10 Times Metallica Did Whatever The Hell They Wanted
The landscape of music would never be the same.
The shining light of the heavy metal community, this year Metallica celebrate 40 years together as a band, a feat that few bands before them have managed to achieve and none with the rabid success of the Bay Area pioneers.
Undoubtedly the most successful metal band on the planet, Metallica’s journey from the snot-nosed thrash punks who wrote the scabrous Kill ‘Em All to the arena conquering juggernauts of the modern day is a storied one.
Full of both critical acclaim and outrage, both the highs and lows of this long standing achievement are down to Hetfield, Ulrich et. al fearlessly pursuing their own creative vision, even if it does sometimes mean shouldering some unwanted consequences.
For all their missteps, however, this stubborn insistence to do things their own way has often been the thing that separated Metallica from the pack. Their pedigree, still standing and selling out stadiums where so many others have fallen before, is a testament to this.
Whether changing the rules of the genre, conquering the big screen or even taking on their own fans, Metallica will not compromise, and here’s ten times that they proved that in spades.
10. 1984 - Fade To Black Redefines The Limits of Thrash
The feral bastard son of New Wave of British Heavy Metal (NWOBHM) and Punk, Thrash Metal exploded out of the California Bay Area in the early 80s as a vicious rejection of the preening Glam Rock craze of the time.
Adorned in denim, leather, long hair and beer stains, the Thrash bands of these early years played a their music at a breakneck pace, full of guitar shreds and double kick drums, whilst barking their vitriol aimed squarely at the Christian Right and Conservative Reagan Establishment of the time.
Metallica emerged as one of the early success stories, and after a few line up reshifts, the iconic Four Horsemen of James Hetfield, Lars Ulrich, Kirk Hammett and Cliff Burton were all but unassailable. Following the relatively meat and potatoes affair of debut Kill ‘Em All, Metallica broadened their horizons on follow up Ride The Lightning,
Without compromising on their brutality, Metallica managed to introduce far more sophistication into their repertoire, largely aided by the classically trained Burton, and nowhere was this more obvious than on the 7 minute masterpiece Fade To Black.
A largely acoustic pseudo-ballad dealing with the despair of suicidal feelings, the song’s light and shade shifts between the angelic and the amplified immediately struck a chord with the fanbase, and its heavy subject matter allowed to to fit perfectly within the genre despite its stylistic shifts. A hint of things to come, this was the first bit of proof that these alcohol fuelled upstarts had more in their arsenal than fast tempos and fiddly solos.
9. 1987 - The $5.98 EP: Garage Days Re-Revisited
Following the tragic and untimely death of Cliff Burton in a bus crash during the band’s European tour, all eyes were on Metallica as questions began to be asked about the band’s future.
Barely allowed time to grieve, the band set about finding Burton’s replacement in a gruelling process that ultimately resulted in Jason Newsted falling into these gargantuan shoes. With the label not wanting to lose any momentum, Metallica were immediately funnelled back into the studio to write the follow up to 1986’s seminal Master of Puppets.
When initial writing sessions only resulted in a single song, the band decided to return to basics and instead record an EP of covers in Ulrich’s garage.
Totally 25 minutes and containing 5 tracks, the resultant EP did not exactly set the world on fire, but it reassured fans that their favourite band were not throwing in the towel just yet. In a cheeky nod to the public, the band deliberately chose to name their release ‘The $5.98 EP’, in an attempt to stop retailers overcharging, even going so far as including a sticker encouraging fans to steal it if it was overpriced.
Whilst this admirable show of solidarity to fans not wanting to pay through the nose would age poorly in the decades to come, it did showcase the band’s refusal to be held by label concerns, and find levity in even the most tragic of times.
8. 1989 - The ‘One’ Video Declares War
Traditionally averse to the idea of a music video, Metallica broke their rule following the release of 1988’s masterfully technical but deeply flawed …And Justice For All, when they recorded a music video which would go down in infamy, the video for One.
Telling the story of a WW1 soldier who loses his limbs, as well as the ability to hear, speak or see, the song is a harrowing depiction of isolation and unimaginable suffering, and the human cost of war.
