10 Things You Didn't Know About Metallica
Untold mysteries of Hetfield.
Metallica are mandatory listening for anyone who's a fan of heavy music. Though they may have metal right there in their name, these thrash giants were able to transcend the sub-genre of rock and convert millions of listeners to become worshippers of all things heavy.
Most of their story is laid out pretty clearly throughout their history, but there are also some subtle intricacies that make the band what they are.
Across almost 40 years, the band has built up an impressive back catalog, but it didn't come without some weird detours along the way. While the band has lost members, weathered through bad albums, and have even been on the brink of their own destruction, they always found a way to come back to the music at the end of the day.
Whether it's in their speed metal prime or in their world-conquering peak of popularity in the '90s, each of the band's periods have little sidenotes that have driven fans wild for years.
Time could have easily worked these things out differently, but given the band's status as one of the greatest of all time, perhaps things worked out exactly like they were supposed to.
10. Cliff Burton's Classical Background
For most of Metallica’s early years, Cliff Burton was always known as the secret weapon. From the leather jackets he sported to the manic bass solos that he would put in between the band’s live sets, Burton was the band’s true resident badass. However, from a musical perspective, Burton could be considered the main outlier in the band.
While a true fan of all things metal, Burton’s musical education was more into the theory side of the music. Even though the band worshipped at the altars of bands like Black Sabbath and Led Zeppelin, Burton would always infuse a bit of classical instrumentation into the band’s material.
Starting with Kill Em All, Burton introduced James Hetfield to the concept of harmony, which ended up playing a key role down the road.
Along with contributing bass lines, Burton also ended up writing a lot of the guitar harmonies in the early days, from the lick at the end of “Creeping Death” to the classically tinged opuses that start of songs like “Fight Fire With Fire” and “Damage Inc.”
Metallica may get marginalized for being a one trick pony by some, but just throw on something like “Orion” if you want to see what the band could really do with Burton among their ranks.
9. They Intentionally Didn't Make Music Videos
As the band were just getting their feet wet in the metal scene, the entire music industry was progressing into unchartered territory. Not long after the band’s debut record came out, a little upstart known as MTV started permeating the airwaves with the first ever music videos. There were plenty of bands like Judas Priest and Twisted Sister gaining a lot of attention through MTV, but you’d have been hardpressed to find Metallica anywhere.
Instead of playing up their more radio friendly material, the band made a deliberate choice not to make videos in their early years. Seeing themselves as a punk rock antithesis to the hair metal movement, Lars Ulrich and James Hetfield didn’t want to compete for attention with the Motley Crues of the world who were gaining traction on MTV.
This kind of deliberate shunning of videos seemed like career suicide, but the band ended up developing a huge cult following despite their lack of exposure. By the time they eventually ended up making a video for “One” in 1989, the band had already achieved arena status as one of the greatest heavy metal bands in the world.
MTV could have given any decent band a boost if they had a good video, but Metallica didn’t need to cater to commercial demands for people to take notice.
8. Enter Sandman was added at the last second
Metallica would probably not be in the position they are in today if not for “Enter Sandman.”
Kicking off their new era with the Black Album, the song has one of the meanest grooves of any Metallica song, with a riff that has become a staple of classic rock. It’s impossible to imagine the album without it, but there was a good chance of the song being left by the wayside.
As opposed to being a Hetfield-led riff, the “Sandman” lick was actually created by Kirk Hammett as he was noodling on his guitar in the middle of the night. When brought into the studio, Lars played with the arrangement until it became the form we know and love today.
For as much badass swagger is in the riff, producer Bob Rock initially turned it down as one of the album’s lead singles.
When going through the band’s demos, Ulrich insisted that “Sandman” was the song that would bring the band over the top, but everyone else felt that the more thrashy “Holier Than Thou” was a better candidate for that coveted lead single spot.
After a sparring back and forth, Ulrich eventually got them to release it, after which it became one of the biggest hits the band ever had. Even though “Holier Than Thou” remains a good song, “Enter Sandman” was the ideal balance of being different and familiar for the band to cross over into the mainstream.
7. Load And Reload Was Originally Supposed To Be A Double Record
After the rigorous tour across the world promoting the Black Album, Metallica certainly deserved a break from the craziness. However, once the band got back into the studio to record their followup, Load ended up being too much of a sellout for some fans to handle. Though the album and its followup ReLoad still get a lot of hate, it wasn’t originally supposed to work out that way.
Rather than releasing 2 monolithic releases years apart, the band had originally envisioned making a double record with the best songs from each of the albums. While there’s going to be plenty of people who hate everything about these records, the idea of having one free-flowing experience with this new style may have ended up working a lot better for them in the long run.
For as many great songs are on these records, there is plenty of filler that could have been relegated to B-sides. On the other hand, having something like “Fuel” alongside “King Nothing” as the next step after the most successful metal album in history could have ended up being just good enough to bring the band back.
Load and ReLoad are far from terrible albums, but it seems like a bit of lost potential that we ended up getting two records of tepid cuts rather than one badass double record.
6. All Nightmare Long Was Originally Slated For St. Anger
Death Magnetic was the type of Metallica release that fans really needed in 2008. Even though the album had its flaws in terms of the mixing, the band was finally back to sounding like thrash metal after years of toying with their sound. “All Nightmare Long” acts as the perfect mission statement for the album, but it’s origins date back to one of the darkest times in Metallica’s history.
Though the riff had been slated for the album early on, its first appearance actually dates back to the St. Anger sessions. According to the demos debuted in the Some Kind of Monster movie, the lick appears when the band is still working in the Presidio studio before James leaves to go to rehab.
