10 Strangest Concept Albums
Hear the oddest concept albums ever committed to vinyl.
Arguments as to who released the first true concept album abound. The Beach Boys' Pet Sounds, Sergeant Pepper by The Beatles, and S.F. Sorrow by The Pretty Things are all routinely put forward as contenders, but way back in the 1940s Frank Sinatra put out a suite of connected songs titled The Voice Of, followed by 1955's In The Wee Small Hours. Even before that, there's Woody Guthrie's Dust Bowl Ballads and Pete Johnson's House Rent Party.
It's all academic really, and whoever you think deserves the credit, the idea of the concept album continues to inspire musicians from across the board.
Many of these are, if not routine, then at least straightforward. Bo Hansson's Music Inspired By Lord Of The Rings and the Kinks' ode to old England, Village Green Preservation Society, are notable examples of easy-to-digest ideas. For this list, however, we're taking a deep dive into a treasury of bizarre and unusual projects. Fictional bands, magical conjoined twins, comic-book characters and hallucinogenic drugs are all present here, alongside some fantastic music.
The allure of the concept album continues, and here you will find some of the most memorable.
10. Abigail - King Diamond
Formed in 1985, Danish heavy metal band King Diamond have devoted a significant amount of their discography to concept albums, perhaps none more curious or convoluted than 1987's Abigail, the band's second studio effort.
This record is one of the group's most popular sets, with several re-releases and a 25th anniversary edition available. The album, in fact, has outlived many members of the band, with King Diamond himself (vocals) and Andy LaRocque (guitar) the only constant members.
The record's plot is as dark as they come. You could well imagine film-maker Ari Aster committing this twisted tale to celluloid. Set in 1845, the narrative follows a young couple, Miriam and Jonathan, as they move into a newly-inherited mansion, despite dread warnings from mysterious horsemen.
The ensuing hauntings, omens and trips back in time could fill this entire list by itself. Expect ghost babies, broken necks and an ending which is too distasteful for words.
9. Joe's Garage - Frank Zappa
Frank Zappa was as prolific as he was inventive. His extensive back catalogue of work includes over 60 albums plus feature-length movies, music videos and art.
Never one to take the commercial route, Zappa's Joe's Garage, a triple-part high-concept rock opera, is about as left-field as they come. It was originally released as two separate albums (in September and November of 1979) and later bundled into vinyl and CD box sets.
Featuring Zappa's trademark mix of jazz, dirty rhythm and blues, garage rock and experimentation, the record follows the story of the eponymous hero, as told by 'the central scrutinizer.'
Joe lives in Canoga Park, Los Angeles, a normal everyman who starts his own rock group, has a series of unsuccessful romantic encounters, loses his money to a government-controlled religion, goes to prison, is released back into a future where music has been criminalized, and slides into madness.
8. Peggy Suicide - Julian Cope
Rising to fame as the chief creative force in acclaimed Liverpool post-punk band, The Teardrop Explodes, Julian Cope followed up with a successful solo career over several albums. Beyond music, Cope is a published author, with works on archaeology and musicology, and two volumes of autobiography. All of the above are well worth your time, but here we're focusing on his seventh solo studio album, 1991's Peggy Suicide.
Cope himself wrote extensive sleeve notes explaining the meaning and background to each song on this deliciously odd record, stating that the entire set was intended as a reflection on humanity's relationship to 'Mother Earth.'
This being Julian Cope, don't expect your usual 'green' lyrics. This is a musician who is as idiosyncratic as they come. There is sense here, and cohesiveness, but it's all filtered through Cope's wildly inventive and decidedly singular lens. Song titles include gems such as: Hanging Out & Hung Up on the Line, Not Raving but Drowning, Western Front 1992 CE and Las Vegas Basement.
7. God In Three Persons - The Residents
Since their first studio album, 1974's Meet The Residents, this anonymous, anarchic collective have released more than 60 records of challenging, inventive and wonderful music. Many of these fall into the concept album category, sometimes loosely and sometimes focused. Good examples include 1979's Eskimo, 1980's The Commercial Album and 1989's excellent Elvis-themed set, The King And Eye.
Arguably none, though, are quite as odd as God In Three Persons.
Released in 1988, this double-album follows the story of conjoined twins with magical healing powers who come under the sway of the mysterious 'Mr X,' a showman-entrepreneur who markets and manages the 'duo,' having them conduct semi-religious services to demonstrate their powers to the public. So far, so strange, but things take a darker turn. Mr X begins lusting after the female twin, only to discover than the twins' sexuality is fluid and their 'worldly' knowledge more advanced than he realised.
In a mad fit of passion, Mr X physically severs the twins, only to come to a horrible realistion.
6. Present The Battle Of The Bands - The Turtles
Formed in Los Angeles, California, in 1965, The Turtles enjoyed several hit singles with a sound that veered from surf-music to folk-rock and pop, scoring their biggest success with 1967's Happy Together. The Turtles went through several iterations, with their best-known line-up consisting of Don Murray (drums), Jim Tucker (guitars), Chuck Portz (bass), Al Nichol (guitar, keys), Howard Kaylan (vocals, keys) and Mark Volman (vocals, guitar, percussion).
Present The Battle Of The Bands, released in 1968, is the group's fourth studio album. It was produced by Chip Douglas, the man behind some of The Monkees' biggest hits, and formed around the concept of a contest between fictional bands, each of which is actually The Turtles. The band adopted a different name for the 12 songs, each of which covered a different style or genre, from rattling country blues to psychedelica, surf, pop and R 'n B.