Strongly inspired by the 1971 movie ‘Johnny Got His Gun’, Metallica took the decision to intersperse sections of the film with black and white footage of the band playing in an abandoned warehouse. As the song reaches its extended instrumental crescendo, the true horrors of the protagonist are realised, as an attempt at euthanasia is thwarted, and he is doomed to spend the rest of his days in a prison of his own skin.
Rightly regarded as one of the greatest music videos of all time, the horrific scenes allowed the music to hold audience interest across the entire 7:45 running time, in an era where bands were often perfectly happy to show off hard rocking party lifestyles in their own video output.
In typical all or nothing Metallica fashion, the band opted to purchase the rights to the movie instead of paying royalty fees for broadcast, and its heavy rotation on MTV, and longstanding legacy, proved this to be a shrewd business decision by a band whose mastery of the game was rapidly becoming unassailable.
7. 1991 - The Black Album Changes Everything
From the opening notes of Enter Sandman, it seemed that the extreme thrash of Metallica’s early days was drawing to close, to be replaced by a new era of mid-tempo, hard rock heaviness which could blow the roofs off their old haunts. This was Metallica, the self titled released known colloquially as ‘The Black Album’, and it was the start of the bands stratospheric rise to Heavy Metal Godhood.
After over a decade of unprecedented success, the thrash metal scene was starting to look tired to those within its sphere. Where it had previously stood as a rallying counter-culture against Glam Rock excesses, the years of substance fuelled abandon had neutered this zeal, as the bands themselves stumbled and fell succumbing to their own cliches and releasing increasingly homogenous placeholder albums.
Never ones to rest on their laurels, Metallica recruited producer Bob Rock, famous for his work with more hard rock stadium bands such as Mötley Crüe and Aerosmith, and entered a gruelling eight month, $1 million recording period that culminated in their most slickly produced and accessible album to date.
Whilst many within the scene derided the move as selling out and going mainstream, they certainly could not deny the numbers. Four weeks at the Billboard number one spot and over 16 million copies sold to date, this was Metallica staking their claim to rule the world.
6. 1999 - Symphony & Metallica
Although not the first to use the concept, that honour goes to Deep Purple in 1969, Metallica’s decision to work with The San Francisco Symphony Orchestra in 1999 would be the first time an overtly Heavy Metal band would attempt to mesh their visceral sounds with that of an orchestra.
Following a suggestion by composer Michael Kamen at the 1992 Grammys, Metallica took Kamen up on his offer seven years later to play two live shows with a full orchestral accompaniment.
Taking songs from almost all of their back catalogue, as well as debuting the crushing No Leaf Clover and the sort of not terrible -Human, the shows were a perfect marriage of the fury of Metallica’s output with the sheer majesty afforded by the symphony.
Naming the endeavour Symphony & Metallica (provocatively shortened to S&M with all the connotation therein), the lush instrumentation and inventive fusion of the two disparate soundscapes was rightly regarded as a triumph by the metal press.
Sadly the last album to feature long suffering bassist Jason Newsted, this would be one last high point before everything started to go very south for Metallica.
5. 2000 - Metallica et. al vs Napster Inc.
With the benefit of hindsight, Metallica’s legal dispute with file sharing network Napster is one with a great deal of validity.
Fast forward 20 years and the music industry is one going through turmoil, with the advent of the internet leading on to illegal file sharing, bands have had to shift their business model to make any money at all, and studios are incredibly hesitant to sign any but the most promising artists in an effort to protect what little capital they have left.
Back in 2000 however, the idea of four millionaires taking a website to court because it gives the fans their music free of charge was an incredibly hard pill to swallow. Despite making a name for themselves in the 80s through the similarly cost free tape trading, Metallica’s decision to protect their intellectual property in such a flagrantly combative way reeked of hypocrisy and greed.
After hearing a demo of an unreleased track on the radio, Lars Ulrich spoke before The Senate Judiciary Committee before taking on Napster and demanding $10 million in damages, as well as the banning of 335,435 user from the service.
The names of these users were delivered in a 600 page document to the offices of Napster, in a wildly misjudged PR move that nearly squandered any and all goodwill Metallica had garnered over the last two decades.
4. 2004 - Some Kind of Monster
There’s no two ways about it, Metallica had been spiralling for some time in the run up to Jason Newsted’s sudden departure in 2001. Citing myriad personal and creative reasons for his exit, including the suffocating control the band exerted, the bassist’s decision was just one of many setbacks caught under the unblinking camera lens for behind the scenes documentary Some Kind of Monster.