At this stage, the riff is still badass, but the detuned mess and shoddy production makes it feel too much like a jam than a well thought out idea.
The band might not have been able to make it work during this stage, but once the band started working on a flamenco flavored lick from Robert Trujillo, the riff finally found its home as the band’s return to their metal wheelhouse.
St. Anger is rightfully dragged through the mud by many, but we at least got one great song out of it a few years down the road.
5. Geddy Lee was supposed to be their producer
During their ‘80s tenure, Metallica had some of the best sounding records of their thrash brethren. While the band dropped the ball a bit with And Justice for All, the work of Flemming Rasmussen and Michael Wagener on albums like Master of Puppets and Ride the Lightning have still held up as some of the best sounding metal songs of all time.
Though the band eventually worked with huge producers like Bob Rock and Rick Rubin, there was another musician the band was eyeing in the early days.
Rather than having Rasmussen turn the knobs for them during the Ride the Lightning, the band was in talks with having acclaimed Rush bassist Geddy Lee oversee production duties. The actual idea behind this feels like a match made in heaven, with Lee’s prog metal mindset working well with Metallica’s epic tracks, along with the eclectic taste of bassist Cliff Burton.
Both parties were eager to begin production with each other, but it was not to be as Lee had to commit to Rush’s touring schedule and next album cycle. Lee has said that he still loves the record that the band made, but the thought of having Metallica under the wing of a band like Rush is one of metal’s greatest ‘what-if?’ stories.
4. Lars was originally supposed to be fired
Lars Ulrich doesn’t really get enough props for being the real heart of Metallica. There have been plenty of occasions where his lackluster drumming style has gotten in the way of great songs, but the Metallica that we know and love today would not be in here if he wasn’t still there. However, the band were very close to continuing without Ulrich in the early days.
While the band were out on tour with fellow thrashers Anthrax, guitarist Scott Ian has said that James and Cliff were talking about sacking Lars once the touring wrapped up. For as much great material as he brought to the band, Ulrich’s intense personality and often shoddy performances led to the band wanting some fresh blood behind the kit.
The plan was still in place for most of the tour, but everything ended up changing when Burton was killed in a bus accident. As the band made their way back to the States to find a new bass player, Ulrich’s tenacity and smart business mind gave the band the shot in the arm they needed to continue on.
Lars may still be called “the worst Metallica member” or “the Napster guy,” but if he had not been there when the band needed him, it’s very possible we wouldn’t be talking about them today.
3. Fade to Black's Borrowed Guitar
It might not seem like it today, but Ride the Lightning was an initially polarizing listen for most Metallica fans.
Some of the band’s greatest songs like “Creeping Death” and “Fight Fire With Fire” are on this album, but the one slow track “Fade to Black” left many fans questioning what kind of band these thrash legends really were. Though it has become a staple of the band’s set nowadays, actually recording the song ended up being a real struggle.
The song’s dejected and suicidal themes were very poignant, but the actual inspiration came from the band’s gear being stolen from their practice space. With nothing from the prior session, James started to strum a new idea where he reflected on the band’s morbid situation. Even with the song’s massive potential, the band didn’t have a proper acoustic guitar to record the song.
Instead of just investing in a new acoustic, Hetfield ended up borrowing an acoustic from one of his friends the night prior to recording. It may have just been a one-off, but this one track went onto become the precursor to future ballads like “Welcome Home (Sanitarium)” and “Nothing Else Matters.” “Fade to Black” has been a fan favorite for years, but the days of recording is something that the band might not want to revisit.
2. Sad But True was originally supposed to be faster
Most fans who mock Metallica for selling out with the Black Album most likely haven’t heard “Sad But True.” For as much as songs like “The Unforgiven” or “Nothing Else Matters” seem poppy by comparison, this is one of the heaviest riffs of the band’s career, with a slow chugging tempo that makes it feel like a monster emerging from the depths of Hell.
In fact, the initial thrash version of the song would most likely be one of the biggest wastes of potential in the band’s career had it seen release.
Though the song didn’t find a home until the Black Album, the detuned riff that Hetfield plays has its origins all the way back in the time of Master of Puppets. When compiling material for the Black Album, Bob Rock was intrigued by the song, but couldn’t get over its tempo.
As opposed to the gargantuan sound we know today, the early demos are much faster, with the vocals being way too rushed and the song’s swagger getting neutered.
As the band toyed with it during the session, Rock suggested that the band slow it down to a midtempo groove, which made the entire riff much more meaty and Hetfield’s melody flowing in a more natural way. Millions of fans were not happy with the Black Album’s changes, but this is one of the few instances where change can be a very good thing.
1. Kirk Hammett screws up solo of Master of Puppets
Master of Puppets will forever be known as Metallica’s magnum opus. As opposed to just being another great metal album, this helped the genre of thrash rise beyond its niche market to become one of the biggest genres in the world. The whole album is stuffed with classics, but there is something special about the title track that has kept it resonating with metalheads.
For as many great elements are in this track, it’s actually messy as hell.
There are subtle nitpicks like Cliff hitting a wrong note during the breakdown, but the most audible screwup comes when Kirk takes his solo. Coming right after the breakdown, Hammett ended up being a bit too enthusiastic about the solo, and at one point you can hear his fingers accidentally fly off the fretboard.
Instead of sounding like a screwup, this actually worked out pretty well, with the fretboard flying acting like an extra layer of craziness in the song. Though it will always be linked with Metallica’s greatest track, Kirk has said that he has never been able to replicate this performance when playing the song live.
Metallica were already on an upward trajectory by Master of Puppets, but it takes a certain type of finesse to have one of your errors seem badass.