For further examples of fictional bands, see the even more extraordinary Morgan Fisher and his Hybrid Kids elsewhere on this list.
5. Music Inspired By The Life And Times Of Scrooge - Tuomas Holopainen
Symphonic and metal may not be two words most of us would readily throw together, but that's where the roots of this entry lie. Songwriter Tuomas Lauri Johannes Holopainen is best known as leader of Finnish symphonic metal band, Nightwish.
For the artist's first solo album, Holopainen chose almost certainly the most unlikely of themes on this list. Released in 2014, the album is not, as you might assume, a meditation on Charles Dickens' famous character as featured in his classic novella, A Christmas Carol. That would be strange enough, but Holopainen had a different personage in mind.
The album is, in fact, based on a graphic novel written and illustrated by Don Rosa, the full title of which is The Life And Times Of Scrooge McDuck; a work which evidently captivated Holopainen, with the musician stating: “This is my longtime dream come true, 14 years in the making, and a homage to one of the best storytellers of our time."
Yes, we're talking Disney's beloved duck and, lest you think this some whacky joke, the record features several notable guest vocalists, a choir, and the London Philharmonic Orchestra.
4. Spider-Man: Rock Reflections Of A Superhero - Various
The superhero genre has arguably never been more popular, with Marvel rolling out franchise after franchise of films and TV shows. While Thor and The Avengers often inject a dose of humour into their worlds, you couldn't imagine the company ever being so bold as to shoe-horn in a musical number. Go back to 1975, however, and that's just what Marvel were looking to do, at least on 'literal' record.
At the time, the business was seeing success with its spoken-word storybook superhero albums, and had the idea that a set of songs might have the same appeal.
Marvel approached Lifesong Records, tasking them with producing a musical album which would appeal to older teens and college kids, focusing on one of their most popular characters, Spider-Man. By all accounts, everyone associated with the record label lent a hand, with the bulk of the work being undertaken by members of critically-acclaimed prog-rock group, Crack The Sky.
The results, while understandably uneven, are better than you might expect. This is a remarkably cohesive and likeable set of songs.
3. Tommy - The Who
British rock legends The Who have never been less than ambitious in scope and eclectic in terms of lyrical themes. With their second studio album, 1966's A Quick One While He's Away, they served up the title track as a nine-minute long, six-movement piece recounting the story of a woman who, abandoned by her lover, finds solace in the arms of 'Ivor the Engine Driver.'
With 1969's Tommy, though, the band expanded the narrative idea, creating one of the first true concept albums, and what a strange concept it is. The record spawned a huge hit in 'Pinball Wizard,' and was later made into a film, which was directed by Ken Russell and starred the band themselves alongside Elton John and a host of other notables.
The 'plot' of Tommy is a little nebulous and certainly bizarre. It concerns the titular character, who witness his father kill his mother's lover, and from that moment on becomes deaf, mute and blind. Various individuals interact with Tommy, including a quack doctor, a sadistic cousin and a drug-pusher. Despite his handicaps, Tommy finds solace in playing pinball machines. He eventually recovers his senses, founds a religious movement, becomes famous and then loses it all.
2. The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway - Genesis
Back in 1974, Genesis were quite a different outfit to their later pop-orientated iteration. At that point they were still fronted by the mercurial Peter Gabriel, and heavily skewed towards ambitious prog rock. This, after all, is a band which took its name from a musical project undertaken while they were still pupils at Charterhouse School – an audio re-telling of the opening chapter of the bible.
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway, their sixth studio album, was recorded at Headley Grange, the same historic building which played host to Led Zeppelin, among others. The story which runs through the record and was devised by Gabriel concerns Rael, a Puerto Rican youth from New York City, and the bizarre situations and characters he encounters on a journey of self-discovery. Along the way, Rael becomes absorbed into a movie screen, gets trapped in a cage, tours a factory where people are 'processed like packages,' has his 'hairy' heart shaved, befriends a blind woman, has sex with snake-people and gets castrated.
Gabriel stated: "I wanted to mix his dreams with his reality, in a kind of urban rebel Pilgrim's Progress." Genesis took the album on tour, constructing an elaborate stage show to accompany the music. It was during this tour, ironically, that Gabriel decided to leave the band.
1. Hybrid Kids - Morgan Fisher
One of two entries on this list to feature fictional bands (see The Turtles elsewhere), Hybrid Kids, originally released in 1979, was a fake compilation album, supposedly featuring bands from the city of Peabody, Kansas. The music was, in fact, created by one man, England's Morgan Fisher, who is probably best known for his role as keyboardist in the rock band Mott the Hoople, which scored big with All The Young Dudes, a song donated to the band by David Bowie.
For this solo album, Fisher presented the work as that of various made-up bands, which many fans and critics took at face value. The songs presented are mostly cover versions of well-known tracks. Fisher's idea was to approach each in a manner diametrically opposed to the originals, and he did so with fascinating and, in some cases, intentionally hilarious results.
Where else could you hear Rod Stewart's Do You Think I'm Sexy reimagined as new-wave/techno, Perry Como as speed punk, You've Lost That Loving Feeling as noise-rock, and Kate Bush's Wuthering Heights as experimental dub reggae?