The film follows the band as they record their eighth studio album, the critically mauled St Anger. Showcasing the creatively barren recording sessions, the search for a new bassist and, most notably, Hetfield’s three month departure for rehab, the documentary reaches its zenith upon Hetfield’s return.
As a therapy sessions rises to boiling point, with Hetfield forbidding work on the album in his absence, Ulrich sums up the ego driven tension between the two that had been simmering since Kill ‘Em All and launches a screamed expletive at the frontman, less than six inches from his face. The future of the band very much held on by a thread.
Whilst contemporaries treated the choice to record therapy sessions as ‘not very Metal’ to say the least, Some Kind of Monster has been rightly regarded as a brave and fascinating look at the struggle of maintaining one of the world’s biggest bands. A landmark for rock documentaries to come, this may just have been the work that saved Metallica’s career.
3. 2011 - THAT Lou Reed Collaboration
After the turbulence of the 90s and early 00s, 2008’s Death Magnetic saw Metallica returning triumphantly to their thrashier roots. Whilst the production left a lot to be desired, much of the squandered goodwill of the past had been returned to the band, and they finally found themselves on level footing again, ready to capitalise and take their next creative step forward.
Nobody in the entire music industry could have predicted that this next step would be a collaboration with experimental rock icon Lou Reed. The former Velvet Underground frontman had spent the best part of fifty years disrupting expectations with his eclectic musicianship, so working with a band as equally daring as Metallica would make sense on paper. Nevertheless, Reed’s predilection for the bizarre and deliberately obtuse did send a worried chill down the spine of many Metal fans.
Their fears would unfortunately be realised when, in 2011, Lulu dropped with all the ceremony of a dead rat at the Christmas feast. Based on the Frank Wedekind plays of the same name, the double album can best be described as Lou Reed mumbling nonsense poetry whilst Metallica lurch through a half baked jam session in the background. People weren’t sure whether to laugh or cry.
Lulu has its defenders, few though they may be, and the ambition it took to make something so avant garde in this day and age is commendable, but this is one work that Metallica fans will be quick to define as a Lou Reed album featuring Metallica.
2. 2013 - Metallica In IMAX
Concert movies are nothing new, bands have been doing them for decades, but Metallica are never a band to do things by halves. When they decided to approach the concept in 2013, in IMAX no less, it was sure that they would do it in a way which was unlike any concert movie before them.
‘Starring’ Dane DeHaan, the movie is a game of two halves. Whilst Metallica play a concert as you would expect in any movie of this style, DeHaan plays roadie Trip, who is tasked with getting fuel to a stranded truck with very important cargo for the band.
Whilst the show is beset by a few narratively determined setbacks, Trip finds himself embroiled in a surreal journey featuring sentient dolls, a full blown riot and a warhammer wielding hunter in a gas mask. Despite these bizarre setbacks, Trip manages to return to the concert after its finale with his cargo in tow; a bag belonging to the late Cliff Burton.
Praised for its creative scope and ambition, like many of Metallica’s off the wall ideas in years past, the movie was a commercial failure. The cost of putting on a show of such a scale without selling tickets and filming the whole thing in IMAX came to an eye watering $32 million. With only $7.9 million taken at the box office, this foray onto the silver screen will likely be one Metallica doesn’t repeat in the years to come.
1. 2013 - The First Band On Seven Continents
Most successful Western bands out there can at least say they’ve played North America and Europe. Many take their success down to South America and Australasia, but fewer still can make their mark in Asia and Africa. There’s only one band on the planet who can legitimately hold the title of playing on all seven continents though, and that band is Metallica.
Titled ‘Freeze ‘Em All’, Metallica became the first touring band to play a set in Antarctica, at a polar research station, back in 2013.
Witnessed by a sparse crowd of 120 people, made up of researchers and competition winners, this was the smallest show Metallica had played for decades, although certainly the most bizarre ever.
Set in a transparent dome, the hour long set list could not use amplification for environmental reasons, so the usually stadium filling racket was instead appreciated through wireless headphones. Live streamed at the time and now available for viewing on the band’s YouTube channel, this unique concert is yet another feather in the creatively fearless Metallica’s cap, and a very Metal entry into the Guinness Book of Records.
Finish The Lyric: Metallica