might be a step away from the over-commercialism of their previous output, often towards a more mature representation of their creative impulse. A change in personnel also often results in an altered sound.
Teen-idols, in particular, are stuck fast in an evolve-or-die situation, so too those artists highly identified with a particular genre which might fall prey to sudden shifts in taste. Many acts, of course, are content to stick to their habitual feel, and do so to great effect, and there is nothing wrong with that.
For this list, however, we have selected ten of the most unexpected and surprising left-turn's by major acts. It's fair to say that every album on this list caused ripples of shock, some positive, many negative. All have an interesting story behind them.
10. Trans - Neil Young
There aren't many artists who have enjoyed such a long and celebrated career as Neil Young. Equally, there are few who produced such an unexpected left-turn as displayed on the singer's twelfth studio album, Trans. Previously known for his majestic country-rock songs, with this 1982 album the singer served up a baffling set of vocoder and synth-driven tracks.
An examination of the unique circumstances at the time tells much. Young had just parted company with his long-term label, Reprise, and signed with Geffen Records. The singer's new contract guaranteed him complete creative control over his output, with a very healthy payout.
Very few people knew, but during that period Young dedicated himself to seeking out new ways of communicating with his son, who was born with cerebral palsy. The repetitive nature of Young's music at the time, together with a quest for new avenues of exploration, both related back to the artist's therapy work with his child.
So displeased were Geffen Records that owner, David Geffen, filed a lawsuit against Young for having produced willfully un-commercial music. The singer counter-sued and both claims were eventually dropped.
9. Swordfishtrombone - Tom Waits
It's not secret that, by the early '80s, Tom Waits found himself increasingly frustrated by the musical cul-de-sac in which he was seemingly trapped, stifled thanks to his own self-projection as 'bar-fly jazz crooner.' Over seven previous albums, the singer had built up a cult following and garnered critical acclaim, but no great commercial appeal.
It's fair to say that Waits was far more bothered by his inability to pin-point exactly what sort of sound he wished to communicate. That all changed with the release, in 1983, of Swordfishtrombones. It was a radical move. The singer changed his record label, manager, producer and personnel, and in doing so produced a set of extraordinary avant-garde rock which embraced everything from mad circus tunes and surrealism to improvised percussion and studio experimentation.
Listening back with hindsight, foreshadows of the revolutionary music to be found on Swordfishtrombones were present in the singer's earlier work. Even so, listeners were understandably shocked and surprised. Waits would never look back again, and the album remains one of the most striking examples of musical changes in direction to be found.
8. Journey Through The Secret Life Of Plants - Stevie Wonder
Journey Through The Secret Life of Plants stands not only as a highly unusual entry in Wonder's discography, but also as one of the most incongruous records ever released on the Motown label. By 1979, the former child prodigy had built up a unsurpassed reputation for his intelligent yet highly accessible soul/R&B work.
Nothing found on Wonder's previous album, the Grammy-winning Songs In The Key Of Life, could have prepared listener's for his next outing. Secret Life Of Plants served as a soundtrack to the film of the same name. That film's producer, Michael Braun, painstakingly described the visual images which Wonder's music would accompany, with the artist then free to match the music to his imagination.
Much of the resulting set is instrumental and slowly-evolving, almost ambient at times. The record relies heavily on synthesizers and programmed sounds. With no fore-knowledge, a listener would be hard-pressed to identify this as a Stevie Wonder record, which is not to say that there is nothing of merit here. In its own way, Secret Life Of Plants makes for a fascinating listen.
7. Their Satanic Majesties Request - The Rolling Stones
Six months after The Beatles unveiled Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, the Rolling Stones released what remains the most divisive album in their discography. With 1967's Their Satanic Majesties Request, the group plunged headlong into psychedelic waters. Extensive use of sound affects, strings, mellotron and unusual rhythms peppered this fascinating, if flawed, set of songs, which map out territory the Stones' would never again revisit.
It's easy to see why this album was so harshly judged upon on its initial release. Unlike The Beatles, who had shown signs of their journey towards the outer reaches on their '66 album, Revolver, Satanic Majesties marked an abrupt and un-heralded change in direction for Mick Jagger, Keith Richards and company. Accusations of bandwagon-jumping abounded. Worse, still, the Stones style and image just didn't seem to fit with the music.
The results are decidedly mixed. Opener, Sing This All Together, comes across as an almost cringe-inducing pastiche. The whimsical Gomper and On With The Show feel equally forced. In Another Land is almost embarrassing. There are some jewels though – 2000 Light Years From Home is genuinely exciting, ditto the muscular, swaggering Citadel.
6. Trilogy - Frank Sinatra
Had it succeeded in its intentions, Trilogy: Past Present Future, would not have been the first grand comeback for Frank Sinatra. In the event, this ambitious triple-album, released in 1980, is still puzzling critics and listeners several decades on.
A concept album of sorts, Trilogy was split into three sides, each devoted to the titular aspects of time. To the singer's credit, Sinatra was completely on-board with the project, by all accounts finding himself rejuvenated with creative vigour.
Side One, Past, is a fine, if unadventurous collection of standards. Side Two, Present, is more interesting and uneven, with Sinatra tackling more contemporary material, including George Harrison's Something, Neil Diamond's Song Sung Blue, and Billy Joel's Just The Way You Are.
The Future is where things get wild, starting with the ten-minute-long What Time Does The Next Miracle Leave – a strange, bloated number which sounds perversely dated. World War None! marches and stumbles into an extended suite which lurches from one peculiar moment to another. Easy, lounge themes bump up against expansive choirs and circus tunes. It might sound great on paper, but Sinatra feels lost throughout.
5. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band – The Beatles
A contentious choice, here, but in context Sgt. Pepper's easily qualifies for this list. With Revolver, The Beatles' had shown signs of their ambition and direction. The sweeping strings and unconventional subject matter of Eleanor Rigby, the off-kilter harmonies of I Want To Tell You and the decidedly experimental, Tomorrow Never Knows pointed the way to what was to come.
Still, however, that album also included the relatively straightforward sweet pop ballads and swinging rockers which had made the band famous. Sgt. Pepper's marked a huge step forward in every way. The group let loose with a wild melange of druggy, quirky pop, tape-manipulations, Eastern sounds and unrestrained imagination, clustered around the high (pun intended) point of Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds.
The extended LSD trip which The Beatles had started with Revolver found its pinnacle with Sgt. Pepper's. It may be difficult to appreciate now, but not all listeners were willing to join the Fab Four on their cosmic journey. From this moment on, the band would never be regarded in quite the same light. Sgt. Pepper's may be an artistic success, but it arguably also set the timer running on the group's life-span.
4. Consequences - Godley And Creme
To fully appreciate Kevin Godley and Laurence Creme you have to journey back to 1972, England, and the formation of art-rock band 10cc. That outfit remains one the UK's best-loved groups, finding a perfect balance between sweet, accessible pop-rock and ambitious, artistic compositions. Equally, 10Cc were a band of two halves, with Graham Gouldman and Eric Stewart skewed toward the pop side.
Perhaps it was no big surprise, then, that in 1976 Godley and Creme, the more experimental half, left to focus on their own unique musical vision. Fans of 10cc could hardly have conceived the results. Consequences, released in 1977, was a triple concept album of dazzling invention, which sacrificed nothing to easy commercialism.
Musically, the album veers from dark, rumbling soundscapes and orchestral rock to wild tape-manipulations and abrasive, industrial sections. It remains a startlingly, innovative document. While Consequences is, for the most part, a world away from the melodic confections of 10cc, nothing on the album sounds deliberately alienating. Even it its harshest moments, there's a strange beauty running through this set, which never ceases to surprise.
3. The Adventures Of Kaptain Kopter & Commander Cassidy In Potato Land - Spirit
Los Angeles band Spirit are a firm contender for 'most underrated act of the '60s/'70s'. Formed in 1967, and featuring the considerable talents of guitarist Randy California, they produced a string of fine albums showcasing an original rock sound which lay somewhere between blues and psychedelia.
Some will be familiar with the name thanks to a long-running and recently-settled court case, with Spirit claiming that Led Zeppelin lifted a melody from their song, Taurus, as the opening for Stairway To Heaven; a claim which was eventually overturned.
Between '72 and '73, Spirit took a sabbatical, and it was during this time that Randy California, together with Spirit's equally talented drummer, Ed Cassidy, put together Kaptain Kopter, a concept album based in the bizarre setting of Potato Land, a strange world populated by the titular vegetables.
Not everything here fails, but the music is far from that which Spirit fans might expect. Beach Boys-esque numbers nestle against psychedelic disco, piano-pop, spoken-word interludes and dreamy ballads. An interesting, uneven, and highly unexpected set.
2. Zinc Alloy And The Hidden Riders Of Tomorrow - T-Rex
T-Rex frontman Marc Bolan was no stranger to changes of musical direction by the time of this release, which saw the light of day in February 1974. Bolan and his band had already swapped their original Tyrannosaurus Rex moniker, under which they had released four albums which leaned heavily towards gentle, psychedelic folk. As T-Rex, the group switched to an electric rock sound, and scored a big hit with their 1971 album, Electric Warrior.
That album is now rightfully considered as a landmark in glam-rock. Bombastic, playful and quirky, the record spawned a chart-topping hit with Get It On, and set the group on course to super-stardom. All of which contributed to the bemusement which greeted the release of Zinc Alloy.
From the off, this album presents itself as a high-speed journey into the sort of no-holds-barred, grab-bag territory then being explored by Miles Davis. The theatrical rock flourishes and sparkling edges are still present, but so too are harsh, frantic glimmers, wailing vocals, rockabilly, funk and a heavy dose of soul. It's a denser, more ambitious record than anything T-Rex had attempted before, and it stands up well to this day.
1. The Plan - The Osmonds
Deservedly taking the number one spot on this list, it's 1973's The Plan by The Osmonds - although the band's 1972 output, Phase III and Crazy Horses, could almost equally well have qualified.
Today, most people know this group of siblings from Utah for two reasons: Little Jimmy Osmond's Long Haired Lover From Liverpool, which topped the UK charts when the singer was just nine years old, and Crazy Horses, the band's screeching psychedelic love-it-or-hate-it number.
This is highly unfair to the group, who in reality displayed a harder, more rootsy edge on most of their recordings right from the off, albeit it too often mixed in with saccharine pop. The Osmonds reinvented themselves somewhat with that brace of '72 albums, switching to a more rock-orientated sound, but still remained firmly mainstream.
The Plan, then, had no precursor. This is a highly ambitious concept album dedicated to the Mormon faith. It contains, by turns, dramatic and unsettling instrumentals, wigged-out hard rock, power-ballads and freaky cabaret numbers replete with quirky sound-effects. There's plenty of fine material here, but you'll need to put the effort in to engage with it.